I'd actually take the lesson the other way. It's hilariously tough for model-makers to acknowledge real-world noise that prevents their theoretically precise models from delivering reliable results.
https://v.cx/2010/04/feynman-brazil-education
> There are no experimental results mentioned anywhere in this book, except in one place where there is a ball, rolling down an inclined plane, in which it says how far the ball got after one second, two seconds, three seconds, and so on.
> The numbers have ‘errors’ in them – that is, if you look at them, you think you’re looking at experimental results, because the numbers are a little above, or a little below, the theoretical values. The book even talks about having to correct the experimental errors – very fine.
> The trouble is, when you calculate the value of the acceleration constant from these values, you get the right answer. But a ball rolling down an inclined plane, if it is actually done, has an inertia to get it to turn, and will, if you do the experiment, produce five-sevenths of the right answer, because of the extra energy needed to go into the rotation of the ball.
> Therefore this single example of experimental ‘results’ is obtained from a fake experiment. Nobody had rolled such a ball, or they would never have gotten those results!
> “If I ask you a question during the lecture, afterwards everybody will be telling me, ‘What are you wasting our time for in the class? We’re trying to learn something. And you’re stopping him by asking a question’.”
In my experience there are almost just 2 types of motivated students: those who want to understand the content of the course and those who want a good grade and ultimately graduate.
There's often a conflict of interest between them. For example the first group wants to learn more, ask more questions, go deeper. The second group sees this as a threat because the additional content may now be on the exam as well. And they often misunderstand this behavior of the first group as just being teacher pleasers/pets.
Or from own experience: when you tell the prof that he accidentally started to cover the same topic that we already covered in the last lecture (because you're there to learn more), you will annoy a lot of people who hoped to get one fewer lectures to study in the course. Less content, less effort, same grade.
You hear the first group having passionate discussions on physics or programming over a beer, while the other group discusses all the latest info of which prof is how demanding, what the grading criteria are, what the deadlines are, which departments you should or should not take courses from, where they have mandatory presence, who does multiple choice tests and who does free-text exams.
I don't have much to conclude, just an observation.
One of the things I think was the best ideas I learned in physics is that physics is all about approximations. Theorists tend to forget this annoyingly, but it helps keep naive scientists from using words like "fundamental" without qualifications, or saying garbage statements like "Newton's law X is wrong."
F = G * m1 * m2 / r²
This tells you that the acceleration of mass 1 is independent of the mass 1 and only depends on mass 2 and the acceleration of mass 2 is independent of mass 2 and only depends on mass 1. But the relative velocities will increase when either m1 or m2 is increased.
E.g. a black hole with the mass of the earth will hit the ground of a (perfectly rigid) earth in almost half the time as a feather would.
(I won't go into relativistic effects here.)
That is, would you expect adding ten pounds to have a meaningful difference in how fast a bike will accelerate down a hill? Even fifty pounds?
It will impact brake force needed to stop. But the speeds are going to be near identical.
I should clarify the last time I had this conversation, I'm talking about 40+ year olds building bikes. They were thinking a heavier bike would accelerate faster down a hill. That just is not how that works.
That is to say, the force from the air does not actively slow you down. It prevents you from speeding up, after a point. (Aerodynamics are, of course, more complicated. But this general model is pretty solid.)
Such that if I want to accelerate faster down the hill, I have to pedal to cause that to happen. Or add a motor.
Yes, acceleration due to gravity is the same, but air resistance has less effect, at all speeds, on the heavier bike. The rate at which the heavier bike gains speed is higher. It accelerates faster.
Take my statements to be, it won't hit a meaningful higher acceleration. Not that it won't necessarily accelerate for longer.
In general, you will accelerate down the hill at 9.8 m/s^2 modified by the incline. No matter how heavy the bike is. (Within the realm of realistic weights.).
Yes, the points you are raising are true. But within the realm of the biker and realistic bikes, not really relevant.
You can say that two larger things attract each other more than smaller things. Especially as they get closer to each other. Catch, of course, is all things on the earth are in the noise range compared to, you know, the earth. If you are talking about gravity and acceleration on the earth, you are talking about 9.8 m/s^2. Pretty much period.
And yes, there are terminal velocities that impact maximum speed. Acceleration, though, is not velocity.
It's clear that there's more force on a heavier object. How much force do you have to apply to counteract a bucket full of rocks from falling to the ground, vs. an empty bucket? Your arm is certainly applying more force to the former.
So then the question becomes Why doesn't the full bucket fall faster? Because it has more inertia, and thus it's more difficult to accelerate. But there's also more force, which overcomes this difficulty. The amount of greater force is exactly identical to the greater inertia, so the acceleration remains the same. The "exactly identical" here is no coincidence.
So yeah, that makes sense.
Similarly, I only mentioned terminal velocity because I said faster. Which could apply there. But my point was focused on acceleration of falling objects. I get that there are a lot of ways to muddy that discussion. As exemplified by my postings. :).
You can use a bunch of words to explain what's really going on there, but it won't change that the brick hits the earth first, hence it falls faster. Unless you can predict the future correctly and communicate this simply to your peers, what's the point of being correct in the terminology?
My point was strictly that many people will falsely think gravity somehow meaningfully pulls lighter objects at a lower rate. This despite days off lessons that gravity on Earth is basically a constant.
That is to say, if your model of speed of things falling is hinged solely on gravity, it will not be predictive in the extremes.
Of course, most folks aren't playing in the extremes, so the simple model will be fairly predictive of everything they do actually toss around the room. Can easily explain why the stack of books fell at the same speed as the basketball when the dresser was knocked over. :)
If only they had told me everything (including friction), then maybe phyics would have made a lot more sense to me. But then again, school math never even mentioned imaginary numbers. School is very incomplete.
Same goes for everything underwater. Which follows from viewing air as a medium you are traveling through.
Are there bad teachers that need to more honestly cover some of the assumptions? Yes. They are a useful tool, though.