Re:Paul Volcker has died
by dragonwriter on Tuesday December 10, 2019 @12:13PM
(#21754391)
> I think it's interesting that this definition of mandate came in 77 immediately ahead of Volker's appointment and he essentially ignored it
The Fed chair doesn't unilaterally set policy, and the Fed Board of Governors in Volker’s term didn't ignore the other parts of the mandate, it just saw inflation as the biggest risk, for reasons which are pretty easy to understand in the historical context, even if they were wrong in hindsight.
> Even today, there is not an employment target, there is only an inflation target and its precisely because no one really knows or agrees on what the employment target should be
That's not entirely true, it's more that it's because they have a very firm idea of what the employment target should be, but it's not a fixed employment level but the (dynamically shifting, in terms of employment measures) point at which further monetary stimulus has little further employment impact but great inflationary impact.
> I think when greenspan acted to raise rates, like Volker, he was predominantly concerned about inflation rather than jobs
Of course; the Board of Governors raises rates when inflation is the greatest concern, it lowers them when jobs are the greatest concern. They’ll admit that quite openly, you haven't made some stunning discovery. The understanding (somewhat simplified) is that there is a range (which moves dynamically based on other factors in the economy) in which easier money produces more employment with comparatively little inflationary effect, and a range (in interest rate terms, a lower level than the preceding range) in which it produces inflation with little jobs effect, as “full employment” has been reached (with the reverse effects in each range for tighter money). The Fed, again somewhat simplified, largely acts on interest rates based on which range it feels the current situation is in, aiming for the moderate inflation/“full employment” boundary.
The Fed chair doesn't unilaterally set policy, and the Fed Board of Governors in Volker’s term didn't ignore the other parts of the mandate, it just saw inflation as the biggest risk, for reasons which are pretty easy to understand in the historical context, even if they were wrong in hindsight.
> Even today, there is not an employment target, there is only an inflation target and its precisely because no one really knows or agrees on what the employment target should be
That's not entirely true, it's more that it's because they have a very firm idea of what the employment target should be, but it's not a fixed employment level but the (dynamically shifting, in terms of employment measures) point at which further monetary stimulus has little further employment impact but great inflationary impact.
> I think when greenspan acted to raise rates, like Volker, he was predominantly concerned about inflation rather than jobs
Of course; the Board of Governors raises rates when inflation is the greatest concern, it lowers them when jobs are the greatest concern. They’ll admit that quite openly, you haven't made some stunning discovery. The understanding (somewhat simplified) is that there is a range (which moves dynamically based on other factors in the economy) in which easier money produces more employment with comparatively little inflationary effect, and a range (in interest rate terms, a lower level than the preceding range) in which it produces inflation with little jobs effect, as “full employment” has been reached (with the reverse effects in each range for tighter money). The Fed, again somewhat simplified, largely acts on interest rates based on which range it feels the current situation is in, aiming for the moderate inflation/“full employment” boundary.