Re:Conscious Perception Of Vision Occurs Outside The Visual ...
by hprotagonist on Monday December 16, 2019 @10:45AM
(#21803844)
>The idea that animals are not conscious comes from religion, not science.
and even then: opinions, as they say, vary wildly.
Re:Conscious Perception Of Vision Occurs Outside The Visual ...
by raducu on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @05:13AM
(#21812233)
What is the definition for consciousnes anyway?
Is it the feeling that you are conscious, can you really differentiate it from proprioception that most animals have.
Is it the bahavior we see in animals recognizing themselves in the mirror?
Or is it language and the ability to produce valid sounding statements about oneself?
Re:Conscious Perception Of Vision Occurs Outside The Visual ...
by treljherthj on Monday December 16, 2019 @09:53AM
(#21803376)
While you are right that we can't exclude the possibility of animals being consciousness, it's well accepted that their conscious level is very low compared to ours.
Re:Conscious Perception Of Vision Occurs Outside The Visual ...
by goatlover on Monday December 16, 2019 @12:08PM
(#21804660)
Is there some neuroscience backing that? Or is this an argument that consciousness is largely based on having language? Which sounds rather anthropomorphic.
Re:Conscious Perception Of Vision Occurs Outside The Visual ...
by bencollier49 on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @12:12AM
(#21810829)
It's an argument by induction. Bacteria (and chair legs) we assume must be less conscious than us. So that sets up a sliding scale with us and the higher mammals at the pinnacle.
Re:Conscious Perception Of Vision Occurs Outside The Visual ...
by ses1984 on Monday December 16, 2019 @10:07AM
(#21803488)
What's a conscious level?
Re:Conscious Perception Of Vision Occurs Outside The Visual ...
by nkrisc on Monday December 16, 2019 @03:35PM
(#21806931)
That sounds like something a theologian moving the goal posts in light of modern findings would say.
Re:Conscious Perception Of Vision Occurs Outside The Visual ...
by wildmusings on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @10:57AM
(#21814767)
The problem is that the term "consciousness" has too many meanings, and any debate about it seems to devolve into people talking past each other.
The only conscious entity that I’m 100% positive exists is myself. If you reject solipsism, none of the traditional criteria that tell apart humans from animals (e.g. language or ethics) hold up to scientific scrutiny as far as consciousness is concerned.
The criteria that have been scientifically vetted (based on information theory among others) also hold for animals and other living beings (genes known as transcription factors form network that are isomorphic in form and function to neuronal circuits).