I haven't read the paper this article is based on, so I can't comment on the study or the reliability of the results.
However, epigentic effects related to the degree of maternal touch have been convincingly demonstrated in naked mole rats in crossover studies. I posted about this research previously. (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18749285)
Contextualizing this single study's result against the much larger, more established evidence from twin studies strongly suggests that one or more of the following is true.
- The results are spurious and won't replicate.
- The results are true, but the association is not causal, and is simply proxying correlation with an upstream factor.
- Lack of touch does lead to methylation in the short-term, but by adulthood there's strong reversion to the mean.
- The methylation has no significant impact on any actual metric that we care about like success, health, personality or wellbeing.
Since identical twins share twice the genetic covariance of fraternal twins, the impact of family environment can be backed out from the respective intra-pair correlation coefficients. In the limit case if genetics played no factor, then fraternal and identical twins should have identical pairwise correlations.
For example suppose pairs of identical twins have 45% pairwise correlation for adult IQ. And say fraternal twins have 25% correlation for the same measure. That would tell us that the population level variance of adult IQ is 40% attributable to genetic heritability, 5% to environmental heritability , and 55% to non-heritable factors (i.e. not genetics and not family environment).
"Twin studies of adult individuals have found a heritability of IQ between 57% and 73%[6] with the most recent studies showing heritability for IQ as high as 80%[7] and 86%.[8]. IQ goes from being weakly correlated with genetics, for children, to being strongly correlated with genetics for late teens and adults. "
Can you think of a reason selection bias could be an issue, thus invalidating twin study cohorts?
A twin study should normalize everything genetically. Ergo epigenetic expression and environment are the only two causal levers. It sounds like you're arguing that parental involvement has a causal impact, which is the point of the studies to a degree.
Perhaps my original question was unclear: is there something the twins do or have done to them that cause a latent selection bias before adoption, thus invalidating the twin studies approach as a whole?
If such an attitude were present in every person, science would not progress at all.
I'm not that long a veteran here, but I think at HN we are more interested in having our minds and ears open and feeling we can comfortably share and discuss articles that make us think, than fostering an attitude like this.
I mean this with respect, whoever you are.
I am a scientist by profession and I have come to believe that the majority of work in this field is wasted because people chase that 5-minute fame. Once you are in the field you can smell the stink a mile away.
It always sounds the same: "A second genetic code discovered", "Touch reflected in the DNA", "Next cure for cancer", "Scientists can edit now genes at high fidelity with CRISPR" all pure bullshit.
it is the premature claim that it changes DNA what is so annoying and misleading.
because once something changes your DNA it suggests that it is there forever (that is why it captures people's imagination)
I don't have the time to dig out the actual study but it looks like [1] it's originating in Canada (not NIH/USA) based on the publication of the press release.
Original comment of thread doesn't understand how much research is behind this idea (touch linked to higher outcomes long-term). I'd strongly recommend the commenter to read tribler's citation as that's scientific consensus at this point. If you want to read the recent study on DNA affects of touch, then below is that source of research.
1 - https://www.med.ubc.ca/news/holding-infants-or-not-can-leave...
Sadly I have prime view how clickbaity ideas like this one drive most of the motivations behind investigations in life sciences.
It is not just this paper that is bullshit, the whole field of "epigenetics" that this paper is a representation of is bullshit as well - this paper is just one out of the long line.
As I pointed out it there is simply no proof that handling changes DNA. It could just as well handling stimulates the development rate which, in turn, also shows up as another signal.
The lie is not that A and B are present at the same time. The lie is presenting story as if A was caused by B. There is absolutely no evidence for that.
Now hundreds of scientists want a piece of the "cool" story, will jump headfirst into proving how LOVE will reflect in the DNA. No one will care about understanding what the heck is methylation - they will all be chasing baby handling and methylation. That's what I have seen happening and will keep happening thanks to papers like this.
Hence why the main source is published with ~90 subjects studied. Science starts with one paper/experiment and builds from there.
> The lie is not that A and B are present at the same time. The lie is presenting story as if A was caused by B. There is absolutely no evidence for that.
That's not a lie. It's called a hypothesis. It's testable. They've tested it and encourage others to test as well.
Of course, you could say: how dare you, how would you even know, ... I work in this field, the p-hacking, harking (hypothesizing after the results are known) is both pervasive and endemic. they massaged the factors, the genders, the ethnicity, the socioeconomic status etc until the model did something that was publishable.
It simply not possible to accurately correlate these two measures: self-reported minutes of touching a baby with the methylation levels of the DNA of that baby - if you are serious about accounting for all the possible variations across all factors
> Are the neuroendocrine effects of these experiences across the lifespan also mediated by DNA methylation? The answer to this question is not yet known.
So what happened in the following ten (!) years, have we finally figured out whether the effect is mediated by DNA methylation? Nah. Instead, they published another bullshit paper, this time about babies being held...
Ten years is (or rather should be) an eternity in science! The 1st smartphone was barely released back then - how far have gone in technology in this time? Yet we are nowhere closer to have proven or disproven the mechanism. Instead, they would much rather maintain the status quo and publish another bullshit paper.
Until the recent ML-based announcement from Google (and maybe not even with that in hand), protein folding research went nowhere for at least 30 years. So I wouldn't be too critical of a 10 year gap.
> They also asked parents to keep track of how long and how often they gave care to their child that involved physical contact, according to a press release.
Most likely has to do with confusing cause-and-effect.
It could be just as well that highly methylated babies cry more and could be more demanding or parents with highly methylated babies are themselves less tolerant to crying thus end up handling babies more.
The problem, they way it is being reported, and they way it lines up with pseudo-scientific mumbo-jumbo groupthink makes it stink. That's why it is newsworthy. People want to believe that handling a baby will change their DNA.
Same bullshit like papers like this:
- Scientists Say They’ve Found a Code Beyond Genetics in DNA - https://www.nytimes.com/2006/07/25/science/25dna.html