News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:CleanFlicks by BjoernKW on Thursday October 31, 2019 @05:13AM (#21406907)
When I saw the title I hoped this to be about a particular kerning issue ...

This is hypocritical at best.

If you don't want sexual content or profanity in your media then either create your own content or pay for the creation of such content.

Manipulating original content to suit your particular moral convictions not only truncates that content but also doesn't help with incentivising the production of original content you might rather want to see.

Re:CleanFlicks by jasonkester on Thursday October 31, 2019 @05:53AM (#21407092)
I see this reaction every time one of these services is discussed here. People with angry, even violent opposition to people fast-forwarding through parts of movies.

It's fascinating. I can't imagine an issue that could affect the parent's life less than this. And yet he and a couple other folks downstream are properly losing their soup over it.

As to the point in question, I tend to disagree that Disney will be disincentivised from making more Star Wars movies because of that time somebody skipped the "Luke's Parents On Fire" scene when showing Episode 4 to their kids the first time.

Re:CleanFlicks by BjoernKW on Thursday October 31, 2019 @06:27AM (#21407262)
Fast-forwarding parts of movies for your own private use is entirely different from selling an unlicensed edited version of original content, which is precisely what CleanFlicks did.

Unless that content is licensed under a free licence that specifically permits you to remix content (e.g. some Creative Commons variants) selling an unauthorised edited version is unethical and probably illegal as well.

By arbitrarily removing parts of original content and publishing the changed versions CleanFlicks were altering it in ways the content creators didn't intend and it's perfectly understandably that those content creators don't want to be associated with these versions.

Re:CleanFlicks by smcl on Thursday October 31, 2019 @07:28AM (#21407575)
BjoernKW isn't angry, violent or "losing their soup" over anything. It was just a comment that stated pretty plainly and succinctly what their impression of the problem was.
Re:CleanFlicks by brobdingnagians on Thursday October 31, 2019 @06:30AM (#21407273)
I pay for content that I want to support and I'm very active in choosing media I want to support and putting my money where my mouth is, but there are many reasons why someone might want to use a service like this:

1. Editing for their children as an audience. Something like Lord of the Rings is a classic with an amazing set of movies, but I might not want to edit a few things for children.

2. Editing gratuitous violence out of an otherwise good film. A lot of movies put in gratuitous violence or swearing just because it is expected to be a "serious film" even though it has no reason to be in it. If there is simply a choice between "Barnie goes to Paris" or "Lord of the Rings" with a few things edited; I know what I'll pick.

3. Slipping standards and ratings in modern movies: classic movies managed to be great without the violence, sex, and profanity. A PG13 of today is very different than a PG13 of yesteryear.

4. Production costs and minority status: the demand for clean films seems low. Producing a state of the art movie costs a lot of money, it's easier to cleanup a film than to produce the same movie from scratch without the objectionable parts. This is something of a minority rights issue and how to fit into a larger society.

5. Triggers and Choice: people have a wide variety of psychological needs and quirks. It is important for them to be able to fit into society and not be traumatized by it. These solutions help a oid things that may trigger things or aggravate conditions.

Choice is similar. You can and should be able to choose what you eat, drink, etc. Same with "mental eating". You can filter your water for things, why not filter what your mind eats to suit your tastes?

Re:CleanFlicks by BjoernKW on Thursday October 31, 2019 @06:38AM (#21407319)
Sure, everyone is fine to do as you described for his or her own private use.

You might think that an otherwise good film contains gratuitous violence but the film's creators put it there for a reason. Even if that reason was a shallow one you can't simply decide for yourself to sell a new "improved" version of that content without asking for permission first, which is precisely what CleanFlicks did.

Re:CleanFlicks by winkeltripel on Thursday October 31, 2019 @07:54AM (#21407710)
right, but for any parent to do that editing by themselves is a monumental task. If the mormons:

1. bought an original copy of each film

2. added an edited DVD to each box

3. re-sold the box with both DVDs

That would seem ethical to me, and abiding by reasonable copyright laws. Their right to remix (even if in somewhat boring ways) should be important.

Re:CleanFlicks by jhanschoo on Thursday October 31, 2019 @09:26PM (#21415510)
> added an edited DVD to each box

The edited DVD is a copy of the original DVD. That is copyright infringement.

> Their right to remix (even if in somewhat boring ways) should be important.

This isn't a remix. A remix should desire to completely change the creative expression of the original into a new creative expression. The edits seek to preserve as much of the creative expression as possible (as much as that does not cross over certain fixed (hence unoriginal) rules). I don't think a reasonable person will think that this is transformative.

Re:CleanFlicks by BjoernKW on Thursday October 31, 2019 @08:15AM (#21407870)
That's just the financial side of things. They'd still be tampering with the original piece of content, which most likely isn't what the artist would've wanted.

Then there's the question of if it's really ethical to want to consume content that at least partially is against your moral values. I completely concur with parents' desire to protect their children. However, if it's about adults finding content morally objectionable the actual ethical choice is to simply not watch that content.

Re:CleanFlicks by jhanschoo on Thursday October 31, 2019 @09:32PM (#21415540)
I disagree with the parent comment (see my reply), but this isn't correct either.

> That's just the financial side of things. They'd still be tampering with the original piece of content, which most likely isn't what the artist would've wanted.

It's culturally important that people are allowed to transform creative works in ways that the author/artist didn't intend or want. Hence parody is allowed. If I were to redact parts of a book I bought in a store and resell that book, it would be legal. It can also even be ethical.

The problem with CleanFlicks is that they made their own DVD copy to contain copied, edited video of the original film. It's a copy, and hence infringes copyright.

Re:CleanFlicks by ballenf on Thursday October 31, 2019 @05:41AM (#21407038)
Are you against ad blockers too?
Re:CleanFlicks by BjoernKW on Thursday October 31, 2019 @05:56AM (#21407102)
Ads are a different topic.

Anyway, ads aren't content themselves but a means for paying for that content, which in itself is completely legitimate.

The reason why I'm not against using ad blockers is that the way ads often are used today poses security and privacy risks as well as performance problems.

Re:CleanFlicks by kd5bjo on Thursday October 31, 2019 @06:47AM (#21407375)
> ads aren't content themselves but a means for paying for that content

I’ve seen plenty of ads that are creative, funny, and engaging in their own right. A lot of talented people lend their creativity to make these, and your statement feels reminiscent of people that say genres they don’t like aren’t actually music. It’s incredibly condescending to dismiss their work as “not content”.

Re:CleanFlicks by BjoernKW on Thursday October 31, 2019 @07:05AM (#21407460)
Then let me define it more precisely: Ads usually are not the content a user requested or wanted to see when accessing a particular media outlet.

In a way, well-designed ads are similar to a well-designed checkout process in that respect: I can admire its beauty or simplicity but I wouldn’t visit a website solely because of it.

Re:CleanFlicks by kd5bjo on Thursday October 31, 2019 @07:22AM (#21407542)
This whole conversation is about the situation where the artist/author includes something that the viewer/user doesn’t want to see. Whether or not to include ads is as much an artistic choice as whether or not to include profanity— they’re both parts of the aggregate experience, and editing them out means you’re no longer experiencing the work as its creator intended. This is evident in that works sometimes include fictional advertisements with the same presentation as you would expect from real ones.

As such, I struggle to see a meaningful distinction between these cases. As a corollary, I also believe online publications have a responsibility to exercise editorial control over the ads that appear on their sites.

Re:CleanFlicks by pjc50 on Thursday October 31, 2019 @07:36AM (#21407623)
Ironically it's not usually the artists' choice, it's not unusual for the actual creators to be under contracts to the publisher which give them very little veto over the context in which a work is shown and what ads are included in it. Especially with works produced by a large number of people like films.
Re:CleanFlicks by kd5bjo on Thursday October 31, 2019 @08:01AM (#21407756)
But it was their choice to enter into the contract in the first place. When someone delegates part of their job to someone else (in this case distribution to the publisher), that doesn’t absolve them of responsibility for the end result— choose your partners wisely, because their choices will reflect on you.
Re:CleanFlicks by gpderetta on Thursday October 31, 2019 @08:26AM (#21407948)
Yet you could make the same claim (" not the content a user requested or wanted to see") for edited movies.
Re:CleanFlicks by dTal on Thursday October 31, 2019 @05:58AM (#21407112)
Ad blockers are distinct as ads are separate from, and frequently interfere with, the actual content. The ads themselves are written by different people.

If the goal is "consume media as the artist intended", then ad blockers are entirely in line with that goal.

Re:CleanFlicks by otabdeveloper4 on Thursday October 31, 2019 @06:27AM (#21407255)
You're bonkers if you think that news websites intend for you to read news without ads.

Ultimately this is just another case of "rules for thee but not for me".