News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Congolese doctor discovered Ebola, but didn't get credit ... by rayiner on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @10:10AM (#21463303)
> He took blood samples before she died and sent them to Belgium, where they had an electron microscope to try to identify the culprit. Scientists there and in the United States saw this was a new virus that caused hemorrhagic fever.

I think the whole thing is more complicated than the article makes it out to be. Clearly, Muyembe should get credit for the field epidemiology and recognizing that this could be something new. But can you say, as the article does, that someone “discovered” Ebola if they didn’t isolate the virus that causes it? Now you can argue the reason Muyembe couldn’t isolate the virus was because of colonialism and the Congolese government not being able to afford an expensive piece of equipment like an electron microscope. But would the Congolese have had electron microscopes but for Belgian colonialism?

I mean, there is a great story here even without the sensationalism. Man from Congo gets a PhD in Belgium, goes back home to help his country, but is held back by lack of local resources. What does Belgium owe in terms of equipping it’s former colony to help themselves? There is good material there.

As someone from a poor former colony myself, I find the whole thing somewhat patronizing. Bangladeshis rely on European and American geneticists to develop GMO rice to feed the country. But if the British hadn’t colonized us, it’s not like we would have developed that technology ourselves by now. But, on the flip side, we had math and civilization and indoor plumbing when the British were tribal people in the forest. No need to patronizingly give us credit for things we didn’t do.

Re:Congolese doctor discovered Ebola, but didn't get credit ... by init on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @12:22PM (#21464675)
> But would the Congolese have had electron microscopes but for Belgian colonialism?

Probably yes. Europe and Central Africa were already connected and trading since the 1400's[1]. The kingdom of Kongo sent an ambassador to Vatican in the 1600's[2]. Things would have played out differently if the slave trade in the Americas did not precipitate the downfall of many African kingdoms. The part of Congo where Ebola was discovered would probably not have been called Congo today.

Colonialism's goal was not to trade or bring technological advances but rather to accelerate the exploitation of the continent[3]. Belgian colonialism in particular was vicious at that.[4]

[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diogo_C%C3%A3o

[2]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emanuele_Ne_Vunda

[3]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Berlin_Conference

[4]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atrocities_in_the_Congo_Free_S...

Re:Congolese doctor discovered Ebola, but didn't get credit ... by jayalpha on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @01:43PM (#21465586)
>> But would the Congolese have had electron microscopes but for Belgian colonialism?

> Probably yes.

Probably not, if you understand how "non integrating gap countries" work.

Re:Congolese doctor discovered Ebola, but didn't get credit ... by danharaj on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @03:08PM (#21466616)
Do you want to explain?
[dead]
Re:Congolese doctor discovered Ebola, but didn't get credit ... by WaxProlix on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @05:08PM (#21468038)
> Trust me in one thing. The answers are unpleasant and especially unwelcome on Hackernews.

It's true, none of us like the role that we and our often similarly-privileged ancestors have played in the systemic rape and plunder of entire continents, or the massive wealth that we still enjoy today as a result. Good callout :)

Re:Congolese doctor discovered Ebola, but didn't get credit ... by jayalpha on Thursday November 07, 2019 @07:26AM (#21472544)
So why did South Korea rise but Ghana did not? Ghana was richer in 1957 than South Korea.
[dead]
Re:Congolese doctor discovered Ebola, but didn't get credit ... by dang on Friday November 08, 2019 @12:32AM (#21480180)
Would you please stop creating accounts to break the site guidelines with? Doing so eventually gets your main account banned as well.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Congolese doctor discovered Ebola, but didn't get credit ... by danharaj on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @06:31PM (#21468749)
> I can assure you there are those of that not only don't have the white guilt mentally damaged mental disease you claim everyone on the site shares with you, but I completely enjoy the fact that my ancestors were intelligent enough to actually think ahead enough to set up their later generations to be more successful and wealthier than them.

Carefully, they're a hero.

Re:Congolese doctor discovered Ebola, but didn't get credit ... by skybrian on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:16AM (#21463963)
At an abstract level, ignoring the politics, it seems like this is a story of successful international scientific collaboration. Some countries have more scientific resources than others, often for bad historical reasons. Working together to achieve important scientific goals still seems like a good response to that?

But scientists are people too and there can be conflicts over who does the work and who gets the credit. This is fundamentally political, where people have conflicting interests and somehow need to make a decision anyway.

Such decisions might be made based on scientific ideals and practical considerations, but compensating the people who lose in a political fight is still important. Telling their story is certainly part of that. Maybe there should be other compensation too?

Re:Congolese doctor discovered Ebola, but didn't get credit ... by danharaj on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @10:24AM (#21463429)
> But would the Congolese have had electron microscopes but for Belgian colonialism?

Belgian colonialism was particularly vicious and damaging. It is certain that its consequences extend to the present day.

Re:Congolese doctor discovered Ebola, but didn't get credit ... by knolax on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @03:46PM (#21467038)
> What does Belgium owe in terms of equipping it’s former colony to help themselves?

Payback for the mass forced labor of Congolese to extract rubber? I don't even live in Belgium or the Congo and we learned about atrocities committed under Leopold II in school[0]. In particular Belgian colonial authorities would cut off the hands of those who failed to meet their rubber quota.

> would the Congolese have had electron microscopes but for Belgian colonialism?

If their economic structure wasn't devastated by mass forced labor then yes, they might have been able to afford one. Colonialism presents no benefit to the colonized, under the British Raj "India's share of the world economy declined from 24.4% in 1700 down to 4.2% in 1950"[1]. The United States (since you mention it in your second paragraph implicitly as an example of an advanced nation) itself was founded to oppose the economic crippling that colonial rule necessitates.

[0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atrocities_in_the_Congo_Free...

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_India

Re:Congolese doctor discovered Ebola, but didn't get credit ... by mannykannot on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:06AM (#21463872)
I think you underestimate the significance of identifying the outbreak as something new. There is a strong tendency to fit our experiences into the framework of what we know, and education might even reinforce that tendency (while the health care professionals tried to explain it as a known disease, the villagers suspected there was something else going on.)

The discovery was not complete at that point, but it did not begin with isolating the virus, either.

Re:Congolese doctor discovered Ebola, but didn't get credit ... by fredgrott on Wednesday November 06, 2019 @11:00AM (#21463809)
even by science standards, isolating the virus counts as discovery unfairly as some would look upon it not isolating the virus counts as failing to discover it. and that goes way back to the early 1800s