News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Her Amazon Purchases Are Real, the Reviews Are Fake by dgellow on Thursday November 21, 2019 @08:42AM (#21593860)
Is the issue of counterfeit products a worldwide problem with Amazon? I'm just asking because I'm in Europe and use Amazon quite often for electronics, and haven't faced issues so far. Could it be that the problem is mostly in the US?

It could be that I just avoided counterfeited goods by chance, or just didn't notice...

Re:Her Amazon Purchases Are Real, the Reviews Are Fake by giancarlostoro on Thursday November 21, 2019 @08:50AM (#21593930)
I am in America and have yet to get screwed by a counterfeit. I wonder if you might be on to something though. Maybe the counterfeits are all stored in specific states and ship from there more frequently since I assume Amazon wants to ship from the closest warehouse to you. Would be good to know what state most of these people live in to see if thats just the pattern. I say this cause I have always heard you can buy counterfeits in NY of any major clothing brand or even electronics.
Re:Her Amazon Purchases Are Real, the Reviews Are Fake by amerkhalid on Thursday November 21, 2019 @10:50AM (#21595323)
I have stopped buying from Amazon because I have received a few product which had something off but I could not tell what.

For example, we used to buy GE fridge filters from Amazon. Every once in a while we would receive a filter which would change taste of water in weird way. New filters usually make water taste slightly different but it was just a bit more off. But we used to ignore that until we start reading about fake products.

So next time when we experienced weird water taste with filter change, I carefully checked our old filter with the new one and sure enough there were subtle differences. Really impossible to notice accidentally.

Since then we started buying filters from Home Depot, and we have had pretty consistent experience so far.

Re:Her Amazon Purchases Are Real, the Reviews Are Fake by MichaelApproved on Thursday November 21, 2019 @09:05AM (#21594081)
> I am in America and have yet to get screwed by a counterfeit.

Well, how do you know?

Maybe they’ve been good counterfeits?

Another possibility is that you’ve never seen the genuine version, so you don’t know what to compare the counterfeit to.

Re:Her Amazon Purchases Are Real, the Reviews Are Fake by thaumasiotes on Thursday November 21, 2019 @10:41AM (#21595192)
>> I am in America and have yet to get screwed by a counterfeit.

> Well, how do you know?

> Maybe they’ve been good counterfeits?

Well, sure. I've bought SD cards (frequently mentioned as a problem category) off of Amazon without ever experiencing a problem. Maybe I've received counterfeits, but I still think it's fair to say I've never gotten screwed by a counterfeit.

Re:Her Amazon Purchases Are Real, the Reviews Are Fake by lotsofpulp on Thursday November 21, 2019 @11:31AM (#21595879)
How many people will be able to discern if they're getting screwed by a counterfeit SD card?
Re:Her Amazon Purchases Are Real, the Reviews Are Fake by boring_twenties on Thursday November 21, 2019 @01:49PM (#21597825)
I mean the downside to a counterfeit card is probably that it is going to fail very quickly. I'd think even grandma would notice if she can't access her photos after a few months?
Re:Her Amazon Purchases Are Real, the Reviews Are Fake by crusty on Thursday November 21, 2019 @05:42PM (#21600536)
I've been screwed by a counterfeit SD card and it seems like the "manufacturer" probably took older, smaller capacity cards where the back stock had outlived demand for those specs and just reprogrammed them to identify as a higher capacity, premium SD from Samsung, reprinted the label (very well), got their packaging basically identical to Samsung's, sent them to Amazon where Amazon seemingly decided they should be co-mingled with the Samsung-supplied cards and sold off as such.

For the consumer, I only realized something was wrong when I filled the actual size of the SD card and started getting errors, but still those errors came from my phone and basically said the SD want being detected and to reformat. So it could have been a phone issue. Only after going down the internet's Amazon counterfeit rabbit hole and then finding a program that checks counterfeit cards did I find out the card was actually a 32GB card with probably some awful I/O rates and not the 128GB that it was a announcing to devices. And for all that time, energy, frustration, money, and data lost to phone reformats, Amazon didn't give two craps. They said I was outside the return window and if my item was defective I should contact the manufacturer. They probably only didn't say "seller" because they were the seller, no 3rd party. It clearly want on the CS script to consider that you can't call the legitimate manufacturer about a defective counterfeit product sold as legitimate by the same business they count on to sell their legitimate products.

Re:Her Amazon Purchases Are Real, the Reviews Are Fake by lotsofpulp on Thursday November 21, 2019 @02:01PM (#21598004)
It could also be slower read and write speeds. Also, I'm not sure of the exact numbers, but the difference in expected life of the product could be in years, such as 1 year for a counterfeit versus 10 years for a brand name.
Re:Her Amazon Purchases Are Real, the Reviews Are Fake by Filligree on Thursday November 21, 2019 @12:33PM (#21596797)
On this website?
Re:Her Amazon Purchases Are Real, the Reviews Are Fake by lotsofpulp on Thursday November 21, 2019 @02:02PM (#21598019)
Maybe more on this website, but how many people test read/write speeds of SD cards, or track their lifespan.
Re:Her Amazon Purchases Are Real, the Reviews Are Fake by londons_explore on Thursday November 21, 2019 @09:43AM (#21594449)
I buy almost entirely counterfeit/knockoff goods. Quality is variable, but paying only 20% of the retail price for a similarish item works out well for me.

I don't really understand why anyone would buy originals to be honest...

I am an engineer, so claims like 'it's made in china and might explode' I can take with an appropriate sized grain of salt. One thing to watch out for is that chinese made devices are not expected to be safe if you don't follow the instructions. For example, if a device says 'do not charge for more than 2 hours', that means if you leave it on charge overnight it will catch fire. In the USA, devices need to be safe even if the instructions aren't followed.

Re:Her Amazon Purchases Are Real, the Reviews Are Fake by hombre_fatal on Thursday November 21, 2019 @10:05AM (#21594736)
This has got to be a troll post. How could anyone think it's acceptable for something to catch fire if they accidentally leave it plugged in too long? Do you set a timer each time you plug something in? Do counterfeiter items always come with their modified counterfeit-only instructions with these new rules to follow? Do they say "Note: this is a counterfeit so we replaced the food bowl's paint with a cheaper lead-based one, thus do not eat from it, especially not your children"?

Oops, I took the bait.

Re:Her Amazon Purchases Are Real, the Reviews Are Fake by londons_explore on Thursday November 21, 2019 @03:32PM (#21599254)
Only 40 years ago, this was the case in the USA.. with rechargeable AA batteries. Chargers at the time didn't have detection for the battery being full, and after a few hours on an inappropriately sized fast charger, a battery would emit steam.

China is just a little behind, and the public has quickly come to assume devices are safe even if abused.

Re:Her Amazon Purchases Are Real, the Reviews Are Fake by logfromblammo on Thursday November 21, 2019 @10:52AM (#21595347)
Isn't there a little engineering principle called "Murphy's Law"? If I recall correctly, the gist of it is "If something can be done incorrectly, it eventually will be done incorrectly."

Designing with Murphy's Law in mind is essential for not killing your customers and burning down their cities, or downing their passenger airliners, or crashing their cars.

It doesn't even cost more, in a company that can be sued for the liabilities of their defective products.

Re:Her Amazon Purchases Are Real, the Reviews Are Fake by rdtwo on Thursday November 21, 2019 @09:59AM (#21594664)
I don’t know what industry you work on where it’s ever ok for things to catch on fire if the user doesn’t follow instructions, but at least in mine even the word fire is out of bounds.
Re:Her Amazon Purchases Are Real, the Reviews Are Fake by zentiggr on Thursday November 21, 2019 @10:26AM (#21594987)
Marketing?
Re:Her Amazon Purchases Are Real, the Reviews Are Fake by boring_twenties on Thursday November 21, 2019 @02:06PM (#21598081)
So the worst case scenario is all the marketing departments burn down?
Re:Her Amazon Purchases Are Real, the Reviews Are Fake by zentiggr on Friday November 22, 2019 @08:16AM (#21605253)
Best case scenario?

I've always thought there should be a .adv TLD, and if you're caught serving anything but first party information outside of that, there would be severe penalties.

Let one TLD take all the cutthroat inhumane tracking, malware, scum adserving, all of it, and let the rest of us browse in peace.

Re:Her Amazon Purchases Are Real, the Reviews Are Fake by Noumenon72 on Thursday November 21, 2019 @08:38PM (#21601700)
Crowding movie theaters.
Re:Her Amazon Purchases Are Real, the Reviews Are Fake by crusty on Thursday November 21, 2019 @06:34PM (#21600931)
Either a trip or someone who buys counterfeit products on the street, where information in the market is known. If you buy a Gucci bag on the street, you know it's not really Gucci and you price accordingly. The same for DVDs, or electronics in a shady camera store. This is different. This is deception by a company that wants you to believe you're buying the real thing and charging you in accordance.
Re:Her Amazon Purchases Are Real, the Reviews Are Fake by eternalny1 on Thursday November 21, 2019 @11:48AM (#21596092)
See the review on this product titled "Changed the formula?" ...

This is common, where a manufacturer will reduce costs by taking a formerly imported luxury product and re-create it with different ingredients from a different manufacturer, but all the reviews from the old product remain.

https://www.amazon.com/Its-10-Haircare-Miracle-Product/dp/B0...

Re:Her Amazon Purchases Are Real, the Reviews Are Fake by pergadad on Thursday November 21, 2019 @10:12AM (#21594814)
As a European I've definitely received fakes from amazon.DE. But I find the game reviews much more bothersome. Most products I now buy somewhere else but living abroad it's difficult to get everything I 'expect' so sometimes Amazon is the only way (eg i bought a 20l bucket on paint from a German Amazon seller that has a real store, as the branded version including shipping of the heavy thing was 30€ less than the cheapest product I could find locally.
Re:Her Amazon Purchases Are Real, the Reviews Are Fake by FractalParadigm on Thursday November 21, 2019 @08:53AM (#21593968)
Just want to throw in my $0.02 as a Canadian, but I haven't had any issues with counterfeit goods in the 4 years I've been buying things (mainly electronics) from Amazon. I also haven't heard anything (first hand) about others receiving counterfeit goods either.

On that note, while I have no idea how Amazon.com works, on .ca it is pretty clear on a product page whether or not the item is sold/shipped by Amazon or a 3rd party. Whether or not this has any bearing re. counterfeit goods, I generally recommended people buy the "Sold and Shipped by Amazon.ca" option even if a 3rd party's listing is cheaper.

Re:Her Amazon Purchases Are Real, the Reviews Are Fake by michaelmrose on Thursday November 21, 2019 @11:37AM (#21595953)
They commingle supposedly identical items from other sellers. You could thus pay more and still get fakes.
Re:Her Amazon Purchases Are Real, the Reviews Are Fake by alibert on Thursday November 21, 2019 @08:59AM (#21594030)
I started to freak out a bit when people here started complaining about fake stuff and the whole story about commingled inventory. That was maybe 1 year or 2 ago.

I have continued to buy stuff from Amazon in Europe since and I have to report that I did not receive any counterfeit stuff (I believe, I checked everything as best as I can). I bought things ranging from screwdriver, SD cards (famously prone to be fake) to electronic/high tech. Costs ranging from 10€ to 1000€.

I'm starting to believe that it is indeed an US problem or like you I'm just lucky?

Re:Her Amazon Purchases Are Real, the Reviews Are Fake by jeromegv on Thursday November 21, 2019 @10:06AM (#21594747)
I feel the big problems started with Fulfilment by Amazon, when anyone and their mother could start selling directly on Amazon through almost no barrier. From anecdata alone (reading forums on FBA, etc) this program seems less popular in Europe. Americans on FBA that are just there for the quick buck typically stick with US FBA and for some reason I haven't read tons of articles on people in Europe using that as a new revenue generator.
Re:Her Amazon Purchases Are Real, the Reviews Are Fake by docdeek on Thursday November 21, 2019 @08:52AM (#21593959)
I would be interested in this, too. I use Amazon in France (mostly) and the UK and Germany (ocassionally) and haven’t had the problems that people speak of in relation to counterfiet goods in the US.
Re:Her Amazon Purchases Are Real, the Reviews Are Fake by wiether on Thursday November 21, 2019 @11:03AM (#21595523)
Same here.

Maybe it's more a marketplace issue ?

I can't see how and why Amazon would sold counterfeits goods.

I've read some reviews complaining about that but it was always from a marketplace seller.

Re:Her Amazon Purchases Are Real, the Reviews Are Fake by laurent123456 on Thursday November 21, 2019 @09:40AM (#21594426)
Never had any issue in France or in the UK either. I got a fake SD card from Priceminister in France, but never from Amazon as far as I can tell.