"Liz Cannon, who heads the Indian River chapter of the Florida Education Association, urged union members to buy retirement investments from Valic Financial Advisors Inc. through a firm owned by the union. That way “we also make money,” she said in a November 2017 newsletter, through regular dividends."
It's stated clearly in the article that there functionally are.
Tip of the iceberg at that. I'm sure there's a few folks between the investment firm and related parties that have bought themselves a boat based on the massive haircut the teachers are taking.
The kick in the gut though is the WSJ article itself. To the naive reader, it makes it seem as if 1% fees are good. They're not. 1% is wildly un-competitive in today's environment.
Especially now that Fidelity offers zero expense radio funds.
https://www.fidelity.com/mutual-funds/investing-ideas/index-...
So yes, 1% is beyond massive and the difference between 1% to 2% isn’t 1%.
The big kickbacks come from the "benefits consulting" companies that "help" small to midsize businesses figure out what vehicles to use to offer benefits for their employees. (This sometimes includes health insurance but we're not talking about that) Their main source of income is commissions to their company for funneling their clients' employees money into the funds themselves. Unsurprisingly, the funds with higher fees pay higher commissions.
The kickbacks to the companies themselves take the form of offloading HR functions onto the "broker" aka benefits consultant. They will do things like print all the materials, give lunch and learns to the employees about the plans, fulfill all the regulatory functions, etc. They also tend to take the HR decision makers out to fancy lunches and things of that sort. So mostly the HR departments are being bribed to look the other way in order for their jobs being easier.
I've pointed out suboptimal fund offerings at multiple small companies and been ignored/rebuffed every time. Every large company I've worked for had really good fund offerings.
It's amazing how simple human laziness and willful ignorance leads to literally millions in wealth being siphoned off of hard working employees into the pockets of benefits consultants and mutual fund companies. The HR departments of many of these companies literally don't care.
Surely the bosses at these employers, who are smart enough to be bosses in the first place, can recognize that they are getting taken for a ride for their own 401k investments just like the employees are. Therefore, the only reason I can come up with that makes sense is the somehow the bosses themselves are getting incentivized to choose suboptimal investment options for themselves.
Unions are democratic institutions and members have the ability to drive changes to this type of thing. Often in many places local teachers unions affiliate with pools of unions or upstream affiliates to get better buying power. Sometimes issues like this are legacy things -- in the past many public school teachers had to use 403(b) plans, as they weren't eligible for or had issues with using 401k or 457 (more common for government) plans.
When my wife was a teacher, her union negotiated membership a "best of breed" 457 plan as a secondary retirement option (they have pensions) that picked investments from different investment firms based on price and performance, as well as negotiated reimbursements. Typically they would get 10-15% rebates from companies like Vanguard or T Rowe Price.
This was, however in a closed-shop environment, not a "right-to-work" state, and both the union and school districts had much better leverage due to the size of the pool.
The fact that you're reading a story about a union in Florida in WSJ is meaningful context. I'm sure they picked this one for a reason.
When 401k-s originally started, it was considered ground-breaking in that it was a way for employers to use their purchasing power (or choosing power) to get lower cost management of funds. It was envisioned as a great thing for employees and employers.
But we all know that is now how new laws are created. A bunch of lobbyists from financial sector lobbied to create this new instrument, which in turn directs more money to them.
Any instrument where the employee doesn't get to control the management of the money is bad for the employee.
There is a similar situation with FSA (Flexible Spending Account). That is day light robbery. Employee has to guestimate how much medical expenses they have in the year. Estimate too little and you lose the tax savings. Estimate too much and the FSA management organization keeps the unspent money. What was originally deducted from your paycheck doesn't come back to you with a 10% additional penalty. No, the person loses 100%. FSA says the money goes to the employer to offset the management costs. This is like the real-estate sales person claiming the seller is paying them.
In other words, you can pay more via a higher monthly premium now, and pay less when you pay for the healthcare. Or pay less for the premium now, and pay more when you pay for the healthcare. Otherwise, the insurance company wouldn't be in business for long.
The difference is who gets to keep the investment earnings from the savings kept until you need healthcare.
https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/irs-plan-now-to-use-health-flex...
And it hurts because a lot of people’s level 2 understanding of personal finance is max out your tax advantaged savings accounts.
FSA’s should be illegal. The advantages they bring to some (large!) don’t justify the theft from others.
Though the program has become widely popular, it's still very clearly a giveaway to the rich. Not only are the wealthy capable of saving a larger amount, we also allow their employers to contribute up to $56,000. Obviously, most employers are not going to contribute $56,000 to their employees retirement savings plan.
Up to 80% of the tax expenditure of 401k plans is captured by the top quintile of income earners. The plans amount to welfare for the wealthy, and indeed the government loses more revenue from these tax expenditures than it spends on many welfare programs like food stamps.
The tax code is structured this way to incentivize saving for retirement. Social security exists for the same reason. The government allows you to defer taxation in these structured vehicles so that you are better able to care for yourself in your old age, so that the government doesn't end up footing the bill.
These accounts are no more a "give away" to the rich than the progressive income tax schedule is a "give away" to the poor.
Since only the rich are employed by employers who offer the benefits of these accounts, it is effectively a give away to the rich. If it wasn't a give away restricted to a certain populace, then it would be de-linked from employment and available for everyone.
Secondly, nobody (well, maybe some people, but mostly nobody) describes the progressive tax schedule as a "give away" to the poor, despite it representing a much larger wealth transfer than these retirement accounts.
So, being an employee of a company that offers a 401k is the new definition of "rich"?
Everyone and their brother has a 401k today. Even many entry level blue collar jobs have 401k plans.
Yes, the current income tax is deferred, and there's the possibility that when it's realized, it will be in a lower tax bracket. For the wealthy, it may not end up being in a lower bracket. However, all of the gains, when distributed, will be taxed as ordinary income; if the money had been invested in an ordinary account, there would have been capital gains, which are taxed at a lower rate.
Support retiring 401k legislation. Call your representatives.
In fact, couples where one spouse who works for an employer with a 401k and one who doesn't are actually punished by lowering the contribution limit for IRA to zero. Someone explain to me why that was put into law.
https://www.investopedia.com/401-k-vs-ira-contribution-limit...
If instead, your employer simply paid you the money they would have paid to subsidize these things, and you paid for the services you wanted, you could actually keep your services in case you changed jobs or lost your job or took time off or whatever. It would be pretty hard to setup an individual pension that behaved like an employer pension, but pensions are already on their way out.
Even if we ignore the above, is the plan they offer right for you? If you don't have a doctor you can save a lot of money just taking an in-network doctor they assign to you - so long as they have enough doctors in network, and doctors are qualified it doesn't matter how many other doctors could see you. Or maybe you have one you like and are willing to pay extra for that. Both are reasonable choices for different people - but you don't get to choose. I'd personally take an extra $5/month in my pocket in exchange for a small in-network list of doctors (so long as it is large enough that I can get help when I need it), my wife is pickier and would pay an extra $10 to choose whatever doctors seems good at the moment - both are valid choices (I'm not sure what we would do if we actually had any choice in the matter: the conversation is only hypothetical now)
https://www.fidelity.com/why-fidelity/pricing-fees
I do see that Fidelity charges $48 per year per account to employers that want to use an HSA though:
https://www.fidelity.com/bin-public/060_www_fidelity_com/doc...
I guess they might have different fees for consumer accounts vs employers, but I have a hard time imagining that they would be more expensive than any other option, given that their whole business seems to be driven by the desire to gain as many AUM as possible by lowering expenses.
I assume they're probably getting some kickback or something from the arrangement of restricting the 401k/HSA member's funds to high fee investments.
Edit: At least for an HSA, one can transfer the funds out into a Fidelity HSA account immediately. With a 401k, you have to wait until you leave your employer, but with an HSA, just request a transfer of funds to your Fidelity HSA, which is free and you can invest in anything you like.