News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by grecy on Monday December 02, 2019 @09:23AM (#21682520)
ummm, please explain?

Surely the US has by far the highest gun murder rate in schools among developed countries.

EDIT: The down votes are interesting - are you down voting because what I said is not true, or because you just don't like that it is true?

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by lolc on Monday December 02, 2019 @09:36AM (#21682629)
Look up how many kids are killed by cars. Then go see how many are killed by guns outside school. Then check how many are killed by guns in school.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by MereInterest on Monday December 02, 2019 @10:06AM (#21682943)
Cars are designed to transport people from place to place, and cause death as an unfortunate side effect. Guns are designed to propel bullets at high speed, and cause death as the intended primary effect.

There can be other conversations about the effectiveness of public transportation, and how the US infrastructure was designed around cars instead of buses/trains, but there is a pretty big difference beyond the number of deaths caused.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by banads on Monday December 02, 2019 @12:03PM (#21684270)
What is your point? Everyone knows cars and guns are designed differently. Seems like you are trying to rationalize irrational terror. Statistics show a student should logically be more wary of dying in a car wreck on the drive to/from school than getting shot at school. Are you suggesting our students should ignore math?
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by umvi on Monday December 02, 2019 @12:57PM (#21684854)
At the end of the day, the dead don't really care how they were killed
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by sdinsn on Monday December 02, 2019 @02:46PM (#21686068)
The primary function is irrelevant.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by shadowgovt on Monday December 02, 2019 @09:46AM (#21682713)
It is an interesting aspect of human psychology that more people are afraid of a mass shooting in a school, though far more students will graduate knowing someone who died in a car crash than someone who died in a mass shooting.

... but it is how human psychology works, so the school must account for it.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by slothtrop on Monday December 02, 2019 @10:19AM (#21683084)
Well 9/11 is etched in the collective psyche, still talked about, and the toll there wasn't great either. Acts of terror terrify. I don't think it's so much that people worry about the odds, they just categorically do not want to accept regular school shootings as a normal thing. Why should they?
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by Mirioron on Monday December 02, 2019 @10:01AM (#21682878)
It's essentially the same thing as air travel safety vs cars. What seemed to work for air travel is to make it into trivia so that any time this point comes up somebody repeats back the trivia.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by slothtrop on Monday December 02, 2019 @10:01AM (#21682885)
Far more school shooting deaths than any other developed country by my count. You're choosing to brush it off because it represents a small percentage of the population. That's a ridiculous position, you could hold the same if school shooting fatalities were in the 10,000s instead of 200s; too insignificant. The weight is in whether it's acceptable or it isn't, not how likely your kid is to get shot. It's been worse in the past 20 years than the 20 years prior. You're either a) tacitly saying that the certainty of future school shootings is absolutely fine with you, or b) that it can't be helped, which isn't true. Pick one.

We don't have to accept high rates of vehicular deaths either. Automation will make this moot in the end, but far stronger punishment for inebriated driving is due, among other things.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by lolc on Monday December 02, 2019 @12:26PM (#21684497)
> You're choosing to brush it off because it represents a small percentage of the population.

That is what you concluded from what I am saying. Why did you conclude that?

> you could hold the same if school shooting fatalities were in the 10,000s instead of 200s; too insignificant

Oh but look at those magnitudes!

> You're either a) tacitly saying that the certainty of future school shootings is absolutely fine with you, or b) that it can't be helped, which isn't true. Pick one.

I did not intend to say either of those things. That's your interpretation. But again, why did you think that? My take: A good chunk of the population in the US is sold on alarmism and "something needs to be done".

> far stronger punishment for inebriated driving is due

Great. Another non-solution giving the appearance that something is being done.

Then when that doesn't work you cry for still more to be done. More punishment. More prying. It's a cycle I won't participate in. I'm disgusted by it!

Why aren't we discussing the resources these kids had, or didn't have, facing their adulthood? How come they decided the way to feel in control was shooting their peers? They're not the only ones! A lot of kids feel that. Few act it out. Thankfully. Why do they feel that? No matter, let's watch their backpacks for guns.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by slothtrop on Monday December 02, 2019 @04:03PM (#21686912)
> That is what you concluded from what I am saying. Why did you conclude that?

> Oh but look at those magnitudes!

You're saying again exactly what you're being cute about in the first sentence. Not much to deduce here.

> I did not intend to say either of those things. That's your interpretation. But again, why did you think that? My take: A good chunk of the population in the US is sold on alarmism and "something needs to be done".

That's interesting because your "take" completely ignores those suppositions you insist do not apply to you. It it CAN be helped, those who believe so would explore solutions: which one do you favor, and why?

> Great. Another non-solution giving the appearance that something is being done.

"Our calculations reveal that increasing rates of prosecution and conviction for DWI would reduce re-arrests for DWI and by implication drinking and driving more generally." -- https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5472385/

It works.

> I'm disgusted by it!

You're disgusted by putting drunk drivers in jail?

> No matter, let's watch their backpacks for guns.

I never said I was in favor of the clear backpacks, not once. That won't deter anything. I do however think the ease of accessibility to guns is great among disturbed young people.

> Why aren't we discussing the resources these kids had, or didn't have, facing their adulthood?

We should. No one says we shouldn't. And yet, are you going to vote or write legislators to allocate resources this way? I doubt it. It's just another way to brush off the whole thing from cons who don't give a fuck and wish people would just not talk about it.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by lolc on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @02:30AM (#21690591)
> cons who don't give a fuck

Well thanks.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by root_axis on Monday December 02, 2019 @02:16PM (#21685756)
Funnily enough, you need to be trained, licensed, and registered with the government to legally operate a motor vehicle.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by LyndsySimon on Monday December 02, 2019 @04:11PM (#21686995)
On a public road, yes.

There’s nothing legally stopping you from buying a car with cash, not registering it at all, and driving it on your own property.

I recall driving farm trucks (and tractors, etc.) while hauling hay when I was about ten years old.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by blattimwind on Monday December 02, 2019 @09:47AM (#21682724)
Your argument is very, very weak whataboutism. Just because people die of other things more frequently does not mean that you are not supposed to prevent deaths. Your argument suggests that we should not be bothering with a justice system at all, because far more people die of cancer and heart disease than are murdered or crippled, therefore it would be dumb to put any money down for preventing and prosecuting murders.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by lolc on Monday December 02, 2019 @10:03AM (#21682908)
No. If we look at the draconic measures being taken the reaction is way out of line with the problem. If we reacted to the other dangers the same way, society wouldn't function.

Schools are turned into high-security institutions, or the appearances of it. Watching kids for fear of them freaking out is not a good signal to send. It means you only care when it's too late.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by slothtrop on Monday December 02, 2019 @10:23AM (#21683131)
A proper measure isn't about "scale of reaction" it's whether it's effective. These draconian measures are red herrings; I'm not sure they're even meant to prevent anything, because they won't work. They will not prevent school shootings, full stop. It's opportunistic bullshit from legislators.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by shkkmo on Monday December 02, 2019 @10:06AM (#21682942)
Do you have any evidence that clear backpacks have a meaningful impact of deaths in schools from guns? Is that impact sufficient to warrant the culture of fear that is being incolcated into these poor kids?

It's not whataboutism, it's cost benefit analysis.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by blattimwind on Monday December 02, 2019 @12:48PM (#21684754)
> It's not whataboutism, it's cost benefit analysis.

GP didn't make that analysis; they merely implied that nothing should be done about school shootings because more kids get run over. That's whataboutism in its purest form: "We should doo something about school shootings!" - "But what about all the kids getting run over???"

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by umanwizard on Monday December 02, 2019 @12:58PM (#21684875)
Imagine that 1 person in the US died per year by getting hit by stray golf balls, and 10 people per year in France. (I'm not saying this is true; just imagine).

It might be true that France has by far the highest stray-golf-ball death rate in the world. But this wouldn't mean it is a significant cause of mortality, or an important object of public policy.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by grecy on Monday December 02, 2019 @02:07PM (#21685659)
Except that we're talking about innocent children being gunned down at school by their fellow citizens. Utterly preventable and disgusting. You might not think it's a big deal, but the rest of the world is horrified by it.

(Also your example is very poor - you should use per capita statistics so countries of different populations can be meaningfully compared.)

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by umanwizard on Monday December 02, 2019 @04:11PM (#21686987)
How would you suggest it be prevented?

I suspect it's some variant of “amend the US constitution to allow the federal government to ban guns”. This is essentially impossible in practice due to the political structure of the United States.

If your response to that is “well then, change the political structure of the United States” then that would involve a violent revolution or some other chaos, which would almost certainly kill more innocent people than mass school shootings do.

> you should use per capita statistics

It doesn't matter, since my example was meant to illustrate a point, not to be quantitatively meaningful. But since you asked, the corresponding per capita numbers would be:

3 per billion inhabitants per year in the US.

149 per billion inhabitants per year in France.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by grecy on Monday December 02, 2019 @06:10PM (#21688099)
> I suspect it's some variant of “amend the US constitution to allow the federal government to ban guns”.

Sigh. You Americans have been taught to think in such black and white terms. It's either "have guns" or "ban guns". You honestly think there is no middle ground, which is utterly and completely moronic because virtually every developed country in the world has a way of dealing with this that America is convinced can't work. Even though the evidence is blatant.

In many, many countries (including the US actually) citizens are allowed to own certain types of guns, and not other types. I ask how many anti-aircraft guns Americans are allowed to own? Or missile launchers? Or tanks with live rounds?

Clearly there are some weapons that regular people can have, and some they can't.

All America needs to do is tighten down what's acceptable, just like other developed countries do. For example, I live in Canada. I have a large calibre hunting rifle, and it isn't even registered. My friend has a handgun which is tightly controlled. Australia is similar.

So people that "want guns" can still "have guns", but the murder rate is much, much lower in those countries than the US, because other more powerful weapons are restricted or even outright banned.

Further to this, it's a simple idea that people should be required to have licenses and training to own a firearm, just like a vehicle. So what if you need to amend the constitution to do that. You've already amended it 27 times - it's not like the thing was perfect the day it was printed and will still be perfect in the year 3500 or some such nonsense.

Be very clear, I am in NO WAY talking about "Ban guns" or "Take guns away". I'm talking about restricting certain types of guns, and restricting certain types of people, which of course America has already done.

It's really not hard. The rest of the world has done it very well, but you guys are still busy arguing black and white while kids are literally being slaughtered in schools, and people at concerts and movie theatres get gunned down.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by shadowprofile77 on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @09:07AM (#21692309)
>So people that "want guns" can still "have guns", but the murder rate is much, much lower in those countries than the US, because other more powerful weapons are restricted or even outright banned.

That right there is resting on a huge unsubstantiated assumption on your part. I personally don't think giving people the right to bear arms necessarily reduces crime but I say this because evidence doesn't really bear the notion out. You say the opposite without any backing evidence. By way of opposing arguments: In most Latin American countries (including the extremely violent one I live in) private gun ownership is either outright banned or extremely curtailed. Despite this, most of Latin America has murder rates per 100,000 that are several times to several DOZEN times higher than those of the U.S. Another example, in the U.S itself, homicide rates (same metric of deaths per 100,000 people) vary enormously from state to state, county to county and municipality to municipality, and the correlation between this variance has very little visible connection to gun ownership rates or gun access restrictions in those same municipalities. Go look at the stats yourself: this is why states like Wyoming, where gun laws are extremely lax, can have extremely low murder rates while places like the city of Chicago, Illinois or Baltimore, have enormously higher homicide rates despite having local gun laws that are nearly as strict as those of many European countries. Other factors besides gun laws are largely to blame for the higher-than-average murder rate in the U.S (by western standards), not access to lots of powerful guns.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by umanwizard on Monday December 02, 2019 @08:14PM (#21688997)
I agree with almost all of your comment. I think as a matter of policy, handguns should be banned or heavily restricted, and if I were in charge of rewriting the US Constitution (which I think is quite shit and a terrible basis for running a modern country), I’d definitely get rid of the second amendment.

You seem to be arguing against what you think a typical American believes, rather than against my actual position.

I’m not arguing that policy shouldn’t be changed. I’m arguing that it’s so difficult or impossible to change, for relatively little benefit compared to other possible reforms, that focusing on it isn’t worth the cost.

The salient difference between the US and other developed democracies is the US’s uniquely broken political structure. What most people don’t understand when comparing the US to Canada or Australia is that the US can’t “just” pass a law making serious and major reforms. It’s simply not possible. In almost every country, when most people agree a law should change, the Parliament just passes it, the head of state agrees to it if necessary, and then that’s it. Not so in the US.

In our naturally gridlocked and fundamentally broken political system, there are only three ways a law can change in a major way at the federal level:

(1) It is obscure enough that nobody cares about it,

(2) It is so widely supported that it can actually get through the deadlock, or,

(3) It doesn’t go through the legislative process at all, but arises from the Supreme Court changing its interpretation of the constitution.

For example: the vast majority of Americans have believed since the 1970s (as far back as my data goes) that abortion should be legal in at least some circumstances. A majority have believed since the early 2010s that gay marriage should be legal. And a solid majority have believed since 2000 (as far back as my data goes, and to be fair it dipped to around half during the Obamacare debates) that the healthcare of all Americans should be the responsibility of the government.

But because of the brokenness of our system, the first two reforms could only be made by the Supreme Court, and we’re still waiting on the third.

We can’t even agree to switch to the metric system, despite practically every educated person agreeing it’s superior.

Given these facts, if you’re going to spend the huge amount of political capital, years of debates to the exclusion of everything else, waiting for once-in-a-generation supermajorities, etc. that were necessary for even a relatively minor reform like Obamacare, you’re better off focusing on something more impactful, like improving transit infrastructure, mitigating climate change, subsidizing poor people’s access to healthy food, or any number of things that will save more lives overall than making mass shootings less likely.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by grecy on Monday December 02, 2019 @08:25PM (#21689064)
Thanks for the very detailed reply. I guess you're right - even though I've spent 5 months in the US this summer, I hadn't understood the difficulties involved in making stuff better.

It sounds terrible, and I'm sad so many people have to live like that.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by umanwizard on Monday December 02, 2019 @08:27PM (#21689079)
All things considered, I think the US is a fine country by global standards. Canada is significantly better in many ways, but the US isn't exactly Syria or El Salvador.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by grecy on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @09:28AM (#21692472)
I've never understood the fascination with comparing the US to developing or undeveloped countries. It's a waste of time, and only causes more inaction because "everything is fine, it's better than x,y,z"

Next you're going to tell me your pro football team is doing just fine because they're better than a high school team. (Even though they're literally on the bottom of the pro ladder)

Surely, what is ostensibly the best country in the world should at the very least be comparing itself to OECD countries if it ever hopes to improve.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by umanwizard on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @01:33AM (#21700101)
You are the one who decided to compare the US against two of the best-governed countries in the world and then be shocked that the US is (almost by definition) not governed as well. Not me. So why am I the one who’s obsessed with comparisons?

I’m just confused about this attitude about the United States. I don’t see people being as smug about the entire spectrum of countries. I don’t see endless threads on message boards about how unbelievable it is that Eritrea and North Korea are governed poorly. And I think if you went to a forum filled with people from one of those countries and constantly talked about how it’s not as nice as yours, people would get annoyed.

We know our country has a ton of problems. Lucky you for being born in one that doesn’t, but that’s not a license to constantly lecture us about something we have zero power to change.

I bring up countries that people don’t hold to as high a standard despite them being so clearly worse-off than the US to invite you to reflect on why that is.

I think for most the most part it’s one of a few reasons: (1) people conflate geopolitical power with development, and think it’s abnormal that the most powerful country isn’t the most developed; (2) people conflate wealth with development, and think its abnormal that the wealthiest country isn’t the most developed; (3) people are just racist and think a country with a mostly Western culture should naturally be highly-developed and well-governed; (4) people see the unwarranted patriotism of a loud fraction of Americans and want to knock them down a peg.

Not sure which it is in your case, but I suspect based on your comments that it’s some combination of (2) and (4). But both are total fallacies.

Wealth is not particularly strongly correlated with quality of governance: Qatar, Kuwait and the UAE are all deeply corrupt yet richer per capita than the US. Hong Kong is one of the richest territories in the world and not a democracy at all. Uruguay and Botswana are vibrant, well-functioning democracies despite being developing countries. So it’s actually not very surprising that the US has a more poorly-structured political system than Canada, Australia, and most countries in Western Europe despite being monetarily richer.

As for point (4) it is obviously a fallacy because at no point did I ever claim the US is the greatest country in the world or that we have more freedom than anyone else or that Canada is a Stalinist shithole or anything else, regardless of the fact that some percentage of Americans might believe those things. On that note...

> what is ostensibly the best country in the world.

Your words, not mine. I think the US is better than most countries in the world, but worse than Canada, Australia, or most countries in Western Europe. Why is that so surprising or confusing?

> Next you're going to tell me your pro football team is doing just fine because they're better than a high school team.

I don’t follow football at all. I find baseball and soccer much more interesting. Funnily enough the political discussion parallels the soccer standings. Can’t tell you how many Europeans have a smug attitude about how “bad the US is at soccer” (as if that’s some sort of moral failing!) despite us having a FIFA ranking of 22 out of 210 federations. Funnily enough I’ve never heard anyone smugly shitting on the national soccer teams of China, India, Canada (sorry!) or Palau.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by asdff on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @03:50AM (#21690887)
Aweful, horrible, tragic, but a sensational statistic at the end of the day. Crosswalks and the cars that ignore them are a more serious killer, but regulated into local news and not international headline coverage. Pedestrians die every 90 minutes in the U.S. due to cars.

https://www.latimes.com/world-nation/story/2019-09-15/pedest...