This is in the site guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
I think all drugs should be legal and think humans have done amazing things with/on drugs. I've also seen this go horribly awry and witnessed some absolutely insane things from people on speed. There's a lot more to it than simply a lack of sleep.
Who knows what's inside meth/speed/cocaine/weed that you buy in the street ?
Psychosis comes from abuse...from binges and lack of basic self care. Life crippling drug abuse is USUALLY a symptom of a deeper problem, rather than the problem itself.
I know, lots of people go crazy on meth. There is also god knows what else in street meth. There are so many people taking amphetamines that are successful and there are people taking prescription methamphetamine as well.
Personally I wouldn't want to be on stimulants, long term, on a daily basis. But just because you know one person(or maybe more) that went crazy and had a personality change on meth, does not mean that there isn't successful use.
There are also plenty of people successfully using opiates as well. So many people use drugs daily and live a normal life.
Anytime someone else makes a blanket statement with no study (example: amphetamine doesn't make you crazy)...all you need is n=1 to disprove that.
For example I have a coin with heads/tails, I hypothesis if I flip it it always lands on heads and we flip it 1 time (n=1), and sure enough it lands on heads that doesn't prove my hypothesis (its very weak support at best), whereas is we flip the coin 1 time (n=1) and its tails that disproves my hypothesis (or at least is strong support my hypothesis is wrong).
It ended up backfiring as I had a manic/psychotic episode, which led to highly erratic behavior that led to me losing my job, burning all my career bridges, etc. Then I also got diagnosed with heart failure. Almost ruined my life in every sense.
Since then I'm just totally sober, off all meds, and fortunately my brain and heart have both fully recovered. Were there other factors that triggered the episode, sure, did I probably have some predisposition to these issues, sure, but I highly suspect that the ADHD meds played a major role in triggering it all and I would highly caution people against them.
Did they start with 5mg Ritalin/day or 20mg adderal 3x/day? Did they take it exactly as prescribed? Did they get 7-8 hours of sleep every day? If they started with 3x20/day and didn't sleep for 36 hours before before having a psychotic beak, well that's to be expected..
Perhaps. They do, however, have a pretty direct relationship with overly verbose writing and excessive use of all-caps formatting.
But I assume many artistic people take them, and I think that is the Faustian deal with the Devil.
“COMPLETE LACK of context of the times”
You misplaced “complete” in your sentence. The article may lack complete context, but there isn't a complete lack of context.
“BREATHTAKING ACHIEVEMENTS during said times”
This reminds me of my peers who brag about how great the music was back when we were kids, as though they can take credit for how good the music was that other people played just because we happened to be alive at the time so we could drop doses of things like amphetamines while listening to it. I would concede that some people who were high on amphetamines could do a lot of things – even great things – that isn't quite a proof of them being a net social good.
“There's an undercurrent here that's almost criminal.”
I'd love to read some actual quotes from the article that support your assertion.
“Stimulants do NOT, in themselves, make you crazy.”
Such as a quote that claims this.
Amphetamines are super addictive and are prone to abuse. You build a tolerance and chase either euphoria or that increased alertness. In military context, the operations surrounding German conquest of France and allied bombing campaigns meaningfully benefited from speed. But there was a pretty significant and trivially measurable human cost to the soldiers who used them heavily.
Check out the book "Blitzed" for an interesting history of it's use in WW2.
Sleeping well, eating well, keeping fit and surrounding yourself with interesting people - those deliver many times more than caffeine and amphetamine without any of the side-effects or the risk of addiction.
A small 8oz coffee has ~120mg caffeine, and a 12oz cup has ~180mg. a 10mg amphetamine has considerably stronger effects on the CNS than even 180mg caffeine, and a far greater psychoactive effect.
We are of course assuming a "typical" individual; there are those who have extreme jitteryness off half a cup of coffee, as there are those who experience myocardial events off typically therapeutic doses of amphetamine.
Tell me what transpires when society loses the tradition of staying amped on uppers for the sake of success?
Let's say society kind of forgets that all success depends on speed, and the next generation isn't clued in on the reality that all prior achievements were the result of maxing out doses?
They try to do it sober, and can't, and don't understand why.
What then?
Interspersed with all this pedantry is a smarmy judgement towards stimulants and COMPLETE LACK of context of the times, and a lack of any societal or species context that recognizes the BREATHTAKING ACHIEVEMENTS during said times of "Oh so bad bad we should be ashamed it's an epidemic!" There's an undercurrent here that is almost criminal.
The sin is not excess, certainly at 5mg a dose. The sin is not 'euphoria', which often turns out to be psych-speak for 'a simple will to live'. What people crave with caffeine and amphetamine is mental alertness. Caffeine delivers, speed delivers more. And with that people can do, have done, incredible things.
Aside from the specific physiological effects like chronically overbearing hearts that also plagues athletes, the worst mental effects of stimulants are often blamed directly on the drug -- not abusers' lack of discipline -- and result from a LACK OF or DISRUPTION OF sleep. Stimulants do NOT, in themselves, make you crazy.