News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to annotate everything by djhworld on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @02:07PM (#21650908)
One thing I hate about annotation in general is everything is siloed.

For example, I have an app on my iPad called PDF Viewer (I think) which is pretty good and has lots of annotating features. I've often used it to highlight pieces of text I'm interested in, or references I might want to follow up on

The follow ups never happen though because the annotations are locked in this app, I can't say, look on my mac to see what I've 'clipped' recently from the app on my ipad, or most other apps for that matter.

Ideally what I'd like is some sort of central place where all my 'clippings' go in a seamless manner, be it from PDFs, photos, websites, whatever.

Re:How to annotate everything by Karrot_Kream on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @07:20PM (#21653583)
Hypothes.is is actually a big champion of open standards. Here's their post https://web.hypothes.is/blog/annotation-is-now-a-web-standar... on the W3C Annotation standard, and you can read the standard to see how to peer your own data.
Re:How to annotate everything by maire on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @02:53PM (#21651379)
I was a little confused about the PDF annotation part of the discussion since this works for me. The author does say that he doesn't have a mac and this might be the issue. It works across all of my devices and all of my apps.

Annotation itself is part of the PDF standard. It is defined well enough that all of the apps I use preserve annotation.

The parts that are missing are both provided by Evernote.

Evernote inserts the major annotations at the start of the file. You can then read a summary of annotations in any PDF app.

Evernote was also the first that automatically converted image based pdfs to "searchable pdfs". When this feature first came out it was awesome. Now I see it everywhere. My scanner automatically converts to searchable pdfs and I have an OCR converter that does the same.

Re:How to annotate everything by djhworld on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @03:52PM (#21651995)
I guess I focussed too much on the PDF aspect, my desire is some sort of system where if I annotate something, be it a PDF, website, image, text file or whatever, I'd like the contents of that annotation (with maybe some context/metadata around where that annotation was from) to go to some central place.

It's tricky though because a lot of apps are siloed, and the interaction ideally would be almost seamless. Like taking a screenshot.

Re:How to annotate everything by maire on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @04:18PM (#21652225)
Yep this is what I use evernote for. When I was working I had to consume and organize a lot of proprietary information and evernote was the only thing that worked. I use evernote clipper in my browser and forward from email. You can put additional information in the note. The generic "web aggregators" don't work for me because they don't work behind a fire wall.
Re:How to annotate everything by j88439h84 on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @02:09PM (#21650923)
This is a really good idea. It means there needs to be standard way to specify the relevant location for a note inside each media format.
Re:How to annotate everything by scottshamus on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @07:07PM (#21653479)
There has been active work on this:

https://www.w3.org/annotation/

It says web annotation but it was born out of an open annotation initiative. The fragment selector supports the most common media types

https://www.w3.org/TR/annotation-model/#fragment-selector

Re:How to annotate everything by hirenj on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @05:41PM (#21652892)
I'm actually partly there with that workflow. I directly annotate PDFs and then let a server side script extract relevant annotations that can be used to place the file in the right folder.

Similarly, I extract out highlighted text, but right now I don't know what to do with it, because I don't know how this workflow should function, especially with regard to updated highlights.

Re:How to annotate everything by Nition on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @05:55PM (#21652990)
Microsoft Courier was designed to solve this ten years ago, by being essentially a digital version of a notebook[1]. You'd fill your notebook with digital clippings from any media and freely annotate them.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UmIgNfp-MdI

Re:How to annotate everything by grblovrflowerrr on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @08:30PM (#21653923)
Yes, this siloing stops me from using annotation features "native" to each app and format as such as well.

Instead, I prefer to exfiltrate information from the silos(apps, formats, etc) and put them into my note taking system. Then I can do highlights, annotations, etc. on my own terms and also get the benefits of centralization such as searching and linking(the OP has another post describing their own system, which is pretty cool[1]). Currently I'm using Notion, which is also a silo of its own, but it's one that gives me a lot of control over how I lay my information out(and an escape plan from).

There are a lot of perspectives on this issue with data silos and walled gardens. But I'm of the opinion that it's a fairly bad state for all of us "end users". Computers to me are about infinite flexibility and malleability, but ironically the tools we have for annotation and remixing are in practice worse than what we have in the physical world. Reading a book in the physical world, I can converse with the author simply by jotting marginalia with my pencil. It's fluid, intuitive, and the medium of paper encourages it(in fact it can't help but be mutated by my use!: pages get bended, stained, torn, etc.). If I want to go further I can add post-it notes to mark interesting passages, I can xerox some pages and create subsections, if it's a magazine I can just tear them all out! That kind of flexibility just isn't available on a computer.

I think it's worth thinking really hard why we're in this state, especially since computing pioneers were actually very optimistic that data and computing would be way more personally malleable than it is now(I've been working on a small comic on this theme myself[2]). For example, check out this short demo[3] of Smalltalk where Alan Kay hooks up a single frame from an animation of a bouncing ball to a painting program, to modify that one frame while also monitoring the loop. Smarter than paper, but way more flexible.

My own thinking lately has been that developers need to think more about how their apps, like your PDF viewer, could cooperate with other apps to achieve our goals. All sorts of deep questions spring forth from here: "what is the best inter-communication system for them to cooperate with?", "how do you design them to intuitive?", "how can you make the UX as good as 'packaged apps'?". And looking at the history of personal computing, these are fairly old questions. The Unix Philosophy provides us with some clues, and its success, even in the smaller world of developer-oriented computing, gives us some hope.

Personally, I'm excited to one day live in a world where my desktop and smartphone and other devices -my computing spaces- feel less like a collection of walled gardens that refuse to intermingle, and more like one big beautiful garden, an ecosystem: lots of small, useful programs, chatting and cooperating, data freely flowing between them, each new program multiplying their collective potential and creating a new ecology, that I can adapt to my psyche and my needs, helping me be a better human.

[1] https://beepb00p.xyz/pkm-search.html

[2] https://twitter.com/yoshikischmitz/status/118845556004515840...

[3] https://youtu.be/AnrlSqtpOkw?t=607

Re:How to annotate everything by karlicoss on Thursday November 28, 2019 @02:16PM (#21659561)
Hey, author here! That's exciting, you basically mirror my thoughts here :)

I agree with what you're saying about siloes, that's especially sad considering that having all this stuff unified and interacting is not some sort of mad science fiction, it's totally possible with technology that we have. It's just tedious for various reasons (one of which is that demand from users isn't high in the first place).

I'm working on a browser extension that unifies annotations and highlights from different sources like pocket, instapaper, hypothesis, or even plaintext notes: https://github.com/karlicoss/promnesia . I've been using it for more than a year, hope to release it soon (few things are specific to my setup, so I need to make them simpler/clearer for other people to use).

Re:How to annotate everything by grblovrflowerrr on Thursday November 28, 2019 @10:31PM (#21661805)
Hey that tool looks awesome, I'm excited to see where it goes!
Re:How to annotate everything by jiriro on Thursday November 28, 2019 @07:07AM (#21656627)
Can I do similar magic as shown in the demo [0] today?

I mean .. is there a system/tool/platform which allows that kind of interaction?

I know about Smalltalk instances like Squeak[1], Etoys[2], Pharo[3] .. Are these capable of what is shown in the demo?

[0] https://youtu.be/AnrlSqtpOkw?t=607

[1] https://squeak.org

[2] http://www.squeakland.org

[3] https://pharo.org

Re:How to annotate everything by grblovrflowerrr on Thursday November 28, 2019 @10:41PM (#21661847)
I'm not familiar enough with any of those systems to definitively say if that demo could be reproduced in them(though I'm very interested in getting acquainted with them). My impression is that all of those environments are quite powerful in different ways though.

Some other systems worth learning more about:

- https://github.com/kenperlin/chalktalk - https://dynamicland.org/

Re:How to annotate everything by j45 on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @04:42PM (#21652402)
Currently I'm using Diigo for inter-platform annotation. It annotates web pages as well as PDFs, with a solid free plan.