>I don't think it's very productive to divide the debate about AI and AGI in "pro-AI" and "anti-AI".
I agree, but his article very much plays with the different camps trope. If he had made an argument like you did, I would've upvoted it, but the way he makes that argument comes down to 'This one expert's prediction disagrees with a bunch of other experts prediction thus those other experts are wrong', which is silly.
The situation with the current debate about AI and AGI is that there is an awful lot of hype and people saying things that make little sense, like the Nick Cave song goes. That is causing all sorts of problems with public understanding of the subject and people interested in the subject are understandably disturbed. Some, like Brooks, try to redress the balance and show up overblown fantasies of self-driving cars in 5 years or AGI in 10, for what they are.
This is actually a stance that comes from at the very least, a genuine interest in the subject, if not a bit of passion for it. It's exactly backwards to see it as an attitude hostile to AI. Brooks is clearly motivated by a wish to reduce the amount of noise and clear the discussion of bullshit. (And of bragging about his past accomplishments, too, indoubitably). That (the bit outside parentheses) can only benefit AI research.