News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:It’s not a zero-sum game for Apple TV+, Netflix, and Disney+ by chipotle_coyote on Monday December 02, 2019 @12:40AM (#21680102)
> An actual 'A la carte' situation is that of the consumer being able to actually handpick the shows they want and only pay for those. This will never happen due to the industry being absolutely hostile to the idea...

We've been able to do this with a substantial number of shows for years, though, by buying individual episodes or "season passes" on Amazon and iTunes. Maybe people just don't know, maybe people think the prices are too high, but more than likely the market has just largely moved on from this model for much the same reason that it moved on from CDs: the rise of streaming. (But put a pin in that for a second...)

> ...second best from a consumer standpoint is a single huge distributor like Netflix where you would pay larger fee but have access to practically everything you want...

This is what we all want price-wise, but would we really, truly want to turn Netflix into the equivalent of the iOS App Store for essentially all legal streaming movies and television?

Everyone blames the proliferation of streaming services on rapacious greed, and, I mean, sure, the profit motive is mighty. But it's also a matter of keeping control. Broadcast networks and cable companies are middlemen who not only take a cut of the profit but who also act as gatekeepers; it's a little mad to think that producers would want to free themselves from that system only to rebuild it with a single all-powerful company in the command seat.

Sure, not all the streaming services will survive, especially at the prices Netflix is currently charging. But I'm not convinced that the world is really going to rise up and rebel against having to pay $50 or $60 a month total to a half-dozen providers for commercial-free, on-demand access to hundreds of thousand of shows versus paying $100+ a month to a single provider.

Re:It’s not a zero-sum game for Apple TV+, Netflix, and Disney+ by paranoidrobot on Monday December 02, 2019 @02:03AM (#21680444)
The problem with buying Season Passes is that they're usually a terrible option for many reasons.

They're usually not available until well after the season premiered (12+ months later), roughly at the same time that the DVD/Bluray comes out.

The quality of them is iffy, at best - SD or HD at poor bitrates. Fine for watching on a tablet or laptop, marginal at best on a TV/Surround system.

They're tied to watching on that specific platform, and you're fucked if you wanted to watch on another platform, and if that platform goes away so do all your purchases.

They're region locked, so if you went overseas for a bit, you can't access them.

They're often either as expensive, or more, than the physical Bluray.

Re:It’s not a zero-sum game for Apple TV+, Netflix, and Disney+ by chipotle_coyote on Monday December 02, 2019 @03:48PM (#21686724)
The season passes I bought on iTunes -- which was admittedly some years ago at this point -- actually added each episode the day after they aired on TV. It's my impression that's still the case with most shows; the exceptions are shows on "premium cable" channels like HBO. The bit rates of the shows that I got were comparable to most of the files that I'd previously pirate^H^H^H^H^H^Hfound just lying on the street like they'd fallen off the back of trucks.

The rest of your complaints are certainly true, though. As I mentioned in another reply, I think it's possible that if this a la carte model had taken off, there would have been successful pressure to go DRM-free just the way that there had been for music, although your mention of region-locking brings up that whole "international rights" folderol that's still with us even in the streaming world, so...

Re:It’s not a zero-sum game for Apple TV+, Netflix, and Disney+ by Benji_San on Monday December 02, 2019 @07:13AM (#21681733)
I'm still waiting for "Steam for TV series/Films". I've always felt that that approach would work better as we're unlikely to get a single streaming service with "most content" akin to music streaming". The model works well for distributing games and doesn't have any of the deal breaking problems that you listed (well except for it going out of business, but should not be a problem as long as you have access to the files). I can't really see a reason why it would not work for films or TV series.

Just provide something that isn't worse than torrents and reasonably priced and I'll happily buy the content I'm interested in.

Re:It’s not a zero-sum game for Apple TV+, Netflix, and Disney+ by sammorrowdrums on Monday December 02, 2019 @07:57AM (#21681957)
Incidentally, steam does stream both standard film and VR content - just not much of it. (So steam is already steam for TV/Films in theory)

For example: https://store.steampowered.com/app/468060/PADAK/

Re:It’s not a zero-sum game for Apple TV+, Netflix, and Disney+ by WorldMaker on Monday December 02, 2019 @03:02PM (#21686254)
Steam briefly had a content deal with Lionsgate, but the partnership didn't work out (very few sales) and they abandoned the idea of selling TV/Films soon after the partnership collapsed. They didn't seem able to get interest from any other studio in that time, either. (Plus they were not able to and disinterested in supporting the industry standard Movies Anywhere mutual-DRM-unlocks-assurance system, so for at least some consumers their attempt was DOA from the start.)
Re:It’s not a zero-sum game for Apple TV+, Netflix, and Disney+ by cercatrova on Monday December 02, 2019 @08:57AM (#21682287)
Do you mean...iTunes? Or are you imagining something different?
Re:It’s not a zero-sum game for Apple TV+, Netflix, and Disney+ by Mindwipe on Monday December 02, 2019 @05:46AM (#21681365)
All those also apply to subscription services, and subscription services remain significantly more popular with users.

Sometimes people on HN might have to accept they are not typical users a bit.

Re:It’s not a zero-sum game for Apple TV+, Netflix, and Disney+ by Goladus on Monday December 02, 2019 @10:09AM (#21682977)
> All those also apply to subscription services

They quite obviously don't. Perhaps most notably availability at premier, which tends to matter a lot for TV shows if you have any desire to be part of the conversation about them.

Re:It’s not a zero-sum game for Apple TV+, Netflix, and Disney+ by concerned_user on Monday December 02, 2019 @07:50AM (#21681910)
Subscription services at least don't lie to you by disguising themselves as if they sell you dvd/bluray but in digital form, and all the process resembling that of dealing with a tangible item.
Re:It’s not a zero-sum game for Apple TV+, Netflix, and Disney+ by erik_seaberg on Monday December 02, 2019 @05:32AM (#21681308)
> maybe people think the prices are too high

Absurdly high. Game of Thrones costs $167 on Amazon, which is more than binge-watching it eleven times using one-month HBO subscriptions.

Re:It’s not a zero-sum game for Apple TV+, Netflix, and Disney+ by rchaud on Monday December 02, 2019 @12:19PM (#21684429)
I don't watch GoT, but that price for an 8-season series with ~10 episodes/season (I"m guessing), is about $2/episode, which I think is pretty reasonable.

I have a box set of the old NBC sitcom Frasier. 11 seasons, 264 (!) episodes, probably $200 total. I've had it for over a decade, and it's been a great thing to have while traveling, or moving to a new home where I won't have Internet set up for a week.

I'm happy to pay a one-time fee for content I'll own forever and can watch in whatever delivery method I want, be it Plex, Kodi or ripped to my phone's SD card. Netflix, Amazon etc can pull these shows off their catalog whenever they want, and shove some unrelated show in my face when their search results don't show what I'm looking for.

Re:It’s not a zero-sum game for Apple TV+, Netflix, and Disney+ by lotsofpulp on Monday December 02, 2019 @07:53AM (#21681927)
How many hundreds of hours of entertainment for $167? Granted it has almost no marginal cost for the seller, but as you said, you can buy HBO for a fraction of $167 and still watch it.

People just like to complain. It has never been cheaper or easier to instantly consume media, yet there is no satisfaction (because they’re comparing it to stealing the media, which is illogical of course).

Of course, there are legitimate issues in countries that have BS licensing restrictions forcing people to use a middle man such as cable or satellite TV providers. Also, copyright terms are far too long in the US, so there are valid reasons to pirate. But price/availability in US usually aren’t it, in my opinion.

Re:It’s not a zero-sum game for Apple TV+, Netflix, and Disney+ by Goladus on Monday December 02, 2019 @10:01AM (#21682892)
> How many hundreds of hours of entertainment for $167?

That's not relevant. The simple fact is that $167 for a season is well beyond the budget of the average person whose opinion you're considering. "Hours of entertainment" is (always) the wrong formula, by the way. Nobody needs to steal anything to enjoy hours of free entertainment doing a myriad of activities. Most TV shows simply make no effort at all to price either episodes or full seasons for a wide market.

Compare two ABC shows on Amazon Video, General Hospital and The Bachelor. General Hospital is a daily soap opera with 36 minute episodes and modest production value. The Bachelor has 2-hour episode with higher production values. A full season of The Bachelor is reasonably priced at $20. Individual episodes are $3.

Individual General Hospital episodes are also $3 each. This doesn't seem too crazy if you're talking about someone who might otherwise miss an episode because they are traveling or something. It's probably steeper than it should be, I imagine most soap fans will just read up on what they missed if they care enough rather than shelling out money to watch. But regardless, the full 241-episode season is $735.00. This is quite obviously not priced to sell as a package. No one would buy that. It is simply 241 episodes times $3.00 per episode, which is a generic Amazon price for an HD episode of anything. In fact you can buy the SD version for $15.00. It is clear that no real thought at all has gone into the pricing scheme.

Re:It’s not a zero-sum game for Apple TV+, Netflix, and Disney+ by chipotle_coyote on Monday December 02, 2019 @04:00PM (#21686873)
> The simple fact is that $167 for a season is well beyond the budget of the average person...

That's true, but the number quoted by the previous poster doesn't match what I'm seeing right now on Amazon, where each season tends to run around $25 on Blu-ray.

> Most TV shows simply make no effort at all to price either episodes or full seasons for a wide market.

I'm not sure I agree with "most." You even cite one example of a show that's priced reasonably and one that's, well, not. The "one size fits all" model of pricing that was adopted years ago seems to be built for weekly-at-most shows, not daily ones. I do think the pricing model was too high, though. (I'd have probably tried $2 per show for HD, not $3, and given tremendous discounts, like 50% off, for season passes. But I don't know whether you can feasibly make that model work for a show like General Hospital at all.)

Re:It’s not a zero-sum game for Apple TV+, Netflix, and Disney+ by lotsofpulp on Monday December 02, 2019 @10:26AM (#21683155)
In discretionary entertainment goods, there is no “should be” price, other than the price a seller is willing to sell at and a buyer is willing to buy at.

If the media owner determine there is insufficient revenue and more can be had by lowering price, they can do that.

What is relevant is that it used to cost much more to get the same product, and it’s up to the buyer to determine what they want to spend to entertain themselves. There’s so many options nowadays, if GoT $/hour is too much, then choose something else.

Re:It’s not a zero-sum game for Apple TV+, Netflix, and Disney+ by Goladus on Monday December 02, 2019 @10:43AM (#21683339)
> there is no “should be” price, other than the price a seller is willing to sell at and a buyer is willing to buy at.

That's true in most markets, but also totally irrelevant to the point. If a seller has no idea what the market will pay for something, and so just slaps on an absurdly high price because they don't actually care about this secondary (a la carte) market at all, that's almost the same as not offering the service at all. If an a la carte service is prohibitively expensive, it might as well not exist for the purposes of this discussion.

Re:It’s not a zero-sum game for Apple TV+, Netflix, and Disney+ by lotsofpulp on Monday December 02, 2019 @11:22AM (#21683841)
The sellers in this discussion are multinational organizations with very well educated people working with access to tons of data. I'm sure that for their own compensation's sake, they are busy figuring out how to extract as much value from their content as possible, which means figuring out how to get as many people to pay as much as they can for it.

They've offered the very show we're talking about, GoT, for $15 per month, when you want to watch, on pretty much any device you want to watch it on. Included in the $15 is pretty much the rest of their award winning content. If buyers think they can get a better deal elsewhere for their entertainment, they are welcome to patronize other businesses.

Re:It’s not a zero-sum game for Apple TV+, Netflix, and Disney+ by Goladus on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @09:37AM (#21702479)
> The sellers in this discussion are multinational organizations with very well educated people working with access to tons of data.

And also likely with layers of bureaucracy, internal and external politics, complex business relationships, and other avenues for dysfunction.

> They've offered the very show we're talking about, GoT, for $15 per month

Sorry I'm not trying to be offensive here but you are losing track of the discussion. My entire argument is that many distribution companies evidently do not care enough about offering a la carte consumption alternative to make the effort to price it reasonably, although the situation is improving as companies get their act together and actually decide to act on the market data they have. (Game of Thrones for example is now $25-$30 per season on Amazon Streaming).

As such, the fact that anything might be available for a subscription at a reasonable market price is not relevant.

Re:It’s not a zero-sum game for Apple TV+, Netflix, and Disney+ by cyborgx7 on Monday December 02, 2019 @08:35AM (#21682150)
> It has never been cheaper or easier

That's exactly the thing though. It has been easier. We all remember it being easier, when we pirated something.

The actual sentence should be "it has never been easier while also getting to pay for it". That's just not a very compelling case.

Re:It’s not a zero-sum game for Apple TV+, Netflix, and Disney+ by chipotle_coyote on Monday December 02, 2019 @04:06PM (#21686941)
I think I'm with allstairSH here, sorry; I just didn't find piracy to be easier than paying for content. Your "all you need is a web browser" case is fine as long as there's something you can browse to that has the content you want -- and as long as the use case is something like what you want, which I think you said was watching stuff in a web browser on a low-end Unix laptop. My use case is very often watching on a 4K television in my living room. And, frankly, I'm not sure what piracy method is easier even in the only-web-browsing case for me compared to "browse to streaming site with desired content."
Re:It’s not a zero-sum game for Apple TV+, Netflix, and Disney+ by cyborgx7 on Monday December 02, 2019 @05:04PM (#21687542)
I'm sure their approach is either for a lot of people. But it is a huge burden for me. And if they just gave me access to the files and maybe an api, it would work for both of us, instead of just for you.
Re:It’s not a zero-sum game for Apple TV+, Netflix, and Disney+ by alistairSH on Monday December 02, 2019 @08:49AM (#21682240)
Is pirating something really easier? Maybe I've been out of that game for too long, but between finding good/complete torrents of content, avoiding my ISP finding out I was doing it (and sending me nastygrams), needing to keep a server up and running to download/store media, juggling front-ends as they evolved (Plex hasn't always been around), ...

Today, I have a single device (AppleTV), a single remote, and can stream just about anything I want. And that content is either bundled with Netflix or Amazon, or available to rent for $5 or so. And I don't have to break the law to do it.

Re:It’s not a zero-sum game for Apple TV+, Netflix, and Disney+ by cyborgx7 on Monday December 02, 2019 @08:54AM (#21682276)
Here in Germany, Torrenting legally is distribution, so I don't do it. But find yourself a decent streaming link aggregator, install an adblocker and you are golden. Anything with a webbrowser can play it. No major legal streaming platform can claim this.

Also, you are comparing effort it takes to set-up something, with effort it takes to use it, which I'd argue isn't entirely fair.

Re:It’s not a zero-sum game for Apple TV+, Netflix, and Disney+ by alistairSH on Monday December 02, 2019 @10:53AM (#21683456)
Setting up my Apple TV took 5 minutes. Plug in the power, set up the wifi, and add a few apps. Much easier than buying a HTPC + NAS + finding the best software to install.

Using is as easy as a smart-phone. Click the search app, find content, hit play. Everything auto-updates, so there's no maintenance. VS a HTPC + NAS which take (slightly) more care+feeing to keep current on software versions.

Re:It’s not a zero-sum game for Apple TV+, Netflix, and Disney+ by cyborgx7 on Monday December 02, 2019 @11:53AM (#21684174)
I feel like you are being dense on purpose here. I talk about anything with a webbrowser and you argue about the complication of htpc and nas.
Re:It’s not a zero-sum game for Apple TV+, Netflix, and Disney+ by alistairSH on Monday December 02, 2019 @12:03PM (#21684282)
Also, you are comparing effort it takes to set-up something, with effort it takes to use it, which I'd argue isn't entirely fair.

I thought you were talking about setting up some sort of torrenting/media server system with this part of your comment.

I agree, using a browser is easy enough. But, why would I when the AppleTV is already connected to my TV and I can do everything with a simple remote and voice commands?

Re:It’s not a zero-sum game for Apple TV+, Netflix, and Disney+ by cyborgx7 on Monday December 02, 2019 @12:07PM (#21684314)
Then don't if it's easier for you. My usecase is I want to watch things on a reltively low powered Linux laptop. They have nothing for me.
Re:It’s not a zero-sum game for Apple TV+, Netflix, and Disney+ by pgwhalen on Monday December 02, 2019 @09:43AM (#21682696)
Pirating is easier in the same way an FTP server is easier than Dropbox.
Re:It’s not a zero-sum game for Apple TV+, Netflix, and Disney+ by lotsofpulp on Monday December 02, 2019 @10:21AM (#21683106)
It’s easier to walk out with groceries than stand in line and pay for them also.

There is no purpose to comparing pirating with legal means.

Re:It’s not a zero-sum game for Apple TV+, Netflix, and Disney+ by cyborgx7 on Monday December 02, 2019 @11:05AM (#21683635)
Try walking out with your groceries sometime and tell me again it's easier.
Re:It’s not a zero-sum game for Apple TV+, Netflix, and Disney+ by josteink on Monday December 02, 2019 @04:12AM (#21680976)
> This is what we all want price-wise, but would we really, truly want to turn Netflix into the equivalent of the iOS App Store for essentially all legal streaming movies and television?

You mean like the music industry has Spotify, Google Music, Deezer, Tidal, Apple Music and many many more, and everyone has a 99% full catalog?

You better motherfucking believe it.

This is the only thing people want in the ultra laggard video-streaming market.

Re:It’s not a zero-sum game for Apple TV+, Netflix, and Disney+ by chipotle_coyote on Monday December 02, 2019 @04:43PM (#21687314)
Of the services you listed, to the best my knowledge, exactly zero of them are profitable yet. Tidal is eternally on the brink of bankruptcy. Deezer's situation has been so bleak they pulled their IPO a few years ago. Google Music and Apple Music are essentially loss leaders being subsidized by their owners. Spotify has always burned through money like it was going out of style. And artists are eternally complaining -- with cause -- that nearly all of them make less money under this system than they did under the old one.

You know what Spotify thinks is the way forward for them? Exclusives. That's why they've spent hundreds of millions of dollars on podcasts. You may love it if they're functionally undifferentiated from their competitors, but they don't. Apple and Google can slide because they're Apple and Google, but services that actually need to pay their own way need to give you a reason to pay them, not Apple or Google.

So, sure. Consumers love "pay $10 a month to whoever you want, eh, it's all the same, tomato, tomahto." But it's not at all clear to me that it's a sustainable model in the long run. And I'm pretty sure the reason the video streaming world didn't even pretend to take a stab at that business model is they don't think it is, either.

Re:It’s not a zero-sum game for Apple TV+, Netflix, and Disney+ by httpsterio on Monday December 02, 2019 @03:10AM (#21680714)
There's only so many hours in a day that can be spent on streaming. I think I have something streaming for about four hours a day (I usually work or so something else at the same time) and so far Netflix's offering has been good enough that I don't have any additional subscribes.

If I want to watch something else, those hours are away from my Netflix usage and I get less for my money in those cases. I don't think that a large offering is what should raise the price, rather the hours I spend watching. If I only watch an hour a day Netflix and Hulu for 3, I think the 10USD or so should be split into 25/75 between those providers.

Splice kinda has a pricing model for their samples and presets that could be applied here. A fixed monthly cost will give me credits with which I can purchase what I want and leftovers from that month gets rolled into the next month. If I could pay 10 dollars and get 10 hours of any content on any provider, I'd buy it. I'd most likely end up paying more each month but at least I wouldn't feel like wasting my money paying a fee for content I'm not gonna watch and feeling like needing to have multiple subscriptions rolling all the time.