News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by sgillen on Sunday December 01, 2019 @02:02AM (#21674271)
I feel like the bigger problem than the electoral college is the senate. I think it’s pretty crazy California and Texas have the same number of senate votes as Rhode Island. It made sense at the time and we do have a house to nominally balance that out. But nowadays it just makes some people’s votes count for a lot more than others.
Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by smsm42 on Sunday December 01, 2019 @04:37AM (#21674697)
Why is it crazy? Do you know the UN? Is it weird that countries like Benin or Qatar or Moldova have same vote in the UN general assembly as China or India or USA?
Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by threatofrain on Sunday December 01, 2019 @12:27PM (#21676573)
Why choose the UN whose story is one of inefficacy and being propped up by US power and money? The UN’s relevance has faded and nobody is optimistic for its resurgence. From that context we speak of sensible organizational practices?

The fact is the idea that somebody born somewhere else has way more power has a smell, and people are talking about that smell now and whether they like it.

Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by smsm42 on Sunday December 01, 2019 @06:09PM (#21678447)
> UN whose story is one of inefficacy and being propped up by US power and money

And yet, it exists and nobody is in a rush to disband it. Despite the fact that it's propped by US money but San Marino (population 33,344) has the same number of votes in UN GA as US.

> The fact is the idea that somebody born somewhere else has way more power has a smell

The only way all people can have exactly the same power if they all have no power at all. Otherwise there would always be somebody richer, smarter, more charismatic, more eloquent, born in better family with better education, etc. etc. which will give them more power. Absolute equality is possible only as equality in being destitute and powerless.

Other aspect of it - I appreciate that somebody living in LA wants to have power over somebody living in rural Appalachia, because there's a lot of people in LA so obviously they should be ruling the whole country. But that's not how US as a country works, and I don't see why people in rural Appalachia would agree to such arrangement. So you have to either conquer them by force (and risk that they would conquer you by force instead) or come to a mutually agreeable arrangement, even if it deprives the LA people of their birthright powers of ruling Appalachia. That's the way it works.

Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by tekkk on Sunday December 01, 2019 @05:58AM (#21674898)
Yet in the EU parliament each country gets representatives proportionate to their size and the positions in the EU commission are filled basically how the larger countries decide? So your analogue doesn't really hold and frankly, just because UN (which gives their largest members veto-power), has one country one vote system, it's quite a stretch to extrapolate that to mean it would be a good fit for national governments too.

Or how would you feel if some rural area in your home country got the same amount of votes than the whole capital? Would make perfect sense, right? But all in all, they are so different organizations serving very different purposes that comparing them isn't even that useful.

Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by jpollock on Sunday December 01, 2019 @12:03PM (#21676388)
The EU is more complex than that, there's the European Council, which is not proportional to population (made up of the heads of state, like the original US Senate). The Council is involved in foreign affairs, particularly trade agreements.

This is why Belgium had a veto over the Canada/EU trade agreement. In particular, it was Wallonia's PM who held the veto because Belgium devolved that power.

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/oct/24/eu-trade-deal-...

Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by smsm42 on Sunday December 01, 2019 @06:19PM (#21678490)
> So your analogue doesn't really hold

I think you miss the idea of how analogies work. If I say "the Moon is affected by Earth gravity just like an apple that falls down is" then if you way "but if I put an apple underwater then it'd flow up instead!" that doesn't mean my analogy didn't work. That means you are talking about different things that are outside of what analogy is about.

The fact that EU didn't choose equal representation for member countries and as the result minor countries are powerless is exactly why minor states in the US do not want such arrangement. Just as with an example above about the apple, your counter-example does not disprove existence of gravity - or flaws in proportional representation between sovereign states - it in fact supports it, you just fail to see how.

> Or how would you feel if some rural area in your home country got the same amount of votes than the whole capital?

If that's the arrangement that is the condition of the union between the rural area and the capital - perfectly normal. I know Bill Gates has much more shares of Microsoft than I do and I don't feel bad about it. Why should I feel bad about those things?

Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by jngreenlee on Sunday December 01, 2019 @02:30AM (#21674338)
Remember as well that the Senate was intended as a sort of administrative body, with each states senators being selected by the state government...not via popular election. In my estimation, the removal of that aspect diluted the original concept to some degree.
Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by jquery on Sunday December 01, 2019 @02:47AM (#21674397)
<del>Given our current status as a superpower,</del> I’m not so quick to judge federalism as an “obviously bad idea”. The balance between the House and Senate is a compromise that prevents the federal government from running roughshod over individual states, while still giving the larger states more of a voice. Federalism, in theory, improves the ability of local people to govern their local affairs, and treats states as semi-sovereign. The Senate is essential as a check on federal power over statehood.
Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by lultimouomo on Sunday December 01, 2019 @02:52AM (#21674417)
> Given our current status as a superpower, I’m not so quick to judge federalism as an “obviously bad idea”.

This is going to make one hell of an argument for Chinese communism in a few years.

Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by jquery on Sunday December 01, 2019 @03:07AM (#21674478)
Touché. I still like federalism, though.
Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by edoo on Sunday December 01, 2019 @03:24AM (#21674540)
People like all sorts of things that aren't good for them.
Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by ddebernardy on Sunday December 01, 2019 @02:43AM (#21674382)
It could be done like in Germany without the spirit of the Senate being lost. Something like 2 representatives plus some number that depends on the population.
Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by axaxs on Sunday December 01, 2019 @02:56AM (#21674435)
Neat idea. Maybe we could give it a name depicting its function, like say, a house of representatives...
Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by ddebernardy on Sunday December 01, 2019 @04:14AM (#21674647)
It's not the same. The House of Representatives is intended to represent the people. The point of the upper house is to represent the States. There's no reason why there shouldn't be some weight thrown in based on some objective criteria like population.

The way it works in Germany is every Lander has 3 seats; they then add up to 3 extra seats based on the population. This over-represents the smaller states too, but not to the point where small states can block the whole country like in the US Senate.

Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by axaxs on Sunday December 01, 2019 @11:31AM (#21676195)
So, of course my comment was tongue in cheek, but not completely. In order to get states to agree to unify, they had to give them incentive in representation. Remember that Germany is the size of a US state. It would be more akin to trying to unify all of west Europe as a country. Would Denmark join if they knew they'd get zero representation based of population?
Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by ddebernardy on Sunday December 01, 2019 @03:29PM (#21677612)
The European Parliament assigns seats to member states based on population, but the European Council gives one vote per state. So the answer is kind of -- they basically did join, in spite of odd representation mechanics. And FWIW I think the Council (and its majority voting rules) is as much in need for reform in this respect as the US Senate.
Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by jakeogh on Sunday December 01, 2019 @03:46AM (#21674589)
Germany lost free speech long ago, along with many other things we take for granted. If they are a model, it's what not to do.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RZhVq1M3bhs

Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by FeeJai on Sunday December 01, 2019 @05:22AM (#21674816)
As a German, this makes me wanna cry. The eastern part has taken over the published opinion and political culture after the reunuification, even though formally the eastern republic dissolved while its states joined the western federal government
Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by edoo on Sunday December 01, 2019 @02:43AM (#21674383)
The 17th amendment completely diluted the intent and blew open the doors to the special interest play field. It will likely be one of the primary reasons we collapse.
Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by jrs235 on Sunday December 01, 2019 @07:15AM (#21675120)
The Constitution is/was a governing document amongst how multiple States would collectively operate. The republic has been lost. State governments no longer have representation in the federal government.
Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by evil-olive on Sunday December 01, 2019 @03:00AM (#21674450)
> I think it’s pretty crazy California and Texas have the same number of senate votes as Rhode Island.

A statistic that has stuck in my head is the prediction [0] that in 2040, 70% of the US population will be represented by 30 Senators, while 30% of the population will be represented by 70 Senators.

0: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/politics/wp/2017/11/28/b...

Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by anfilt on Sunday December 01, 2019 @05:06AM (#21674775)
The senate is for the states. If we changed it, some states will have less say. It's also a problem since for example in the west the vast majority of the land is federally owned. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_lands#/media/File:Map_...

How do you think Nevada would react if nuclear testing was being conducted again. How do think Montana or Idaho would react if the federal government gave logging rights to companies outside of local communities. If you reduce the states power and say over federal polices that effect them the most why even have states. Why even have tiered levels governance.

Local governments exist for a reason. Federal laws and polices can effect certain areas more or exclusively. Ignoring those people who reside in that area because the majority outside the area wish to do something is just tyranny by the majority. Therefore areas which people reside also need to voice their concerns. What we currently have is a blend.

The senate and house have to agree on things to get bills passed. The house is already based off population. Having the two houses ensures that states and peoples concerns are voiced through their representatives. States with a larger population already get more say in the house. The senate ensures that each states government is represented equally.

It's also sad that less people vote in state and local elections than federal ones since local government a lot times is much more important.

Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by jrs235 on Sunday December 01, 2019 @07:19AM (#21675131)
I think it would be even better if in order for bills to pass, a majority of the House must pass and a majority of States, via both Senators from a given State, must pass the bill too.

We shouldn't talk about Senator John For voted for or against bill Y, but rather California voted for or against bill Y. The individuals ought not matter except to their State's governments/legislatures.

Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by kortilla on Sunday December 01, 2019 @02:57AM (#21674437)
How did it make sense at the time but not now? The entire point of the senate is to treat each state as an equal entity regardless of population. What changed?
Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by Redoubts on Sunday December 01, 2019 @09:03AM (#21675518)
slavery.

It affected literally every design decision of this nation between founding and the civil war.

Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by kortilla on Friday December 06, 2019 @10:46PM (#21728328)
Most states in the west didn’t have slaves and still joined under the notion of being a state with rights.

“Slavery” is used an excuse to not think critically about things from before the civil war that you don’t like.

Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by bayareabadboy on Sunday December 01, 2019 @02:39AM (#21674366)
You should look up the Virginia plan and the New Jersey plan
Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by SeekingMeaning on Sunday December 01, 2019 @02:20AM (#21674315)
Don’t forget about the house of representatives
Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by lazyasciiart on Sunday December 01, 2019 @02:38AM (#21674364)
They didn’t.
Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by masonic on Sunday December 01, 2019 @04:15AM (#21674651)

  I think it’s pretty crazy California and Texas have the same number of senate votes as Rhode Island
When CA was admitted to the Union, it had a lower population than RI.

CA had the third-lowest population of all US states, yet nobody was saying CA didn't "deserve" two Senate seats because of that.

(Source: 1850 Census)

Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by xref on Sunday December 01, 2019 @04:19AM (#21674661)
Actually, people did say that. Even the founding fathers disagreed on the composition of Congress. It’s been argued for/against since day 0.
Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by billfruit on Sunday December 01, 2019 @02:56AM (#21674436)
I feel the entire opposite, this distribution ensures that all states are dealt in a equal manner by the federal government. India the seats in the upper legislature are distributed unequally between the States, causing smaller states to be marginalized, which could also cause issues. Bigger states could align together and push measures that are detrimental to the intesests of the smaller states.
Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by Iv on Sunday December 01, 2019 @03:06AM (#21674476)
Which is another way to say that smaller state want a way to undemocratically leech out things from more populous areas.

Bigger states aligning and pushing measures that are in their interests rather than in smaller states interests is called democracy.

The opposite is called privilege based on state of residence.

Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by billfruit on Saturday December 07, 2019 @05:42AM (#21729538)
Then what interest would small states have in joining a federation? In my view, a 'federation' implies equality between the states comprising it, and the voting rights of the citizens of the bigger states suffer a dilution, which is the price of joining the union.
Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by billfruit on Sunday December 01, 2019 @03:58AM (#21674617)
Will it be acceptable to the member states of the EU, any configuration that makes some members more equal than others?

Also in countries like India, this could offer a perverse incentive for states to refrain from population control policies.

Also some states having larger populations than others is a historical accident.

Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by Iv on Sunday December 01, 2019 @10:08AM (#21675782)
There are 500 million members to the EU. I am in favor of all of them being equal, yes. We still have to quelch local nationalisms so there are some compromises being made to give state some kind of sovereignty, like the US used to need 200 years ago, but once the reasons for these are removed, remove these privileges.

India: You assume states work against each other and populations automatically favor their states over the federation they belong to. If that's the case, you have a cultural problem to solve first. I doubt this is the case in the US right now.

And yes, there are various reasons for some state to be populous. It is irrelevant with the question on whether all the peoples' vote should have equal weight.