Note: this isn’t about strict numbers. 1,000 true fans paying 10 bucks a month might be enough. The same paying $2 a month? Doesn’t pay the bills of a family.
I like the concept as well, because it seems a lot more approachable than trying to build a unicorn, but what if only the top 0,1% really get 1,000+ true fans? Still a power law.
The rule of thumb for email subscriber to paying customer is actually closer to 1% (compared to your 10%) which just means it's that much harder. I don't think there is a rule of thumb for "true fan" conversion, where it might be as high as 50% for something like Tesla and 1% for something like Comcast.
Really? Maybe not every family (and definitely not in the Bay Area), but those numbers work out to $120-240K/year, with no requirement on where you live.
EDIT: I can't be trusted with mental math. Leaving the above unchanged, but it's answering a comment that used different numbers that never actually existed. The correct numbers are $24-120K/year, which is obviously a very different discussion about feasibility.
This may hold true for music, given a long enough time. Not so much with a newsletter which is limited by the language (at best two), and has a quite limited shelf life.
So "1000 true fans" is already a big filter.
In fact, e.g. for 2017, 99% of the 377 billion streams were from the top 10% of 2017’s most-streamed tracks alone. Less than 1% of streams accounted for all other music.
Sure, but to create a venture scale business you only need a few hundred highly successful ones; you need around 250 power users to create a $100M business.
And creating "250 power users" at that scale is crazy hard.
For those interested: howitactuallyworks.com
Also, I think you are discounting what a lot of "creation" is, as it is a much larger area than is generally considered, IMO.
For example, there seem to be a lot of erotica going on in patreon and elsewhere, where models sell prints and special content (e.g... nipples?).
Or, there is a ton of videogame streaming going on, which should be considered content creation, and some of the millions of twitch streamers actually make good money.
Many people also sell special content connected to their podcast/streaming whatever, I just ended up yesterday on a financial youtube channel where the author has a paid-only weekly chat with the subscribers.
The only thing which I think won't increase much is writers self-publishing. That seems to already have been a thing for years now.
And how many are making a living out of their Patreon? Most Patreons I’ve seen are hobbyists making a few bucks on the side. Those aren’t careers, so the 100k number is meaningless. (In fact, I looked it up, and 100k is the number of “creators” making at least $1, or have at least one patron.[1])
[1] https://techcrunch.com/2019/02/12/patreon-business/
Edit: The TechCrunch article further down claims that Patreon had about 4300 creators earning $1k/mo at that time.
Most of which make close to nothing (server costs, and way less than 10K/year).
>And it's not a super popular platform yet.
No, but it's the #1 platform for direct fan support.
Substack is like the person who sold tools to the gold prospectors during the gold rush. They will probably do okay.
These things are tools that lower the barrier of entry to creating but that alone doesn’t generate mass demand for creators. You will see power laws apply just like it does in many situations, and there will be a handful of people who can pull six or seven figures in something like writing a paid email newsletter.