News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Paul Volcker has died by matthewdgreen on Monday December 09, 2019 @08:41PM (#21748825)
The alternative story I’ve heard is that “stagflation” happened to coincide with a massive surge in oil prices due to OPEC — which are an input to just about every product we use, hence increasing prices — and Volcker’s deflationary recession just happened to coincide with OPEC falling apart. But this alternative explanation seems so obviously different from the lesson in your post that it can’t be the full story, so I assume there’s some nuance.
Re:Paul Volcker has died by roenxi on Monday December 09, 2019 @09:48PM (#21749163)
This goes to a basic framing issue that crops up all the time in economics. [Situation] => [Authorities Do Something] => [New Situation] then everyone assumes that the authorities were primarily responsible for the change.

It seems like pretty intuitive logic but it doesn't make any sense on inspection; people adjust to changing economic circumstances much faster than the authorities can change things. The situation will change quickly even if the authorities do nothing. Lessons that get 'learned' about crises and responding to them are probably a build-up of rain dances rather than actual knowledge.

It is a situation primed to promote economic witchcraft. Nobody agrees with which parts of are the most cargo-culty because political groups generally support the stupid ideas which happen to favour them.

Re:Paul Volcker has died by pdonis on Monday December 09, 2019 @09:36PM (#21749105)
The nuance, if you want to call it that, is that you can't do controlled experiments with the actual world economy, so we don't know what caused stagflation or what caused it to end. We can't go back and re-run the experiment and do something different (don't raise interest rates, or keep OPEC from collapsing) to see if it changes the outcome.

It's notable that you use the word "story": that is exactly the right word. These are stories we tell ourselves to try to make sense of what happened. But we should not mistake them for actual knowledge that would allow us to predict what will happen in the future. It isn't.

Re:Paul Volcker has died by mattrp on Monday December 09, 2019 @08:45PM (#21748846)
The nuance is that fed chairs don’t criticize each other and with rare exception all come from the same elite club - much like Supreme Court justices. I think your assessment is more likely the actual reasons for the cause / end of simultaneous stagflation/inflation.
Re:Paul Volcker has died by kennethh on Tuesday December 10, 2019 @10:42AM (#21753458)
The increased oil prices were due to increase in the money supply after the Vietnam War. Money printing usually leads to increased prices of products. Nixon removed the fixed conversion of Dollar to Gold with the Nixon shock (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nixon_shock) which made it possible to print even more money. The gold price increased from less than 200 in 1977 to over 800 in 1981 as a response to a lack of faith in the dollar.
Re:Paul Volcker has died by nickbauman on Monday December 09, 2019 @09:23PM (#21749037)
The economist Ha Joon Chang has written extensivly how a somewhat higher target interest rate, like 5-7%, is actually better overall than the super-low targets the fed has. Lower interest rates tend to favor financial incumbents because they make money anyway because they have more and can sit on it, which implies that the money isn't actually helping develop new value in the market.
Re:Paul Volcker has died by dragonwriter on Monday December 09, 2019 @09:27PM (#21749054)
> The economist Ha Joon Chang has written extensivly how a somewhat higher target interest rate, like 5-7%, is actually better overall than the super-low targets the fed has.

Better for what circumstances? The Fed doesn't start with interest rate targets, they start with a dual mandate on employment and inflation control and set interest rates based on expected results based on that mandate, which can at times be high and are now low (which is mostly, currently, a sign of monetary policy compensating for an extended period of defective fiscal policy.)

Re:Paul Volcker has died by mattrp on Monday December 09, 2019 @11:02PM (#21749495)
Inflation is the only mandate. There’s been a lot of discussion about whether employment should play into their role. When it does creep in it’s around now outdated discussions about whether going beyond so called full employment causes inflation to rise. Clinton was the first to get a fed chair to admit there was no such thing as full employment and later it was Yellen who really pushed fed policy to ignore employment levels. There are some out there who say we are playing with fire by not targeting an employment number and that sometimes includes me but then I think about the woman in the street I saw about a year ago. At first I was worried she’d been robbed or attacked, she was yelling really loudly but as I got closer I realized she was yelling that she’d finally gotten a job. That would probably never had happened under a fed that targets an arbitrary 5% unemployment Figure and that is one of the many criticisms I’ve had for past fed actions that have ignored the little man by playing god up in their star chamber.
Re:Paul Volcker has died by dragonwriter on Monday December 09, 2019 @11:37PM (#21749621)
> Inflation is the only mandate.

No, it's not. Under the Federal Reserve Act (specifically, 12 U.S.C. § 225A) there is actually a triple mandate, as monetary policy is to aim to acheive “maximum employment, stable prices, and moderate long-term interest rates.”

Inflation control (stable prices) is the second listed.

Re:Paul Volcker has died by mattrp on Tuesday December 10, 2019 @12:53AM (#21749996)
I think it's interesting that this definition of mandate came in 77 immediately ahead of Volker's appointment and he essentially ignored it. The fed have always had a bit of heart burn over whether their job includes employment. Even today, there is not an employment target, there is only an inflation target and its precisely because no one really knows or agrees on what the employment target should be. I think when greenspan acted to raise rates, like Volker, he was predominantly concerned about inflation rather than jobs even though raising rates did cool the economy and reduce jobs. And yet, neither man or policy was punished for essentially ignoring the employment component. Now in more recent years, Yellen has been out on the forefront of pushing the limits of what full employment means but her successor seems to be more interested in getting the fed back focused onto the issue of monetary policy. Hopefully this clarifies where I'm coming from...do you substantially disagree with this assessment or is it just the fact that I confused the issue by phrasing my argument in a way that seemingly conflicts with the statute?
Re:Paul Volcker has died by dragonwriter on Tuesday December 10, 2019 @12:13PM (#21754391)
> I think it's interesting that this definition of mandate came in 77 immediately ahead of Volker's appointment and he essentially ignored it

The Fed chair doesn't unilaterally set policy, and the Fed Board of Governors in Volker’s term didn't ignore the other parts of the mandate, it just saw inflation as the biggest risk, for reasons which are pretty easy to understand in the historical context, even if they were wrong in hindsight.

> Even today, there is not an employment target, there is only an inflation target and its precisely because no one really knows or agrees on what the employment target should be

That's not entirely true, it's more that it's because they have a very firm idea of what the employment target should be, but it's not a fixed employment level but the (dynamically shifting, in terms of employment measures) point at which further monetary stimulus has little further employment impact but great inflationary impact.

> I think when greenspan acted to raise rates, like Volker, he was predominantly concerned about inflation rather than jobs

Of course; the Board of Governors raises rates when inflation is the greatest concern, it lowers them when jobs are the greatest concern. They’ll admit that quite openly, you haven't made some stunning discovery. The understanding (somewhat simplified) is that there is a range (which moves dynamically based on other factors in the economy) in which easier money produces more employment with comparatively little inflationary effect, and a range (in interest rate terms, a lower level than the preceding range) in which it produces inflation with little jobs effect, as “full employment” has been reached (with the reverse effects in each range for tighter money). The Fed, again somewhat simplified, largely acts on interest rates based on which range it feels the current situation is in, aiming for the moderate inflation/“full employment” boundary.

Re:Paul Volcker has died by SkyMarshal on Tuesday December 10, 2019 @01:47PM (#21755515)
>Lower interest rates tend to favor financial incumbents because they make money anyway because they have more and can sit on it

I think that's rather due to the Cantillon Effect, which posits that those who are closest to new money issuance (primary dealers, banks, etc) extract more value from it.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Cantillon#Monetary_the...

Re:Paul Volcker has died by m0zg on Monday December 09, 2019 @09:07PM (#21748946)
Same reason why the USSR collapsed, BTW. Oil prices collapsed by mid 80s, and the USSR couldn't survive for very long without those export revenues. Gorbachev took over just as oil prices have hit the bottom. And if you look at the same graphs, you will see that Putin's economic recovery was largely sustained by the upward trend in hydrocarbon prices. To this day Russia has not even begun to diversify its economy.
Re:Paul Volcker has died by mattrp on Monday December 09, 2019 @11:12PM (#21749522)
Technically the ussr collapsed because externally it had to settle accounts in the US dollar and low oil prices - it’s only export - couldn’t provide sufficient hard currency to do this but your point is still correct. Reagan knew this and leveraged it to the maximum even to the point of ruining our own oil economy and increasing our reliance on and strengthening our “allies” in the Middle East some of whom we later had to topple and some of whom we still struggle with today. It’s notable that this lesson wasn’t lost on China who long resolved that it would never run out of hard currency the way the USSR did. Russia on the other hand... as you point out they can’t seem to realize a diversified economy is one that collaborates and is open.
Re:Paul Volcker has died by m0zg on Tuesday December 10, 2019 @03:53AM (#21750813)
It's even worse than that. The ruling elite knows that on the one hand it's non-removable, but on the other its days are numbered (Putin is quite old and he won't live forever; what happens after he dies is anybody's guess), so they pillage and burn whatever they can while they can, with impunity. Diversifying the economy would require a long term view. The folks currently in power don't even realize anything is wrong per se - oil and gas money works pretty well for them.
Re:Paul Volcker has died by rm_-rf_slash on Monday December 09, 2019 @09:23PM (#21749030)
A cynical counterargument would be to point to the taxpaying cybercriminals to show evidence towards Russia’s burgeoning tech sector.

https://slate.com/technology/2018/02/why-the-russian-governm...

Re:Paul Volcker has died by m0zg on Monday December 09, 2019 @09:35PM (#21749098)
I'm pretty sure criminals pay no taxes on their ill gotten gains in Russia. Heck, most "legal" businessmen there are forced by the extreme oil-oriented taxation regime to maintain "gray" books and only pay taxes on revenues that aren't under the table. Normal businesses can't really survive the kinds of taxes levied on oil/gas monopolies. It is far easier to pay off your local friendly government tax agent who would then miraculously buy a Maybach and a villa in Switzerland on $20K/yr government salary.