News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Against Economics by diego on Thursday November 14, 2019 @06:07PM (#21540514)
This article lost me at "printing money does not cause inflation." How would that be possible? The only answer would be that money is increasing in value for some reason, and the government must print more to keep prices stable (otherwise they would fall). Even then, it would be a technicality.
Re:Against Economics by djokkataja on Thursday November 14, 2019 @06:59PM (#21540943)
There are multiple cases where an increase in money supply doesn't lead to inflation; the United States in recent years comes to mind:

"A good example is in a recession, the stock of money may rise 5%, however, people will be making fewer transactions and therefore the velocity of circulation will fall. This explains why quantitative easing (increasing the money supply) did not cause inflation between 2009 and 2016." [0]

The article I link below contains 3 more examples:

[0] https://www.economicshelp.org/blog/111/inflation/money-suppl...

Re:Against Economics by marcusverus on Thursday November 14, 2019 @09:38PM (#21541789)
You are arguing that this is sometimes true. The author was clearly arguing that it is generally true:

"We now live in a different economic universe than we did before the crash. Falling unemployment no longer drives up wages. Printing money no longer causes inflation."

He is stating that we are in a different universe, with the clear implication being that the following items, which he does not qualify, are the new reality.

Re:Against Economics by corporate_shi11 on Friday November 15, 2019 @11:06PM (#21550940)
He is referring to QE not causing inflation. The truth is that it did cause inflation, but in asset prices not consumer goods.
Re:Against Economics by bildung on Saturday November 16, 2019 @06:27AM (#21552104)
But gains in asset prices are not inflation. Inflation is per definition the rise of prices in consumer goods.
Re:Against Economics by corporate_shi11 on Saturday November 16, 2019 @01:53PM (#21554249)
The CPI inflation metric certainly does exist, but the idea of inflation can apply to any basket of goods.
Re:Against Economics by bildung on Monday November 18, 2019 @05:01AM (#21563081)
But is have to be consumables that are put into the basket. Inflation/deflation doesn't make sense otherwise. If an asset gains in nominal value, that means nominated in that asset, the consumables fell in price, i.e. we observe deflation.

If the valuations of housing and stocks rise, this isn't inflation: If I owned them then I can sell these and buy more consumables than before, not less.

Re:Against Economics by rayiner on Friday November 15, 2019 @10:30PM (#21550815)
I cannot stress enough that the author, David Graeber, is a professor of anthropology.
Re:Against Economics by bjourne on Saturday November 16, 2019 @02:50AM (#21551547)
That the author is right follows from simple logic. Assume A implies B. Observe A but not B. Conclude that A implies B is false.

Replace A with "printing money" and B with "increased inflation."

Re:Against Economics by roenxi on Friday November 15, 2019 @10:06PM (#21550729)
To add some precision: doesn't lead to consumer price inflation.

Increasing the money supply has caused massive inflation; the price of gold isn't where it is because the colour yellow is in fashion. Asset prices are out of control.

Re:Against Economics by littlestymaar on Saturday November 16, 2019 @03:50AM (#21551671)
The price of gold (or silver)isn't out of control at all. There has been a peak (because people viewed it as a reliable asset) and then the situation stabilized (for gold) and almost returned to its level before 2008 (for silver) whereas the money from the QE is still here!

https://framapic.org/pSCHdCxNc2w4/wRKHzipzlWHp.png

Re:Against Economics by roenxi on Saturday November 16, 2019 @07:05PM (#21555734)
Picking on 2005 as a start year, because that was a little before QE, to 2019 silver has risen at a 5% p.a. rate and gold at at 8% rate. The official inflation rate over that time is 2% (from https://www.usinflationcalculator.com/).

I put it to you that the value of gold is not really rising at a real rate of 6% per annum. That is better than the US economy! It is much more likely that QE caused asset price inflation. Silver probably doesn't get treated so much as an asset because storing it is so much harder than gold.

Re:Against Economics by littlestymaar on Sunday November 17, 2019 @04:14AM (#21557155)
> silver has risen at a 5% p.a. rate and gold at at 8% rate

It hasn't. It grew (a lot), then fell, then grew (more reasonably) again.

This is not the kind of shapes you are supposed to see when talking about inflation. Using “mean growth” is meaningless in that context.

Re:Against Economics by roenxi on Sunday November 17, 2019 @04:36AM (#21557205)
Well no in fact there is no 'shape you are meant to see'. Inflation can be expressed in prices smoothly or in sharp jumps. People probably anticipated more money was going to be printed and priced it in, then when the Fed started tapering traders wound back to current state rather than forward-looking guesses. A sentence of speculation on my part there I know.

It is a fact that there is a big real gap between the pre-QE price and the post-QE price. You can hand-wave and claim that because the chart is the wrong shape it doesn't count - and argument which I obviously am going to reject. But even accepting that, are you really comfortable saying that these commodities are securing real value increases? I'm a mining engineer and it isn't because it is getting 3-6% per annum harder to mine commodities each year in real terms. If you don't like 2005 pick any year prior to the financial crisis; gold is mysteriously outperforming the inflation.

Quacks like a duck. QE probably went in to asset prices.

Re:Against Economics by littlestymaar on Sunday November 17, 2019 @08:01AM (#21557739)
> Well no in fact there is no 'shape you are meant to see'. Inflation can be expressed in prices smoothly or in sharp jumps.

But sharp drop isn't an option, hence my argument.

> It is a fact that there is a big real gap between the pre-QE price and the post-QE price.

Sigh! The graphs show that there is no such “gap”.

> But even accepting that, are you really comfortable saying that these commodities are securing real value increases? I'm a mining engineer and it isn't because it is getting 3-6% per annum harder to mine commodities each year in real terms.

If course it's not tied to any real value, that's never been my argument. The initial point was: “increase in the money supply by QE didn't cause the prices (including asset prices) to rise”. And you even agree with that when you say this.

> If you don't like 2005 pick any year prior to the financial crisis; gold is mysteriously outperforming the inflation

(And BTW gold is rising again in 2019, while there has been no QE policy in years in the US).

Re:Against Economics by roenxi on Sunday November 17, 2019 @03:27PM (#21559882)
> But sharp drop isn't an option, hence my argument.

Obviously it is an option; it just happened with gold.

> Sigh! The graphs show that there is no such “gap”.

Price was $15,000/kg in US dollars and is now cruising pretty easily above $40,000/kg US. You can sigh and pretend not to see it all you like but you are still ignoring pretty clear evidence of about 8% nominal growth/6% real growth annually in a shiny rock.

I'll admit to being quite impressed that you can look at a 260% price change upwards and say it doesn't count as a price increase because you think the chart is the wrong shape.

> And you even agree with that when you say this.

No I don't. QE is the most likely factor causing these unreasonable 'real' increases in asset prices that are very well illustrated in the gold price. The idea that gold is getting more valuable in real terms is foolish, so the fact it is showing such outrageous gains in real prices since pre-QE is strong evidence that actual inflation in assets is higher than 2%.

> (And BTW gold is rising again in 2019, while there has been no QE policy in years in the US).

Actually they just got going again. A forward-looking analyst might reasonably guess that there is a lot of money about to hit the markets.

https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/WALCL

Re:Against Economics by littlestymaar on Sunday November 17, 2019 @03:44PM (#21559961)
> Obviously it is an option; it just happened with gold.

It's not an option in case of an inflation mechanism. If it was inflation, it wouldn't drop like this. That's the signature of speculation which is something totally different.

> Price was $15,000/kg in US dollars and is now cruising pretty easily above $40,000/kg US. You can sigh and pretend not to see it all you like but you are still ignoring pretty clear evidence of about 8% nominal growth/6% real growth in a shiny rock.

There is no gap on the graph, nor there is a 8% annual growth. But as you keep ignoring the shape of the curve and keep acting as if it didn't exist, I'm uninterested in pushing this discussion forward.

Re:Against Economics by roenxi on Sunday November 17, 2019 @03:48PM (#21559974)
So what are you calling the price rise? An 8% annual drop?

How do you get from $15,000 to $40,000 without annualised growth? I'm intrigued.

EDIT Just pointing out, the averaging I'm doing its reducing the relative inflationary impact of QE on asset prices because I'm including a lot of time to today where there was no QE.

Re:Against Economics by littlestymaar on Sunday November 17, 2019 @04:22PM (#21560126)
> How do you get from $15,000 to $40,000 without annualised growth? I'm intrigued.

With a 25% annual increase while no QE was running (2005-2008), a 75% annual increase with QE(2009-2012), a 0% increase with no-QE (2012) followed by a 30% drop when QE3 was launched! (sept 2012), then a little decline during the whole QE3 and which continued after QE3 was stopped (Q4 2014) until 2016, then again some fluctuation in an upward trend.

If you see a temporal correlation between QE and the price of gold, I can do nothing for you as you are blinded by your ideological convictions.

Good day.

Re:Against Economics by perl4ever on Saturday November 16, 2019 @02:29AM (#21551495)
I don't think gold is a good example of whatever you are saying is happening.

Gold hit a peak about eight years ago, and before that, while it was going up in kind of an apparent smooth exponential curve, there wasn't any significant blip from the financial crisis, 9/11, or anything else. Is there even a generally accepted explanation for this behavior? If post-crisis spending is blamed, how did the market for gold "know" for years in advance?

Re:Against Economics by perl4ever on Saturday November 16, 2019 @03:50AM (#21551670)
I did some looking around, and ran across a page which claims gold was particularly low around 2000 because of central bank sales and rose steadily for almost a decade because energy prices were going up. Also, I remember how cheap gas was around 2000 as well.
Re:Against Economics by CharlesColeman on Thursday November 14, 2019 @06:23PM (#21540636)
> "printing money does not cause inflation." How would that be possible?

I haven't read this particular article, but I've read elsewhere that traditional tools used by central banks to increase inflation are being observed to empirically no longer work. I understand many of these techniques are analogous to "printing money" in a controlled way. That points to failures in their models of the economy and of inflation.

I also think I've read that at least some of the reason for this may be higher than expected levels monopoly-type powers active in the economy that conspire to keep prices and wages, and therefore inflation, down. My recollection is hazier on this part.

Edit: this might be the article I was thinking of:

Are Superstar Firms and Amazon Effects Reshaping the Economy?: The biggest companies may be influencing things like inflation and wage growth, possibly at the expense of central bankers’ power to do so.

https://www.nytimes.com/2018/08/25/upshot/big-corporations-i...

> Two of the most important economic facts of the last few decades are that more industries are being dominated by a handful of extraordinarily successful companies and that wages, inflation and growth have remained stubbornly low.

> Many of the world’s most powerful economic policymakers are now taking seriously the possibility that the first of those facts is a cause of the second — and that the growing concentration of corporate power has confounded the efforts of central banks to keep economies healthy.

> Mainstream economists are discussing questions like whether “monopsony” — the outsize power of a few consolidated employers — is part of the problem of low wage growth. They are looking at whether the “superstar firms” that dominate many leading industries are responsible for sluggish investment spending. And they’re exploring whether there is an “Amazon Effect” in which fast-changing pricing algorithms by the online retailer and its rivals mean bigger swings in inflation.

Re:Against Economics by throw0101a on Thursday November 14, 2019 @06:39PM (#21540767)
> I haven't read this particular article, but I've read elsewhere that traditional tools used by central banks to increase inflation are being observed to empirically no longer work. I understand many of these techniques are analogous to "printing money" in a controlled way.

There are circumstances where printing money does increase inflation.... and circumstances where it does not:

> When short-term interest rates reach zero, further monetary easing becomes difficult and may require unconventional monetary policy, such as large-scale asset purchases (quantitative easing).

* https://www.brookings.edu/blog/ben-bernanke/2017/04/12/how-b...

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero_lower_bound

It should be noted that central banks are not omnipotent: they do have some influence, but they do not have all the influence. When governments enact austerity, which depresses demand and economic activity, thus reducing inflationary tendencies, they are working at cross-purposes to the central banks.

After the Great Recession we saw central bankers cut rates, but governments cut spending, thus the two cancelling each other out to a certain extent.

Re:Against Economics by donatj on Thursday November 14, 2019 @06:15PM (#21540573)
Yup, came here to make the same complaint. The article just throws that out there as fact with no justification or citation.

Just need to look at what's going on in Venezuela, right now.

Increased supply of anything lowers it's value.

Re:Against Economics by lordnacho on Thursday November 14, 2019 @06:21PM (#21540621)
> Increased supply of anything lowers it's value.

Network goods? Are telephones more valuable when more people have them? Road networks?

Just pointing out that many things in economics are not so obvious.

You're right that you need to cite things that go against the orthodoxy. At least to have sane debates. But of course he could have cited the current money printing era, where if you believe the official figures there's not a lot of inflation anywhere in the west. I'm not so confident in the figures, but that's at least some evidence that printing a load of money doesn't cause inflation.

Re:Against Economics by beerandt on Thursday November 14, 2019 @07:33PM (#21541155)
I know there's an economic element to networks, but in the context of what we're talking about, more people having a telephone is a measure of the products quality, not supply. Capacity of the network would equal supply. Right?

Unless I'm grossly missing something.

Re:Against Economics by IggleSniggle on Saturday November 16, 2019 @12:21AM (#21551163)
The value of a single phone is zero, 2 phones grants each owner the ability to contact one person (2 units of value total), 3 grants 3 owners 2 each (6), 4 -> 3 (12), 5->4 (20). In other words, increasing the size of the network multiplies the value of the entire network by that amount (factorial).

In a phone network, there are a few different tipping points where the _ubiquity_ adds additional value. At a certain point, having a phone is worthwhile because everyone you could possibly want to talk to also has one. (this is also why I still have an account on Facebook).

The same can be said of a currency network. It becomes more valuable the more people you can exchange it with. People using US dollars outside the US gain value from knowing they have a trusted "stable third party" currency, and at the same time US dollars become more value to citizens of the US because they can now use that currency for purchases in that other country.

Having 20 phones with one owner is practically worthless, even though the network capacity is theoretically high. Distributing those phones among twenty people is what generates the real value. But you can't really distribute 20 phones equally among 200 people.

You need sufficient saturation of currency for its distribution to be of any real value, because you need enough quantity to be able to use it to do its job as a holder of arbitrary value exchange.

Re:Against Economics by beerandt on Saturday November 16, 2019 @12:44PM (#21553855)
I appreciate the response. I get that... (I think)

I just don't get why that necessarily has anything to do with supply itself. It has to do with the distribution, and as a result, the quality or utility of the network.

As you said, one person having 20 phones is off dubious value, but 20 additional people with phones might increase the network's quality.

The supply (20) is independent of the resulting quality/saturation/useful node count.

On the other hand, increased nodes could be seen as a negative. Like the US-Russia hotline. Or Facebook after it opened up to users without college email accounts.

Sometimes supply might affect the quality of a network, and therefore the value of having a node (phone) on that network. But to say supply increases with demand is misleading, to me. Increased quality increases demand, at a rate greater than the rate demand is decreased due to increased supply.

If supply happens to increase quality, then yes supply might dominate the equation such that demand increases as supply increases. But that doesn't mean the fundamental relationship between supply and demand has changed, it's just been minimized for particular cases.

Or maybe I'm just getting confused by transitive semantics.

Re:Against Economics by IggleSniggle on Saturday November 16, 2019 @02:27PM (#21554420)
I would agree with most of what you said here. To echo your semantics and in the greater context of this thread, I was merely pointing out that increasing the supply (and in the case of money, distribution/saturation) could increase the "quality" at a rate faster than the forces that that push the "quality" down in terms of "quality" per unit of currency. In the specific case of money, there is an additional group psychology at play: if you believe your money won't be worth as much tomorrow as it is today, then you should spend it today if you can. Since the value derived from currency is in its exchange (it's not producing any value sitting under a mattress), it increases the "quality" of the currency for it to be circulating.
Re:Against Economics by beerandt on Saturday November 16, 2019 @08:47PM (#21556057)
Yea, if we're talking about money supply I suspect the phone comparison might be apt in a slightly different way.

I haven't seen anyone touch on it in this thread, but I've read opinions where people have blamed companies for hoarding all of the newly available cash, especially for stock buybacks.

If there's any truth to that, it would make sense, since companies can usually get better rates and first dibs at market level loans/ bonds/ etc than small business or individuals.

In the phone analogy, (if we assume there's some value having multiple phones) this would be like a new dialing prefix being released, and companies buying up the numbers hundreds at a time at bulk rate discount, leaving little or no additional numbers for individuals.

So supply was increased, but the businesses hoarding new numbers prevents any quality improvement if the network.

Re:Against Economics by pjc50 on Friday November 15, 2019 @06:03AM (#21543915)
Venezuela is a great example that hyperinflation, or substantial consumer price inflation, is mostly a forex phenomenon, and in turn a balance of trade problem. Because you can't print other countries' money.

Venezuela is a disaster because its export industries collapsed, and it doesn't have the advantage that western countries have of being an inward investment destination. So all sorts of things have to be imported, and the dollars needed to import them become increasingly scarce.

Printing money is a symptom. If the presses stopped then all that would happen is that paper money would become increasingly scarce as well as worthless.

Re:Against Economics by trcarney on Friday November 15, 2019 @12:55PM (#21547020)
I think you conflated value and price. Increased supply of anything lowers it's price not it's value. For example, oxygen is extremely valuable, can't live without it, but it is also very abundant. Therefore, its price is $0 almost everywhere. When you go to a ski resort, where the air is much thinner, there then becomes a market for oxygen and the price goes up[0]. The price changed with supply, not the value.

[0] https://www.oxygenplus.com/blogs/articles/why-oxygen-plus-is...

Re:Against Economics by littlestymaar on Saturday November 16, 2019 @03:41AM (#21551650)
Because it's pretty clear to anyone close to economics. Nobody is monetarist nowadays, because data shows they were simply wrong [1].

The monetarist pitch was sexy because it sounded intuitive and elegant, that's why it spread so broadly. But it's worthless. Too bad for elegance and intuitiveness, if the reality doesn't match your model, you must throw it away.

> Increased supply of anything lowers it's value.

It doesn't work this way for money. otherwise,how would you explain that Euro isn't getting cheaper in dollar since 2015 when BCE is injecting billions of Euros on the market while the US has stopped QE for a while?

[1] https://fredblog.stlouisfed.org/2014/08/m2-velocity-and-infl...

Re:Against Economics by fzeroracer on Thursday November 14, 2019 @06:49PM (#21540859)
If we take the opposite of your logical argument, then lessened supply of anything increases it's value. That's a logical proposition stemming from your original thesis.

Now let's try applying that to bus networks. The more busses we have on the road, the less they're worth. If we reduce the supply of busses, then busses will be more valuable.

But this ignores the network effects of increasing the supply of something. If we increase the supply of busses, then we also increase the demand for busses and the value of busses through increased ridership. A single bus is worthless, but a fleet of busses is valuable to a community.

Re:Against Economics by beerandt on Thursday November 14, 2019 @07:57PM (#21541286)
I honestly don't get these network arguments. The market isn't for seats on buses, it's for timely transportation.

The quality of the transportation affects the value. Which in the case of buses, more buses equals a better, more frequent and readily available product. The number of seats isn't the limiting factor. It's just a side effect of somewhat standardized bus sizes.

Am I missing something?

Re:Against Economics by tuberelay on Friday November 15, 2019 @03:38PM (#21548515)
If you print money and then give it all to big banks who use it to ramp up the price of equities, it never really reaches the average person for them to be able to ramp up the price of the basket of things which CPI measures. Inflation here is seen in the stock market tripling, but that isn't included in government measures.
Re:Against Economics by QuesnayJr on Friday November 15, 2019 @10:54PM (#21550904)
Because it's not inflation. It would be an asset bubble. Except it's not even that -- the P/E ratio on stock is high now because the economic news has been good, but it's nowhere near dotcom bubble levels (https://www.multpl.com/s-p-500-pe-ratio).
Re:Against Economics by Zarath on Saturday November 16, 2019 @04:41PM (#21555155)
I don't know, I mean, things like rent and healthcare costs seem to be increasing at runaway speeds. I'm sure lots of other things are too, just not TVs or whatever.
Re:Against Economics by cortesoft on Friday November 15, 2019 @10:40PM (#21550852)
I remember hearing about new economic theory that talks about inflation being related to latent productive capacity. If, for example, a factory is only producing at half capacity because there is not enough people with money to buy their product, they can simply increase production if more money is put into the system without raising prices. It is only once a factory is at full capacity that it would raise prices to match the supply/demand curve.

Our modern economies have a lot of latent capacity, especially since so much of our economy these days does not have a lot of raw materials involved. More Netflix subscribers don't use much more raw materials to serve them. We are not limited by things like oil and iron anymore, so we don't hit supply issues which cause inflation.

Re:Against Economics by QuesnayJr on Saturday November 16, 2019 @02:25PM (#21554407)
This is basically Keynesianism, which is the leading paradigm in macroeconomics. The challenge is knowing how much excess capacity there is in the economy. Unemployment is 3.6%, so I would guess not a lot, but I could be wrong.
Re:Against Economics by afpx on Friday November 15, 2019 @04:26AM (#21543509)
I think he means that printing money doesn’t change supply and demand curves. It only lowers the value of the money that one already has. For example, if one government prints more money, it doesn’t cause Global inflation. It just makes one country’s money worth less.
Re:Against Economics by aaronbwebber on Thursday November 14, 2019 @06:18PM (#21540602)
No, that is not the only answer. There is at least one other possibility, which is that the demand for money is increasing.
Re:Against Economics by diego on Thursday November 14, 2019 @06:19PM (#21540610)
Well, if the demand for money is increasing and the supply is stable, then the value increases. Definition of supply and demand.
Re:Against Economics by nlfwhulsdhouv on Thursday November 14, 2019 @06:27PM (#21540671)
Interestingly, you're doing exactly what the article is criticizing.

The orthodoxy of "everything is supply and demand" has failed to predict many recent, important macroeconomic phenomenon. On the hand, the heterodox economists that draw from a variety of traditions and ideologies have had a reasonable success rate with predicting some of these important events; yet they are still treated as crackpots.

The reality is orthodox economics is just one theory of politics and the organization of society, which sometimes applies and sometimes doesn't. Treating everything as just "[the] definition of supply and demand" forgoes observing interesting and important phenomenon that seemingly work in opposition to or independent of supply and demand. Ignoring these phenomenon restricts your ability to understand and predict macroeconomic effects, and degrades your legitimacy as a 'science'.

Re:Against Economics by wahern on Saturday November 16, 2019 @08:11AM (#21552470)
The laws of supply and demand apply to everything, period. But they can only be predicative if you know the correct numbers. And because they do apply to everything, perfect accuracy and precision would require measurements that we don't know how to make or could make, as well as measurements for stuff we don't even know about. In applied economics people necessarily make simplifications, like assuming nominal prices in currency accurately reflect the various considerations consumers and producers have in mind. Suffice it to say, even tiny errors can easily and quickly produce bogus assessments and predictions.

The proper criticism to basic economic laws isn't that they don't control, it's that we systematically underestimate (another measurement error!) our capability of applying them well, both ex post as well as and especially a priori.

The same problem exists in all fields, it's just that many problems are relatively more tractable; solutions may not diverge as quickly, are more tolerant of inaccuracy and imprecision, generally producing more useful results. But at some point your numbers are sufficiently off that your predictions and models produce results widely at odds with reality. Such as all the various crazy and contradictory hypotheses regarding cosmological phenomena; hypotheses which turn on tiny uncertainties regarding various parameters.

But in economics there are fewer constants and a heck of a lot more free variables for even simple predictions. It's quite literally intractable. That's why people often conceptualize "the market" as a giant calculator. We know the basic principles to the calculator, but at scale nobody can arrive at the solution faster than the giant calculator itself. Anyone telling you they can do so is necessarily lying to you. But in general the only people telling you that are politicians, pundits, and other people with an agenda, though sadly too many of them are also economists.

Re:Against Economics by throw0101a on Thursday November 14, 2019 @06:46PM (#21540831)
> The orthodoxy of "everything is supply and demand" has failed to predict many recent, important macroeconomic phenomenon.

Can you give some examples of these many unpredicted phenomenon?

Re:Against Economics by nlfwhulsdhouv on Thursday November 14, 2019 @06:50PM (#21540868)
Re:Against Economics by throw0101a on Thursday November 14, 2019 @07:22PM (#21541093)
I've been reading Krugman and DeLong for the last ten years, and they've been calling things pretty accurately in that time, so I have no idea what the author is smoking.
Re:Against Economics by specialist on Saturday November 16, 2019 @08:12AM (#21552474)
Krugman's recent mea culpa about globalization is a nice example of intellectual honesty.

I like to read the critics, contrarians. Including some I deeply respect but strongly disagree with, like Tyler Cowen.

Keeps me sharp, honest. With myself. Hopefully.

Re:Against Economics by dredmorbius on Thursday November 14, 2019 @07:39PM (#21541184)
When we're talking about prices of goods, an increase in demand increases the monetary price of the goods. Price itself is a ratio, as William Stanley Jevons noted, of currency per unit of good.

When we're talking about demand for money, an increase in demand for money means that it is valued more highly than goods or services. The price of money in this context, is ... goods and services. That is, a higher demand for money means a (comparatively) lower demand for goods and services.

Which is to say, a propensity to offer a smaller amount of money for a given unit of goods and services.

An increased demand for money === a decrease in nominal prices. By supply/demand logic.

Re:Against Economics by wahern on Saturday November 16, 2019 @07:49AM (#21552409)
Depends on what the price is denominated in. I initially read "price" as price in foreign currency, which would increase.

Actually, that works for anything, like bananas--you'd pay more bananas for the same amount of that paper currency, thus the price in bananas increases.

Re:Against Economics by aaronbwebber on Thursday November 14, 2019 @06:29PM (#21540686)
No, the value does not increase. The price increases. Price and value are different in economic contexts, and you quite clearly were referring to "value" as economic value in your first comment, and are now using "value" to refer to price.
Re:Against Economics by jmcqk6 on Friday November 15, 2019 @11:09AM (#21545968)
Are you asking theoretically or empirically?

Because using actual events from history, it's true that printing money may not cause inflation.

When theory fails to describe reality, the failure is in the theory, not reality.

Re:Against Economics by nullc on Friday November 15, 2019 @11:54PM (#21551088)
> This article lost me at "printing money does not cause inflation." How would that be possible?

Consider the equation of exchange (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equation_of_exchange): MV = PQ.

The amount of money (M) can be increased without prices (P) going up so long as either the velocity (V) of money goes down or the economy (Q) becomes larger.

Re:Against Economics by Zarath on Saturday November 16, 2019 @04:42PM (#21555159)
Just off the top of my head, if money supply increases at the same rate as human population growth, it seems like inflation should remain constant?
Re:Against Economics by nullc on Sunday November 17, 2019 @08:09AM (#21557766)
Yes, to a super vague hand-wavy level (which all this sort of economics is..)-- e.g. ignoring that not all persons are equal in the economy.
Re:Against Economics by Turing_Machine on Thursday November 14, 2019 @07:45PM (#21541220)
> The only answer would be that money is increasing in value for some reason, and the government must print more to keep prices stable (otherwise they would fall). Even then, it would be a technicality.

I don't think that's a technicality at all, but rather the norm in an expanding economy. In such a case the supply of money must increase in order to maintain stable prices. More stuff to purchase requires more money to purchase it.

Inflation occurs when the supply of money increases faster than the amount of goods and services available for purchase, or if the money supply remains the same, but the goods and services available somehow decrease (for instance, after a lost war or natural disaster).

Deflation occurs when the supply of goods and services increases faster than the amount of money, or when the supply of money decreases with the goods and services remaining the same.

We've seen a lot of bad inflation in recent history, but it's not often appreciated that deflation can be equally ruinous. The Great Depression is an example of what you get if deflation gets out of hand. The prices for everything from stocks and bonds to apples and wheat plummeted, but it sure didn't lead to a consumer's paradise.

Re:Against Economics by viburnum on Thursday November 14, 2019 @07:22PM (#21541089)
There’s been a huge increase in the money supply around the world since the GFC and hardly any inflation. This should not be a surprise because monetarism already failed as soon as it was tried 35 years ago. Simple models of the price level do not work. Output, trade, interest rates, investment, consumption, conflict between capital and labor, it all matters.
Re:Against Economics by hogFeast on Thursday November 14, 2019 @07:52PM (#21541258)
The point wasn't to cause inflation but to stop deflation.

This is a mistake that people almost always make with economics: failing to understand the decision contemporaneously.

By the metrics under which it was conceived, it had the intended effect (although some unfortunate side-effects...as ever).

Re:Against Economics by bildung on Saturday November 16, 2019 @06:24AM (#21552096)
I think the author didn't elaborate further because while this is non-intuitive and tends to rail up the internet armchair economists, it actually is a well researched phenomenon.

One pointer would be the term "liquidity trap", e.g. this here as a starter: https://www.investopedia.com/terms/l/liquiditytrap.asp

Japan in particular had this problem for decades.

And I have to point out "printing money does not cause inflation" is exactly what happened in the US and Europe after 2007/8. There was massive QE but no increase in inflation (inflation was actually reduced).

Re:Against Economics by littlestymaar on Saturday November 16, 2019 @03:35AM (#21551637)
Interestingly enough, the Monetarist view, which link between inflation and money creation is mostly a myth that was debunked long ago[1] (if you look at the history of the US since the 60s you'd see that this «hypothesis» doesn't hold, neither in short terms nor in long terms).

But it was so obviously intuitive for the layperson that it caught rapidly in the opinion, and now it's considered common sense.

[1]: https://fredblog.stlouisfed.org/2014/08/m2-velocity-and-infl...

Re:Against Economics by afterburner on Thursday November 14, 2019 @06:47PM (#21540842)
The US "printed money" after 2008, and it did not cause inflation. Maybe your understanding is wrong.
Re:Against Economics by throw0101a on Thursday November 14, 2019 @07:06PM (#21540992)
The printing-money-will-not-cause-inflation was predicted by Keynesians:

> Suddenly it seems as if everyone is talking about inflation. Stern opinion pieces warn that hyperinflation is just around the corner. And markets may be heeding these warnings: Interest rates on long-term government bonds are up, with fear of future inflation one possible reason for the interest-rate spike.

> But does the big inflation scare make any sense? Basically, no — with one caveat I’ll get to later. And I suspect that the scare is at least partly about politics rather than economics.

* https://www.nytimes.com/2009/05/29/opinion/29krugman.html

The economic models said that the Fed should have decreased interest rates until they reached -6.7% (i.e., well below zero), but this that was impractical, the next-best thing was flood the market with cash equivalent, and that inflation would not appear:

* https://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/11/16/the-madness-of-...

> It seemed totally obvious to many people that with the Fed adding to the monetary base at breakneck speed, high inflation just had to be around the corner. That’s what history told us, right?

> Except that those who knew their Hicks declared that this time was different, that in a liquidity trap the rise in the monetary base wouldn’t be inflationary at all (and that the relevant history was from Japan since the 1990s and from the 1930s, which seemed to confirm this claim). And so it proved, as shown by the red marker down at the bottom.

* https://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/05/17/money-inflation...

> According to mainstream theory, among the characteristics of a liquidity trap are interest rates that are close to zero and changes in the money supply that fail to translate into changes in the price level.[2]

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liquidity_trap

The [2] is a 1998 paper by Krugman talking about Japan. So ten years before the Great Recession there were already models on how to think about increasing M2 from other countries' experiences.

Re:Against Economics by afterburner on Friday November 15, 2019 @11:54AM (#21546404)
Exactly, thank you.

It's also worth noting Keynesian economics was 70 years old in 2008. People willingly forgot this stuff to justify other political priorities.

Re:Against Economics by Proziam on Thursday November 14, 2019 @07:28PM (#21541127)
The buying power of $1 USD has diminished massively over time and continues to do so. Every year the money in your wallet is worth at least 1.8% less. Over your lifetime that becomes a substantial loss in buying power.
Re:Against Economics by luckydata on Thursday November 14, 2019 @08:46PM (#21541548)
1.8% is significantly below the targets those policies are pursuing. So printing money doesn't seem to be producing any (desired) increased inflation.
Re:Against Economics by basementcat on Saturday November 16, 2019 @01:42AM (#21551359)
That is an example of monetary policy working exactly as intended. If the buying power of $1 USD didn’t diminish, there would be an incentive for people to hoard their wealth instead of investing and spending their wealth to build the economy.
Re:Against Economics by shrewduser on Friday November 15, 2019 @11:55PM (#21551090)
the US dollar was also in massive demand during 2008 as it is during every downturn or when risk goes up.