News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:CUDA Toolkit Release Notes by andybak on Sunday November 24, 2019 @05:05AM (#21619433)
Any title that gives us a clue why the story is worthy of note. At the moment it's frustrating as you have to click through to find out if you want to click through.

(title at the time of my comment was "CUDA Toolkit Release Notes")

Re:CUDA Toolkit Release Notes by pilooch on Sunday November 24, 2019 @06:38AM (#21619773)
As an ML + open source developer for over 10y, MacOS support for deep learning is already long gone, Linux is the prime AI/ML OS. However, Apple and NVidia parting away is a good omen for GPU competition I believe. Whatever Apple hw comes up with, if usable outside MacOS software stack, it'd be an interesting alternative.
Re:CUDA Toolkit Release Notes by navaati on Sunday November 24, 2019 @08:36AM (#21620317)
> if usable outside MacOS software stack

Except, of course, according to Apple’s history regarding the matter, it won’t.

Re:CUDA Toolkit Release Notes by iguy on Sunday November 24, 2019 @09:02AM (#21620470)
Unless the swift-for-tensorflow effort cross-fertilises something interesting, I suppose? If you were asked to guess the most likely path by which AMD cards become widely useful, perhaps this would be as good a bet as any.
Re:CUDA Toolkit Release Notes by vkaku on Sunday November 24, 2019 @11:21AM (#21621322)
Someone will need to get ROCm on MacOS, or something like that.

God, I really hope AMD goes out of the deal with Apple as well. I'd rather people abandon macOS early than have to put up with Apple imposed implementations like Metal, HLS and Webkit.

At the end of the day, Apple should realize that having money alone does not make you , by any means, a popular company. It's the little things that make people sign up for Apple.

Re:CUDA Toolkit Release Notes by vkaku on Sunday November 24, 2019 @11:09AM (#21621234)
Emphasis on `if usable`

I don't think the general crowd will adapt itself to go on to Apple's stack unless it is radically better.

Till Apple gets its developers to use what it makes, by enforcing it on its App Store, like the way it pushed people for Webkit - Otherwise it won't have takers.

Re:CUDA Toolkit Release Notes by gbrown on Sunday November 24, 2019 @09:03AM (#21620474)
crosses fingers in OpenCL
Re:CUDA Toolkit Release Notes by sergiomattei on Sunday November 24, 2019 @11:10AM (#21621243)
Agreed. Quite frankly the new title doesn't help people understand why it's newsworthy.
Re:CUDA Toolkit Release Notes by dang on Sunday November 24, 2019 @02:24PM (#21622637)
By the time we changed the title, the comments were making that quite clear.
Re:CUDA Toolkit Release Notes by sergiomattei on Sunday November 24, 2019 @04:20PM (#21623508)
Good point.
Re:CUDA Toolkit Release Notes by pvg on Sunday November 24, 2019 @07:06AM (#21619907)
As the whiner who whined about this title - the story isn't worthy of note at all, other than someone fishing a supposedly-important detail out of it and putting it in the title. Apple hasn't as much as sold a machine with an Nvidia GPU for many years. This non-editorializing thing is explained in great illustrative detail here:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21617907

Re:CUDA Toolkit Release Notes by jsgo on Sunday November 24, 2019 @09:52AM (#21620729)
Perhaps they haven’t sold Nvidia hardware, but the allowance of Nvidia’s web drivers so that I could connect my eGPU w/ GTX 1080 to the 13in Macbook Pro was one of the primary reasons I bought the MBP.

It is fine if they want to kill off features off upcoming hardware, but killing off the capacity to use something that was used for months is not the best look. If Metal Only was the goal, add a prompt when someone enables said web drivers that they’re going off the reservation snd that they assume the risk.

These release notes seem to be Nvidia giving up the ghost that they’re going to be able to resolve this dispute and High Sierra is the last release where all but a couple of really old Nvidia GPUs work.

Re:CUDA Toolkit Release Notes by dahart on Sunday November 24, 2019 @10:57AM (#21621130)
Yep; you’re right. And Metal isn’t the only goal. Preventing people from going off the reservation is the goal. I can see both sides; there are both upsides and downsides for both Apple and their customers. Either way, at this point, Apple’s strategy is clear and widely known. It sucks you can’t use eGPU with Mac, and I’d still be primarily using a Mac if you could, but it’s no longer an available choice. As consumers, the only option now is to vote with our pocketbooks.
Re:CUDA Toolkit Release Notes by pvg on Sunday November 24, 2019 @11:15AM (#21621290)
The configuration you're describing was never officially supported - I'm not arguing the changes in this support is a good or bad thing just addressing the concern Nvidia might be trying to sneak something super-important past people in release notes and thus the editorializing should perhaps get a pass.
Re:CUDA Toolkit Release Notes by minimaxir on Sunday November 24, 2019 @01:02PM (#21622086)
Even AMD eGPUs have a lot of compromises (e.g. HDCP issues), although those may or may not be Apple's fault.

I bought a lower-spec MBP with the expectation of using eGPUs (in the hope Apple and Nvidia would make up), but it's good to see it confirmed that it won't be worthwhile.

Re:CUDA Toolkit Release Notes by andybak on Sunday November 24, 2019 @07:13AM (#21619939)
1. I didn't know the fact highlighted in the original title 2. Doesn't this have an impact on eGPUs, Hackintoshes and other customizations?

It basically means heavy GPU-based work is pretty much a Linux/Windows only thing now. Huge problem as machine learning starts to become an interest topic for people in the art and design community.

Re:CUDA Toolkit Release Notes by dahart on Sunday November 24, 2019 @10:21AM (#21620895)
> Huge problem as machine learning starts to become an interest topic for people in the art and design community.

Out of curiosity, what Mac apps are you and other professionals using for art & design? Being a part time artist & ex-Mac person, I thought the stereotype of Mac being an artist/designer’s machine was almost gone. Most professional artists I know have had to switch away from Mac. To be fair, most artists I know are doing 3d and need GPUs. But I’m honestly wondering what else is keeping people on Mac and how well the platform is serving professional designers and artists today.

Re:CUDA Toolkit Release Notes by pvg on Sunday November 24, 2019 @07:23AM (#21619978)
For 1., again, the standard isn't 'someone might not have known a detail in the story', it's 'does the title represent the story'. If that particular detail is worthy of highlighting, it's easy to find (or even write!) a story about that or point it out in a comment. For 2., that's been the unfortunate case for ages but more importantly, see 1.
Re:CUDA Toolkit Release Notes by andybak on Sunday November 24, 2019 @12:00PM (#21621640)
It's not a "detail" if it's pretty much the only reason to post or read the story in the first place.
Re:CUDA Toolkit Release Notes by pvg on Sunday November 24, 2019 @12:22PM (#21621813)
Sure, it might be an important detail to you but that's just not how titling HN stories works, as explained at great length in the thing linked in my comment and many other places.