News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by h0l0cube on Monday December 16, 2019 @10:36PM (#21810286)
> For reasons of genetics, hybrid seeds cannot be reused in the next season.

Can you provide supporting evidence/materials to back this claim?

Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by LennyWhiteJr on Monday December 16, 2019 @11:23PM (#21810557)
Cash crops use something known as hybrid vigor (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heterosis) which breeds together two distinct, albeit mediocre, blends into a single offspring that is sort of like a super plant. The catch though is that it only works for a single generation, and if you were to replant the crop's offspring you would end up with a highly undesirable crop. For this reason, almost no farmers replant using their harvest. This pre-dates the use of GMO seeds.

Every summer in the midwest you get armies of workers who do something called 'detasseling' where you walk through the seed fields and rip off the male genetalia of one of the two breeds, which forces the seeds to be pollinated in a specific way. The result is the seeds that are used to plant next years crop.

source: I grew up on a corn farm.

Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by habnds on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @10:33AM (#21814475)
> The Bowman case has come about after the 75-year-old farmer bought soybeans from a grain elevator near his farm in Indiana and used them to plant a late-season second crop. He then used some of the resulting seeds to replant such crops in subsequent years.

https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2013/feb/12/monsanto...

Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by vectorEQ on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @06:01AM (#21812451)
is this for all farms or just very large ones? i can imagine small time farmers perhaps not having such super seeds / plants?
Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by philipov on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @06:24AM (#21812542)
The case of hybrid vigor I'm familiar with is from camels during the middle ages. One hump camels are adapted to hot desert climates, while two hump camels are adapted to cold steppe climates. This created a divide between central asia and the middle east where you would have to switch camels as you traveled. There were people who learned to crossbread the camels to create a hybrid that was stronger than either and could survive in both climates, and they began to dominate trade routes in the area. The catch was that the hybrid vigor only lasted a single generation, and if you tried to breed them again you'd get runts.
Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by tempguy9999 on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @06:51AM (#21812643)
Aside: I grew normal and F1 hybrid courgettes (american = zucchini) as a kid and can confirm the hybrids were proper little triffids compared to the pure-strain plants.

Regarding the camels, can you dig up a link, am curious. Thanks.

Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by philipov on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @07:25AM (#21812793)
I learned about hybrid camels from the work of Dr. Richard Bulliet, particularly this lecture:

https://youtu.be/ublh9JkbeuM?t=2350

I linked to the start of the section where he begins discussing the migration of the Turks into Iran (39:10). Discussion about hybrid camels is from around 45:26 onwards.

Amazon link to his book: Cotton, Climate, Camels.

https://www.amazon.com/Cotton-Climate-Camels-Early-Islamic-d...

Here is the entire playlist of his 46 lectures on World History, of which the first link is lecture 13. His lectures are not just him retelling the material in the textbook, but rather gives criticism about how the textbook was constructed (He is the lead editor), and stories from his own research:

https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLXxM47ZxXvkaODXkQBO5R...

Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by tempguy9999 on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @07:44AM (#21812918)
Thanks, will follow up.
Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by mlrtime on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @08:47AM (#21813356)
Smaller farmers have consultants that come out and help plan for seed/herbicide/pesticide. Farming is very complicated now and many farmers just run the equipment.
Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by stevehawk on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @07:42AM (#21812905)
It's pretty much all farms in the US, since most farms in the US are hard corn or soy farms. It's large and small. Bank owned and family owned. Everyone buys their seed every year. It's not some conspiracy, it's just better business for the farmer.
Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by kls on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @11:06AM (#21814873)
Heirloom and organic farmers tend to reseed from heritage crops. I will give you they are a small subset of farming but the cross germination is having an effect on them.
Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by metiscus on Monday December 16, 2019 @10:41PM (#21810310)
Depending on the plant, you'll get either of the two species used to make the hybrid instead of the hybrid itself.
Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by h0l0cube on Monday December 16, 2019 @11:19PM (#21810527)
Thank you, and excuse my naivete here. So what makes the hybrid route the optimal way to produce these GM plants, rather than cross-breeding in a way that survives reproduction? Do we know GM crops to always be hybrids of this nature?
Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by samvher on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @02:16AM (#21811395)
The way I understand it (I took a course in this 5 years or so ago but might not remember correctly) it's a matter of ease of matching up certain chromosomes. Like people, plants tend to have chromosomes in multiples (though not necessarily 2). From one generation to the next, for a given set of chromosomes, a parent only passes half on to the child, and this is pretty much random. That means that for a plant breeder it's very undesirable to have parents with genetic diversity: this diversity results in randomness (unpredictability) in the offspring. BUT you don't want offspring that has identical copies for all these chromosomes because those are not strong genotypes (this is where the hybrid vigor comes in, you want plants with diverse chromosomes). The solution that plant breeders have found is that you take parents which have copied chromosomes, but you take 2 different parents and you control who the parents are. That way the offspring gets a mix, but the content of that mix is highly predictable.

Some side issues are that the parents are only suitable for breeding (they don't have strong genotypes themselves) and that if you take this offspring and mix them again you get a genetic shuffle which reintroduces unpredictability. This second generation will also perform very poorly, or at least unpredictably.

For seed companies you can tell that this is attractive in 2 ways: they can produce quality seed relatively easily, and the farmer always needs to buy the seed that they use for production because the farmer does not have the parent plants and the second generation is unusable.

Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by bregma on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @09:23AM (#21813659)
A mule is a hybrid. It's bigger and stronger than either a donkey or a horse. It is infertile. It's the same with your garden variety hybrid corn or tomatoes. Big easily stotable and shippable product (but without flavour or desirable texture), but is infertile or doesn't breed true.

Not all hybrids are infertile. Maize corn was developed from its wild progenitors through centuries of genetic modification through selective hybridization -- it is not a plant found in nature -- and that required viable offspring. The same goes for other major crops developed by scientists in the past few centuries, like potatoes, tomatoes, and peppers (interesting pattern there, they all originated in the same part of the world).

It's incorrect to conflate hybridization with modern direct gene manipulation (GMO). They both have the same goal, and effectively do the same thing, but are completely different approaches. Hybridization requires the cross-breeding of unrelated varieties or species, and involves both genetic and epigenetic selection. GMO is directly splicing genes of a single organism to produce altered offspring. Don;t confuse the two.

Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by LennyWhiteJr on Monday December 16, 2019 @11:26PM (#21810570)
Hybrid vigor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heterosis

It lets you create a sort of super crop... but it only works for a single generation. ‾\_(ツ)_/‾

Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by mcv on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @03:18AM (#21811679)
It's not just GM plants. In fact, the GM crops might not even be hybrids at all (I don't really know). But many fruits that we love, like most citrus fruits, as well as bananas, are the result of cross-breeding between different species.

Why is this optimal? Well, I guess it isn't always. I'm willing to bet there are more failed hybrids than successful ones, but sometimes when you combine traits from different species, you get something that's bigger or tastier than the originals.

I have no idea about other crops; I was under the impression that grain and many other common crops could be replanted, but maybe it can't.

Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by galangalalgol on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @12:43AM (#21810993)
Also, as someone said above, this predates GM, its unrelated.
Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by logfromblammo on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @10:32AM (#21814462)
F1 hybrids are the first generation (filial-1) offspring of two homozygous parents, both of which breed true for certain genetic factors.

The F1 hybrid is a uniformly heterozygous cross. They will be a consistent and uniform mix of desired genetic factors, much like clones, but all siblings of parents that are themselves like clones.

The F2 generation will be less consistent. The genes will recombine such that the desired high-producing mix of genes will not be present in all offspring. By the F3 generation, it will almost be back to the diversity of a genetically unmanaged population. Harvest times will spread out, such that by the time the slowest plants mature, the fastest ones may already be spoiling or eaten by birds.

F2 seed can be sold and planted the next season, at a lower price, but the yield will be lower than with F1 seed. F3 seed is not economically viable to sell for planting, as the farmers that habitually save seed probably already have F3 or greater from their last crop, or an heirloom cultivar.

Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by Angostura on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @10:57AM (#21814764)
A lot of commercially sold seedstock is F1 hybrids https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/F1_hybrid

... first generation crosses between different parent strains. If you sow the seed from F1 hybrids (F2) they don't have a consistent phenotype

Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by Metacelsus on Monday December 16, 2019 @10:45PM (#21810324)
Mendel's law of independent assortment.
Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by Red_Leaves_Flyy on Monday December 16, 2019 @10:58PM (#21810382)
Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by xadhominemx on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @09:53AM (#21813973)
Have you tried google? This is a very basic fact about hybrid seeds.
Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by nimbius on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @01:42AM (#21811245)
monsantos 'terminator' seed comes to mind.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetic_use_restriction_techno...

Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by h0l0cube on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @02:22AM (#21811429)
The article doesn't specifically mention Monsanto, though I couldn't imagine them not pursuing this technology.

Also, thankfully:

> As of 2006, GURT seeds have not been commercialized anywhere in the world due to opposition from farmers, consumers, indigenous peoples, NGOs, and some governments.

It's a common narrative that Monsanto did release crops into the wild that caused nearby farms to produce sterile crops after incidental cross-pollination. It seems like this is misinformation?

Re:Nebraska farmers vote overwhelmingly for Right to Repair by seattle_spring on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @11:16AM (#21815011)
It's absolutely misinformation, as is almost everything else you read on the subject of GMOs.