News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U of Chicago projected to be the first U.S. university to... by Finnucane on Monday November 04, 2019 @11:29AM (#21443162)
I work at one local university, and my wife works at another. One thing we've definitely noticed (and this is a widespread problem) is that the administration is becoming more top-heavy. There are cutbacks in faculty, support, and teaching staff, more reliance on adjuncts (academic temps, basically), and so on, while central administration grows. Expensive new buildings contribute, but less than people suppose. But that is a tangential problem, in that wealthy donors want to give big gifts for vanity projects rather than to, say, scholarship funds.
Re:U of Chicago projected to be the first U.S. university to... by o09rdk on Monday November 04, 2019 @01:41PM (#21444864)
Former tenured professor.

I think your impression is generally spot-on although there's nuances and it's more complicated than that.

In general, universities are suffering from many of the same pressures as other fields. Nonprofits are being run as profit-generating centers, and the implicit promotion track goes from faculty to senior faculty to administration, if you're even on tenure track. The administration salaries are increasing, as are the number of administrative positions (deans, associate deans, vice associate deans, assistant deans, etc.), and the structures are becoming increasingly hierarchical. Things are very top-heavy and expensive to run because the salary budget is so disproportionately distributed.

I don't think that's all of it, though. The rest of it is harder to quantify, but is the flip side of the educational bubble coin. Students are rushing to go to college in record numbers, which then puts pressure on colleges to stand out to attract more students and more high-paying students who become high-donating alumni. Institutions that should be getting public funding are not, which then trickles down to students; other private institutions then benefit from the increased tuition norms etc.

It's a complicated problem that involves HR and administrative practices and norms, economic incentives within university funding structures, incentives coming from a broken employment system in the US, problematic incentives coming from federal grant structures, etc. etc. etc. etc.

Re:U of Chicago projected to be the first U.S. university to... by Ancalagon on Monday November 04, 2019 @05:02PM (#21447012)
Can you expand on the broken employment system in the US? Honestly just curious.
Re:U of Chicago projected to be the first U.S. university to... by DuskStar on Monday November 04, 2019 @06:10PM (#21447706)
If I had to complain about things, it would be these:

1. Lack of workplace training - very few employers will pay for you to train/gain experience, partly because there's nothing preventing someone from jumping ship for better pay once the training is complete

2. Credentialism - the things that actually matter in hiring are either difficult or illegal to test for (conscientiousness, knowledge, intelligence), and so degrees are used as proxies instead

Re:U of Chicago projected to be the first U.S. university to... by paulddraper on Monday November 04, 2019 @08:01PM (#21448570)
> very few employers will pay for you to train/gain experience

Yes and no.

Most HVAC shops will pay for technician's training.

Most dev shops pay for technical conferences.

Most managers have access to management seminars and training.

Expecting an employers to pay tens of thousands of dollars seems weird, but many employers do pay on a smaller scale for skills training.

> degrees are used as proxies instead

Though conventional wisdom is that a degree doesn't matter 5 years after graduation.

Nor does it seem that prestigious positions are even that picky in practice. Yes, there are a number of Harvard, Stanford, Yale alumni in Congress, but other seven of the top 10 colleges for Congress members are public state schools. [1]

[1] https://www.usnews.com/news/slideshows/the-top-10-colleges-f...

Re:U of Chicago projected to be the first U.S. university to... by crowbahr on Saturday November 09, 2019 @01:04PM (#21493070)
Dev shops pay for technical conferences but few tech places want to hire fresh, green devs and train them up. They all would prefer experience.

It's why you see so many forums talking about sending out applications to hundreds of places for months when searching for their first job, then never having a problem again after.

Re:U of Chicago projected to be the first U.S. university to... by angry_octet on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @03:00AM (#21450508)
The degree you get certainly matters for graduate admissions though. For example, at both MacGill and U of Montreal they don't take any account of industry experience when you are applying for grad school. And they assume grade inflation, so unless you scored A average you can give up.
Re:U of Chicago projected to be the first U.S. university to... by blaser-waffle on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @12:20PM (#21454410)
Schools in QC are a different breed, though. The cost for QC residents is very low, and the cost for non-QC residents is still pretty tolerable. This means there are lot of applicants -- like why not, it's cheap -- and they can be picky.

I've also noticed that Canada and Australia place far more emphasis on formal credentials than US colleges. US Uni's will take you if you can demonstrate competency and can pay; Uni Melbourne won't talk to you unless you have the exact, specific kind of degree. Ditto for UBC, U Sydney, etc.

Re:U of Chicago projected to be the first U.S. university to... by paulddraper on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @08:39AM (#21452238)
That's true. It's a relatively small set of jobs that require a medical, law, or phd degree.
Re:U of Chicago projected to be the first U.S. university to... by mikekchar on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @01:13AM (#21450113)
I'll just throw this out here: for IT you almost don't want your in-house trained people to stay very long because it's pretty important less experienced people to get a variety of different experiences. I would say that people who stick to their first job for a decade or so tend to become under performers and I don't think it's generally because they can't find another job. Breadth of experience is really valuable in this field.

I've often thought it would be amazing if you could do the equivalent of professional football (soccer) lending of players. Lend a developer to another company for a few years with the expectation that they will come back. If they decide to stay then the borrowing company give some compensation. But it would mean having very strict contracts that limit the freedom of workers, so it's almost certainly a no go. I wish there was a way to make it work, though...

Re:U of Chicago projected to be the first U.S. university to... by o09rdk on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @01:07PM (#21454910)
I think in general I mean that people are seen as cogs in a machine, rather than individuals to be trained, and there's no safety net from the government, either in terms of real retraining or advanced education or life benefits or anything.

HR gets a million applications, people are evaluated on what boxes can be checked off rather than their skillset, etc.

With regard to the educational system, the problem is that degrees are seen as signals or credentials (to use the language of the article) rather than as a background. That's admittedly a fuzzy distinction, but it really reduces the degree to the degree per se rather than the host of courses and experiences the person during college. So, we talk about "useless degrees" without recognizing that someone might have had equivalent coursework and experience without majoring in something else per se. In the end it doesn't matter.

Re:U of Chicago projected to be the first U.S. university to... by moduspol on Monday November 04, 2019 @12:10PM (#21443743)
I worked for five years at a private university a few years ago, and my experience is similar, although to add a little:

It never felt like a plan or conspiracy to make administration costs bigger. It's just very easy to do when you have more money coming in, year after year. In another economic environment, you'd get a "hard no" because the money isn't there. But when there is, expenditures become just another bargaining chip. Maybe you get your seventh librarian this year, and I get my fifth network guy next year.

New buildings (as you stated) aren't as big of a contributor as expected due to the convoluted role of donations, grants, etc. But another big factor for those buildings is that we were getting loans for them, too, and those were based on (big surprise) long term forecasts presuming this gravy train is going to keep on chugging for the next 30+ years. And even then we were getting projections of our "debt capacity" and always riding that line, so it's debt on top of debt all the way down.

I don't know about big schools, but for a smaller one like ours, there was no visible bad faith. These kind of things just happen when you can keep bringing in more and more money and so can your competitors.

Re:U of Chicago projected to be the first U.S. university to... by ahi on Monday November 04, 2019 @10:01PM (#21449206)
I work in academic IT. My job is mission critical to the existence of 3 other project manager jobs. The bureaucracy grows to meet the needs of the growing bureaucracy is not a joke.
Re:U of Chicago projected to be the first U.S. university to... by Finnucane on Monday November 04, 2019 @02:55PM (#21445745)
>But another big factor for those buildings is that we were getting loans for them, too, and those were based on (big surprise) long term forecasts presuming this gravy train is going to keep on chugging for the next 30+ years.

Harvard got spectacularly burned by the genius planning of Larry Summers in that regard.

Re:U of Chicago projected to be the first U.S. university to... by supahfly_remix on Monday November 04, 2019 @12:33PM (#21444001)
Are the people who actually teach the classes (professors who teach and TAs) getting raises matching the tuition raises in your school? Or, is all of the money diverted to administration?
Re:U of Chicago projected to be the first U.S. university to... by moduspol on Monday November 04, 2019 @12:45PM (#21444138)
I wasn't in a position to be explicitly told, although I did at one point see an anonymized list of faculty salaries and they did not seem unreasonable (only one in six figures). This school is about 40 minutes away from a city with an international airport.

I think "diverted" is perhaps a strong word here. The way administrators see it, the administration is necessary to even reach the point where faculty can teach classes, and provides a significant role in empowering them to do so.

And there's some validity to it. Besides, students' expectations with regards to faculty haven't changed nearly as much over the last ~20 years when compared to administrative departments. Students absolutely expect good WiFi, good Internet speeds, Google Apps-quality e-mail, and that's just tech stuff. Colleges are implicitly competing with other colleges with things like on-campus events, residence halls, modern cafeterias, online course registration, athletics... all kinds of stuff. There's a lot of money involved in these expectations that has outpaced the faculty side.

But it's cyclical. We pump money into those things to keep retention up because we need to because the other schools are doing it.

Re:U of Chicago projected to be the first U.S. university to... by klipt on Monday November 04, 2019 @10:36PM (#21449375)
> Students absolutely expect good WiFi, good Internet speeds, Google Apps-quality e-mail, and that's just tech stuff.

My personal internet with Comcast is ~$60/month, so assuming universities have greater bargaining power due to scale that shouldn't make much of a dent in tuition. And my college email interface was clunky but I just set it up to forward everything to Gmail, which is free.

Re:U of Chicago projected to be the first U.S. university to... by moduspol on Monday November 04, 2019 @11:14PM (#21449558)
It's not really reasonable to compare a residential ISP to one for a college campus. It probably is cheaper if you count only the Internet service itself, but everything between that ISP and each end user's device has significant fixed and maintenance / upgrade costs attached. Your residential ISP can give you an all-in-one modem / WiFI router and you're good to go.
Re:U of Chicago projected to be the first U.S. university to... by pirocks on Monday November 04, 2019 @05:40PM (#21447429)
On the case of California all the salaries of public employees aka. University of California employees are public, Googleable information.
Re:U of Chicago projected to be the first U.S. university to... by paulddraper on Monday November 04, 2019 @08:05PM (#21448595)
> These kind of things just happen when you can keep bringing in more and more money and so can your competitors.

Yep. If appetite and available funding grow year after year, even the most honest of colleges will have a hard time not expanding costs.

Fortunately, it's still pretty easy to get a 4-year degree from a solid school for < $40,000 tuition not including scholarships.

Pricy, but still far less than the $1m extra lifetime earnings.

Re:U of Chicago projected to be the first U.S. university to... by diablerouge on Monday November 04, 2019 @08:13PM (#21448648)
Hmmm, I'd beg to differ.

I lived at home, with my parents, and went to a state school and paid in-state tuition. Found online PDFs of all my textbooks, and I'm still just barely scraping in at under 40,000. This is from 2016 to 2020 (finishing up my last few courses over the next 6 months.) And the administration is still considering (aka going to pass) an 11% tuition increase, after a 9% increase just 2 years ago.

It's even worse for people who don't live near a university and need to live on campus, pay for meal plans, etc.

Re:U of Chicago projected to be the first U.S. university to... by paulddraper on Monday November 04, 2019 @08:25PM (#21448718)
Note that I only mentioned that number for tuition.

Rent, food, clothing, etc. will of course be more than that. $10,000/yr doesn't even clear the poverty line, college or otherwise. [1]

My number might have been a bit low, but average in-state public college is $10k/yr for tuition and fees. [2]

I went to college in Florida and Utah. Their top ranked public universities right now cost $6k/yr and $8k/yr respectively.

[1] https://www.thebalance.com/federal-poverty-level-definition-...

[2] https://www.usnews.com/education/best-colleges/paying-for-co...

Re:U of Chicago projected to be the first U.S. university to... by wtvanhest on Monday November 04, 2019 @11:35AM (#21443245)
Yes, admin is a problem, but its not just admin. If you are a professor making 150k+, you have to ask yourself how much of your salary is being funded by rampant, unsustainable borrowing.

Colleges need dramatic, across the board cost cutting including professors, admins etc.

Colleges are in for a world of pain in the next 50 years.

Re:U of Chicago projected to be the first U.S. university to... by Bjartr on Monday November 04, 2019 @05:58PM (#21447586)
Why shouldn't a professor make 150k? I mean, from a societal point of view.
Re:U of Chicago projected to be the first U.S. university to... by ahi on Monday November 04, 2019 @10:04PM (#21449222)
How much of that is skimming off what the grad students do? ...who get a poverty wage adjunct position
Re:U of Chicago projected to be the first U.S. university to... by wtvanhest on Monday November 04, 2019 @11:19PM (#21449571)
If that is what they are earning without burdening thousands of students with unsustainable debt over their careers than I'd argue nothing is wrong with it.

For example if the salary is 100% from NIH grants and the prof makes 500k, more power to them.

If the prof makes 100k and all their salary is funded by student loans, then they should decide whether their livelihood is worth the externalities they are creating.

Its a moral choice

Re:U of Chicago projected to be the first U.S. university to... by lazypenguin on Monday November 04, 2019 @11:39PM (#21449658)
150k/year. Let’s assume the professor teaches 4 units per semester and maybe 2 in the summer (or research or some equivalent). Comes out to 15k/unit. Let’s say 15 students per unit just to represent smaller classes comes to $1k/unit/student/year. Each unit is like 3hrs/week for 12 weeks on average. So comes out to something like $28/hr. Doesn’t seem unreasonable to me.

Average course load for a student is like 6 units a semester so using the back-of-the napkin math above it should cost roughly $6k/per semester for students to have a full course load of $150k professors. $12k/year + other expenses is a far cry away from $100k that is being charged.

Re:U of Chicago projected to be the first U.S. university to... by wtvanhest on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @01:42AM (#21450236)
$12k a year is completely unacceptable.

Other costs are also unacceptable. Colleges charge $500+/month for shared rooms. And require freshman to stay in them.

Nevermind the fact that your math misses several major cost categories like building maintenance, fringe benefits for professors (+30% of salaries at least).

In your hypothetical example, students are paying $20k/year before getting ripped off on the cost of the dorm and meal plan.

If a prof is making 150k, class sizes need to be 300+ and they need to teach 1,000 kids a semester

Re:U of Chicago projected to be the first U.S. university to... by Finnucane on Monday November 04, 2019 @11:51AM (#21443494)
>If you are a professor making 150k+, you have to ask yourself how much of your salary is being funded by rampant, unsustainable borrowing.

Also, how much of your funding comes from unsavory sources like Jeffrey Epstein and the Saudi government.

Re:U of Chicago projected to be the first U.S. university to... by haberman on Monday November 04, 2019 @11:45AM (#21443391)
Do colleges make their budgets public? When a program is taking too long to run the first step is to profile. What does the data say on college costs?

> But that is a tangential problem, in that wealthy donors want to give big gifts for vanity projects rather than to, say, scholarship funds.

In the past I've felt quite motivated to give to scholarship funds. It resonates a lot if you yourself relied on scholarships to go to college. But I feel somewhat more cynical about this since I've seen costs spiraling out of control. The actual price of college can have anything bundled in there. I want to support students, but I feel less good about supporting ballooning costs that are twice inflation when I haven't heard a good reason for this.

Re:U of Chicago projected to be the first U.S. university to... by paulddraper on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @06:06PM (#21457790)
Certainly public colleges have public budgets.
Re:U of Chicago projected to be the first U.S. university to... by big_chungus on Monday November 04, 2019 @11:30AM (#21443181)
Ahh, the iron law of bureaucracy at work. https://www.jerrypournelle.com/reports/jerryp/iron.html
Re:U of Chicago projected to be the first U.S. university to... by gnicholas on Monday November 04, 2019 @10:32PM (#21449360)
An AEI report on 'administrative bloat' in higher education: https://www.aei.org/carpe-diem/diversity-and-other-administr...
Re:U of Chicago projected to be the first U.S. university to... by setpatchaddress on Monday November 04, 2019 @11:43PM (#21449665)
AEI is a hard-rightish conservative think tank. I’d be wary of trusting anything they publish about money and schools.
Re:U of Chicago projected to be the first U.S. university to... by gnicholas on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @01:52AM (#21450272)
You're right that they're libertarian/conservative in this regard. But they've published a number of articles with relevant facts about the growth of administrative roles in higher ed, and the associated costs. I haven't seen those facts questioned anywhere — have you?
Re:U of Chicago projected to be the first U.S. university to... by bryanlarsen on Monday November 04, 2019 @11:49AM (#21443467)
Re:U of Chicago projected to be the first U.S. university to... by Finnucane on Monday November 04, 2019 @11:53AM (#21443522)
That data is only for public universities.
Re:U of Chicago projected to be the first U.S. university to... by blaser-waffle on Tuesday November 05, 2019 @12:43PM (#21454648)
Arguably those are the only ones we should care about -- they're getting our state tax funds.

Private Uni's are, well, private. They can charge what they want, and if the average Pell Grant or other DoE loans aren't enough that's not the Uni's problem.

Re:U of Chicago projected to be the first U.S. university to... by cmpolis on Monday November 04, 2019 @05:12PM (#21447110)
This comment is sadly familiar to me - it sounds exactly how my friends in healthcare describe the state of their industry (more admin, fancy buildings, less focus or spending on patient care).