News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by rayiner on Saturday November 09, 2019 @12:54PM (#21492964)
> In 1919, alarmed by the growing presence of “peoples of Asiatic races,” the Anti-Alien League called for a constitutional amendment “to restrict citizenship by birth within the United States to the children of parents who are of a race which is eligible for citizenship”—i.e., whites. Senator Wesley Jones, of Washington State, promised to introduce such a measure—a proposal not unlike today’s calls to end birthright citizenship.

The majority of countries don’t have birthright citizenship, and Ireland and New Zealand got rid of it in the 21st century. Yet in the view of the New Yorker, that common rule is “not unlike” a rule that would limit citizenship to a specific race.

(I’m a big proponent of birthright citizenship. But the New Yorker’s framing of it devalues it by making it seem like the baseline, instead of an example of American exceptionalism.)

Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by tormeh on Saturday November 09, 2019 @01:00PM (#21493028)
>American exceptionalism

Almost the entire North and South America has it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jus_soli

Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by rayiner on Saturday November 09, 2019 @01:22PM (#21493204)
The US is historically unique in its ability to Americanize immigrants and lift them into prosperity. Birthright citizenship isn’t unique to the US, but the is a pillar of what makes the US unique.
Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by pcwalton on Saturday November 09, 2019 @02:03PM (#21493522)
Honestly, Canada is actually doing better than the US in assimilating and lifting immigrants into prosperity these days, because it has a more modern immigration system (having avoided legislative gridlock and populist backlashes, for the most part) coupled with birthright citizenship. Consequently, Canada has a larger proportion of immigrants than the US. It also slightly beats the US on most measures of human development.
Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by Mikeb85 on Saturday November 09, 2019 @04:36PM (#21494536)
Canada is terrible at assimilating immigrants, the only reason we have less poverty is because our immigration laws are much tougher than the US' and we take in mostly richer immigrants.
Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by pcwalton on Saturday November 09, 2019 @04:38PM (#21494555)
As I mentioned below, Canada admits more immigrants per capita than the US does, and far more refugees (it surpasses the US in absolute numbers, not even per capita).
Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by SamReidHughes on Saturday November 09, 2019 @06:59PM (#21495404)
You're ignoring all the untalented, unskilled immigrants the U.S. admits, that aren't refugees, which is what drives down U.S. numbers.
Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by Mikeb85 on Saturday November 09, 2019 @04:42PM (#21494585)
That doesn't mean we're not more selective. Numbers per capita say nothing about the selection process, especially when it's far lower in terms of sheer numbers.

The refugees we do take in (28k per year is nothing) get a decent amount of support mainly because most of our immigrants are relatively rich Chinese, Indians, Filipinos, etc...

Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by pcwalton on Saturday November 09, 2019 @04:49PM (#21494616)
New U.S. immigrants are about as educated as new Canadian immigrants: https://www.cato.org/blog/new-us-immigrants-are-educated-new...

In fact, new U.S. immigrants are a bit more likely to have advanced degrees.

Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by Mikeb85 on Saturday November 09, 2019 @04:58PM (#21494681)
More likely to have advanced degrees but less educated overall.

The US takes in more outliers due to high-paying jobs in SV and on Wall Street, Canada takes in richer immigrants on average. Your own charts reflect that.

Edit - look at Figure 3. 40% of immigrants to Canada have a bachelors or advanced degree. Versus only 29% of US immigrants.

And that doesn't even take into account the fact that many immigrants to Canada come here to go to university (paying more than double what local students pay).

Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by desert_boi on Sunday November 10, 2019 @12:16AM (#21496516)
How much immigration in Canada is undocumented/illegal (depending on your political persuasion)?
Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by Mikeb85 on Sunday November 10, 2019 @01:15AM (#21496703)
Almost none. It exists but not in any large numbers because illegal immigrants can't work, get bank accounts, drivers licenses, go to schools, etc...

If you're a business owner and hire illegal immigrants, you risk up to 2 years jail time personally and a $50k fine. So almost no one takes that risk.

The few that are here illegally generally come legally, overstay and have family to harbour them.

And keep in mind I'm in an industry that, in the US, is known for employing illegal immigrants (restaurants). In 17 years, I've never seen one nor heard of anyone hiring them. I'm sure it happens in a few ethnic enclaves but it's definitely not typical.

I read a statistic somewhere that California alone has more than 10x as many illegal immigrants as all of Canada.

Of course I should also add, we do of course allow more legal immigration per capita than the US, many irregular border crossers are granted temporary status while their cases are processed and in general our bureaucracy seems less insane than the US'.

Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by Aloha on Saturday November 09, 2019 @03:07PM (#21493967)
I'm skeptical that Canada does better at assimilating, just based on first hand empirical evidence I've seen in Vancouver and Toronto. I would agree that Canada is doing better at lifting people out of poverty currently.
Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by toasterlovin on Saturday November 09, 2019 @04:11PM (#21494377)
Canada doesn’t do better at lifting people out of poverty. They’re just more selective in who they let in and don’t have a huge second world country at their southern border.
Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by dang on Tuesday November 12, 2019 @02:29AM (#21512209)
Edit: I misread the comment. Sorry!

Please don't post flamebait to HN. We've had to ask you this before. We ban accounts that do it. I don't want to ban you, so please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and fix this.

Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by toasterlovin on Tuesday November 12, 2019 @11:24AM (#21515311)
Hey dang, I agree with your warnings down thread. I let the person I was responding to get to me and I should have conducted myself better. Sorry. I’m having a hard time figuring out what the issue is with this particular comment, though.
Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by dang on Tuesday November 12, 2019 @01:42PM (#21516777)
I went back to look for the obvious flamebait which I saw in there, and realized that it was I who had misread your comment. Argh! I'm sorry.

Moderation is guesswork done in haste, because that's the only way to get through the mountain of content that piles up every day. But it's really bad to get scoldings wrong.

In case you're curious, I read your comment as from a Canadian perspective, referring to the U.S. as a second-world country as a snarky swipe. Most likely I was primed to do this because I'm Canadian and have sometimes heard people talk that way. But clearly you were making an economic argument with that statement, not taking a nationalistic swipe, so there was no need for a moderation reply. Now that I read more closely, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21495051 was the comment that actually did the thing I read into yours, so I'll post a moderation reply there.

Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by toasterlovin on Tuesday November 12, 2019 @02:17PM (#21517131)
No worries. I definitely need to work on my tone when I get riled up (as evidenced by my remarks down thread; European chauvinism regarding the US is a pet peeve of mine), so the larger point still stands.

Thanks again for what you do on here. HN is my favorite place to exchange ideas.

Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by dang on Tuesday November 12, 2019 @03:06PM (#21517582)
Appreciated. And given your username I hope you saw the toaster threads!

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21432144

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21164014

Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by pcwalton on Saturday November 09, 2019 @04:33PM (#21494524)
Canada's immigration rate is 5.3 per year per 1000 residents (200K per year, population 37.59M). The US immigration rate is 3.6 per year per 1000 residents (1.18M per year, population 327.2M). And in absolute (not per capita!) terms, Canada resettles more refugees than the US [1]. The US is in fact more selective (probably owing to decades of legislative gridlock leaving us with an outdated bureaucratic nightmare of an immigration system nobody on either the left or the right likes).

[1]: https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2019/06/19/canada-now-...

Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by Mikeb85 on Saturday November 09, 2019 @04:46PM (#21494600)
200k per year isn't that much. And yes Canada is more selective. Per capita numbers (especially when absolute numbers are that low) say nothing about how selective we are.
Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by toasterlovin on Monday November 11, 2019 @02:31AM (#21502876)
I'm not sure how you come to the conclusion that Canada has less selective immigration. The Canadian system is merit based and has a relatively low rate of illegal immigration. The US has 50 million hispanic Americans (about 13 million more people than the entirety of Canada). Almost all of their ancestors were not in this country 70 years ago. And many of their ancestors came to this country illegally and, thus, faced no sort of selective filter whatsoever.
Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by JamesBarney on Sunday November 10, 2019 @04:48AM (#21497288)
Imagine two countries of 100,000 people. The first lets in 1,000 people per year, all of postgrad degrees. The second lets in 500 per year selected from a lottery.

Which is more selective?

Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by LOLNOPENOPE on Saturday November 09, 2019 @11:18PM (#21496375)
From the same source you just shared there's a graph of refugee resettlements.

Canada only is ahead of the US as of 2018. Historically Canada hasn't even been close.

Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by teh_klev on Saturday November 09, 2019 @05:53PM (#21495051)
> and don’t have a huge second world country at their southern border.

Some might dispute that claim.

Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by dang on Tuesday November 12, 2019 @01:56PM (#21516932)
Please don't post nationalistic flamebait to HN. We ban accounts that do that. If you'd please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and use the site in its intended spirit, we'd be grateful.
[dead]
[dead]
[dead]
[dead]
Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by dang on Tuesday November 12, 2019 @02:30AM (#21512217)
Please don't perpetuate flamewars on HN. We're trying to avoid that here.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by toasterlovin on Sunday November 10, 2019 @09:00PM (#21501548)
You casually slandered my entire country and now you have a problem with my tone? What, exactly, do you expect? Especially when you’re just flat out wrong. I’m not even arguing that the US is the best, merely that it’s clearly a first world country, as evidenced by the incredible prosperity that most Americans participate in.

And regarding health care and a social safety net: you should familiarize yourself with Medicaid and our welfare programs. Many of the poorest Americans receive assistance of various kinds, on par with many first world nations.

Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by teh_klev on Monday November 11, 2019 @12:21AM (#21502359)
> You casually slandered my entire country

I made an observation about the state and its governance, not the inhabitants. These are two quite different things.

Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by toasterlovin on Monday November 11, 2019 @02:25AM (#21502857)
Alright, I'm out of here. Just for the record, though: only one of us offered any evidence to support their position. And it wasn't you.
Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by dang on Tuesday November 12, 2019 @02:30AM (#21512213)
Starting and perpetuating flamewars will get you banned here. Please don't do that on HN.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by justinclift on Monday November 11, 2019 @04:25AM (#21503275)
As a data point, "first", "second", "third" world country (the term) means a different thing than you're both trying to convey.

It's a literal grouping of countries by an old system, rather than meaning "economic" or "cultural" backwater.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three-world_model

As a 2nd data point, the median income response is about economic power. It's obviously possible to be economically strong whilst at the same time having poor culture.

There seem to be several current examples of this in the world. :/

Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by toasterlovin on Monday November 11, 2019 @10:07AM (#21505380)
You are citing a historic (and outdated) meaning of the three world system. The current meaning is essentially an economic classification:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_World

“Since the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991, the definition has instead largely shifted to any country with little political risk and a well functioning democracy, rule of law, capitalist economy, economic stability, and high standard of living. Various ways in which modern First World countries are often determined include GDP, GNP, literacy rates, life expectancy, and the Human Development Index.”

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_World

“Subsequently the actual meaning of the terms "First World", "Second World" and "Third World" changed from being based on political ideology to an economic definition.”

Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by justinclift on Monday November 11, 2019 @11:43AM (#21506264)
Thanks, wasn't aware of the change being regarded as anything official. Looks like it could be considered as such these days. :)
Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by mchaver on Saturday November 09, 2019 @01:59PM (#21493490)
Hmm, I think the other countries in the Americas have been pretty successful at integrating immigrants as well. The prosperous ones also offer opportunities for those immigrants. I think being the largest economy and being so influential is more unique among other nations.
Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by namirez on Saturday November 09, 2019 @03:47PM (#21494247)
> the is a pillar of what makes the US unique.

Or perhaps you've not lived in other countries. Don't get me wrong; the US is doing fine, but honestly it's no so unique or even the best place for an average immigrant. For some highly-skilled immigrants, however, the US is unique in terms of opportunities.

Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by rayiner on Saturday November 09, 2019 @04:40PM (#21494566)
I’m an immigrant to the US from an Asian country.
Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by Braggadocious on Sunday November 10, 2019 @04:11AM (#21497204)
>“to restrict citizenship by birth within the United States to the children of parents who are of a race which is eligible for citizenship”—i.e., whites

White was also not considered a race in the 20's. There were Nordics, Jews, Irish, Eastern Europeans, and Southern Europeans. American eugenicists also were very much into "building" a race. They would have family breed competitions at fairs where families would compete like dogs or livestock for who were the best breeding stock. It wasnt a white vs colored, it was a tall, intelligent, hard-working, disease-free, group of mostly northern europeans vs anyone short, stalky, diseased, epileptic, mentally deficient, criminal, promiscuous, obsessed with art, etc. For instance, Irish were considered a problem because they didnt work hard, were obsessed with art and music, were short, and susceptible to tuberculosis. Mind you, this is not scientific fact, this is just the nonsense they spouted at the time. They also believed in a thing called "Germplasm" which roughly translated to gene pool, but of course even today we're not exactly clear on what's genetically inheritable and what isnt.

I should also mention, this is the deeply disturbing origin of the progressive movement in america. Using what they thought was superior scientific understanding of the natural world, the IQ test, birth control, the gifted student program, the use of performance metrics in school and workplaces to justify glass ceilings, firings, mass deportation, and mass sterilizations of anyone deemed deficient in any way by society. The work americans did to create a legal framework for eugenics would be borrowed by the Nazis to create their own legal framework for the deportation and final solution of the jews.

Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by dragonwriter on Sunday November 10, 2019 @05:57AM (#21497484)
> White was also not considered a race in the 20's.

Yes, it was.

> There were Nordics, Jews, Irish, Eastern Europeans, and Southern Europeans.

The existence of those groups, and the fact that then-current concepts of whiteness would exclude some or all of them, doesn't change the fact that “White” was the identity of the dominant racial group, and had been for quite some time by the 1920s.

> I should also mention, this is the deeply disturbing origin of the progressive movement in america.

No, it wasn't. Oh, deeply disturbing it was, but it wasn't the origin of the progressive movement in America. It's true that the eugenics movement occurred within one of many (often overlapping in time) movements that took the name “progressive” in US history, but it wasn't the first, nor one historically strongly connected to any of the modern groups with the name.

Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by Braggadocious on Monday November 11, 2019 @12:24AM (#21502374)
I respect your decision to be completely and utterly wrong. The progressive movement was the movement of eugenics. We were going to improve the human race through science, technology, and industrialization. Rockefeller Foundation funded eugenics research. Carnegie and Stanford created the scientific studies that would help support hundreds of new eugenics laws. UC Berkeley, Harvard, Columbia, etc would teach eugenics to students. We wiped the history clean of all this during WWII, but if you do some keen wikipedia'ing, or go oldschool and read some books, it's all there for you.

And no, there was no group of white people saying white people are all great, stick together, etc. That wouldnt happen until the 60's and 70's, after eugenics was taboo.

Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by dragonwriter on Monday November 11, 2019 @04:03AM (#21503171)
> I respect your decision to be completely and utterly wrong

That’s hilarious but...

> The progressive movement was the movement of eugenics.

There, again, have been a number of separate “progressive” movements in US history, eugenics was a minority view within one of them. But, while you are wrong here, it's not nearly so flagrantly wrong as:

> And no, there was no group of white people saying white people are all great, stick together, etc. That wouldnt happen until the 60's and 70's, after eugenics was taboo.

I don't think it ever happened; even white racists don't tend to think white people are all great. But, no, white racists that saw the race they favored as the “white” race did not first show up in the 1960s-1970s, as evidence by the Cornerstone Speech in which Confederate Vice President Alexander Stephens laid out his view of the central case for the Confederate cause in 1861: “...Our new government is founded upon exactly the opposite ideas; its foundations are laid, its cornerstone rests, upon the great truth that the negro is not equal to the white man; that slavery, subordination to the superior race, is his natural and normal condition. ...”

Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by Braggadocious on Monday November 11, 2019 @04:39AM (#21503342)
The progressive era was between the start of the industrial revolution and the start of WWII.

>even white racists don't tend to think white people are all great.

You are so committed to this modern liberal partisan revisionist historiography that you are willing to admit the narrative doesn't make any sense, and yet equally willing to keep at it. That's commitment.

Irish, Italians, russians, and other "inferior" whites were always considered white. "White" has never and will never be the barrier to entry into this country or into the american hierarchy. Looks, charm, stature, sharpness of mind, focus on meaningful pursuits like work, not being too interested in "meaningless pursuits" like art and music. Not being promiscuous, no criminality, no epilepsy, no "feeble-mindedness" or imbecility. This is what race was about. Virginia aristocracy, the Boston Brahmins etc, were spurred on by the leading science and technology of the day, to believe these attributes were genetically inherited and "selected" by nature, which meant they could also be selected with Mendelism. We were not interested in a "white race." Since race was something you could control, we were interested in a "superior american germplasm" a genepool of the best of the best while the rest were sterilized, aborted, deported, or imprisoned in jails, asylums, or reservations. American eugenicists were interested in "building a race." A concept Hitler adopted and was quoted talking about fairly often.

Racism was not white vs black. Its nowhere near that simple

Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by dragonwriter on Monday November 11, 2019 @09:24AM (#21505032)
> Racism was not white vs black.

Racism was and is more complex than just white vs. black, but that wasn't your claim upthread that I have been arguing against.

What you claimed previously was that white was not considered a race before the 1920s. It absolutely was, and there are copious prominent invocations of white racial identity in US history prior to that time—as I've shown with the Cornerstone speech—and while racism is more complex than just white vs. black (and ideas of just who is white have evolved), white vs. black has been a key racial divide for the whole history of the country.

Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by lasagnaphil on Sunday November 10, 2019 @08:18AM (#21497837)
I'm currently reading about this now on Wikipedia, and holy crap this a chunk of US history that I've not looked before. It seems that the eugenic movement was fully developed in California, way before the Nazis imported it from them and used it to their advantage...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eugenics_in_the_United_States

Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by Braggadocious on Monday November 11, 2019 @12:27AM (#21502393)
California sterilized more Americans under the eugenics movement than any other state. Virginia is second. This was not a small movement. I suggest reading the book "Imbeciles" by Adam Cohen. Most historical societies downplay a lot of what happened, so you can find things on wikipedia but to get a full picture, books are better. I'm right now looking to find what exactly the eugenics curriculum was at UC Berkeley and Stanford since it was an entire area of study at many universities at the time.
Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by NeedMoreTea on Saturday November 09, 2019 @02:33PM (#21493737)
Ireland didn't get rid of it, they restricted it and it remains very generous compared to just about everywhere else. One parent an Irish or British citizen, or with right to residence in either Ireland or Northern Ireland - there may well be other categories acceptable. They retain the island of Ireland extra-territorial limit too.

This, along with the grandparent clause, has the probably unintended consequence that something astonishing like a sixth or eighth of the UK is eligible for Irish citizenship.

Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by pjc50 on Saturday November 09, 2019 @03:38PM (#21494199)
Yep. Brexit caused a wave of people researching their Irish ancestry for the passports. Not to mention that children of NI residents can potentially claim two birthright citizenships.
Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by rayiner on Saturday November 09, 2019 @07:09PM (#21495443)
Those restrictions are exactly what Steve King’s bill imposed. Citizenship would be limited to children born in the US with at least one parent that was a US citizen or legal permanent resident: https://www.congress.gov/bill/116th-congress/house-bill/140. It was deemed too racist to pursue even under the Trump administration.

There is no equivalent to the grandparent thing in the US, but that would be deemed even more racist.

Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by 8note on Saturday November 09, 2019 @11:17PM (#21496374)
this is worded on a way that suggests that because the Irish one isn't particularly racist, or at least not in a particularly bad way, that an equivalent law in the US shouldn't be considered racist.

That ignores the difference in immigration and emigration between the two countries. in Ireland, it enables ethnic Irish to return home if their ancestors moved away, whereas in America, it would promote migrants from one non-ethnically American country over another, which in the context of prioritizing white immigrants over anything else, makes it pretty racist

Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by rayiner on Saturday November 09, 2019 @11:48PM (#21496450)
> this is worded on a way that suggests that because the Irish one isn't particularly racist, or at least not in a particularly bad way, that an equivalent law in the US shouldn't be considered racist.

I’m pretty sure it’s worded to imply that the Irish one is pretty racist, but they just don’t realize it because the Overton window in Europe is very skewed on this issue.

> That ignores the difference in immigration and emigration between the two countries. in Ireland, it enables ethnic Irish to return home if their ancestors moved away, whereas in America, it would promote migrants from one non-ethnically American country over another, which in the context of prioritizing white immigrants over anything else, makes it pretty racist

Why should ethnic Irish migrants get preference over anyone else? Would it be okay if the US did something similar for ethnic British?

Re:When America Tried to Deport Its Radicals by raincom on Saturday November 09, 2019 @02:54PM (#21493872)