Re:Cable to the Stars – The Skyhook [video]
by baby on Sunday November 17, 2019 @11:27AM
(#21558590)
kurzgesagt is my favorite youtube channel and I really wish we had more channels like this so that people wouldn’t replace TV with youtube so easily.
I think education is the most important thing and for this reason kurzgesagt is the only thing I’m donating to every single month.
If you too think education is the best way to make the world a better place consider buying their super cool 2020 calendar or subscribing to donate monthly:
https://www.patreon.com/Kurzgesagt
I highly recommend watching pretty much all of their videos!
Re:Cable to the Stars – The Skyhook [video]
by luc4sdreyer on Sunday November 17, 2019 @09:40AM
(#21558057)
From the show notes[1]:
> It’s also interesting that certain designs, such as the one proposed by Moravec (1977), consider a tether whose rotation is chosen such that its instantaneous velocity when touching the atmosphere is minimized, and effectively zero at the tip during the moment of maximum extension into the atmosphere.
Re:Cable to the Stars – The Skyhook [video]
by sandworm101 on Sunday November 17, 2019 @09:45AM
(#21558077)
There is no free lunch. To be useful, skyhooks need to be much much heavier than the stuff they throw around. Getting them up there, and servicing them, is something beyond anything. Think of every launch ever in the history of space. That, to biuld skyhook A.
Re:Cable to the Stars – The Skyhook [video]
by ClumsyPilot on Sunday November 17, 2019 @10:31AM
(#21558324)
I dont agree. Skyholk is infrastructure, so you want it to lift smaller payloads daily, rather than a heavy payload once a month.
If you typical rocket lifts 20T, you would built a small sky hook to lift like 1T, and use it to lift fuel and other consumables cheaply. That would bootstrap you to build larger one in the future
Re:Cable to the Stars – The Skyhook [video]
by wolfram74 on Sunday November 17, 2019 @09:52AM
(#21558115)
Additionally, this one of the first times I've seen a description of the skyhook that brings up what I've always been wondering about: Conservation of momentum. Admittedly, since a skyhook would already be in orbit, it can use much more efficient ion/plasma engines, but it will still need to re-boost periodically. Especially since for a long time earth is going to be a net-mass exporter.
Re:Cable to the Stars – The Skyhook [video]
by OnlineGladiator on Sunday November 17, 2019 @02:03PM
(#21559399)
The video covers this. For every vehicle it launches into orbit, it will also be used to decelerate returning ships back into the atmosphere - conserving its momentum.
So it works in theory. I have a hard time imagining it work in practice.
Re:Cable to the Stars – The Skyhook [video]
by shkkmo on Sunday November 17, 2019 @10:06AM
(#21558175)
If SpaceX hits their goals with Starship, this might become feasible. I would imagine that the economic viability of a spacehook will lag well behind having sufficient launch capacity to build one.
> SpaceX clearly intends to build dozens of Starships. With an eventual flight rate of once per day per Starship, we’re looking at roughly a million tonnes to orbit per year. That exceeds the current launch market of about 500 T/year by a substantial margin. [0]
Re:Cable to the Stars – The Skyhook [video]
by Geee on Sunday November 17, 2019 @01:52PM
(#21559340)
SpaceX plans to build a capacity of 10 million tons of payload to orbit per year with their Starship fleet. Also this won't cost too much, just $130-$200B.
Re:Cable to the Stars – The Skyhook [video]
by theothermkn on Sunday November 17, 2019 @11:54AM
(#21558714)
I think what bothers me most about this kind of paid fluff is that it fools the viewer into thinking they've learned something worthwhile, when they've only seen something pleasant. Another poster linked to a brief Wikipedia article, and even it mentioned that the technology is nowhere near ready, citing erosion by atomic oxygen as one concern.
What we have here is a glossed-up version of the simple observations that spinning things spin, and "rolling" things move faster at the top than at the bottom. The rest has been left as an exercise for the reader's active and uninformed imagination. Don't fall for it.
FWIW, my guess is that exactly 0 tethers as described in the video will ever play an important role in getting humans into space, for various reasons of various veracity. But it's all guesswork, which is all any of us have. Oh, and sign up for Brilliant.com.
Re:Cable to the Stars – The Skyhook [video]
by ohiovr on Tuesday November 19, 2019 @07:03AM
(#21572218)
Actually, chunky salsa problem for people aside, why couldn't this technology be used for sweeping out space trash? Maybe waste management or Rumpky could make a deal.
The teather could also be electrodynamic. By putting a current on it it can push against the earths magnetic field like an electric motor. This can help with momentum loss slinging trash into the atmosphere.
Re:Cable to the Stars – The Skyhook [video]
by wiradikusuma on Sunday November 17, 2019 @09:55AM
(#21558130)
What happen if the payload got slingshot off-course? Since it has no rocket on its own (the reason to use skyhook), it could end up in the middle of nowhere.
Re:Cable to the Stars – The Skyhook [video]
by sandworm101 on Sunday November 17, 2019 @10:11AM
(#21558212)
Not mentioned in video: there can be only one. We couldnt have multiple 1000km long objects on different orbital planes. Collissions would be inevitable. These things change speed with every 'hook' event. Predicting collisions would be extreemly difficult, and impossible to do in time to setup an avoidance. And just give up on those 30,000+ unit sat constellations. Flies to the flyswatter.
We would have to keep them all in one plane, probably to line up with the moon. This would seriously limit thier use beyond orbits in that one plane.
Re:Cable to the Stars – The Skyhook [video]
by sandworm101 on Sunday November 17, 2019 @11:48AM
(#21558689)
Except you cant. The rotation of one tether changes witg each hook event. No two would ever be turning at the same rate. So you cannot bolt multiple into a wheel system. You could certainly improve one, make it heavier/longer/bigger, but it cannot have multiple strands.
This part of the video alludes to what I'm getting at. Granted, they are using a moon as the weighted object, so rotation wouldn't be affected by hook events.
I wonder how massive the weighted object would have to be to make rotation changes negligible, or at least manageable.
Re:Cable to the Stars – The Skyhook [video]
by sandworm101 on Sunday November 17, 2019 @12:01PM
(#21558746)
Even with a moon, there would be considerable wobble. A strand lifing a ship would slow down relative to the moon. The moons rotation would eventually accellerate the strand back up to the moon's rotation rate, but there would be considerable back-and-forth motion. Pick up too heavy a load and the strand may start to wrap around the moon.
Re:Cable to the Stars – The Skyhook [video]
by m4rtink on Sunday November 17, 2019 @10:52AM
(#21558423)
I think thats too pesimistic - indeed, with current sats limited by current high launch costs to no or low available delta-V, it would be difficult. With more advanced hight delta-V sats & tugs to move dead sats it should be perfectly possible to avoid collisions via active guidance.
Re:Cable to the Stars – The Skyhook [video]
by jessriedel on Sunday November 17, 2019 @11:59AM
(#21558736)
> And just give up on those 30,000+ unit sat constellations. Flies to the flyswatter.
The satellites in these constellations are constantly maneuvering. There's no reason they couldn't easily avoid a sky hook with active correction.
> We would have to keep them all in one plane, probably to line up with the moon.
What keeps them from being synchronized? By moving counter-weights up and down the tether, you can adjust the rotation speed with no net expenditure of energy. So as long as there is a schedule such that skyhooks in different orbital planes are "horizontal" when crossing each other, you can actively maintain that schedule even as ships are extracting and depositing energy from the skyhook.
Re:Cable to the Stars – The Skyhook [video]
by rini17 on Sunday November 17, 2019 @01:38PM
(#21559264)
I fear that by the time this becomes feasible, the orbit will be too crowded already with satellite megaconstellations. Surely the satellites will be equipped with collision avoidance, but tether is bigger target than another sat.
I think education is the most important thing and for this reason kurzgesagt is the only thing I’m donating to every single month.
If you too think education is the best way to make the world a better place consider buying their super cool 2020 calendar or subscribing to donate monthly: https://www.patreon.com/Kurzgesagt
I highly recommend watching pretty much all of their videos!
Isaac Arthur: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TlpFzn_Y-F0
> It’s also interesting that certain designs, such as the one proposed by Moravec (1977), consider a tether whose rotation is chosen such that its instantaneous velocity when touching the atmosphere is minimized, and effectively zero at the tip during the moment of maximum extension into the atmosphere.
[1] https://sites.google.com/view/sources-skyhooks/
If you typical rocket lifts 20T, you would built a small sky hook to lift like 1T, and use it to lift fuel and other consumables cheaply. That would bootstrap you to build larger one in the future
1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_Shuttle
> The typical payload capacity was about 50,045 pounds (22,700 kg) but could be increased depending on the choice of launch configuration
So it works in theory. I have a hard time imagining it work in practice.
> SpaceX clearly intends to build dozens of Starships. With an eventual flight rate of once per day per Starship, we’re looking at roughly a million tonnes to orbit per year. That exceeds the current launch market of about 500 T/year by a substantial margin. [0]
[0] https://caseyhandmer.wordpress.com/2019/10/29/the-spacex-sta...
https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1192547668817375232
I think we are more-less capable of doing it currently.
What we have here is a glossed-up version of the simple observations that spinning things spin, and "rolling" things move faster at the top than at the bottom. The rest has been left as an exercise for the reader's active and uninformed imagination. Don't fall for it.
FWIW, my guess is that exactly 0 tethers as described in the video will ever play an important role in getting humans into space, for various reasons of various veracity. But it's all guesswork, which is all any of us have. Oh, and sign up for Brilliant.com.
The teather could also be electrodynamic. By putting a current on it it can push against the earths magnetic field like an electric motor. This can help with momentum loss slinging trash into the atmosphere.
I find the concept fascinating, but would humans withstand it?
We would have to keep them all in one plane, probably to line up with the moon. This would seriously limit thier use beyond orbits in that one plane.
But I'm also imagining a more sophisticated ferris-wheel, where you stick two together (side-by-side), allowing for even more capacity.
Picturing it like spokes on a bicycle wheel might also help.
I wonder if there would be much need for more than one.
Fair point, that would indeed be a problem.
This part of the video alludes to what I'm getting at. Granted, they are using a moon as the weighted object, so rotation wouldn't be affected by hook events.
I wonder how massive the weighted object would have to be to make rotation changes negligible, or at least manageable.
The satellites in these constellations are constantly maneuvering. There's no reason they couldn't easily avoid a sky hook with active correction.
> We would have to keep them all in one plane, probably to line up with the moon.
What keeps them from being synchronized? By moving counter-weights up and down the tether, you can adjust the rotation speed with no net expenditure of energy. So as long as there is a schedule such that skyhooks in different orbital planes are "horizontal" when crossing each other, you can actively maintain that schedule even as ships are extracting and depositing energy from the skyhook.
that surpasses man in strangeness.
He sets sail on the frothing waters
amid the south winds of winter
tacking through the mountains
and furious chasms of the waves.
He wearies even the noblest
of the gods, the Earth,
indestructible and untiring,
overturning her from year to year,
driving the plows this way and that
with horses.
And man, pondering and plotting,
snares the light-gliding birds
and hunts the beasts of the wilderness
and the native creatures of the sea.
With guile he overpowers the beast
that roams the mountains by night as by day,
he yokes the hirsute neck of the stallion
and the undaunted bull.
And he has found his way
to the resonance of the word,
and to wind-swift all-understanding,
and to the courage of rule over cities.
He has considered also how to flee
from exposure to the arrows
of unpropitious weather and frost.
Everywhere journeying, inexperienced and without issue,
he comes to nothingness.
Through no flight can he resist
the one assault of death,
even if he has succeeded in cleverly evading
painful sickness.
Clever indeed, mastering
the ways of skill beyond all hope,
he sometimes achieves brave deeds.
He wends his way between the laws of the earth
and the adjured justice of the gods.
Rising high above his place,
he who for the sake of adventures takes
the nonessent for essent loses
his place in the end.
May such a man never frequent my hearth;
May my mind never share the presumption
of him who does this.
Antigone, Sophocles