News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by cbanek on Sunday December 08, 2019 @02:25PM (#21737670)
(I'm not speaking for any of my current or past employers, just for myself, and how I've seen this play out. One employer being a telescope impacted by Starlink, and the other being SpaceX, I want both sides to succeed.)

First, astronomers know that satellites can disrupt observations. They've known for a while, and have had to deal with things like flares from Irridium satellites, which were probably when these problems were first taken seriously. (It was a design defect where shiny panels would reflect the sun in a very efficient way).

Astronomers use all sorts of image processing, because satellites aren't the only noise in the picture. The CCDs have to be kept cryogenically cool, and there's all sorts of electrical noise as well. There's not a lot of photons being collected in the grand scheme of things, so dealing with the noise floor is a real problem. There are all sorts of ways for removing tracks. And don't forget weather!

Now, that being said, even I was confused why this would cause a problem. The satellites are in low earth orbit, so low that they won't be able to reflect the sunlight, since they are in earth's shadow. Only during twilight and dawn will satellites be in the right position to reflect the sunlight back to the ground off of some panel.

Now, these are not prime observing hours for many people, since it is still not as dark as it could be. So most people point into the darkest parts of the sky (up) rather than at parts where there is still twilight (like nearer the horizon).

But for some types of observations, like near earth asteroids, you want to point into the evening sky to look for them, since that is one of the places you want to look, and the sky conditions should be good enough. In these pictures you'll get streaks of light as the satellites pass through.

Even if there is no light reflecting, these satellites could occlude a distant star or galaxy momentarily. You wouldn't see a streak as much as the light would go away and come back. This would affect how bright you see the star, since over the time of the exposure (let's say 30 seconds) you'll collect less light while something is blocking the light. This can also make it a bit more tricky to look at variable stars, where the light gets stronger and dimmer naturally.

I would say that astronomers definitely knew about these problems, since they have to deal with all sorts of similar problems, but the pitch didn't get fevered until people saw the first set of Starlink satellites and just how bright they were. SpaceX moves a lot faster than astronomy.

As for SpaceX not thinking about the astronomical implications of Starlink, I could believe that. I think most of them were more concerned with if it is possible rather than the implications of doing it. As much as I would think the two fields would know more about each other, I find they are very different and run in different circles it seems (launch vehicle industry vs astronomers), so I could easily see not much cross pollination between the two. For example, there were lots of NASA astronauts and air force people visiting SpaceX, but I don't remember one astronomer (not that I met everyone).

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by mstipetic on Sunday December 08, 2019 @03:10PM (#21737973)
This sounds to me like a new technology and a way of operating has come and we're trying to make it accommodate the old way of doing things.

If we really have a way to launch thousands of satellites easily, can't we replace the terrestrial functionality with that? Let's launch hundreds of satellites observing near earth asteroids.

If a private company can do it, governments definitely can

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by cbanek on Sunday December 08, 2019 @05:57PM (#21739031)
So while it sounds good that we've fixed the launch industry and can launch everything cheaper, that we should only have space based telescopes, space telescopes are a very different game from ground based telescopes.

First, as others have pointed out, is size. Ground based mirrors are very large, in the 10s of meters, and those mirrors are extremely heavy, like tons. You can't lift one of those mirrors up on one rocket, so you'll have to figure out some kind of in orbit construction. Not impossible, but we haven't assembled a lot of things in space, probably the biggest would be the ISS. But telescopes have tricky tolerances...

Which leads me to the next issue: not only is it heavy, but telescopes are fragile. They have to be very carefully calibrated and put together. Launching something into space tends to be a very bumpy ride, and making something that can withstand that kind of vibration for launch, and then the thermal problems while in space would be certainly not trivial.

But let's say you could build something and get it to work in orbit. Then it's still hard to service. Servicing the hubble to fix the optics was a very hard mission, and the hubble is relatively close to the earth. And that was when we had the shuttle, which we don't now.

Cooling is very tricky for both telescopes and space. Since there's no air to radiate to, you can get big thermal gradients over the length of your craft and you have to be very careful how you point it. Same for the optics and the camera, you want to make sure they have as little thermal gradient as possible.

Unlike a lot of commercial satellites, many scientific probes and telescopes are constantly refitted and reused. Ground based telescopes frequently reuse the same expensive (typically one-off) mirrors and put better cameras on them all the time. This is pretty hard to do in space.

That being said, being in space does have a lot of advantages, the most obvious one being a lack of atmosphere to mess with your observations. But assembling large telescopes in space still isn't exactly easy.

I think over time though, we will be heading to more space based telescopes as the cost comes down. But many slower moving telescope projects (mostly slow due to government funding) were started before Starlink was even announced.

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by manicdee on Sunday December 08, 2019 @07:09PM (#21739431)
The large telescope mirrors aren’t single parts even in terrestrial telescopes. We have to assemble and calibrate them on their isolated mountaintops, starting with the giant support structures intended for suspending the mirrors against the pull of gravity with minimum distortion regardless of orientation of the telescope.

We then add active optics to compensate for atmospheric distortion, alter airline routes and city lighting to help improve conditions, and then pray for no clouds on the nights we want to observe.

Constructing telescopes in space will become a reality within the next decade, while terrestrial telescopes currently in planning will be finding it harder and harder to navigate the mixture of light pollution, accessibility and indigenous rights. I expect there are terrestrial telescopes already in planning and even at early stages of construction which will never be finished. Between the ever-growing forest of red tape and the ever shrinking cost of building space telescopes in orbit, there will be an inflexion point where it makes sense to dedicate the remaining budget of a terrestrial telescope project to building its spaceborne replacement.

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by strainer on Sunday December 08, 2019 @11:28PM (#21740399)
> Ground based mirrors are very large, in the 10s of meters, and those mirrors are extremely heavy, like tons.

Seemingly fantastically - SpaceX is currently constructing a system designed to launch 100 tons to LEO, for as low as $35/kg [1]. Musk says this capability is what the Starlink business is to pay for. It appears lately, more realistic than it has sounded.

[1] https://caseyhandmer.wordpress.com/2019/10/29/the-spacex-sta... ( https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21397285 )

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by sectiondetail on Monday December 09, 2019 @10:18AM (#21743325)
One of the things I'm most excited about related to Starship is its landed mass capability for science purposes. Imagine being able to build radio and optical telescopes in the Daedalus crater on the central lunar far side. They'd be shielded from the optical and radio noise of the sun for 2 weeks out of 4, and permanently shielded from Earth. Or imagine infrared telescopes at the bottom of permanently shadowed polar craters, where ambient temperatures are even colder than in interplanetary space. No need to design and deploy a complex sunshield and worry about maintaining spacecraft orientation. The science potential of reusable heavy-lift rockets can't be understated.
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by flashman on Tuesday December 10, 2019 @10:47PM (#21759388)
So SpaceX creates the problem and sells the solution - brilliant business strategy :P
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by Filligree on Sunday December 08, 2019 @03:41PM (#21738147)
Terrestrial telescopes are huge. Hubble is comparatively tiny, and launching a telescope the same size as the ones we use down here would be completely out of the question with any near-term launch capability.
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by mstipetic on Sunday December 08, 2019 @03:53PM (#21738236)
Well let's figure out a way to assemble them in space.

Hubble is thirty years old, and is being used now as a reference. I don't understand all this negativity. Had we had this mindset, Hubble would not have been there

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by wpietri on Sunday December 08, 2019 @04:11PM (#21738337)
Part of the negativity is who benefits from the problem versus who has to pay to fix it. If SpaceX were causing a problem for astronomers while also for free launching radically better space-based tools, it wouldn't be nearly as big a deal. But instead SpaceX hopes to pocket a lot of money, while the harms are falling on other people.
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by avmich on Monday December 09, 2019 @07:07PM (#21748178)
> SpaceX hopes to pocket a lot of money

and SpaceX customers hope to pocket a lot of use for that money. So taking that point literally - tiny astronomer's society is against the whole Earth load of Spacelink customers, and of course those customers' needs on average trump astronomers' ones.

I'm exaggerating, of course.

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by wpietri on Monday December 09, 2019 @07:42PM (#21748451)
You're also confusing money with value. If we only go by market price, air pollution should be fine, since lots more people buy electrical power than die from coal plant particulates. But market price only captures a relatively narrow slice of value, and it's heavily biased in favor of people with money.
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by mrandish on Sunday December 08, 2019 @04:47PM (#21738603)
> SpaceX hopes to pocket a lot of money

True but to their credit SpaceX's launch prices are substantially lower than pre-existing options and they have been a leader in a step change in competitive launch options coming to market.

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by wpietri on Monday December 09, 2019 @12:57AM (#21740679)
So? I don't understand how that's material to my point.
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by kbenson on Sunday December 08, 2019 @04:12PM (#21738350)
Hubble's mirror is 8 feet in diameter, and you aren't going to be assembling something as high precision as that in space, at least not from a few components. If we had the manufacturing capability to make it from scratch in space, maybe, but that's a much larger enterprise.

There is a question of whether 100 a foot diameter telescopes can work as well or better than one 8 foot one. Or 500. If it's about photons hitting the lens, do enough lenses in an area and post-processing make up for the fact that they aren't connected?

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by nine_k on Sunday December 08, 2019 @05:09PM (#21738727)
There are several large terrestrial telescopes that use assemblies of a number of coordinated smaller mirrors.

This looks like something reasonably doable on Earth orbit with the current launch capabilities.

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by ceejayoz on Sunday December 08, 2019 @04:20PM (#21738397)
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by mstipetic on Sunday December 08, 2019 @04:51PM (#21738627)
Well let's make the manufacturing capability to do so. It's as if the "manufacturing capability" is some limited rare earth metal. What is the actual limited resource other that ingenuity and engineering?
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by ryan93 on Sunday December 08, 2019 @05:01PM (#21738672)
You can’t manufacture complicated objects in space
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by mstipetic on Sunday December 08, 2019 @05:18PM (#21738791)
We shouldn't have been able to land on the moon using whiteboard engineering and calculator level computers, but we did
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by hgoel on Monday December 09, 2019 @11:50AM (#21744106)
That won't magically make it feasible to manufacture such precise objects in space anytime soon.
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by avmich on Monday December 09, 2019 @07:12PM (#21748225)
In fact, in space we can make something which we can't do on Earth - weightlessness being the critical enabling factor.

With capabilities to launch as cheap as Spaceship promises, we can develop space manufacturing rather soon.

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by Rebelgecko on Monday December 09, 2019 @04:20PM (#21746724)
Why shouldn't we have been able to land on the moon?
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by avmich on Monday December 09, 2019 @07:09PM (#21748197)
Because, as you've said, we can't manufacture complex objects in space.
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by unfunco on Monday December 09, 2019 @12:20PM (#21744375)
Is the ISS not comparable in size?
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by whatshisface on Sunday December 08, 2019 @03:35PM (#21738117)
That's a good point. SpaceX could be the key to launching a horde of new Hubbles. However that's not so likely in the short run because everything is going towards the JWST.
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by mstipetic on Sunday December 08, 2019 @03:42PM (#21738157)
JWST is a great project and a type of project we should strive for. I'm personally just annoyed why the conversation is so defensive and negative.

I don't know much about astronomy, but from what I understand the Earth's atmosphere is hard to deal with, why aren't we talking more about what can be done with this new tech, and not how it makes current things more difficult

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by ixf on Sunday December 08, 2019 @04:22PM (#21738409)
Earth's atmosphere is annoying, yes, but for huge swathes of observational science it's not a deal-breaker. Not having massive telescopes on the ground where you can fiddle with your instrumentation and take advantage of apertures and construction techniques simply not possible in space _is_ a deal-breaker.

The required precision for construction of telescopes is incredible, and doesn't translate to space well, especially once you start talking about apertures that even folded won't fit into even the largest Starship SpaceX is proposing.

Ground-based astronomy is here to stay and with good reason. SpaceX needs to avoid or minimise the harms to these users of the night sky.

There is another aspect of harm, too - the casual observer. The night sky is a precious resource and shared by all. Introducing huge constellations which in many parts of the world will be visible year-round (and in some quite heavily populated areas like northern Europe, even through the night at some times of year) is like building a huge mobile phone mast outside someone's window and expecting them not to complain, but on a much larger scale.

Light pollution is a huge issue, and satellites can pollute just as well (if not more effectively) than ground based sources - it needs to be an ecological consideration of any launch.

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by mstipetic on Sunday December 08, 2019 @04:58PM (#21738663)
I live in a very large city in Europe. I think the number of stars you can see is less than 20. Ground based pollution is horrible, I don't know how you can compare those two.
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by greglindahl on Sunday December 08, 2019 @05:38PM (#21738924)
If you go back 100 years, you could see stars great from the middle of your very large city in Europe. Then the lights came, one by one.

This process is just starting with satellites. Can you see the connection now?

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by iudqnolq on Sunday December 08, 2019 @05:21PM (#21738809)
Maybe because large telescopes aren't in very large cities.
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by Reason077 on Sunday December 08, 2019 @10:04PM (#21740092)
Here’s an example of a large telescope in a very large city:

https://www.rmg.co.uk/discover/explore/great-equatorial-tele...

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by greglindahl on Sunday December 08, 2019 @06:51PM (#21739330)
100 years ago, lots of them were.
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by iudqnolq on Sunday December 08, 2019 @06:57PM (#21739371)
Kind of. Some on mountains near cities, but even then light polution was an issue they had to mitigate.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_optical_telesc...

In general, I'm fine with scientists needing to accommodate people more than they had to 100 years ago.

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by greglindahl on Sunday December 08, 2019 @07:10PM (#21739437)
That list of telescopes only goes back to 1932, and I studied astronomy at one of the institutions in question.

As an example, why is this area named Observatory Hill? https://www.google.com/maps/place/Observatory+Hill,+Cambridg...

> In general, I'm fine with scie!tists needing to accommodate people more than they had to 100 years ago.

Indeed, that's the majority opinion.

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by iudqnolq on Sunday December 08, 2019 @07:15PM (#21739463)
You're right, not quite 100 years.
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by greglindahl on Sunday December 08, 2019 @11:00PM (#21740307)
... it's named Observatory Hill, in the middle of Cambridge Massachusetts, quite near to downtown Boston, because it has an observatory that used to work great before light pollution.
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by avmich on Monday December 09, 2019 @07:15PM (#21748247)
> Not having massive telescopes on the ground where you can fiddle with your instrumentation and take advantage of apertures and construction techniques simply not possible in space _is_ a deal-breaker.

Why do you think telescopes in space - where they don't need to fight gravity just to stand - can't soon, with reasonable development, surpass land-based ones in capabilities?

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by ceejayoz on Sunday December 08, 2019 @04:22PM (#21738408)
It's the kind of telescope we should strive for, but definitely not the sort of project we should.

It's more than a decade late and billions over budget.

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by greglindahl on Sunday December 08, 2019 @05:37PM (#21738912)
I'm personally just annoyed that people are so happy to be annoyed at each other every time this discussion comes up, so there's that.

Astronomers have been talking and acting for decades to take advantage of new technologies like orbital observatories.

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by dnautics on Sunday December 08, 2019 @05:49PM (#21738978)
As an expert would you be able to comment on my speculation:

It seems like this whole hullabaloo is because a SpaceX launch happened to coincide with a rare event at an inopportune time:. The alpha monocerotids have a narrow band with a long recurrence time (2h window, with a peak recurrence on the order of 10 years). Moreover, some monocerotid observers are in parts of the world where they will appear near Dawn or dusk, so yes some of the starlinks will flash (as you mentioned). In general, the SpaceX launches will only cluster in that fashion a few days after launch as they haven't disperesed into final formation yet. Any other time this wouldn't be a problem.