News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by busterarm on Monday December 09, 2019 @02:01PM (#21745290)
Avid sci-fi reader here. Gibson had maybe 3 good books in him. 30 years ago. Cyberpunk, although influential, was a short flash in the pan. Him and a few others (Rudy Rucker, etc) made some contributions.

There's far better out there and I never understood why Gibson has been written about so much when his output is so little.

Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by daeken on Monday December 09, 2019 @02:19PM (#21745449)
> Cyberpunk, although influential, was a short flash in the pan.

Which is why The Matrix and its sequels were a huge box-office flop, why the most anticipated game of 2020 isn't cyberpunk (and definitely doesn't have 'cyberpunk' in the title), and why there haven't been half a dozen extremely successful adaptations of (mostly recent) cyberpunk works over the last few years. /sarcasm

Seriously though, cyberpunk never died, it just became the default for most sci-fi works due to the fact that we now live in that world.

Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by naravara on Monday December 09, 2019 @02:43PM (#21745703)
>Seriously though, cyberpunk never died, it just became the default for most sci-fi works due to the fact that we now live in that world.

Although interestingly, it's much shinier and prettier than we expected. And most of the grimy/slummy parts of the world still seem trapped in the past.

Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by coldtea on Monday December 09, 2019 @03:17PM (#21746045)
>Although interestingly, it's much shinier and prettier than we expected. And most of the grimy/slummy parts of the world still seem trapped in the past.

Is it? I'd say that's the view from the nice top floors. And are the "grimy" parts "trapped in the past" or next door to the "future"? I'd say cyberpunk hit the nail in the head:

https://www.city-journal.org/san-francisco-homelessness

https://www.washingtonpost.com/gdpr-consent/?destination=%2f...

https://www.hhs.gov/opioids/about-the-epidemic/index.html

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2019/oct/30/homeless-dea...

https://qz.com/1592826/the-middle-class-is-shrinking-generat...

Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by gpderetta on Monday December 09, 2019 @04:21PM (#21746725)
Yes. Gibson shows us the dirtiest most dagerous parts of the sprawl, but his world is not the distopya most people think (not that it is necessarily a great place either). On Gibson own words even the poorest inhabitants of the sprawl still have a better quality of life than many third world countries today.
Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by naravara on Monday December 09, 2019 @04:08PM (#21746605)
>And are the "grimy" parts "trapped in the past" or next door to the "future"?

They don't actually intermingle much with the future as cyberpunk might have made us think though. Usually the nightmare cyberpunk scenario was that you find yourself in debt peonage to some corporate overlord. But that's a dramatic overestimation of our value to corporate overlords.

Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by jacobush on Monday December 09, 2019 @04:21PM (#21746729)
I feel so much like in debt serfdom.
Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by nottorp on Tuesday December 10, 2019 @03:39AM (#21750749)
[quote]why the most anticipated game of 2020 isn't cyberpunk (and definitely doesn't have 'cyberpunk' in the title),[/quote]

I strongly doubt even 10% of the anticipation about Cyberpunk 2077 is due to the title and subject matter. The creators redefined the first person rpg and then the open world rpg successfully with the fantasy Witcher series and there would be the exact same hype no matter what kind of world their next game would be set in.

Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by busterarm on Monday December 09, 2019 @05:27PM (#21747343)
I'm not saying that it didn't have a huge cultural impact.

As a distinct genre, Cyberpunk lived for maybe 8 years. It's influences are huge, but all I'm saying is that his literary contributions are few. Also in that genre, Harlan Ellison probably deserves as much if not more credit.

He gets way too much smoke for not enough fire.

Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by mattkevan on Monday December 09, 2019 @02:27PM (#21745537)
Cyberpunk doesn’t feel so novel anymore because we’re quite literally living in a Cyberpunk dystopia. We don’t just notice it in the same way that fish don’t notice it’s wet.

As for Gibson’s Neuromancer aesthetic, it’s been strip-mined and recycled so thoroughly that it no longer has the shock of the new.

As a similar example, the bullet-time effects used in the Matrix (which itself owes a huge debt to Gibson) were so different, they went from jaw-dropping to cliche almost immediately through overuse.

Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by pharke on Monday December 09, 2019 @03:20PM (#21746077)
>Cyberpunk doesn’t feel so novel anymore because we’re quite literally living in a Cyberpunk dystopia.

Not really. Our AI is speciously intelligent, our computers are woodenly interactive, our governments are unimaginatively democratic, and our corporations are predictably mercantile. There is a general feeling of living in a pre-cyberpunk present but little of that world has materialized and I feel, like notions of a coming atomic age, it will continue to languish unfulfilled until replaced by another fashionable future.

Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by __jal on Monday December 09, 2019 @02:25PM (#21745520)
Taste is intensely personal, and everyone gets their own.

Impact on the genre and on culture in general, however, is an more objective thing, and by that measure, Gibson is a giant.

> I never understood why Gibson has been written about so much when his output is so little.

As a huge science fiction nerd, I get impatient for new mind candy, too. But I far prefer a few stellar novels to a stream of forgettable pap, and by that measure, Gibson also over-performs.

Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by antoinevg on Monday December 09, 2019 @02:10PM (#21745356)
The world he created was all around you by the time you were born so you probably wouldn't understand.
Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by ozim on Monday December 09, 2019 @02:24PM (#21745502)
That is such a great point.

From all other stuff I was reading and watching, I had that idea about a story. Not quite like "The Matrix" but something about people trapped in virtual world. I was also getting myself to finally read William Gibson, this year I got to read "Neuromancer". That was eye opening thing, I had to check twice when that book was released.

Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by pjc50 on Monday December 09, 2019 @02:52PM (#21745793)
Neuromancer itself was written on a typewriter. That's how different the world was.
Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by jdkee on Monday December 09, 2019 @03:00PM (#21745870)
Exactly.

"At the time you coined “cyberspace,” you’d supposedly barely spent any time on a computer. That’s hard to believe.

Oh no, I had scarcely seen one. Personal computers were not common objects at all, and I had been writing short fiction on the kind of manual portable that hipsters are starting to pay really good money for now. And then a friend of mine called from Texas and said, “My dad just gave me this machine called an Apple IIc, and, like, it automates the writing of fiction — you’ve gotta get one.” So I went down to a department store, which was the only Apple dealership in town. I bought the IIc and the printer and the bits you needed to make it work and took it all home in a box, and never looked back. It was a godsend for me because I can’t type, and having this endlessly correctable, effortlessly correctable way to write was fantastic."

https://www.rollingstone.com/culture/culture-news/cyberspace...

Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by matwood on Monday December 09, 2019 @03:01PM (#21745879)
Great point.

Somewhat related, but I have hard time watching older shows/movies where the plot only works because people do not a have cell phones. I even grew up before cell phones, but they are such a part of our lives now it is hard to look past when they are missing.

Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by shantly on Monday December 09, 2019 @05:39PM (#21747436)
Modern cell phones are a hellish technology for people trying to plot stories. Every single person's carrying a superior version of a 1960s spy's kit, and can magically send anything recorded on it to anyone else in seconds. It takes serious effort to make any event or information plausibly known only to a limited circle, should any of them wish it to be otherwise.

It's become almost an in-joke how horror movies so often have to find a way to dispose of or disable cell phones early in the plot.

Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by sectiondetail on Monday December 09, 2019 @03:35PM (#21746235)
>Somewhat related, but I have hard time watching older shows/movies where the plot only works because people do not a have cell phones.

One of the funniest moments in the Buffy spin-off Angel was when the title character was trapped somewhere, and after managing to escape he's asked by his friends why he just didn't use his cellphone to call for help - at which point he's at a genuine loss for words, because he did have one with him at the time.

Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by aidenn0 on Monday December 09, 2019 @06:36PM (#21747899)
Serial Experiments Lain is another SF work that makes little to no sense today, though the time between its release and obsolescence was much shorter (10 years later it already seemed quaint).
Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by staticman2 on Monday December 09, 2019 @11:22PM (#21749560)
Lain, like Neuromancer, is best viewed in my mind as a sort of dark, surreal fantasy story.
Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by EliRivers on Monday December 09, 2019 @02:12PM (#21745382)
Perhaps similarly to how someone today watching Pulp Fiction for the first time will see something cliched and derivative.
Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by hindsightbias on Monday December 09, 2019 @04:18PM (#21746695)
I watched a Peckinpah movie with a youth and my eyes nearly rolled out of my head when they went there, but then I realized he was being generationally ironical.
Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by busterarm on Monday December 09, 2019 @05:24PM (#21747316)
I was born the year he wrote Neuromancer and I had already been familiar with his work before I was 10 (and playing Shadowrun since like '91). It's not an age thing.
Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by mherdeg on Monday December 09, 2019 @02:24PM (#21745506)
I just finished "Rewired: the Post Cyberpunk Anthology" which has some commentary mixed in about this issue. The editors' view seems to be in part that Gibson's work was influential precisely because of the reaction it got.

Do we WANT to live in a post government mega corporate future where everyone has mirror shades? The folks who got to thinking about that when Gibson was telling us about that future came up with some great ideas.

Gibson's modern work still feels good to me but it feels more like fiction than science fiction because we've crept into his future.

Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by empath75 on Monday December 09, 2019 @02:04PM (#21745311)
Neuromancer by itself is enough to make him worth studying.
Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by cletus on Monday December 09, 2019 @02:23PM (#21745494)
I knew someone would bring up Neuromancer and honestly I'm with the GP here. I find Gibson highly overrated. I find Neuromncer in particular extremely overrated. It's not bad. It's just nothing exceptional as a piece of writing.

Now I read it many years after it came out so I suspect a lot of the fawning comes from nostalgia and those who happened to be the right age when it came out to be blown away by his ideas.

There GP had it right though. Cyberpunk was a flash inn there pan and a lot less interesting once you realize it was a thinly veiled expression of xenophobia about the Japanese.

Some works are exceptional because their exceptional. Others are viewed as such because they're pioneering and while credit is due for Novell ideas often the only thing holding that up later is nostalgia over what's really a pedestrian work of fiction.

Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by ctdonath on Monday December 09, 2019 @02:30PM (#21745565)
Those who live in the visionary's future do not appreciate how extraordinary that vision was at the time.

So much of what you consider "normal tech" today seemed mind-blowing fantasy when predicted. In a world of 16,384-byte 4MHz computers communicating at 110 bits per second, high-res VR via multi-core multi-GHz computers networked at gigabit/s [0] was magic we didn't know how to comprehend. So much linguistic/cognitive representation was lacking that "futuristic" then sounds primitive/confused today. Once you grasp the context it was written it, you may see how insightful & innovative the works were.

[0] ...used to watch cat videos and argue with strangers.

Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by cletus on Monday December 09, 2019 @05:04PM (#21747126)
So those is wrong on two fronts: we don't live in Neuromancer's future and many of the ideas you attribute to him predate him quite significantly.

Technologically augmented humans? Nope.

Pervasive VR? Hardly.

Dystopian future? Not realty.

Corporations supplanting governments? That's a stretch.

There was a book from the 1950s or 1960s (the names escapes me) that looe decline in sending bits, the natural conclusion of which was that in the coming decades you would be able to share your experience in real time to anyone else the planet. Off that's not VR I don't know what is.

Gibson may have popularized it in sci-fi (although I'm not entirely convinced of that) but nostalgia really seems to be trying to cast there present in Gibsob's future more than I think is justices.

Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by jdkee on Monday December 09, 2019 @02:57PM (#21745837)
This reads like someone who did not read Neuromancer when it was released in 1984, so they fail to understand how groundbreaking it was for the time. And someone who doesn't know it was the first novel to win all three major awards of the science fiction genre. And how influential the novel (and the Sprawl trilogy) were to a broader cultural movement.
Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by cletus on Monday December 09, 2019 @03:59PM (#21746505)
This comment reads like one from sometimes who stopped at the first sentence when it became clear I don't fawn over Neuromsncer because I _literally_ said I read it years later.

I also makes the point that it may well have been groundbreaking butt groundbreaking doesn't necessarily mean good fiction.

Interestingly Goodreads had it are 3.9/5 and a quick scan of the 5 star reviews all seem to mention how groundbreaking it was.

I can give credit for that but if you take that offer of the picture you're left with a completely forgettable work of fiction.

As for those who say how her predicted the future... Did he? Did he really? We don't live in a dystopia, VR is a gimmick, corporations haven't replaced governments and enhanced humans are still a fantasy.

As for the cell phone as a portable computer, the Pl prediction for that goes back to at least 1974 with The Mote in God's Eye.

This thread has done nothing but affirm my view that many people get completely enraptured with and are unable to separate themselves from nostalgia.

Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by e12e on Monday December 09, 2019 @07:16PM (#21748254)
Maybe some new readers expect something... More? I personally am a great fan - and I do think William Gibson And Bruce Sterling did a lot to cement cyberpunk as a strong genere (not alone, Vernor Vinge, Philip K Dick certainly played a big part).

But the line continues back - William Gibson wrote a new foreword to Tiger, Tiger / The Stars My Destination by Alfred Bester. And Richard Morgan's series Altered Carbon continue forward in this vein of combining punk/pulp, dystopia and technology.

Personally I grown more and more fond of Gibson's vision of escaped AIs being worshipped as Vodou legbas.

Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by jhbadger on Monday December 09, 2019 @02:35PM (#21745618)
There was certainly an anti-Japanese streak to cyberpunk, which hasn't held up well. But what was more important was that cyberpunk predicted was a future in which the real power was held by giant international tech companies rather than governments. That is basically the world that we live in.
Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by EliRivers on Monday December 09, 2019 @02:27PM (#21745535)
Cyberpunk was a flash inn there pan

I disagree. Cyberpunk is now one of the principal, default sci-fi tropes.

Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by TrentLarr on Monday December 09, 2019 @02:35PM (#21745615)
>thinly veiled expression of xenophobia about the Japanese.

while that is an unfortunate and awful aspect of one its central aesthetic tenants, i do not think that it is the core.

Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by mlyle on Monday December 09, 2019 @03:32PM (#21746197)
Kind of an understandable xenophobia, given rhetoric in the US in the early 80's. It's a work that fits the cultural context of the time it was written, in that respect.
Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by ericmcer on Monday December 09, 2019 @02:07PM (#21745334)
Who is far better? I mean I would put like Gene Wolfe and PKD ahead of him among a few others, but he’s definitely a top tier sci fi author in my book.
Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by busterarm on Monday December 09, 2019 @05:34PM (#21747393)
Great examples! I think Gibson's work is built on roads mostly laid by Ellison & Zelazny. I think he has about 3 absolutely great books but the rest of his output is pretty unremarkable.

That's a far cry from the output and impact of PKD specifically (favorite author, btw).

Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by atombender on Monday December 09, 2019 @07:28PM (#21748335)
Samuel Delaney was a big influence; Gibson wrote the foreword to newer editions of Dhalgren.

Gibson has also said John Brunner was also a big influence, and praised The Sheep Look Up (which is great).

I wonder if Gibson read Alfred Bester, whose The Stars My Destination certainly has something cyberpunk in it. His lesser-known novel The Computer Connection (also known as Extro) is also terrific.

Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by numbsafari on Monday December 09, 2019 @02:46PM (#21745732)
I’m not sure what you mean by “his output is so little”.

Just because he hasn’t become the overly verbose waster of words that so many others have (ahem...) doesn’t mean he doesn’t have a solid body of work. I count 15 books on my shelf that bear his name. “So little”?

Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by e12e on Monday December 09, 2019 @07:06PM (#21748169)
Wait, 15 books?

Burning Chrome

Neuromancer, Count Zero, Mona Lisa Overdrive

The Difference Engine (w/Bruce Sterling)

Virtual Light, Idoru, All Tomorrow's Parties

Pattern Recognition, Spook Country, Zero History

The Peripheral

That's 12?

Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by atombender on Monday December 09, 2019 @07:31PM (#21748352)
With the graphic novel Archangel and his non-fiction collection Distrust That Particular Flavor you get 14, at least. The sequel to The Peripheral comes out in January.
Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by EliRivers on Monday December 09, 2019 @02:08PM (#21745342)
"...when his output is so little."

Unless you're his publisher, the measure of a good writer is not how many books he's churned out. Look at Donna Tartt; she does one a decade.

Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by paggle on Monday December 09, 2019 @03:08PM (#21745952)
Ugh Donna Tartt's books are such horrible juxtapositions of beautiful writing and terrible plots. If she crafted worse sentences I could just skip her awful books but the way she writes leaves me in the position of feeling compelled to read them and then hating how dumb the plots are.
Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by sectiondetail on Monday December 09, 2019 @04:53PM (#21747030)
Sounds like my reaction to Neal Stephenson. His phrasing is godly. His plotting is godawful.
Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by shantly on Monday December 09, 2019 @05:44PM (#21747470)
My "favorite" part of The Diamond Age was when he had a whole scene solely so one character could explain to the reader what another's (lame) motivation had been for the last half the book or so, as it had been in no other way established or explained up 'till then and the book was about to wrap up.
Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by tech2 on Tuesday December 10, 2019 @02:36PM (#21756025)
Every time I read a Stephenson novel I have to break through that first quarter to a third before I'm fully taken in. It's like a dog or cat finding a comfortable position to sleep in. Snow Crash, The Diamond Age, Cryptonomicon, all require me to push through that first part before I can get comfortable.

I had tried (and failed) to read Crypto about 3 times before I finally broke through and realised his plotting wasn't bad, he just couldn't set it up right, or something.

Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by busterarm on Monday December 09, 2019 @06:49PM (#21748036)
For all of my problems with Neal, The Big U is an amusing read.
Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by sectiondetail on Tuesday December 10, 2019 @08:48AM (#21752360)
I think it's because he hadn't learned a whole lot of bad pacing habits at that point, but had already developed a strong descriptive style. Snow Crash is an evolution of that. The pacing is a mess, but entertainingly so, and the first-class descriptive writing and dialogue makes up for it.

He desperately needs an iron-fisted editor in his life. It's a tragedy that he doesn't.

Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by paggle on Tuesday December 10, 2019 @01:35PM (#21755359)
In what ways is the “pacing” of Snow Crash a “mess”? Not really familiar with the concept of pacing. Thanks
Re:How William Gibson Keeps His Science Fiction Real by killion on Monday December 09, 2019 @02:55PM (#21745824)
I enjoy his early work as well. I read his newer ones but mostly out of an appreciation for the old stuff.

I find the new books to be about things that are very low stakes, like an ad agency, or rich people from the future messing with people as a hobby. Because of that I'm less engaged.

But even with the low stakes the language is very high minded. I spend a lot of time with the lookup feature, which makes me glad I use an e-reader.