News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by RcouF1uZ4gsC on Monday November 04, 2019 @01:36PM (#21444808)
It is not just foreign governments using paid trolls. Apparently Hilary Clinton used paid trolls against Bernie Sanders in 2016.

https://www.latimes.com/politics/la-na-clinton-digital-troll...

>Hillary Clinton's well-heeled backers have opened a new frontier in digital campaigning, one that seems to have been inspired by some of the Internet's worst instincts. Correct the Record, a super PAC coordinating with Clinton's campaign, is spending some $1 million to find and confront social media users who post unflattering messages about the Democratic front-runner.

> “It is meant to appear to be coming organically from people and their social media networks in a groundswell of activism, when in fact it is highly paid and highly tactical,” said Brian Donahue, chief executive of the consulting firm Craft Media/Digital.

Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by kop316 on Monday November 04, 2019 @01:49PM (#21444963)
Yep. That was really bad on Reddit during the election. If you even broached certain topics about Hillary, it was downvoted/flagged right away. Then the day after the election, Those topics actually came up.
Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by Gibbon1 on Monday November 04, 2019 @02:25PM (#21445377)
The week after the election was interesting because the trolls didn't have new marching orders. So it was suddenly just random people.
Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by SlowRobotAhead on Monday November 04, 2019 @03:28PM (#21446116)
Exactly. It was weird, a stark contrast to the months up before it. All of a sudden the political subs were... reasonable. I’d love to see a little more research into pre/post event stats.
Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by mieseratte on Monday November 04, 2019 @03:44PM (#21446303)
> All of a sudden the political subs were... reasonable.

Yeah... no. It went full "Not My President" overnight.

Hell, not even overnight. It went full "Not My President" that very night.

And if you think that's bad, had to deal with brass at work (fintech) proclaiming that we needed to spend an insane amount of capital in preparation for the record trade volume we would need to process because the markets were going to collapse.

Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by whamlastxmas on Monday November 04, 2019 @03:28PM (#21446106)
Also funny because one of the /r/politics rules was that you were not allowed to accuse someone of shilling. I just checked now and it's still one of the top rules. Given how pro-Hillary and anti-Sanders that sub became overnight, it seems that they were wanting to subdue the commentary on the proven paid influence HRC had.
Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by SlowRobotAhead on Monday November 04, 2019 @03:30PM (#21446145)
> Given how pro-Hillary and anti-Sanders that sub became overnight

I was there for that too. It literally was flip of a switch speed. One of the big turning points I saw regarding the election.

Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by whamlastxmas on Monday November 04, 2019 @03:52PM (#21446375)
It was EXTREMELY pro-Sanders for a very long time. The entirety of reddit was extremely pro-Sanders. I have to believe reddit owners/admins were complicit in this shift because it was so overwhelming and even today, dissent is extremely difficult. The most notable pro-Sanders sub outside his boring official campaign one(chapotraphouse) is quarantined.
Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by EasyTiger_ on Monday November 04, 2019 @04:41PM (#21446816)
Oh they knew exactly what was going in. Reddit suddenly became militantly pro-establishment and a much nastier place overall. I think the massive amount of Bernie enthusiasm scared some people, Bernie stuff was constantly hitting the front page.
Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by qnsi on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @06:42AM (#21451457)
Tbh I was brownsing Reddit few weeks ago and it looks like it’s full of communist jokes and Bernie Sanders
Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by starik36 on Monday November 04, 2019 @06:51PM (#21448089)
How it it quarantined? /r/OurPresident/ routinely shows up on /r/all and I never signed up for it or anything.
Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by bduerst on Monday November 04, 2019 @03:33PM (#21446181)
I'm not sure when you're referencing, but Russian troll farms used Sanders to divide the left on social media websites.
Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by kop316 on Monday November 04, 2019 @03:38PM (#21446239)
He was referring to just how pro-Sanders/Anti-Hillary Reddit was up until the electron primaries. Right after Hillary got the nomination in 2016, it turned to Pro-Hillary. /r/politics was particularly bad on all of that. The first day after the election was the first time any news about the private email server was even allowed on /r/politics.
Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by iron0013 on Monday November 04, 2019 @04:24PM (#21446661)
"Right after Hillary got the nomination in 2016, it turned to Pro-Hillary."

Isn't that exactly what you'd expect to happen if a lot of the commenters where Democratic voters acting as rational agents in good faith? If I were a Bernie supporter in 2016 who wanted the Democratic candidate (whoever that might end up being) to win, why would I shit on Clinton after she won the nomination? It'd make more sense to support her, and I think that's what a lot of people did. That's certainly exactly what I did.

Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by whamlastxmas on Monday November 04, 2019 @04:32PM (#21446721)
Because they maliciously sabotaged Sanders in an extremely undemocratic way and Sanders supporters would want accountability and change so that doesn't happen again?
Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by mieseratte on Monday November 04, 2019 @03:43PM (#21446294)
> but Russian troll farms used Sanders to divide the left on social media websites.

Weird, IMHO Hillary and the Democrat party really seemed to be the one's doing the dividing.

Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by 9HZZRfNlpR on Monday November 04, 2019 @07:17PM (#21448263)
It's weird that the fact Russians targeted also heavily BLM doesn't get attention. They ran the biggest FB page, tons of other on other platform. Mueller pdf is s fascinating read, I suggest everyone to read it. It's not dry at all and has everything for every side in it.
Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by whamlastxmas on Monday November 04, 2019 @03:48PM (#21446345)
It's a tired argument. Like saying Jill Stein is a Russian asset because literally 1 post in 10,000 (from troll farms) mentioned her as a "redirection" effort. Yes, mentioning Sanders is also a way to redirect from voting for Hillary. Suggesting he's somehow accountable or responsible for this is ridiculous though.

The only person HRC has to blame for losing is herself. The amount of actual-fake-news where there was total bullshit made up about her was nearly non-existent, and especially so when compared to the bullshit made up about Trump (paying hookers to pee in a bed Obama slept in, which got REAL mainstream media coverage thousands of times).

Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by dragonwriter on Monday November 04, 2019 @07:26PM (#21448342)
> Like saying Jill Stein is a Russian asset because literally 1 post in 10,000 (from troll farms) mentioned her as a "redirection" effort.

That's not why Stein is called a Russian asset; they did the same with Sanders, who acknowledged and rejected what they were doing when it was discovered, and wasn't nearly as often labeled that way. Aside from the difference in each candidates response there's other behavioral differences including, well, things like this:

https://www.nbcnews.com/news/world/guess-who-came-dinner-fly...

Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by mieseratte on Monday November 04, 2019 @03:53PM (#21446396)
> Like saying Jill Stein is a Russian asset because literally 1 post in 10,000 (from troll farms) mentioned her as a "redirection" effort.

Therein lies a good point I routinely use to befuddle, is how do you know these trolls are working on behalf of someone for their benefit, or working on behalf of the opposition as a way to attempt to discredit?

Attribution is hard.

Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by klyrs on Monday November 04, 2019 @07:24PM (#21448326)
> compared to the bullshit made up about Trump (paying hookers to pee in a bed Obama slept in, which got REAL mainstream media coverage thousands of times).

This is so absurd. Given the quantity of bullshit, self-incrimination and self-contradiction coming out of his mouth, it's really hard to imagine feeling a need to make up more...

Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by mistermann on Monday November 04, 2019 @03:55PM (#21446411)
This is news to me, are you able to cite any specific evidence? (Not vague allegations or assertions of fact, but rather actual, specific, somewhat confirmable evidence.)
Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by whamlastxmas on Monday November 04, 2019 @04:35PM (#21446763)
I mean if you want to make a startup that analyzes language and maps it to a political bias and then run an analysis on the millions of reddit comments, you'd probably make a decent amount of money. Otherwise no, you'd have to go spend dozens of hours reading reddit comments over various historical timeframes
Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by bduerst on Monday November 04, 2019 @05:53PM (#21447541)
It comes from the federal indictment of the Russian troll farm called the Internet Research Agency in February 2016, in which the IRA would “use any opportunity to criticize Hillary and the rest (except Sanders and Trump—we support them.)”

This has been confirmed with research by independent media analysts like Johnathan Albright.

There's a good summary here: https://slate.com/technology/2018/02/what-we-know-about-the-...

Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by mistermann on Monday November 04, 2019 @06:24PM (#21447832)
There is no evidence in there, only claims with a healthy peppering of qualification or misleadingly speculative terms like "alleged", "according to", "supports the idea", "believed to be", Russian-"linked", etc.

If you look carefully, you might even notice there's not even an attempt to provide any evidence. Like any other article on this topic, it just presents the claims as if evidence has been provided. But there is none, only allegations, and "believed to be" based on easily spoofable attributes.

I'm not denying all of this was the Russians, I'm just pointing out that I've never seen any actual evidence, or encountered anyone who was able to provide me anything that is more than narrative based allegations, completely devoid of evidence.

I in no way expect to change your mind, I am simply stating my understanding of what is actually known (and published) versus what is speculation.

I likely won't be able to reply again due to going against the grain, but if you can post any actual evidence I promise to read it and adjust my beliefs accordingly. If posting a link to a multi-hundred page document, please include some hint as to what page some actual evidence exists on as 100% of the people I've encountered online who have taken this approach have all for some reason decided to not reveal where these shocking proofs that they've certainly personally read can be found in the document, for some strange reason.

Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by bduerst on Monday November 04, 2019 @08:34PM (#21448774)
So the Slate article is a summary - I didn't pretend it was a published peer reviewed journal article or anything else. I also upvoted your question so I'm not sure why both your question and my answer were downvoted.

If you are genuinely interested in this, then it is easy enough to search out what they're referencing in the article. Even the Albright research (I found it), but I'm not even sure you know what your burden of proof is here.

Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by mistermann on Monday November 04, 2019 @09:06PM (#21448945)
> So the Slate article is a summary - I didn't pretend it was a published peer reviewed journal article or anything else. I also upvoted your question so I'm not sure why both your question and my answer were downvoted.

>>> I'm not sure when you're referencing, but Russian troll farms used Sanders to divide the left on social media websites.

>> This is news to me, are you able to cite any specific evidence? (Not vague allegations or assertions of fact, but rather actual, specific, somewhat confirmable evidence.

> ~you reply with a link to a document which is exactly what I asked you to not reply with.

I expect this is why you were downvoted.

I am downvoted (on this comment, and several others within a span of a few minutes) for not accepting the popular meme. This topic seems to be very strongly identity-related, so logical thinking seems to become very downgraded, replaced by post-hoc rationalization and a variety of other fascinating cognitive quirks.

I mean, think about it - we are on HN, a website full of very intelligent people, and any comment asking for evidence on certain topics will be downvoted. Why doesn't one person ever provide some evidence and utterly crush the "idiot" conspiracy theorists? I believe the reason is, because people literally can't think properly in certain situations. Their heuristics completely overpower their conscious and logical mind, knowingly or not. Hopefully someone starts to notice this and actually studies it, because it seems like it could be very harmful to society.

I believe this is one of the root problems of the day, so I will continue to point it out and take my downvotes in lieu of reasoned disagreement, which never comes.

> If you are genuinely interested in this, then it is easy enough to search out what they're referencing in the article.

I've done so many, many times, and at the end of the trail (if the link aren't dead as some are in the linked article), inevitably the factual proof is always based on one or more articles that I earlier described as "claims with a healthy peppering of qualification or misleadingly speculative terms like "alleged", "according to", "supports the idea", "believed to be", Russian-"linked", etc."

I continue to ask those who assert factual knowledge on the matter, and continue to be disappointed.

> I'm not even sure you know what your burden of proof is here.

I do: none, because I've made no assertion, I've only asked for evidence of yours: "Russian troll farms used Sanders to divide the left on social media websites."

I am quite certain there is only suspicion of this. This is certainly the case with the "Russian" trolls on Twitter, because they said it outright, as well as described their identification methodology. I can't comment for sure on Facebook, because I've never encountered an article that describes the identification methodology.

Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by EasyTiger_ on Monday November 04, 2019 @04:36PM (#21446776)
I mean it’s actually worse now since 2016.
Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by criley2 on Monday November 04, 2019 @02:11PM (#21445229)
This is a classic example of whataboutism.

1. Governments using trolls is different than campaigns hiring people to discuss politics. Campaigns get volunteers all the time to affect public discourse by going door to door, sending mailers, and doing all kinds of things.

2. Trolls specifically have an antisocial goal. The trolls employed by Russian military intelligence engaged in a psy-ops campaign against America to raise domestic tensions along racial and social lines. They specifically targeted races and ideologies and used aggressive, violence-promoting tactics. By contrast, Hillary hired Americans to talk about politics online.

3. It's not illegal for campaigns to hire citizens to promote their politics online. It is illegal for foreign governments to engage in military intelligence psy-ops campaigns against our citizens, and for campaigns to coordinate with those campaigns and request them.

I think the worst part about seeing you bring up "Correct the Record" is that they spent $9 million dollars in a $1.6 billion dollar campaign. https://www.opensecrets.org/pacs/lookup2.php?strID=C00578997...

The conspiracy theories and propaganda that were created about this program are some of the most ridiculous lies of the 2016 cycle, and I think really go to show how little research people are willing to do before they repeat propaganda. "Correct the Record" exposes a classic propaganda pipeline for the right, because it was a tiny program that did very little, but the right managed to turn it into a massive huge conspiracy where every pro-Hillary comment must be a troll. Which was a response, of course, to the validated and legitimate left criticism that pro-Trump actors were actually foreign psy-op campaigns. There needed to be a "Both-sides-ism" to excuse the fact that a foreign government conducted a military intelligence operation against our elections.

Even today this conspiracy boogeyman gets play all over the internet, a remnant of disinformation used to justify an attack on our elections.

Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by hos234 on Monday November 04, 2019 @02:33PM (#21445481)
I don't agree. All this activity whether its legitimate volunteers OR trolls has not generated any real sustainable outcomes.

Both are just mindlessly trying to hit metrics(like/views/clicks/upvotes etc). And everyone is very satisfied hitting them.

But nobody has yet proved in any country, in any part of the world all this mindless metric hitting activity (amplified robotically by the news media) is actually producing a sustainable outcome.

Doesn't matter what problem domain you pick where are the outcomes that justify all this activity? One guy gets the likes today, another gets the likes tomorrow.

It's a trap. You see the same dynamics play out in Poland, Brexit, Modi's India, Duterte etc.

That only goes away once the Like/View/Click based ecosystem is dismantled.

Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by criley2 on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @08:07AM (#21451972)
And I view this as false equivalence. Americans clicking like for American content is fundamentally different than an influence campaign by military intelligence to engage in psyops against us.

It's sad and shocking that folks treat a massive attack on the US homeland as "equivalent to Hillary fans posting comments on Reddit".

It really goes to show you how America is failing here: if no one will defend the homeland against attack, there won't be a homeland to defend.

You're welcome to cry about "clicks" and "likes" but we were attacked and are continuing to be attacked by sophisticated, and trained intelligence officers whose goal is to increase tension, increase terrorism, increase violence: and guess what -- they are succeeding. Terrorism is up. Violence is up. Tension is up.

Feels like a huge "wake up" moment, but of course the fake "both sides" propaganda paralyzes folks into such cynicism that they watch one-sided terroristic violence roil our communities and they shrug and complain about "views"

Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by hos234 on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @10:15AM (#21453066)
The main point is likes/views/clicks don't have to be shown or displaying them can be delayed. It's that simple to reduce random group behavior.

If you don't understand what role they play, or even worse, misunderstand what role they play please read some Social Psychology specifically Conformism and how it is triggered.

The problem is most people who designed the platforms are only now learning about these things and are trying to undo the effects pretending they don't need to make changes to the original design.

Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by erikpukinskis on Thursday November 07, 2019 @12:22AM (#21470664)
It is sorta interesting though, your “it’s different, it’s ok if Americans do it” line is actually kinda anti-liberal. I mean, no borders, no one is illegal, Russian troll farmers get their vote too?
Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by ineedasername on Monday November 04, 2019 @02:01PM (#21445103)
US campaigns doing it is, while still bad, is vastly different. One is an issue of sleazy election campaigns. The other is a matter of foreign interference with a country's fundamental sovereignty.
Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by lucideer on Monday November 04, 2019 @02:08PM (#21445188)
Not sure I see the effective difference between bad faith domestic interference in democratic process and foreign interference in democratic process. Both have the same end result.
Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by ineedasername on Monday November 04, 2019 @02:23PM (#21445363)
Well, one of them is illegal. Also, the foreign variety advances the possibly incompatible goals of the foreign country while the domestic version tends to be between individuals with differing but legitimate visions of how the country should be run.
Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by inetknght on Monday November 04, 2019 @02:29PM (#21445428)
> Well, one of them is illegal.

I would argue that both of them are illegal.

Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by mocha_nate on Monday November 04, 2019 @02:44PM (#21445612)
Yeah. And the original statement was ”vastly different”... Definitely disagreeing on that first point
Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by ineedasername on Monday November 04, 2019 @05:07PM (#21447068)
If it's illegal for a campaign to have paid shills posting bad things about one candidate and good things about another, then I'd agree the difference is much smaller than I first started, but I'm not aware of any law that would be breaking.
Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by ineedasername on Monday November 04, 2019 @05:05PM (#21447053)
I could be wrong, but I don't think it's illegal to have paid shills talking up one candidate or smearing another.
Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by darth_skywalker on Monday November 04, 2019 @02:13PM (#21445254)
On the other hand, politicians have been trying to manipulate voters for centuries - it seems like a new danger that foreign governments are now trying to manipulate voters.
Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by RcouF1uZ4gsC on Monday November 04, 2019 @02:24PM (#21445367)
>it seems like a new danger that foreign governments are now trying to manipulate voters

This is not a new thing. Take for example, Poland historically used to elect a monarch. Various European powers would try to influence who was elected. In 1733, this famously culminated in the War of the Polish Succession.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_of_the_Polish_Succession

Going back even further, Persia would back different Greek politicians.

This game of influencing foreign elections is a game that has been played for centuries, and is likely not going away any time soon.

Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by Amezarak on Monday November 04, 2019 @02:26PM (#21445393)
It isn’t new at all. Foreign countries have been doing it since the invention of democracy.

You can see this very vividly demonstrated in any classical histories, like Thucydides, all the way up through history, with all types of elections, from actual every-single-citizen democracies to the just-the-Electors HRE.

This is also true in American history from the very beginning, when French interests, for example, worked against Adams. Or more famously, when the British strongly intervened to ensure the re-election of FDR.

https://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2017/01/when-a-forei...

The Kennedy election was also famously the target of Russian interference.

https://time.com/4851449/trump-jr-russian-kennedy-history/

Simply put, there’s no foreign country in world history that wasn’t or isn’t interfering in domestic elections they have any kind of interest in. It would be very foolish not to. It’s a game that has gone on since the invention of democracy and will always go on, because every incentive is aligned with it and there are no norms against it.

In general, you have to be very careful when people claim something is new and unprecedented. Sometimes they just don’t know and lack the necessary context, but often they’re constructing a narrative that relies on historical innocence/ignorance of relatively mundane detail. This has been a major problem with our news media that has been getting worse for decades: they don’t do the very important job of putting things into historical or even a current cultural context. Instead, they create narratives that are easy, get people fired up and consuming more news, and often inadvertently (or sometimes advertently) serve a partisan purpose.

Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by wuliwong on Monday November 04, 2019 @02:17PM (#21445307)
I would argue the foreign govt angle also is not new. The US at least has interfered with foreign elections before the internet era.
Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by ineedasername on Monday November 04, 2019 @05:08PM (#21447079)
Sure but just because the US are hypocrites on the issue doesn't mean we should tolerate it.
Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by wuliwong on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @01:42PM (#21455309)
I certainly am not arguing against that. My point was that it isn't new not that we should tolerate it.
Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by atmosx on Monday November 04, 2019 @02:07PM (#21445180)
> US campaigns doing it is, while still bad, is vastly different.

How so?

Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by nerdponx on Monday November 04, 2019 @02:33PM (#21445474)
I disagree. It should be illegal, like fake paid product reviews, except instead of losing some money you lose your rightful political representation.
Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by inetknght on Monday November 04, 2019 @02:08PM (#21445194)
> US campaigns doing it is, while still bad, is vastly different. One is an issue of sleazy election campaigns. The other is a matter of foreign interference with a country's fundamental sovereignty.

Foreigners getting paid by US citizens to the US citizens' dirty work is still a matter of foreign interference with a country's fundamental sovereignty.

Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by raxxorrax on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @05:07AM (#21451062)
Otherwise it is just the sovereignty of Iraq.
Re:Undercover reporter reveals life in a Polish troll farm by alexis_fr on Monday November 04, 2019 @02:28PM (#21445417)
If a country’s citizen are so receptive to foreign influence, then those citizen are not at the required level to vote in a democracy, or the ideas are really good. We all know the flaws of democracy, but foreign interference through ideas is either a problem of the homeland having ideas that should be repelled, or really gullible people. Raising education levels is the solution, not asking other countries to « not interfere ».

Especially with the track record of the CIA.