News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Open Letter to the Linux Foundation by voxl on Friday November 08, 2019 @01:12PM (#21485016)
If someone says they're going to bomb an event on Twitter should they be banned? Yes, everyone agrees.

If someone says they're a race realist and that they're going to make fun of all the black people in tech should they be banned? Not everyone agrees.

If someone analyzes IQ studies about race realism to highlight the flaws in methodology but doesn't outright condemn race realism should they be banned? No, everyone agrees.

To claim that its 1984 because we're trying to work out the fuzziness in the middle is absurd.

Re:Open Letter to the Linux Foundation by michaelmrose on Friday November 08, 2019 @01:41PM (#21485325)
If in one context someone expresses beliefs I find odious but they do not say odious things or behave improperly in another say tech conferences I think they ought to be able to come to a conference and talk about tech.

I don't say this because I want to help odious people but because I don't want other people judging me.

People have many different beliefs and it ought to be sufficient to respect one another rather than agree on all points.

What if merely not denouncing trumptards with sufficient vigor is sufficient to paint me as undesirable.

Re:Open Letter to the Linux Foundation by potatoz2 on Friday November 08, 2019 @03:31PM (#21486399)
That's a fair fear to have and these are difficult questions.

But take what you advocate to its logical extreme: what if I say it'd be ideal if all minorities would die of terrible diseases to "cleanse" tech/the country/etc., but without calling for direct violence. It's an opinion. Would you be OK with me speaking at a conference and being given the associated prestige?

Re:Open Letter to the Linux Foundation by pnako on Friday November 08, 2019 @07:26PM (#21488484)
Sarah Jeong was actually _hired_ by the New York Times after tweeting the kind of vile language you are mentioning. So clearly it's not a problem for everyone. But I understand it's a whataboutism argument.

So my position is that organizations and individuals should, generally, be free to speak, and free to organize as they see fit (including hiring, or not, someone). Because it's the best way to minimize conflict.

Re:Open Letter to the Linux Foundation by Fellshard on Friday November 08, 2019 @07:42PM (#21488580)
I would agree with you, /except/ that we should also then hold organizations to their own standards, because if they violate them, it indicates that their proclaimed standards are disingenuous, and are covering for some other reason.
Re:Open Letter to the Linux Foundation by Canada on Friday November 08, 2019 @04:03PM (#21486724)
I would be totally OK with listening to your technical presentation. I'm not concerned with your other opinions. Or rather, I refuse to be forced by others to be concerned with your other opinions.

I'd listen to quality presentation on a technical subject that interests me even if the presenter was Hitler or Pol Pot.

I don't think I like the opinions of this Sarah Mei on Twitter, but I'd happily listen to her talk on another subject that does interest me.

Re:Open Letter to the Linux Foundation by Fellshard on Friday November 08, 2019 @04:28PM (#21487003)
Exactly this. And Robert Martin has made similar sentiments clear in prior discussions with her.
[dead]
Re:Open Letter to the Linux Foundation by a1369209993 on Saturday November 09, 2019 @12:46AM (#21489865)
Seriously? You'd ignore someone's (we're assuming, for the sake of argument) otherwise insightful and well-reasoned technical presentation because you dislike them personally for unrelated (if justified) reasons? Because that is literally ad hominem[0].

0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ad_hominem

Re:Open Letter to the Linux Foundation by ianwalter on Saturday November 09, 2019 @01:02AM (#21489912)
Yes, without a doubt. Its not about “disliking them personally”. In that example it’s about not giving legitimacy to someone who doesn’t deserve it. In the grand scheme of things, some technical insight is insignificant compared to the perpetuation of evil and suffering.
Re:Open Letter to the Linux Foundation by Canada on Saturday November 09, 2019 @09:06AM (#21491606)
I'm not sure how listening to someone's presentation or reading their article about Ruby on Rails conveys legitimacy on their political views.

In your view, how does this transfer of legitimacy take place?

Re:Open Letter to the Linux Foundation by Fellshard on Friday November 08, 2019 @11:57PM (#21489714)
If your conscience is burdened by hearing the words someone says, may I propose you need to work on filtering words? That implies you are digesting and importing everything you hear directly into your worldview, instead of examining what people say critically in case they are lying or being disingenuous.
Re:Open Letter to the Linux Foundation by ianwalter on Saturday November 09, 2019 @12:56AM (#21489896)
“Hearing the words” is an oversimplification. By attending that talk you are giving this person legitimacy. You are implicitly saying that this person belongs in our society. You are contributing, in a small way, to our society being open to wildly dangerous people. I personally don’t want to live in a society where people who wish death on minorities are accepted. This is not hard!
Re:Open Letter to the Linux Foundation by Fellshard on Saturday November 09, 2019 @01:18AM (#21489965)
I continue to not buy the 'lending legitimacy' argument at all. Listening to someone's words helps me understand more accurately what they are attempting to convey. It is up to me to use that conveyed perspective correctly. I'd rather hear the words of someone I fiercely disagree with than craft a strawman in my own head to counter, because then I can correctly craft the antidote when speaking to others who /are/ being persuaded by such a view.
Re:Open Letter to the Linux Foundation by michaelmrose on Saturday November 09, 2019 @11:30AM (#21492429)
Maybe this person fell for a conman and in fact still DOES belong in our society. More than 49% of the country is stupid but 49% isn't literally hitler.
Re:Open Letter to the Linux Foundation by DuskStar on Saturday November 09, 2019 @12:04AM (#21489728)
Well, to turn things around... You think people haven't just kept their head down, ignored the speaker's politics, and paid attention to the technical aspects of a talk when it's coming from someone on the left?
[dead]
Re:Open Letter to the Linux Foundation by michaelmrose on Sunday November 10, 2019 @02:11PM (#21499574)
In your opinion a single picture from 2016 showing that person wearing a Maga hat is sufficient to render them a non person forever?
Re:Open Letter to the Linux Foundation by Throwawayaerlei on Saturday November 09, 2019 @07:54AM (#21491219)
Just to be very clear, what is you Solution to these irredeemable people who you believe don't "belong in our society"? What can it be other than death, or exile resulting in premature death?

Have you thought through the implications of trying to do this to at minimum 1/3 of the population of the US? And what that 1/3 or more are concluding from this opinion being widely expressed in the US right now?

Re:Open Letter to the Linux Foundation by ianwalter on Saturday November 09, 2019 @08:18AM (#21491342)
No the solution is not death. Thats is such a lazy conclusion. If you know someone has a really terrible and dangerous opinion, you dont have to attend their tech talk. Just dont support them in any way personally. Its that simple.
Re:Open Letter to the Linux Foundation by Throwawayaerlei on Saturday November 09, 2019 @08:38AM (#21491463)
But that's not what you said:

"A person like that does not belong in our society much less should be given my time."

What you're saying now only covers the last part of your statement, what about the "does not belong in our society" part?

And why are you evading the questions about what effects these type of statements have on the 1/3 or more of the US that's targeted by them? You really think that's a free action?

Re:Open Letter to the Linux Foundation by zapita on Saturday November 09, 2019 @05:54AM (#21490771)
Would you still be as comfortable listening to a technical presentation by an advocate of violent ethnic cleansing of minorities if you yourself belonged to a targeted ethnic group?

Would you still be ok listening to “a quality presentation by Hitler” if you were Jewish and your grandparents died in the Holocaust?

Re:Open Letter to the Linux Foundation by 4bpp on Saturday November 09, 2019 @07:02AM (#21491016)
Not the parent poster, but probably in a similar boat because I would be ok listening to "a quality presentation by Sarah Mei" even though I am considered a member of a group I have a creeping suspicion they would be quite happy to send to the "showers" if only the political climate allowed them to - and I'm very glad it doesn't! - and already had a number of relations get hounded out of society by their associates.

(Yes to the Hitler question too.)

Re:Open Letter to the Linux Foundation by michaelmrose on Saturday November 09, 2019 @11:27AM (#21492415)
I'd wait for Hitler to finish presenting and then get a rope and hang him until dead. How we deal with extremes can be revelatory but often just muddies the water. For example here it introduces multiple novel elements that aren't present in the original example. The need for justice, personal threat, emotional involvement that nearly always destroys any hope of rational argument.

More importantly in America it can't be a moral crime to vote for the wrong side else we can't continue as a republic. Our country requires the ability to have regularly scheduled revolutions without being torn asunder.

Re:Open Letter to the Linux Foundation by Throwawayaerlei on Saturday November 09, 2019 @11:48AM (#21492548)
More importantly in America it can't be a moral crime to vote for the wrong side else we can't continue as a republic. Our country requires the ability to have regularly scheduled revolutions without being torn asunder.

The Republic is dead, there is no credible path forward that's going to continue it, in part because one side has stopped accepting the results of our "regularly scheduled revolutions" if they don't win. Which perhaps not counting G. H. W. Bush has been steadily more clear with each Republican Presidential election victory starting with Nixon before Watergate.

Re:Open Letter to the Linux Foundation by Canada on Saturday November 09, 2019 @08:46AM (#21491497)
Yes to both questions.

Hitler would have to be presenting something really outstanding to make it worth my while. Hitler and Pol Pot are extreme examples of mass murderers, of course. I'm resorting to such hyperbole to make a point: I'm not going to deny myself access to helpful information just because I can't stand the person offering it, nor do I believe it is reasonable to ask others to do so.

Operation Paperclip is a good example of this principle in practice involving actual Nazis.

Re:Open Letter to the Linux Foundation by zapita on Saturday November 09, 2019 @02:34PM (#21493738)
Do you think your jewish, black or lgbt peers, for example, would answer the same? Would they also be comfortable with your "resorting to hyperboles to make a point"?
Re:Open Letter to the Linux Foundation by Canada on Saturday November 09, 2019 @06:18PM (#21495193)
I'm not sure, I'll have ask if they're interested in Mein Fuhrer's Modern client side Javascript tutorial and get back to you.
Re:Open Letter to the Linux Foundation by HeroOfAges on Monday November 11, 2019 @01:07PM (#21507111)
Allow me to answer this question for you: As a Black man in tech (my skin crawls every time I have to make this clear i n these types of discussions because I absolutely DESPISE identity politics) I would answer the same. There, you have an answer from someone who's opinion carries more weight in this context because of the color of my skin. Also, Canada's great grandparent comment was less hyperbolic than yours.
Re:Open Letter to the Linux Foundation by someguydave on Saturday November 16, 2019 @12:38AM (#21551210)
Do you think Jews want the world to forget Hitler?
Re:Open Letter to the Linux Foundation by 08-15 on Friday November 08, 2019 @01:41PM (#21485331)
> If someone says they're going to bomb an event on Twitter should they be banned? Yes, everyone agrees.

What? No, not everyone agrees! That someone should be arrested, but keep his Twitter account. We have laws and law enforcement for a reason, and we don't need companies to play speech police, which, incidentally, in this particular case, would make law enforcement more difficult.

> If someone analyzes IQ studies... everyone agrees.

Unfortunately, you're wrong again. Some radicals would want you banned for merely using the word "race", regardless of context.

Re:Open Letter to the Linux Foundation by DuskStar on Friday November 08, 2019 @02:05PM (#21485564)
> What? No, not everyone agrees! That someone should be arrested, but keep his Twitter account. We have laws and law enforcement for a reason, and we don't need companies to play speech police, which, incidentally, in this particular case, would make law enforcement more difficult.

Exactly what I was thinking. And frankly, I'd rather have someone post "Imma shoot up ur confrence" and get arrested because of that post than have them avoid Twitter and instead, yaknow, actually shoot up the conference.

Re:Open Letter to the Linux Foundation by lliamander on Friday November 08, 2019 @02:44PM (#21485966)
Who needs laws when you can just ban people from using an ATM if they disagree with the values of a bank?
Re:Open Letter to the Linux Foundation by traverseda on Friday November 08, 2019 @01:29PM (#21485191)
Huh, that's not where I'd have assumed those lines were.

* Yes, everyone agrees

* Almost everyone agrees on this one

* Not everyone agrees, but the public consensus seems like they'd probably be banned.

I guess we just live in different filter bubbles.

Re:Open Letter to the Linux Foundation by michaelmrose on Saturday November 09, 2019 @11:13AM (#21492317)
Banning 1/3 of the nation who voted for a horrible person from every participating every again in social society in any venue right thinking individuals run doesn't seem like a grey area. Twisting "safe space" to mean a space free of people who hold bad opinions instead of a space in which you can expect to share your thoughts without being treated poorly again doesn't seem very grey.
Re:Open Letter to the Linux Foundation by superbatfish on Friday November 08, 2019 @01:19PM (#21485088)
OK, but to imply that the response to the "fuzziness in the middle" should be the same as the response to an extreme violation is also absurd.