News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Fires Four Workers, Including Staffer Tied to Protest by dataduck on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @05:15AM (#21636985)
I don't know if Google's story here is honest, but the two protesters' certainly aren't. They were not organizing anything to do with improving the working conditions or treatment of their co-workers - they were explicitly attempting to subvert company policy for their own political ends, in ways which are highly controversial and likely went against the wishes of many of their peers. There is no reasonable way you could call this legitimate union activity.

While others have rightly pointed out that Google's statements about stalking and harassment are vague enough that they could refer to reasonable activities, I have no doubt that people engaging in this kind of political intrigue would have to resort to some kind of harassment at some point.

I'm not saying that Google is right here. But the fired protesters are definitely in the wrong.

Re:Google Fires Four Workers, Including Staffer Tied to Protest by high_derivative on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @09:47AM (#21638660)
In particular, looking at one of the fired employee's Twitter, even in October, they were publicly bashing their employer, calling them evil, etc. pp [0]

[0] https://twitter.com/Tri_Becca90/status/1187460338784055296

It really does come off as if they are using unionizing as a veil for their political activism.

Shitting all over your employer on social media tends to be symptomatic for a certain character style who was long welcomed at Google, and probably felt empowered to take it further and further, to a point of actively damaging the company's interest. It takes someone pretty tone-deaf to do that and not expect to be fired.

Re:Google Fires Four Workers, Including Staffer Tied to Protest by hos234 on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @05:51AM (#21637156)
Google is a political entity. Anyone controlling info flow is.

There are lot of people in Google deluding themselves that this is not true, while taking decisions that effect millions of people. Who elected them? That contradiction will always create political tensions.

If they don't want to be political they should stick to tech like phones and browsers and sell off Search and YouTube. Until that happens don't call polical objections and resistance wrong.

Re:Google Fires Four Workers, Including Staffer Tied to Protest by anongraddebt on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @06:01AM (#21637211)
There is a difference between 'resistance' (whatever that even means) against your own company versus against fellow employees.

In what universe should a company let workers organize against fellow employees apart from simply having those workers complain to HR? This is particularly specious when organizing for 'political' reasons.

This is the issue: were they organizing for the purposes of 'resisting' the company or were other employees also apart of what they were 'resisting'? If the former, then what Google did seems questionable. If more like the latter, then the people rightfully were fired.

Re:Google Fires Four Workers, Including Staffer Tied to Protest by koheripbal on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @08:13AM (#21637949)
You cannot accept a paycheck from a company, while also be trying to subvert it internally.

It is crazy you don't understand that.

Re:Google Fires Four Workers, Including Staffer Tied to Protest by dspillett on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @08:53AM (#21638233)
If you aren't part of the company you can't subvert it internally because you aren't internal. Your logic seems rather flawed. Unless you are expecting them to work for the company for free while trying to subvert it.
Re:Google Fires Four Workers, Including Staffer Tied to Protest by stale2002 on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @09:35AM (#21638567)
No, they could work somewhere else, while attempting to oppose Google.
Re:Google Fires Four Workers, Including Staffer Tied to Protest by dspillett on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @06:49AM (#21647097)
But that is not "trying to subvert it internally".
Re:Google Fires Four Workers, Including Staffer Tied to Protest by stale2002 on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @07:00AM (#21647158)
Regardless, they should still leave and try to oppose it while working somewhere else.
Re:Google Fires Four Workers, Including Staffer Tied to Protest by darkwater on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @08:38AM (#21638124)
Why not? Being inside the company you are in the best position to actually change/subvert it for real.
Re:Google Fires Four Workers, Including Staffer Tied to Protest by theincredulousk on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @02:32PM (#21641758)
Well you can but now carry a baseline hypocrisy that undermines anything you’d hope to accomplish.

I have a hard time respecting these people for that reason. Hard not to view someone as entitled, or having some form of delusional idealism, when they trash their company on Twitter. Every tweet was made either shortly before or after one their exceptionally large Google paychecks was direct deposited into their account.

Further highlighting this obscure world view, they thought they wouldn’t be fired for these things? Maybe they did know they’d be fired - that would at least be a credible signal of rational thought and motivation.

Re:Google Fires Four Workers, Including Staffer Tied to Protest by dwild on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @10:58AM (#21639375)
You certainly can, what stop you from it? You never had a disagreement at your work? You never tried to convince them that their decisions were bad? Then you were "subverting them"...

The fact that you were disagreeing with their ethics or politics doesn't change a single thing.

It's also completely useless and hurt the conversation to do personal attacks like saying it's "crazy" to not share your opinion.

Re:Google Fires Four Workers, Including Staffer Tied to Protest by bhhaskin on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @11:39AM (#21639876)
HR stops you from doing that. Publicly bad mouthing the company you work for is definitely grounds for termination. If it was any other company in any other state it would have happened quickly and swiftly. It wouldn't be a news story.
Re:Google Fires Four Workers, Including Staffer Tied to Protest by wildfire on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @05:21PM (#21643360)
> Publicly bad mouthing the > company you work for > is definitely grounds > for termination

Having not read any of the tweets in question, I can not say what the content is about.

However, according to https://www.hg.org/legal-articles/can-you-fire-someone-for-t..., speech about working conditions and union organising is protected.

I suspect none of us armchair lawyers will come up with a simple way to analyse these tweets with a lot of context that isn't available.

Re:Google Fires Four Workers, Including Staffer Tied to Protest by dwild on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @01:25PM (#21641111)
> Publicly bad mouthing the company you work for is definitely grounds for termination.

We aren't talking about termination on that ground though. We wouldn't have this discussion here if it was, I would actually agree with it (though I would still find it sad that the company wouldn't try to improve what an employee see as an issue).

> HR stops you from doing that.

Here's the exact quote from the comment I was answering to:

> You cannot accept a paycheck from a company, while also be trying to subvert it internally.

We weren't talking about "Publicly bad mouthing" but about "subvert it internally", or in a less threatening way "changing how the company works internally". I believe you have all the rights to do this even on its paycheck, it's about improving what the company does, which is pretty much what employees are paid for.

Re:Google Fires Four Workers, Including Staffer Tied to Protest by samcday on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @08:30AM (#21638073)
Of course you're entitled to your point of view, but dismissing any other perspective on the matter as "crazy" is, well, itself a little bit crazy ;)

Putting aside the contract law side of this, philosophically what you're saying doesn't make sense to me. If Google were to direct some of its employees tomorrow to restrict the flow of information relating to a hot-button political issue, right in the middle of an election cycle, would it be crazy for some of the employees to attempt to "subvert" the company to prevent that from happening?

Re:Google Fires Four Workers, Including Staffer Tied to Protest by zeveb on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @10:36AM (#21639155)
> If Google were to direct some of its employees tomorrow to restrict the flow of information relating to a hot-button political issue, right in the middle of an election cycle, would it be crazy for some of the employees to attempt to "subvert" the company to prevent that from happening?

Yes, it would be. What they should do in that case is resign. Google isn't the military — you can leave any time you want to.

And while it may not be easy for a black janitor to leave Billy Bob's House of Cars if Billy Bob starts airing racist commercials, given Google salaries and Google's technical reputation, I think it's probably incredibly easy for a Googler to leave at any time.

If you cannot support your employer's decisions, you leave. Think what an impact that would make!

Re:Google Fires Four Workers, Including Staffer Tied to Protest by CydeWeys on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @12:08PM (#21640211)
Maybe you would resign, but plenty of other people would rather stay and fight. You can have much more impact by staying and fighting than by leaving.
Re:Google Fires Four Workers, Including Staffer Tied to Protest by koheripbal on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @08:12AM (#21637939)
Yeah, these folks were brazen. They would have gotten much much worse in the tactics they were willing to use to pressure fellow employees to their political ends.
Re:Google Fires Four Workers, Including Staffer Tied to Protest by bogwog on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @09:01AM (#21638296)
Why are you giving Google the benefit of the doubt, but not to the employee? Do you have more details about the situation beyond that letter Google sent out, or are you just trusting Google by default because...well, I can't imagine why.
Re:Google Fires Four Workers, Including Staffer Tied to Protest by SpicyLemonZest on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @10:04AM (#21638822)
Because Bloomberg asked at least one of the fired employees for comment, and she would not comment even to deny Google's story.
Re:Google Fires Four Workers, Including Staffer Tied to Protest by bogwog on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @10:17AM (#21638952)
So? That doesn't mean they're guilty. There are many reasons why they wouldn't want to give a comment. Maybe they're planning a lawsuit and their lawyer told them to keep quiet.
Re:Google Fires Four Workers, Including Staffer Tied to Protest by SpicyLemonZest on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @10:35AM (#21639144)
There are many reasons why Google wouldn't want to give a comment too, but they did it anyway.

I'm not saying I know for a fact they're guilty. I have no objections to anyone who wants to withhold judgment. But I don't think it's reasonable to look at a clear, unrefuted accusation of misconduct and say "well I don't trust Google".

Re:Google Fires Four Workers, Including Staffer Tied to Protest by dwild on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @11:07AM (#21639471)
> There are many reasons why Google wouldn't want to give a comment too, but they did it anyway.

Which only show that Google has more to win by giving a comment than if they didn't. That could show that steering the public opinion is more beneficial to them than what may follow.

> I don't think it's reasonable to look at a clear

They clearly mentioned "including personal matters such as 1:1s, medical appointments and family activities". After reading the comment and understanding that they actually just subscribed to the work calendars of theses peoples, that do happens to put personal activities there. They made it seems like their goals was to follow their personal activities, which more likely wasn't. It made me realize how disingenuous their memo was and wasn't made to show the truth but to smear them.

This is why I don't trust them in this situation. Is this reasonable?

I want to add that not trusting Google in this situation doesn't means I do trust the employee that got fired. As you said, they gave no response, thus I have nothing to use to either trust them, or not.

Re:Google Fires Four Workers, Including Staffer Tied to Protest by SpicyLemonZest on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @11:45AM (#21639950)
Again, I have no objection to the position that we shouldn't trust either side and have no idea what really happened. But it doesn't sound like that's the position you're taking; you mentioned 2 sentences earlier that you've concluded Google's statement was a disingenuous smear campaign.
Re:Google Fires Four Workers, Including Staffer Tied to Protest by dwild on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @01:17PM (#21641014)
I came to a conclusion based on what Google said. I explained how I came to that conclusion in detail too. You makes it seems like my position is wrong, can you details that a bit more?

You may have misunderstood the last paragraph, where I say that I don't know if I can trust the employees yet either, I wasn't talking about Google, that was explained in the first part of the comment.

Re:Google Fires Four Workers, Including Staffer Tied to Protest by tanderson92 on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @10:51AM (#21639297)
Is it unreasonable because google has never before done things untrustworthy with regards to their employees?

https://www.latimes.com/business/technology/la-fi-tn-tech-jo...

https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2019/mar/11/google-ex...

Re:Google Fires Four Workers, Including Staffer Tied to Protest by SpicyLemonZest on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @11:49AM (#21639994)
It's unreasonable to decide that, because Google has done bad things in the past, every single thing they say is necessarily a lie.
Re:Google Fires Four Workers, Including Staffer Tied to Protest by tanderson92 on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @11:55AM (#21640063)
That is not what 'distrust' means.
Re:Google Fires Four Workers, Including Staffer Tied to Protest by isoskeles on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @11:45AM (#21639948)
Because the actions described are unsurprising for these types of people (antagonistic people who write unhinged stuff on twitter, refer to their employer as "evil", and so on).
Re:Google Fires Four Workers, Including Staffer Tied to Protest by bogwog on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @04:53PM (#21643130)
Just because someone isn't praising a mega corporation 24/7 doesn't mean they're unhinged.
Re:Google Fires Four Workers, Including Staffer Tied to Protest by isoskeles on Thursday November 28, 2019 @01:14AM (#21654999)
Referring to your employer as "evil" is definitely not the same as "isn't praising a mega corporation 24/7".
Re:Google Fires Four Workers, Including Staffer Tied to Protest by overthemoon on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @09:08AM (#21638358)
This is within the purview of union activity. The notion that their peers didn't agree is speculative. At the barest level, Google is an unusual company in an unusual technological, social, and political position, and their employees have the right to organize to shape that via union activity. It's part and parcel of labor organization. I mean, that doesn't mean you have to accept it, but to say that it isn't legitimate union activity is incorrect.
Re:Google Fires Four Workers, Including Staffer Tied to Protest by RickJWagner on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @07:50PM (#21644326)
I've always viewed my employers as a means to support myself and my family. I keep political activites separate. (The same way I keep recreational, religious, etc. activities separate. No use in telling my coworkers everything about me!)

I think such a housecleaning is understandable. I don't force my politics on others, I wouldn't want theirs forced on me. My colleagues do not speak for me in this regard.