News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by atypicality on Monday November 25, 2019 @12:54PM (#21630806)
Axios cherry picked the Bureau of Labor Statistics data for the 12 states that confirm the writer's bias. They should have analyzed all states with low minimum wages vs high minimum wages for the overall picture. Reports are out there showing while many of the minimum wage earners who have not lost jobs from the hourly increase are reporting weekly scheduled hours being cut back across the board.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by Pigo on Monday November 25, 2019 @01:35PM (#21631232)
I've read reports of Target, and similar companies, cutting back hours of many employees. I take such reports as anecdotal, but I didn't catch them talking about this in the article at all.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by Cheyana on Monday November 25, 2019 @01:45PM (#21631351)
I work part-time stocking shelves at a Walmart, and I can say from first-hand experience that while there is talk of cutting hours, the reality is that it won't happen at this time.

Shelves don't stock themselves. Robots are a long way away, no matter what you hear, as the current process is inefficient enough to make it difficult for automation. Robots won't clean poop out of the urinals, or off the floors (yes, people do take a shit where they are not supposed to).

I can also guarantee you that Walmart is not hurting by paying people 11 bucks an hour, and they still won't be hurting if they raise it by a couple of bucks. The CEO of Walmart even advised the feds that they should raise the minimum wage.

Employees are necessary, and will be for a while.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by blix on Monday November 25, 2019 @02:14PM (#21631640)
> The CEO of Walmart even advised the feds that they should raise the minimum wage.

High minimum wages favor larger entities than can leverage economies of scale. Amazon has expressed similar support. I don't think this is entirely altruistic.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by kuzimoto on Monday November 25, 2019 @02:52PM (#21632052)
Yep, larger companies are probably way better equipped to deal with raising the minimum wage.

This will just hurt small/medium business.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by asdff on Monday November 25, 2019 @04:31PM (#21633034)
It will hurt small/medium businesses that can't afford to not exploit their workers.

If your business plan is reliant on having an artificially high staff due to exploiting an artificially low wage, then you don't have much of a business plan at all. "But what of all the poor businesses engaged in a race to the bottom to maximize personal profit?" Let's not think of the parasites here.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by blix on Monday November 25, 2019 @04:52PM (#21633203)
It's not like Amazon/Walmart don't exploit workers, they just do it farther away. And are you really claiming they are not engaged in a race to the bottom? McDonalds is going to be better positioned to invest in automated ordering kiosks than any independent diner... is this because they are a beacon of chivalrous capitalism, or because they have been much better at exploitation?

This is the weirdest defense of oligopoly. I've never understood it.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by Pigo on Monday November 25, 2019 @04:20PM (#21632933)
Well everyone just wants to buy from three companies anyways, right? Just like everyone only wants to visit 3 websites? And everyone really only wants 1 ISP to choose from. /s
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by jcims on Monday November 25, 2019 @02:46PM (#21631998)
It's not altruistic at all. In ten years Amazon (and likely WalMart) will be out of that labor market entirely and their competition will be left with the baggage.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by blix on Monday November 25, 2019 @02:55PM (#21632095)
Assuming their competition will be left.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by dv_dt on Monday November 25, 2019 @01:56PM (#21631463)
I think the unethical part we get into with Target/Walmart/et al is the staffing of multiple shifts of part time work when it's obvious by the numbers that they're avoiding paying benefits for the hiring of fewer full time workers. The systemic question here is if we should allow it to be a financial advantage for companies to do that - especially large profitable ones with a footprint all over our nation.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by alasdair_ on Monday November 25, 2019 @02:31PM (#21631840)
>The systemic question here is if we should allow it to be a financial advantage for companies to do that - especially large profitable ones with a footprint all over our nation.

The tying of health insurance to employment is the core issue. We give massive tax breaks to corporations via tax-deductible health insurance which naturally favors those employers with larger labor pools (who can therefore negotiate the best discounts).

We need to move to medicare for all and then treat health insurance over and above that like any other taxable benefit provided by an employer.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by UnFleshedOne on Monday November 25, 2019 @04:08PM (#21632838)
Ironically, consolidating the same amount of hours in fewer employees suffers the same effects people say raising minimum wage does -- reducing the total number of people involved. Some people get more hours and benefits, others get fired.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by dv_dt on Monday November 25, 2019 @05:00PM (#21633281)
Yes that's a poor and hopefully temporary side effect - but it would get more people covered with medical benefits. It may also not be that bad en effect because unfair scheduling practices for the part time hires. The part-time scheduling is reported to take up essentially full time commitments to be on "standby" with poor stability in the scheduled times on/off. So if one wasn't instantly available to come off standby, one would get penalized - to avoid that, you couldn't take other part time work.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by ohazi on Monday November 25, 2019 @02:14PM (#21631639)
That's to avoid paying for health insurance (two 20 hour employees with no insurance vs. one 40 hour employee with insurance). Minimum wage applies across the board, so cutting hours wouldn't change anything.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by jandrese on Monday November 25, 2019 @02:03PM (#21631529)
They aren't cutting hours with the labor market this tight. That's scaremongering.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by grumple on Monday November 25, 2019 @02:14PM (#21631641)
So for these companies, it might make sense to hire more part-time employees and keep people under full-time if crossing that full-time threshold costs more.

In any case, jobs are created to fulfill a need. Companies don't just hire people in order to spend their new tax breaks or because they get to pay less - they do so to fulfill particular needs they have.

On the other hand, if a company was overstaffing due to being able to pay basically nothing, then sure, some minimum wage jobs may be lost. So the very worst-paying jobs might have been cut down slightly. But I'm doubting this is a major factor, as there's a lot of pressure to not overstaff no matter what wages are.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by vkou on Monday November 25, 2019 @03:48PM (#21632636)
If Target could have cut hours, and maintained revenue, they would have done that anyways.

They haven't, though, and they won't.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by egdod on Monday November 25, 2019 @02:00PM (#21631506)
Axios is pretty biased.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by cosmodisk on Monday November 25, 2019 @05:15PM (#21633392)
To me this is still positive. If one was making 40h x $10 and now does 31h x $13, it means the person has more time to invest in oneself,maybe do some community college course or whatever. I'd be more than happy if my CEO would give me Fridays off instead of giving a pay rise.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by atypicality on Monday November 25, 2019 @05:26PM (#21633477)
It might work out for you personally but it still doesn't address the issue of not making a living wage. If their weekly paycheck isn't any more than it was, they're still coming up short on their monthly expenses.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by cosmodisk on Monday November 25, 2019 @05:36PM (#21633541)
Yes,I'm not disputing that, however it then becomes possible to find a second job,or some side gig. Also, I'm not sure I follow the logic of reduced hours.For instance, a company employs 10 people full time.Then the state hikes up the min wage and suddenly thy all cost 10% more to the company.If the company reduces the headcount,it also reduces its productivity if nothing else changes, so it ends up costing even more to the company. Am I missing something?
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by beatgammit on Monday November 25, 2019 @05:31PM (#21633504)
And if they're not making enough, they may need to work two jobs where they were working one, which results in less time (though maybe a little more money).

There are a lot of variables here that need to be examined before we can decide whether it's largely a success.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by dv_dt on Monday November 25, 2019 @01:20PM (#21631095)
This maybe leads to the question of why we should favor any business to continue operating in a space that may be a net negative contribution to our society. Without enforcing minimum wage, and perhaps least minimum full time to part time employment ratios, we face businesses competing on prices by undercutting labor instead of other avenues of improving operating efficiency.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by darawk on Monday November 25, 2019 @01:24PM (#21631125)
> This maybe leads to the question of why we should favor any business to continue operating in a space that may be a net negative contribution to our society

What does the minimum wage have to do with contribution to society?

> Without enforcing minimum wage, and perhaps least minimum full time to part time employment ratios, we face businesses competing on prices by undercutting labor instead of other avenues of improving operating efficiency.

Some businesses cannot be profitable and therefore will not exist at certain minimum wages, though. The US minimum wage is a big part of why manufacturing jobs have moved out of the US, for instance.

That might be a trade we're willing to make. There may be good reasons to make it, but it is not without cost.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by Flozzin on Monday November 25, 2019 @01:42PM (#21631328)
If a business can only exist if you exploit your labor force, then maybe your business shouldn't exist.

The portion of people that work jobs for fun or a little extra income are a minority. There are more examples of people working several minimum wage jobs just trying to survive.

Maybe there is a compromise somewhere though. How about if you pay the minimum wage, then the owners/stake holders cannot make more than the lowest paid person.

The head(s) of a company making good money(so I'm lumping some small businesses in here too), while saying that they just can't afford to pay their workers a decent wage, leave a bad taste in my mouth.

Off topic, but I feel the same way about all the businesses saying we need cheap labor from Mexico or South America for the businesses to survive, since Americans won't do the job. It creates an underclass of people. If you can't find workers due to wage, and you cannot afford to pay more, the solution isn't to find a class of people that have it so bad, that living in poverty in America is a good option.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by whatok on Monday November 25, 2019 @02:12PM (#21631616)
Businesses need cheap labor from outside of the US because everyone in x industry is using cheap labor that has an artificial ceiling due to years of unchecked illegal immigration. Competition in x industry is now centered around this new labor price point and in some cases is far below minimum wage. At that point, many drop out of the labor force instead of working a difficult and manual labor job that pays less than minimum wage. This is a failure of government to have a coherent and sensible immigration policy and an additional failure to deal with the spillover effects of not having one.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by darawk on Monday November 25, 2019 @03:06PM (#21632210)
> If a business can only exist if you exploit your labor force, then maybe your business shouldn't exist.

In what sense is offering someone money to do something for you exploitation?

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by atypicality on Monday November 25, 2019 @02:18PM (#21631675)
> If a business can only exist if you exploit your labor force, then maybe your business shouldn't exist.

Say bye-bye to your iPhone and all of your other beloved gadgets.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by Flozzin on Monday November 25, 2019 @02:24PM (#21631745)
No reason to say goodbye to them. It would just mean that the price would have to increase, or the industries that produce them will have a smaller profit margin.

Apple has $245 billion in cash right now.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by CharlesColeman on Monday November 25, 2019 @01:47PM (#21631369)
> Some businesses cannot be profitable and therefore will not exist at certain minimum wages, though.

It's also worth noting that some businesses probably can't be profitable without chattel slavery, though it's hard to find examples since the practice has been illegal for so long.

> The US minimum wage is a big part of why manufacturing jobs have moved out of the US, for instance.

No. I'd say the bigger part of the reason was free trade agreements with countries with substantially lower wages, which encouraged job movement for little more than wage arbitrage reasons, minimum wage or no. The average income per capita in Bangladesh is apparently $600/year [1]. Americans would starve and die of exposure on those wages.

[1] https://www.ceicdata.com/en/indicator/bangladesh/annual-hous...

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by darawk on Monday November 25, 2019 @06:31PM (#21634066)
> It's also worth noting that some businesses probably can't be profitable without chattel slavery, though it's hard to find examples since the practice has been illegal for so long.

The difference between slavery and wages is that one of them is enforced by violence. The other is an offer, that may be taken or left. That difference is supremely important, and makes those things completely incomparable.

> No. I'd say the bigger part of the reason was free trade agreements with countries with substantially lower wages, which encouraged job movement for little more than wage arbitrage reasons, minimum wage or no. The average income per capita in Bangladesh is apparently $600/year [1]. Americans would starve and die of exposure on those wages.

I mean, I think we're saying the same thing. Those free trade agreements are what enabled the labor to be off-shored, because the labor is cheaper. I don't think we disagree here.

> The average income per capita in Bangladesh is apparently $600/year [1]. Americans would starve and die of exposure on those wages.

No they wouldn't. Nobody takes a job at a wage that causes them to starve and die of exposure. Therefore such jobs do not exist. You take a job so as to avoid starving and dying of exposure. If you are going to starve and die anyway, you might as well not be working.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by CharlesColeman on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @10:00AM (#21638785)
> The difference between slavery and wages is that one of them is enforced by violence. The other is an offer, that may be taken or left. That difference is supremely important, and makes those things completely incomparable.

Sorry, they're not "completely incomparable." You just selectively pulled out some context for slavery to make that claim, but left the wage-work situation in an idealized context-free zone. The context for wage-work can be starvation or death by exposure, if the offer isn't taken. The fact that there's some side that can be reckoned to have made some nominal choice is not sufficient to legitimize it, just as similar choice is not sufficient to legitimize someone voluntarily selling themselves into chattel slavery. Also, contracts and property rights are enforced by violence, and I highly doubt you think they're illegitimate, so being "enforced by violence" doesn't seem to be that significant of a differentiator here.

If we're supposed to wring our hands about the poor businesses that are unprofitable due to the minimum wage, I see no reason why we should not do so over ones that are unprofitable for other reasons, like slavery, child-labor restrictions, and worker safety laws.

> I mean, I think we're saying the same thing. Those free trade agreements are what enabled the labor to be off-shored, because the labor is cheaper. I don't think we disagree here.

No we're not. Minimum wage laws are minimally relevant to offshoring because the wages in countries were the work moved are simply unlivable in the US.

> No they wouldn't. Nobody takes a job at a wage that causes them to starve and die of exposure. Therefore such jobs do not exist. You take a job so as to avoid starving and dying of exposure. If you are going to starve and die anyway, you might as well not be working.

Exactly. There's no way Americans could compete for jobs on price with Bangladeshis. So in a free trade regime, jobs are going to move to Bangladesh regardless of any American minimum wage laws. By itself, free trade is necessary and sufficient for extensive offshoring of American jobs.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by xyzzyz on Monday November 25, 2019 @02:16PM (#21631664)
> Americans would starve and die of exposure on those wages.

No, they wouldn’t. Americans survived on wages lower than that in the past. They would simply have to adjust their lifestyle to look more like the one of Bangladeshi —- unless you assume that Americans are somehow extremely inept compared to Bangladeshi.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by macintux on Monday November 25, 2019 @04:59PM (#21633275)
You can’t be serious.

The only way to survive on $600/year is to live somewhere that’s a viable income. There’s nowhere in the US where you can do that, unless you count unofficial homeless encampments, and I’d wager anyone living there who only brought in $600/year in government benefits and other sources would quickly die.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by CharlesColeman on Monday November 25, 2019 @02:39PM (#21631930)
>> Americans would starve and die of exposure [in America] on [Bangladeshi] wages.

> No, they wouldn’t.... [Americans] would simply have to adjust their lifestyle to look more like the one of Bangladeshi

I appreciate your honesty, but listen to what you're saying. No one "simply" accepts massive regressions in living standards across large swaths of the economy, and that's exactly what you'd need for Bangladeshi wages to be livable in the US. That kind of thing leads to revolutions, and rightly so.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by asdff on Monday November 25, 2019 @04:36PM (#21633065)
Are you implying that the people currently starving and dieing of exposure living in bangladeshi-style slums right on the streets of San Fransisco is an acceptable outcome? We should be paying more people a wage that forces them to live like that?

Or do we look at the growing inequality in this country and realize we can definitely afford to add a couple bucks to a poor guys hourly rate so he doesn't have to give 60% of his income to the parasite landlord every month.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by atypicality on Monday November 25, 2019 @05:22PM (#21633449)
What do you have against landlords? Every situation has an economic element to it. It shouldn't be assumed that every person who is a boss, landlord or business owner is assumed to be some sort of crook for having money. Maybe the landlord is upside down on his property and takes a loss every month. You just don't know.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by jonhendry18 on Monday November 25, 2019 @01:52PM (#21631425)
"Some businesses cannot be profitable and therefore will not exist at certain minimum wages, though"

If they require lower wages in order to be sufficiently profitable, but those lower wages mean the employees have to rely on taxpayer funded safety nets to survive, maybe the business shouldn't exist?

Because otherwise this is essentially a demand for taxpayers to subsidize the profits of a private enterprise.

If Target and Walmart need employees on food stamps in order to make a profit, maybe we should just fully nationalize them instead of just subsidizing their profits.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by gamblor956 on Monday November 25, 2019 @01:33PM (#21631217)
The markup on most products is such that US businesses could easily manufacture their products in the US at current minimum wages and still handily profit.

They simply choose not to, because that means they have to pay their executives and owners less money and no executive wants to forego their country club membership, each of which is equal to the salary and benefits of 3 or more line workers, or their annual bonus, which is equal to the salary benefits of between 5 and 20 line workers. Or hell, the excess of what their salary is over the value they actually provide to the company (usually just a lit bit over an individual line workers' contribution).

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by OnlineGladiator on Monday November 25, 2019 @01:42PM (#21631321)
> The markup on most products is such that US businesses could easily manufacture their products in the US at current minimum wages and still handily profit.

What data are you basing this on?

You're also ignoring the most important part - consumer choice. People buy cheap shit because it's cheaper. It's the foundation of Walmart. So let's say the companies here did manufacture here, but then a foreign competitor offers a significantly cheaper product - how do you reconcile that without going out of business?

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by asdff on Monday November 25, 2019 @04:39PM (#21633095)
If you were a small business you should be spending your time lobbying for tariffs against exploitative international manufacturers or even local subsidies instead of lobbying to pay your employees less out of your bucket of gold every year.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by didibus on Monday November 25, 2019 @01:54PM (#21631447)
I think that's precisely the issue. Economists thought that driving an open market would push up wages as efficiencies come back around, thus both driving for cheaper goods and higher wages. But they didn't anticipate exactly the effect of globalism and the exodus to China happening so quick.

Foreign industries could be taxed to some level relative to what their workers are paid and their working conditions to even out the domestic companies disadvantages maybe. That's already happening to some extent.

I don't know if that or fixed minimum wage is the solution by the way. But I'm saying clearly that's the problem. Companies don't all start with an equal footing, and that can put out of balance the free economy.

https://foreignpolicy.com/2019/10/22/economists-globalizatio...

Edit: Eh, I forgot that you can't really have rational discussions on slightly political topics. If you think something I said isn't logical or true, please partake in the conversation.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by UnFleshedOne on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @11:58AM (#21640106)
> both driving for cheaper goods and higher wages

This actually works -- cheaper goods for developed countries and higher wages for China. On the balance this is a win economically. Environmentally it is the opposite -- better for developed countries and worse for manufacturing ones.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by RoyTyrell on Monday November 25, 2019 @01:40PM (#21631292)
> the excess of what their salary is over the value they actually provide to the company (usually just a lit bit over an individual line workers' contribution).

Is that for every CEO at every corporation? How are you measuring and making that determination? Does that hold true for other executive positions?

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by sjg007 on Monday November 25, 2019 @02:11PM (#21631602)
Same with illegal immigration. Some businesses won't be profitable or exist without them.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by Eric_WVGG on Monday November 25, 2019 @02:08PM (#21631575)
> > This maybe leads to the question of why we should favor any business to continue operating in a space that may be a net negative contribution to our society > What does the minimum wage have to do with contribution to society?

Seven years ago, the McDonalds corporation issued memos to employees instructing on how to file for SNAP (food stamps). Rather than paying employees what they need to survive, McDonalds was effectively shifting that cost onto taxpayers. https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2013/10/instead...

A system where jobs provide money to consumers who participate in the economy, pay into social security, etc. is one that makes a "positive contribution" to societal balance sheet. One that hoards its income and doesn't pay into the system costs society money, hence "a net negative".

"Some businesses cannot be profitable and therefore will not exist at certain minimum wages, though." Right, but some businesses can pay minimum-wage-or-higher and be profitable, but the CEOs figured out that they can just keep that money for themselves and shift it onto the welfare system.

This is why a lot of critics of modern capitalism claim that we already have socialism, we're just not doing it efficiently.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by maxk42 on Monday November 25, 2019 @01:36PM (#21631243)
On the contrary, many of the lowest-paid jobs are lowest-paid because they're non-profits, volunteer organizations, or other organizations that provide some social benefit. Raising the minimum wage prevents these organizations from doing as much good for society.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by FabHK on Monday November 25, 2019 @02:01PM (#21631516)
> weekly scheduled hours being cut back across the board.

So you're saying the minimum wage laws are leading to more jobs? (If everyone works less, then more people must presumably be hired.)

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by sobhaobnONJ on Monday November 25, 2019 @02:31PM (#21631831)
The people being hired are not the ones having their hours scaled back. If demand for labor rises at a natural average over time in an area then minimum wage could reduce scheduled hours while overall growth still creates job demand. It'd be more interesting to see the effects of minimum wage increases on the average yearly income for employees in the area for that reason.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by born_a_skeptic on Monday November 25, 2019 @03:26PM (#21632412)
When I see Axios articles I automatically think, "Well, it's probably pushing some sort of liberal agenda or policy." Just being completely honest.
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by mistermann on Monday November 25, 2019 @03:43PM (#21632582)
I'm not familiar with Axios, but this article had a rather strong taste of propaganda to me.

"The bottom line: Opposition to higher minimum wage laws is increasingly based in ideology and orthodoxy rather than real-world evidence, economists say."

I also see little acknowledgement of the fact that this sort of analysis is extremely complex, that there are many variables in play, in ways that are not terribly obvious or easy to measure.

Whenever I see people characterizing people who are increasingly suspicious of experts as ~stupid, I feel the urge to ask them if they believe this style of narratives-presented-as-facts plays no role in the phenomenon, and whether they've ever considered the idea prior to my question.

Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by IshKebab on Monday November 25, 2019 @01:59PM (#21631495)
If their total pay isn't less that sounds pretty great!
Re:Job loss predictions over rising minimum wages haven't co... by atypicality on Monday November 25, 2019 @02:14PM (#21631648)
Agreed. But that wasn't the end goal for the $15hour movement. The entire effort was touting 'living wage' so making the same take home check isn't helping anyone except for maybe less money spent on day care for their kids.