News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AGI Has Been Delayed by Tenoke on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @04:33AM (#21700817)
Let me honestly summarize this article:

Part 1 - Musk and others said we'll have self-driving cars all over the place by 2020. Author tweeted that we wont and discusses that for roughly half the article.

This part finishes with a quote by Urmson that he expects self-driving cars to take "up to 30-50 years" before they are really common.

Part 2 - this one quote aobve agrees with the author so he then looks at an actual forecast from a 2018 “Human Level AI” conference where some/most think AGI will occur soonish.

For some reason, he decides Urmson is the only relevant expert, and says these "more large hats than cattle, but [...] people with paying corporate or academic jobs" from the conference must be wrong because Urmson's prediction doesn't match them.

He then does the same for Kurzweil and FHI - they dont match Urmson's prediction either.

Thus AGI has been 'delayed'.

_______

The argument is in my opinion so badly made that I am wondering if the 17 people who upvoted read it, upvoted just because they are anti-AI in general, or because they like the author for other reasons.

Edit: This article is also from May, so it's appearance on the frontpage given the quality puzzles me further.

Re:AGI Has Been Delayed by YeGoblynQueenne on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @05:24AM (#21701048)
I don't think it's very productive to divide the debate about AI and AGI in "pro-AI" and "anti-AI". Brooks is certainly hard to see as an "anti". He has a long career in AI research, he's the founder of at least three robotics companies (that I know of) including the one that created the Roomba, perhaps the only example of a robot that people actually have in their homes today, and in general he has made significant contributions to AI. He's best known for the "subsumption architecture", a robotics architecture that at the very least shook up things in its time (I personally think it's so much old cobblers but that's not the point).

The situation with the current debate about AI and AGI is that there is an awful lot of hype and people saying things that make little sense, like the Nick Cave song goes. That is causing all sorts of problems with public understanding of the subject and people interested in the subject are understandably disturbed. Some, like Brooks, try to redress the balance and show up overblown fantasies of self-driving cars in 5 years or AGI in 10, for what they are.

This is actually a stance that comes from at the very least, a genuine interest in the subject, if not a bit of passion for it. It's exactly backwards to see it as an attitude hostile to AI. Brooks is clearly motivated by a wish to reduce the amount of noise and clear the discussion of bullshit. (And of bragging about his past accomplishments, too, indoubitably). That (the bit outside parentheses) can only benefit AI research.

Re:AGI Has Been Delayed by Tenoke on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @05:35AM (#21701091)
>I don't think it's very productive to divide the debate about AI and AGI in "pro-AI" and "anti-AI".

I agree, but his article very much plays with the different camps trope. If he had made an argument like you did, I would've upvoted it, but the way he makes that argument comes down to 'This one expert's prediction disagrees with a bunch of other experts prediction thus those other experts are wrong', which is silly.

Re:AGI Has Been Delayed by computerex on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @08:07AM (#21701810)
Elon Musk is not an AI expert. Just pointing this out. That's not true in anyway.
Re:AGI Has Been Delayed by Tenoke on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @08:20AM (#21701889)
Nobody is calling Musk an expert in this comment or in the article.
Re:AGI Has Been Delayed by hdhdhe3i on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @04:37AM (#21700838)
I not sure I see the value in treating academics as individuals and not a single entity here. Academic consensus matters more than any individual academic, so why not treat it as a single gestalt entity?
Re:AGI Has Been Delayed by Tenoke on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @04:38AM (#21700844)
You can treat it as a single entity. The questionable thing is then throwing out 'the consensus' because a single other expert gives a different prediction.
Re:AGI Has Been Delayed by The_rationalist on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @04:53AM (#21700901)
What are you talking about? There is no scientific consensus that fully autonomous cars will be available for 2020s. It require necessarily AGI cognition on some tasks and research have zero clue, zero formal roadmap to achieve AGI. Thus any prediction is baseless, absurd wishful thinking. As what I say is true, unless a sound refutation is provided, this should be the scientific consensus.
Re:AGI Has Been Delayed by Tenoke on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @04:55AM (#21700919)
We are talking about the linked article. In it there is a an estimate by a bunch of scientists which has been rejected in favour of one person's estimate. None of it is about 2020 by that point in the article or this discussion.

Perhaps, you are confused because you thought we are talking about a worldwide scientific consensus?

>As what I say is true, unless a sound refutation is provided, this should be the scientific consensus.

This is not what consensus means (and again, nobody is claiming today that there is a consensus that self-driving cars will arrive in 2020).

Re:AGI Has Been Delayed by The_rationalist on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @05:20AM (#21701028)
you are confused because you thought we are talking about a worldwide scientific consensus? Yes.
Re:AGI Has Been Delayed by leereeves on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @05:00AM (#21700942)
Why would fully autonomous cars require AGI?

Yes, an "AI" that is simply a collection of situational task-specific algorithms will encounter situations it can't handle.

But humans encounter situations they can't handle too. A fully autonomous but non-AGI car could simply do what humans do: pull over, turn around, or call for help.

Re:AGI Has Been Delayed by short_sells_poo on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @05:31AM (#21701076)
> A fully autonomous but non-AGI car could simply do what humans do: pull over, turn around, or call for help.

Right or wrong, there is going to be (as you can already see on Tesla) disproportionately harsh response to the AI failing in a car, doubly so if it results in an accident. Humans mess up, and if someone is found to be at fault, they are punished. We also feel compassion to other human beings. E.g. killing another human, doubly so when by accident (ie not premeditated), is likely haunt anyone to the end of their own life.

A machine is afforded no such sympathy, and if anything, the machine is looked at with vastly increased suspicion and scrutiny because it lacks empathy.

We have to face reality here. If the current implementations do a hack job and just handwave problems away: "meh, humans make mistakes too", they run a very strong risk that there is going to be a big backlash, people in general will write self driving cars off as fundamentally unsafe and set progress back 50 years.

A technology like this has to adapt to humans and our biases, the other way around is not happening.

Re:AGI Has Been Delayed by leereeves on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @06:15AM (#21701252)
How did you get from "pull over, turn around, or call for help" to "meh, humans make mistakes too"?

A completely non-AI self-driving solution could be cautious and responsible, and sometimes the cautious, responsible thing to do is pull over.

So while what you say is true, I don't think it's relevant to whether or not AGI is required for self-driving.

Re:AGI Has Been Delayed by short_sells_poo on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @04:04PM (#21706955)
How do you make the system decide that a situation is uncertain? It might have high conviction in an outcome only because it lacks general understanding. You cannot just handwave the problem away saying "oh just pull over when the system doesn't know". You are ignoring the most difficult class of errors, high conviction but incorrect predictions.

This is not a question of reducing complexity, as even very simple statistical tools will sometimes give you high conviction (and yet incorrect) predictions because they are simplified models.

The assumption that error conditions are easier to recognize and control than normal operating conditions is insidious.

For example, an AI could misidentify a patch of ice with very high conviction that it is line marking. A human could too, but we are talking about an AI that has to recognize when it's unsafe and pull over (as you wrote).

I'm sure you've seen the case where an NN taught to recognize wolves did so by picking up the presence of snow as the sole feature in a photo. Only because that happened to be the most distinguishing feature of images with a wolf on it! That AI would only recognize a wolf as long as the photo had some snow. It'd also of course misidentify mere snowy landscapes as a wolf. The mistake is silly, but issues like this are very difficult to diagnose once the inputs become more complex.

Re:AGI Has Been Delayed by The_rationalist on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @05:25AM (#21701050)
I'll give you a trivial example: to my knowledge, current AI cannot accurately drive when there is rain or snow.

The thing is, there are much more situations than a human can handle than the best pattern matcher of the world can. Some situations just require reasoning beyong pattern matching and current AI are all about correlations but have zero causal reasoning ability.

Re:AGI Has Been Delayed by icebraining on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @06:03AM (#21701202)
Both Waymo and Torc's cars are already driving in rain and snow (example: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fKiWM1KjIm4).

> The thing is, there are much more situations than a human can handle than the best pattern matcher of the world can. Some situations just require reasoning beyong pattern matching and current AI are all about correlations but have zero causal reasoning ability.

Sure, but are there many situations where reasoning is required to not have an accident? I mean, humans aren't great at sudden reasoning either, it's something that takes time to engage in. I don't really care if my car just can't handle tricky situations, as long as it doesn't hit anyone or stops in the middle of the highway.