News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cutting the speed of ships has benefits for humans, natur... by sfifs on Monday November 11, 2019 @07:32AM (#21504294)
20% increase in the world's trading inventory and working capital tied up to get a 0.7% reduction (24% x 3%) in emissions. Yeah makes complete sense to pursue vs. other avenues! </sarcastic>
Re:Cutting the speed of ships has benefits for humans, natur... by Richard_East on Monday November 11, 2019 @08:03AM (#21504479)
Plus increase in labour costs due to slower transit times, longer shipping times pushing more companies to use air transport... a whole lot of unintended consequences.

I think its still best to focus our political willpower on accelerating the transition to electric vehicles. There is the obvious human health benefit of not having hundreds of millions of tiny engines exhausting fumes at the ground level of cities.

Re:Cutting the speed of ships has benefits for humans, natur... by dragontamer on Monday November 11, 2019 @11:40AM (#21506235)
> I think its still best to focus our political willpower on accelerating the transition to electric vehicles.

Electric vehicles, for the near term, remain a toy of rich people. Apartments will NOT have electrified parking lots, outside of a select few spaces. Tesla's "Supercharger" requires 150 kW of power-delivery per parking space. (Average american household uses ~30 kW-hrs per day, or roughly 1.25 kW on the average).

The real solution is public transportation. Electrifying public transportation (ex: monorail, trams, electric busses, etc. etc.) forces the ENTIRE car-less class to go electric. We're talking about 20%+ of America will be "forced into electric" if public transit were upgraded.

Pushing more Americans onto public transit will only make those numbers better. Tax incentives to Amtrak / Busses and other such programs should make public transit more popular.

Re:Cutting the speed of ships has benefits for humans, natur... by nickfromseattle on Monday November 11, 2019 @04:10PM (#21508938)
>Apartments will NOT have electrified parking lots, outside of a select few spaces

Why not? Are you sure that won't happen as demand increases? Is it too expensive? How much does it cost?

I was in London recently and they had electrified lamp posts. None of the houses had garages so this enabled the residents to buy electric.

Re:Cutting the speed of ships has benefits for humans, natur... by dragontamer on Monday November 11, 2019 @04:45PM (#21509231)
> Why not? Are you sure that won't happen as demand increases? Is it too expensive? How much does it cost?

I don't have the real numbers. But I can run some estimates in my head to see what is or isn't reasonable.

I'm thinking on the scale of my neighborhood. I have ~5000 housing units in my neighborhood (Mixed-housing development: single-family, townhomes, condos, and rental properties such as apartments). We have a bit over 12,000 humans living in my neighborhood.

The neighborhood design is currently scaled at maybe 20MW of power or less. I don't know for sure, but 6MW (average daily load), x3 because summer has higher loads (air conditioning)... just for a rough estimate for the power-infrastructure of my neighborhood.

Again, I don't have precise numbers. But 20MW capacity is probably the capacity of my neighborhood covering 12,000 people.

-----------

20MW will cover 133 Tesla Superchargers (150kW per). That is to say, to provide 3% of the homes in my neighborhood with a supercharger, the power-capacity needs to be doubled for the entire neighborhood.

A more reasonable estimate is for 22kW chargers (much slower, but 3-phase power and more easily supported for sure). In this case, roughly 900 chargers can be installed if my neighborhood doubles its electric capacity (18% of homes can have an electric vehicle).

And many homes are 2x or 3x car households. So really we're aiming at 200% or 300% cars-to-homes ratio if you want to go "all electric vehicles" across the whole neighborhood. To get there, my neighborhood needs to deploy something on the order of 200MW of power-capacity.

--------

So now, ask yourself. What is approximately the cost of providing 10x more electricity to every single neighborhood in the country? Its not going to be cheap, that's for sure.

Re:Cutting the speed of ships has benefits for humans, natur... by iknowstuff on Monday November 11, 2019 @04:59PM (#21509335)
Overnight charging does not require a supercharger. That's for quick stops on long journeys. All people need on a daily basis in their apartment buildings are ~4kW outlets which in the 220V world is basically any outlet.

And mind you those cars charge at night, when people are not using as much electricity.

Tesla Model 3 has a range of 250 miles at 54kWh. Say you need a range of 50 miles every day. 50mi/250mi range * 54kWh = 10.8kWh per day. This can easily be charged overnight at ~3.5kW (220V * 16A) - will take a little over 3 hours.

Re:Cutting the speed of ships has benefits for humans, natur... by dragontamer on Monday November 11, 2019 @05:03PM (#21509379)
I understand that my estimates are a bit off, but you're welcome to provide a back-of-the-napkin power-capacity result yourself if you think you have a better methodology.

5000-homes x 7kW charger == 35MW of capacity that needs to be added to my neighborhood. Still a lot of electricity, no matter how you cut it (upgrading from 20MW current capacity -> 55MW).

------

As I said, I don't have hard numbers. But we need a starting point that we agree upon for planning purposes. If you have better numbers, please share.

------------

> Tesla Model 3 has a range of 250 miles at 54kWh. Say you need a range of 50 miles every day. 50mi/250mi range * 54kWh = 10.8kWh per day. This can easily be charged overnight at ~3.5kW (220V * 16A) - will take a little over 3 hours.

EDIT: https://www.fueleconomy.gov/feg/noframes/41189.shtml

26 kWh/100 miles. EPA measures 13kW-hrs of charging every 50-miles. So my numbers are slightly different, but still within the magnitude of your result.

But that mileage will be different in the winter. This link suggests a drop of 33% efficiency... so 50-miles needs 20 kw-hrs of charging. https://teslamotorsclub.com/tmc/threads/33-range-loss-in-col...

Re:Cutting the speed of ships has benefits for humans, natur... by iknowstuff on Monday November 11, 2019 @05:11PM (#21509441)
For America: The average commute is 16 miles. 16x2/250x54kWh = 6.912kWh/day. Most modern residential circuits are 15 or 20 amps, so we're looking at a max load of either (15A x 120V =) 1800W or (20A x 120V =) 2400W. 6.912kWh/1.8kW = 4 hours of charging.

5000 * 1.8kW = 9MW when all cars are pulling the maximum load. Mind you, they will be pulling it at night, when there is excess capacity available due to lower energy use from other appliances.

Re:Cutting the speed of ships has benefits for humans, natur... by dragontamer on Monday November 11, 2019 @05:13PM (#21509453)
> The average commute is 16 miles.

That's 32-miles from home-to-work-and-back, not including grocery shopping or kids activities, or leisure activities (ball-games, bar, restaurants).

I think 50-miles is closer to reality. The average car is driving far, far, more than 16-miles per day in my experience.

32-miles just from work alone.

> max load of either (15A x 120V =) 1800W or (20A x 120V =) 2400W.

No sane person will be charging on 120V x 15A. Your 77kW-hr Tesla 3 will take 42-hours to charge on that circuit. 20A x 120V is going to take 32-hours to charge from empty. Similarly ridiculous.

Well, almost. I actually am a big proponent of hybrid-vehicles. A hybrid vehicle with 50-mile capacity will charge on a 120V x 15A circuit every night just fine (and use gasoline as a range-extender when necessary). Until power-infrastructure is better built out, I think the PHEV model is going to be friendlier to our cities and neighborhoods.

---------

To put it another way: 120V x 15A circuits charge your car at 7-miles (of range) per hour (of charging). For small batteries such as PHEVs (Volt, Prius Prime), this might be sufficient (20-miles of electric charge, maybe 50). For a 220+ mile Tesla 3 (or any other high-range electric vehicle), that's too slow.

Re:Cutting the speed of ships has benefits for humans, natur... by iknowstuff on Monday November 11, 2019 @05:42PM (#21509718)
I agree you'd want a better circuit. In Europe, people will simply use three-phase outlets to get 12kW. We are talking about average power consumption overnight though. About whether huge infrastructure changes are immediately necessary/insurmountable, or if we'll get by just fine. Trickle charging to replenish the energy used on an average day clearly does not need a lot of power. Even 50 miles can be recharged in 5 hours overnight.
Re:Cutting the speed of ships has benefits for humans, natur... by dragontamer on Monday November 11, 2019 @05:47PM (#21509748)
Sometime in the next 10 years, we'll have "smart grid" systems which will coordinate high-load activities such as car charging, appliance usage, air conditioners and more.

"Smart grid" doesn't exist yet however. For now, people will plug in their vehicles... maybe synchronized after 8pm (or whenever "night-time" energy kicks in, to save a bit of $$$), and charge at 7kW from their 3-phase power unit for the next 2 or 3 hours.

The energy companies will see this as a big spike at 8pm when the car-charger timers automatically go off, and then the energy usage will let off by 12-midnight or so.

Re:Cutting the speed of ships has benefits for humans, natur... by davidgould on Monday November 11, 2019 @09:34PM (#21511030)
What you keep seeming to miss is that you only charge the amount you drive. If you drive 50 miles you can charge on a level 1 (120V 12A = 1.4kW) in 8 hours while you sleep. It does not matter whether the car is a Spark EV (18kWh battery) or a Tesla P100 (100kWh battery) because you only charge to replace the amount you used up, not the total amount the car could hold.
Re:Cutting the speed of ships has benefits for humans, natur... by dragontamer on Tuesday November 12, 2019 @10:15AM (#21514695)
If you have a Tesla Model 3, and drive 100-miles in a day (ex: go to work, visit your cousins for their birthday, then come home), it will take 14-hours on a regular 120V x 15A charger to recharge those 100-miles.

8-hours of charging on 120V x 15A charger only charges 55 miles. You won't "recover" the 100-miles until 20-days later (-100-miles from a big-driving day, +55 miles of charge on Day1. -50 miles on the 2nd day, +55 miles on Day2, etc. etc).

Realistically speaking, the 120V x 15A charger is simply insufficient for people who actually drive 50-miles a day (and occasionally drives 100-miles).

Factor in the 33% loss of energy in the winter, factor in a mistake or two (ex: forgetting to plug in the vehicle), factor in a few nights without power (ex: hurricane or California Fires), and you're completely sunk.

----------

If you're buying electric, you need the 7kW charger (or faster), to ensure that your vehicle is fully topped off every night. That way, on your "emergency" days when two or three things happen (hurricane + visiting the cousins), you'll have enough charge to actually make it through the day.

Alternatively, buy a PHEV so that you can always leverage gasoline in those high-milage or power-outage situations.

Re:Cutting the speed of ships has benefits for humans, natur... by paganel on Monday November 11, 2019 @07:36AM (#21504315)
> 20% increase in the world's trading inventory

Which will most probably cause the producers to want to reduce that inventory by not producing that much anymore, which will further ease the pressure on the environment. Yeah, that will most probably raise some prices, but as a species we can't have our cake and eat it at the same time, at some point we do have to price in the externalities.

Re:Cutting the speed of ships has benefits for humans, natur... by MuffinFlavored on Monday November 11, 2019 @10:36AM (#21505644)
> Which will most probably cause the producers to want to reduce that inventory by not producing that much anymore

I don't think that's how that works. I'm pretty sure producers produce because there is demand and they are selling their product. They aren't producing for the fun of it.

Re:Cutting the speed of ships has benefits for humans, natur... by paganel on Monday November 11, 2019 @10:45AM (#21505730)
> there is demand and they are selling their product.

I agree with this, but reducing the ships' speed will reduce the rate and the price at which you can potentially deliver said products to the consumers, which in effect will reduce the effective demand.

As an example, I bet there's lots of people that would want to have rocks delivered to them from the Moon, i.e. there is a notional demand for Moon rocks, but because transporting rocks from the Moon to said customers is prohibitively expensive the effective demand for such an item is close to 0. Making trans-oceanic transport more expensive works the same way.

Re:Cutting the speed of ships has benefits for humans, natur... by MuffinFlavored on Monday November 11, 2019 @11:15AM (#21505985)
Wouldn't this just move more goods that need to be delivered time-sensitively to the air, which pollutes even more?
Re:Cutting the speed of ships has benefits for humans, natur... by paganel on Monday November 11, 2019 @11:37AM (#21506198)
Some of them probably, yeah, but it will make them more expensive by at least an order of magnitude so that demand will certainly fell. Measures like these are in effect additional taxes.
Re:Cutting the speed of ships has benefits for humans, natur... by xondono on Tuesday November 12, 2019 @02:24AM (#21512191)
That's when I'm getting lost

>but reducing the ships' speed will reduce the rate and the price at which you can potentially deliver said products (Emphasis mine)

The moon rock argument would be solid if the prices were to rise, but by your own admission, it would lower them. The regulation just bans "high-speed" expensive shipping.

As another commenter has stated, this will just make time-sensitive shipments to switch to the cheapest alternative, and for non-time-sensitive items like consumer goods, this will just mean higher stockpiling in origin.

As anyone who has work on In-demand manufacturing will tell you, the slower the transport the higher the waste.

Re:Cutting the speed of ships has benefits for humans, natur... by xondono on Monday November 11, 2019 @08:21AM (#21504597)
How do you get to the conclusion that producers will want to reduce their output?

If anything they will increase it, since the feedback loop that tells them when to cut back is now way slower, and most consumer facing would rather overproduce than lose sales.

Re:Cutting the speed of ships has benefits for humans, natur... by paganel on Monday November 11, 2019 @09:16AM (#21504954)
> How do you get to the conclusion that producers will want to reduce their output?

An output that just sits as additional inventory doesn't actually produce any revenues, at some point it becomes economically rational to reduce said output to levels that make sense again (i.e. that don't sit in deposits collecting dust instead of being in customers' hands half a world away).

Re:Cutting the speed of ships has benefits for humans, natur... by Nasrudith on Monday November 11, 2019 @04:31PM (#21509129)
Alternatively couldn't that easily cause a rise in the number of ships at sea instead? Less supply for the demand means that it would pay to get into it even with reduced yield. And building around 20% more ships isn't exactly trivial environmentally.
Re:Cutting the speed of ships has benefits for humans, natur... by Camas on Monday November 11, 2019 @08:04AM (#21504488)
Speed limits wouldn't price in any externalities.
Re:Cutting the speed of ships has benefits for humans, natur... by paganel on Monday November 11, 2019 @09:17AM (#21504966)
As I tried to explain earlier, speed limits will most probably reduce the rate at which products are sold, which will most probably cause the price of said products to increase. That's the "price in" element I had in mind.
Re:Cutting the speed of ships has benefits for humans, natur... by Camas on Tuesday November 12, 2019 @08:52AM (#21514040)
That's not pricing in an externality though, it's just raising the cost.
Re:Cutting the speed of ships has benefits for humans, natur... by jonstewart on Monday November 11, 2019 @09:30AM (#21505071)
Other commentators are pointing out your gross flippancy about world capital and whatnot. I will say, when optimizing code, I take every 0.7% improvement I can get. As the world shifts to optimizing for CO2 emissions, every 0.7% that can be done soon and without capital investment is a no-brainer.

The fast ships are likely operating at inefficient speeds, which is only made possible by transporting premium cargo where the increased costs are absorbed by the ultimate higher prices of the goods. In a real sense, the world is paying too much by a psychological need for instant gratification.

Note that cargo ships have all sorts of negative externalities beyond CO2 emissions. For example, the studies that are coming out now on the impact of fine particulates... well, I’d short the Diesel engine all the way to $0. So while a carbon tax might be the best global win for all industries, this sounds like one that could be implemented tomorrow and have a real impact.

Re:Cutting the speed of ships has benefits for humans, natur... by danw1979 on Monday November 11, 2019 @08:42AM (#21504739)
Are you implying that most of the world's trading inventory and working capital is, at any given moment, afloat on cargo ships ?
Re:Cutting the speed of ships has benefits for humans, natur... by cascom on Monday November 11, 2019 @09:22AM (#21505004)
no, but the value is staggering given that commercial vessels may have hundreds of millions of dollars of product aboard at any given time [1]

Check out the the number of commercial ships on this map - tell me slowing them all down is a good idea for world trade. [2]

[1] https://cdn.ihs.com/www/pdf/Vessel-Accumulation-Cargo-Value-...

[2] https://www.marinetraffic.com/en/ais/home/centerx:-15.5/cent...

Re:Cutting the speed of ships has benefits for humans, natur... by jellicle on Monday November 11, 2019 @09:50AM (#21505232)
That's a huge reduction in world emissions for a rather tiny cost.
Re:Cutting the speed of ships has benefits for humans, natur... by hackeraccount on Monday November 11, 2019 @01:03PM (#21507076)
How confident are you in the estimate of cost? Heck, I'm not even confident in the estimation of emission reduction - this seems very much like something that might have weird knock on effects that causes surprising results.