News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Meditation reduced an opioid dose needed to ease chronic ... by alwaysanagenda on Monday November 11, 2019 @12:46PM (#21506895)
I read this as:

"The answer to the opioid epidemic is just some meditation and reducing your dosage. Everything is OK, guys. Really."

Effectively, a native ad to prop up big pharma.

Re:Meditation reduced an opioid dose needed to ease chronic ... by dang on Monday November 11, 2019 @02:11PM (#21507836)
"Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith."

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Meditation reduced an opioid dose needed to ease chronic ... by yabadabadoes on Monday November 11, 2019 @02:22PM (#21507942)
If by quoting this you are saying good faith applies to article sources as much as to other HN members then I think that guideline could be clearer.
Re:Meditation reduced an opioid dose needed to ease chronic ... by dang on Monday November 11, 2019 @03:10PM (#21508384)
I thought that for a while too, but then realized that article writers are someone, so it's covered.
Re:Meditation reduced an opioid dose needed to ease chronic ... by michaelmrose on Monday November 11, 2019 @03:37PM (#21508622)
Requiring commenters to assume good faith and attack the strongest possible version of the argument is a wonderful tool to keep discussion civil and productive.

I don't see how this can possibly by applied to the internet at large which is absolutely full of loud evil people operating in bad faith.

Re:Meditation reduced an opioid dose needed to ease chronic ... by dang on Monday November 11, 2019 @08:06PM (#21510567)
HN is a large enough sample that I don't think it's so different from humans in general, including internet humans in general. If that's right, then the differences you're talking about are mostly contextual.

In this context, we do much better by practicing the guidelines in relation to everyone, even article authors. The point is not that we owe them that, but that we owe ourselves that, because it's how we can maintain our community together.

Re:Meditation reduced an opioid dose needed to ease chronic ... by michaelmrose on Tuesday November 12, 2019 @07:47PM (#21519990)
I respectfully disagree that internet humans are a representative sample of humans or that HN humans represent a sample of internet humans. In both cases the sample isn't random.

Perhaps overly optimistically I believe both samples are on average better than the overall population. People that have access to an internet connection have on average a better chance of also having access to an education. People that read hacker news are on average more likely to be the type who have the desire to read and comprehend a topic more so than the average person who often desires no more than a shallow understanding of what they believe will directly effect themselves and their fortunes.

I do think we often speak more frankly OF people than TO them even when being civil. I can think of a fair number of people where honest dialogue regarding them or their ideas would be at best insulting no matter how neutrally one proposed to conduct one self. Wherein these people literally promote evil not speaking plainly is a greater ill than being unkind.

Article's written by such folks are literally all over the net but rarely if ever appear on the main page for Hacker News. You have I'm sure more insight than I about whether they are submitted in the first place. I guess you can say its practicable to be decent to one another in an environment composed by a great than average concentration of decent people wherein all the really indecent people are either discouraged from entering in the first place or excluded thereafter.

Re:Meditation reduced an opioid dose needed to ease chronic ... by MFogleman on Monday November 11, 2019 @01:21PM (#21507261)
An ad to prop up big pharma by suggesting that people cut their opioid use by 75%?

Lets assume that this is an ad to prop up big pharma. Something between 1 of the 2 following extremes happens.

1. Every opioid user takes up meditation, and is able to reduce their opioid use by 75%. This would generally be considered a very good thing, even though it would cost big pharma 75% of their opioid profits.

2. The woman in the article is the only person in the world with this reported success, nothing changes.

Are you suggesting that forces at play are hoping that the second happens, yet all the lawsuits and criminal investigations against opioid manufacturers and distributors will go away, in part due to articles like this, despite the lack of change in numbers?

Re:Meditation reduced an opioid dose needed to ease chronic ... by hinkley on Monday November 11, 2019 @02:43PM (#21508145)
It's easier to coax people into a trap when they believe there's an escape.

It's a big part of pressure sales dark patterns, I believe.

Re:Meditation reduced an opioid dose needed to ease chronic ... by yabadabadoes on Monday November 11, 2019 @01:37PM (#21507441)
I'm afraid you aren't jaded enough.

For medications under patent, it really doesn't matter if the standard dose is 10mg or 100mg, the standard dose will have the chosen price. Since they sometimes have to sell both dosages at two different prices per mg, they also need bribes to try to make pill splitting illegal either in general or at least in medicare. With opioids "additives to prevent abuse" are also a great way to prevent pill splitting.

I should probably add that no matter how jaded one is, the field of applying meditation to pain in Western medicine predates any newer interests by big pharma. Jon Kabat-Zinn has some good research stretching back to 1980.