News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Copyright Troll May Have Set an Expensive Precedent for C... by squiggleblaz on Tuesday November 12, 2019 @06:28AM (#21513284)
It's not obvious that the losing party should have to pay the legal fees. (By that, I take it you mean lawyer's cost, not court costs.) To a measurable extent, success is based on ability to pay. If an individual is sued by someone with corporate counsel or a relatively poor person is sued by an incredibly rich person, should they be made to pay twice?

It also would invite too many disputes into the courts, since an aggrieved party could feel it's almost free - the person who hurts them to the tune of a couple of hundred dollars will have to pay tens of thousands and they get nothing. It is possible that some disputes have a genuine good party and a genuine dodgy party, but in many cases they're just people who life happened to. The loser should compensate the other party but not necessarily get punished. If the loser was being malicious, they should be made to pay. But we shouldn't assume the loser is malicious, just that they lost.

It seems to me if you want the loser to pay, you'd have to create a regulated system for costs in order for them to be fair. A clever lawyer might have a way to take additional payments, but they'd have to be outside of the system, not recoverable by the court. But doesn't that end up in exactly the same situation as before?

Re:Copyright Troll May Have Set an Expensive Precedent for C... by zaarn on Tuesday November 12, 2019 @06:57AM (#21513394)
In Germany a regulated system of costs exists, the amount of compensation you pay to the winning party is capped and uses a fixed hourly rate equal for both parties.
Re:Copyright Troll May Have Set an Expensive Precedent for C... by nannal on Tuesday November 12, 2019 @07:11AM (#21513447)
So you have the same problem, a rich person can pay over that hourly rate and have better representation and a poor person is capped at that rate.
Re:Copyright Troll May Have Set an Expensive Precedent for C... by zaarn on Tuesday November 12, 2019 @08:02AM (#21513702)
You can't pay them significantly more, for certain court cases (especially for copyright violations) there are hard caps on a number of fees the attorney can raise. Plus you can get a significant sum of the cost paid by the state, even IF you loose.
Re:Copyright Troll May Have Set an Expensive Precedent for C... by ambicapter on Tuesday November 12, 2019 @11:07AM (#21515153)
The poor person is not "capped" by the law, but by their inability to pay more, which is the case in both systems.
Re:Copyright Troll May Have Set an Expensive Precedent for C... by moccachino on Tuesday November 12, 2019 @07:32AM (#21513533)
In a way, but the downside to the losing party is limited. Also in (at least some of) these systems, it is not an automatic order for the losing party to pay, the court can decide to order it or not.

I don't think there really is any feasible way to prevent rich people and companies to have access to more/better representation.

Re:Copyright Troll May Have Set an Expensive Precedent for C... by anoncake on Tuesday November 12, 2019 @07:19AM (#21513473)
No. They can't. That's the point.