News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Powerful Statement of Resistance from a College Student o... by nopriorarrests on Sunday December 08, 2019 @04:27PM (#21738437)
The problem here is Gessen uses Zhukov's words to bash Donald Trump, but neglects to mention that Zhukov is a right-winger who supports Trump, and the Tea Party. He's also anti-feminist & new yorker readers would feel differently if they knew these things. It's disingenuous.

https://twitter.com/27khv/status/1203785706860109830

Re:Powerful Statement of Resistance from a College Student o... by scandox on Sunday December 08, 2019 @06:01PM (#21739049)
If you're quoting someone you should indicate that. If you're quoting Bryan MacDonald well I think you should validate it pretty carefully. And if you are Bryan MacDonald...well I'm not surprised how you turned out Bryan.
Re:Powerful Statement of Resistance from a College Student o... by nopriorarrests on Sunday December 08, 2019 @06:05PM (#21739067)
Yes, I'am quoting Bryan MacDonald, sorry if it wasn't clear. And since I speak russian, I can attest that his tweet is factually correct.
Re:Powerful Statement of Resistance from a College Student o... by kelvich on Sunday December 08, 2019 @06:20PM (#21739161)
Well, there is a video where Zhukov tells that he doesn't agree with principle of collective responsibility advocated by _some_ feminists. Calling him anti-feminist after that is kind of big jump, isn't it?
[dead]
Re:Powerful Statement of Resistance from a College Student o... by penguintester on Sunday December 08, 2019 @09:32PM (#21739971)
It should be obvious, if you are a supporter of democracy, that the right to free speech, expression and the right to not be dragged out of your house in the middle of the night and sent off to the Siberian gulags should be indispensable in any developed society today. All of these values form the foundational core from which a healthy society can thrive and grow and love (according to his definition of it in the article). Yet all of these qualities are sorely void in the Russian state today. In their place is a corrupt apparatus put in place by Putin and his underlings, with the intent of efficiently plundering and exploiting the country's assets for their own personal gain. Any resistance to this on going robbery are put down by a brutal, organized network of thugs with the full backing of "the state". This klepocratic system have the Russian people locked into a vice grip while their futures and their childrens futures are slowly bled out of them like blood from a giant leech. The young man decided to take a stand against this system, to speak out against their blatant corruption, fully accepting that he might lose some of the brightest years of his life locked up in a Russian jail cell. And what's even more impressive to me is that his resistance may very well be for naught, besides adding a name to a long list of dissidents that have been imprisoned/murdered for daring to speak out against the regime. Even being fully aware of these facts, he has chosen to stand for something that he believe is worth fighting for, consequence be damned. This act had taken more courage than anything that I've ever done in my entire life, combined.

And yet your take away from this article is he's a Jordan Peterson fan. Fucking LMAO.

Re:Powerful Statement of Resistance from a College Student o... by Supermancho on Sunday December 08, 2019 @09:05PM (#21739888)
I'm not sure how you get "right winger" out of someone who doesn't believe in identity politics.

I'm basically a socialist christian who voted for Trump (but will go Bernie next time), but I'm not into equality of outcome between social segments. Am I supposed to be right wing because I don't subscribe to liberal attempts at equality of outcome (between socially delineated groups)?

Re:Powerful Statement of Resistance from a College Student o... by krastanov on Sunday December 08, 2019 @10:43PM (#21740240)
I have never seen a mainstream liberal to push "equality of outcome" ideas. I have seen liberals push for detailed understanding of what leads to different outcomes and for "equality of opportunity". And I have seen only far right people bring up the notion of "equality of outcome", usually as a strawman as above.

And yes, being against the government helping with upward social mobility (the only way I can rephrase what you described, but I sincerely hope you will correct me if I misunderstood) is certainly part of modern American right wing politics.

Re:Powerful Statement of Resistance from a College Student o... by Supermancho on Monday December 09, 2019 @10:16AM (#21743300)
> I have never seen a mainstream liberal to push "equality of outcome" ideas

These are in the wording of initiatives across multiple US states with broad enough support to pass (eg California Senate Bill 826). The mainstream term is affirmative action; a proportional equality of outcome.

If you havent seen mainstream liberal eoo, I can only assume that it is due to willful ignorance.

Re:Powerful Statement of Resistance from a College Student o... by krastanov on Monday December 09, 2019 @10:57AM (#21743680)
Modern "affirmative action" is not about "equality of outcome" - that would be a silly and unsustainable model. Most of the efforts in that direction are about "ensure there are women and PoC at the interview" and "blind the interview", not about hiring people based on gender or race without consideration of their abilities.

To your particular example, see section 1.c and 1.g for research on the usefulness of their mandate. I personally feel that more research is necessary to understand these effects, I can even agree with someone saying that these efforts are a silly and unpractical bandaid. But instituting a rigid rule against measurable biases is not "equality of outcome", it is very much "equality of opportunity" (nobody would hire an incompetent woman as a board member if that is what worries you)

Re:Powerful Statement of Resistance from a College Student o... by Supermancho on Thursday December 12, 2019 @10:32AM (#21772620)
> Modern "affirmative action" is not about "equality of outcome

Yes it is. Creating orthogonal standards to meet, in order to axjieve a quota is for the purpose of eoo, within a series of (future) outcomes.

Re:Powerful Statement of Resistance from a College Student o... by krastanov on Thursday December 12, 2019 @10:34PM (#21778963)
You disregarded most of my comment: The whole point is that you can have affirmative action without different standards. Affirmative action, when done properly, is about ensuring you have diverse candidates for the job, the rest comes naturally without lowering the standards.
Re:Powerful Statement of Resistance from a College Student o... by Supermancho on Monday December 16, 2019 @10:55AM (#21803961)
I did not.

> The whole point is that you can have affirmative action without different standards

No. Measuring diversity (for some value of) requires a new standard (sometimes called a rule or requirement or some other deflection), minimum.

Re:Powerful Statement of Resistance from a College Student o... by scandox on Sunday December 08, 2019 @06:13PM (#21739117)
Well even a stopped clock tells the right time twice a day.
Re:Powerful Statement of Resistance from a College Student o... by 80386 on Sunday December 08, 2019 @06:07PM (#21739079)
The BBC describes Zhukov as a "libertarian activist": https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-50684676
Re:Powerful Statement of Resistance from a College Student o... by kelvich on Sunday December 08, 2019 @06:13PM (#21739121)
But note that journalist who wrote that tweet is actually works for Russia Today -- russian state propaganda outlet. So don't take that seriously.
Re:Powerful Statement of Resistance from a College Student o... by chr1 on Sunday December 08, 2019 @06:30PM (#21739223)
Turns out even people who work for Russia Today tell the truth sometimes (if they were consistently lying they would be telling the truth after all:).

I have watched Zhukovs videos before he got arrested, he self identifies as a libertarian, supports Trump as a lesser evil compared to Sanders and Warren, and likes Jordan Peterson. Because of this Russian twitter was abuzz today with feminists arguing whether it was ok to support him. So the article indeed misrepresents his views.

Re:Powerful Statement of Resistance from a College Student o... by AndrewBissell on Sunday December 08, 2019 @06:22PM (#21739174)
Is the tweet correct or not? Is your point here that

- Zhukov is not actually a Tea Party Trump supporter and the tweet is made up, or

- Zhukov is all these things but it would not in fact be relevant to New Yorker readers, or

- Zhukov is all these things, but the facts should be ignored because they are coming from an unapproved source?

Re:Powerful Statement of Resistance from a College Student o... by kelvich on Sunday December 08, 2019 @06:42PM (#21739280)
I was just saying that collaboration with RT is a big red flag. Talking about tweet itself it's definitely not correct at least in anti-feminist part. Also whole tweet intention is kind of ad hominem, original article discussed Zhukov's speech and his sentence, not his personality.
Re:Powerful Statement of Resistance from a College Student o... by jsnk on Sunday December 08, 2019 @07:09PM (#21739432)
> I was just saying that collaboration with RT is a big red flag

How come?

Re:Powerful Statement of Resistance from a College Student o... by nirv on Sunday December 08, 2019 @07:16PM (#21739472)
It comes from the consistent history of the factually incorrect propaganda reporting, with direct funding from the state budget. The very same state that dictates convictions to judges for political prisoners upon a phone call from the state administration.
Re:Powerful Statement of Resistance from a College Student o... by woodandsteel on Sunday December 08, 2019 @06:51PM (#21739331)
So are you saying that because Zhukov is, you claim, a right-winger, that means that his criticisms of Russia are wrong, and that Russia is actually a pretty good place?

Oh, and by the way, I don't know if Zhukov actually is a right winger, but Putin definitely is.

Re:Powerful Statement of Resistance from a College Student o... by nopriorarrests on Sunday December 08, 2019 @07:01PM (#21739395)
No, I just find it amusing that Masha Gessen is praising some person, who, if relocated to USA while keeping his political views intact, will instantly become alt-right monster and God knows what else (see Covington kids case).

Funny how these things work.

Re:Powerful Statement of Resistance from a College Student o... by woodandsteel on Sunday December 08, 2019 @07:39PM (#21739574)
The question of how good or bad Russia is, is a million times more important than an amusing observation about a particular journalist. So let me ask you again, what do you think of it?
Re:Powerful Statement of Resistance from a College Student o... by nirv on Sunday December 08, 2019 @07:02PM (#21739400)
> So are you saying that because Zhukov is, you claim, a right-winger, that means that his criticisms of Russia are wrong, and that Russia is actually a pretty good place?

There is no causal connection between the OP's message and this assumption. The initial argument is that the journalist interpreted the Zhukov’s letter and his (right-wing libertarian) views in accordance with her political (left-wing and anti-Trump) views.

edit: Putin is authoritarian right-wing, which has nothing to do with Zhukov's libertarianism. As follows at least from his indictment.

Re:Powerful Statement of Resistance from a College Student o... by m0zg on Sunday December 08, 2019 @06:28PM (#21739210)
It's also par for the course for Gessen. She's extremely biased, and she doesn't even try to hide it. There's no nuance whatsoever in what she writes, it's all black and white for her. I'm not sure why she still calls herself a "jornalist".

His statement, however, looks like something a US conservative would largely agree with: decries identity (in his words "atomization") politics (which Gessen largely supports), calls to strengthen traditional families (which Gessen opposes), calls for individual responsibility, etc. For the record: I don't know about his "anti-feminist" views, but I agree with what he says in that particular statement.

It's directly applicable to the US as well - people are pretty much at war with each other here, and at least half the population is quite willing to give up their liberty for taxpayer funded government handouts. Having grown up in the USSR, I know where this particular road ends.

There's one bit of context that people in the US will miss: the Soviet legacy. Back then people relied on the government for _everything_ and had little to no individual responsibility for anything. You worked for peanuts and by Western standards lived in poverty, but a lot of the stuff was "free" and you didn't have to worry about your future - it was largely predetermined.

A large, older chunk of Russian population still lives like that and has futile expectations that the government will solve whatever problems they might have. The government stopped doing that some 30 years ago, but they don't know any better. I think this, and the extreme level of corruption, is why the GDP of Russia is less than that of Texas. IMO for a country with such insane wealth of natural resources, and a pretty decent education system this is shameful.

Re:Powerful Statement of Resistance from a College Student o... by notfromhere on Sunday December 08, 2019 @07:26PM (#21739510)
The whole 'government doing anything is a slippery slope to socialism' is such a worn cliche. It's much more likely that having a large, disadvantaged population thats cut off from class mobility or basic life necessities is what encourages people to start dragging landowners into the streets.

There's a reason why the Great Depression led to a number of relief programs - the threat of a soviet-style communist uprising was pretty high.

Re:Powerful Statement of Resistance from a College Student o... by m0zg on Sunday December 08, 2019 @09:26PM (#21739958)
There also were some pretty great "relief programs" in the USSR at the time, where millions of people were relieved of their food and left to die of starvation. A government powerful enough to give you everything is also necessarily powerful enough to take everything.

And "class mobility" is a 100% capitalist concept. Under communism there's no "upper class" to be mobile to.

As of 2018, the US is experiencing the lowest poverty rate in history (considerably lower than e.g. UK, Germany, and France), and record low unemployment as well.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2019/09/10/us-povert...

Re:Powerful Statement of Resistance from a College Student o... by notfromhere on Monday December 09, 2019 @12:58AM (#21740688)
Repeating things doesn’t make them true. People aren’t asking for the government to do everything, they’re asking for affordable healthcare and education
Re:Powerful Statement of Resistance from a College Student o... by m0zg on Monday December 09, 2019 @01:17AM (#21740766)
But that's not what the government can actually deliver. All the government can really do is take money from one set of people under threat of violence, and give it to another set of people. That's it. It's a parasite. It doesn't produce anything. If you believe in the law of conservation of energy, adding government to any process will only make it less efficient. See e.g. US student loans and what that did to college tuition.
Re:Powerful Statement of Resistance from a College Student o... by andrepd on Wednesday December 11, 2019 @12:36AM (#21759881)
Governments obviously do more than what your absurd statement implies. They are democratically controlled veichles of power. One of the things they do is some measure of redistribution of wealth, attempting to counter the capitalist tendency for wealth concentration.

Bizarre references to "conservation of energy" (?) aside, you can simply look empirically. Places with low social and economic inequality are factually better places to live.

Re:Powerful Statement of Resistance from a College Student o... by m0zg on Saturday December 14, 2019 @07:07PM (#21793335)
The US is factually a better place to live than most other countries, in spite of the high "inequality".
Re:Powerful Statement of Resistance from a College Student o... by JetSpiegel on Saturday December 14, 2019 @09:20PM (#21794031)
For subset of Americans, sure.