> The lawsuit claims that then-CEO Kevin Burns shot down that idea, saying, “Half our customers are drunk and vaping like mo-fos, who the fuck is going to notice the quality of our pods.”
Zuck: Yeah so if you ever need info about anyone at Harvard
Zuck: Just ask
Zuck: I have over 4,000 emails, pictures, addresses, SNS
[Redacted Friend's Name]: What? How'd you manage that one?
Zuck: People just submitted it.
Zuck: I don't know why.
Zuck: They "trust me"
Zuck: Dumb fucks
He didn't say anything that anyone who takes three seconds to think "wait, how is this free, what are they doing with this data" wasn't/isn't thinking.
That's way different than saying who cares if we poison people, they're alcoholic hipsters
And it's specially damning if that's a quote by a person that's now in charge of so much sensitive data.
It's not damming at all. With no knowledge of where or when the quote is from, just looking at it I immediately go "likely a college student, with no business experience whatsoever, made a casual statement in conversation with a friend long before his product grew to the size it is today and now random people on the internet are vilifying for something he said in casual conversation probably a decade and and a half ago even though the comment shows no malice and is more a statement of disbelief in how little people think about their privacy"
...He's literally offering up their personal information on demand. "No malice"? That word doesn't mean what you think it means.
Contrary to what you seem to believe, people can have a good moral grounding in their late teens/early twenties. What evidence do you have which shows he's changed at all?
At that size of the site/database that's no different than going "here's my rolodex, who's info do you want".
[0]: https://newsroom.fb.com/news/2007/11/facebook-unveils-facebo...
Assuming the allegations are substantial and true, Danaher should be very grateful that he's protected by the law. I can't imagine the urge for vengeance that would be felt by a parent of someone who died from this.
The CDC findings were that black market THC pods are causing the deaths. It seems most of the current moral outrage and reactionary, emergency regulations on (nicotine) vaping have been because people have not been doing their research at all.
[1]: https://www.nytimes.com/2019/10/28/podcasts/the-daily/vaping...
It's called grandstanding
If we could work out a way to financially incentivise taking care of each other many of our problems would change swiftly and dramatically.
Then the vape company has a direct incentive to help me be successful.
Such a payment system should be assisted by government (ie. Government should give out forms which prove your earnings), and banks (who would remember who is due what percentage of your earnings and distribute appropriately).
The basics of such a system already exists in the UK, where students commit to paying 9% of their future income to pay for university (with a time limit and money limit).
This is a classic move in our economy: 1) product or service slowly becomes more expensive relative to income, 2) a subsidy that was supposed to go to the bottom tier to help even the playing field but is now used by more and more people due to 1 adjusts it's payout to return to it's planned effectiveness, then 3) product or service operator notices that consumers have more available money and adjusts their cost upwards.
Similar effects have been observed in more nuanced ways, like the costs of fresh fruits and vegetables being higher than boxed and processed foods, so low income food subsidy programs bump their monetary payouts to encourage purchasing of fresh foods, and some boxed or processed foods have a statistically unusual bump in retail prices in the area. This is the kind of bullshit that really starts to make me think that the USA needs a secondary monetary system (not bitcoin/blockchain, and not Dollar based) to be used for redemption of welfare and entitlement benefits which would make it impossible to track between something like an increase in food stamp benefits and monetary compensation for the use of those benefits. I'm cool with Kraft thinking that Velveeta cheese "product" needs to be more expensive in our magical capatalistic society, I'm just not cool with them thinking that only because the lowest income shoppers suddenly have 5 more cents in their account every month.
Just pointing out the obvious, people do crazy and harmful shit for money all the time (eg. Juul execs). Possibly more often than people with more “legitimate” reasons (eg. Vengeance).
So uh, do such people actually exist? The article doesn't suggest that anyone died.
For all we know Juul shipped 1M mint pods contaminated with strawberry flavour. The fact that the story completely avoids this is a bit suspicious.
"Mr. Breja brings this action after he was terminated in retaliation for whistleblowing and objecting to the contaminated pod shipment and other illegal and unsafe conduct that has jeopardized and continues to jeopardize public health and safety and the lives of millions of consumers, many of them children and teens."
I think it's safe to say this isn't about strawberry flavoured mint
I was simply reflecting on the factors at play in situations like this.
And the VCs who enable and amplify such behaviors. These are the real power players who give the Tim Danaher's the confidence to continue with their terrible actions.
I mean, that's how America's been since the very beginning. First we had slavery, then we had corporations getting away with killing workers through heinous workplace negligence, e.g. the Triangle Shirtwaist Fire. I'm not saying it's good that this has always been so, or that citizens should be apathetic in the face of repeated sociopathy, merely that realizing that the country's always been like this is a necessary step for understanding why the serial killers in suits seem to have so much power.
Other causes have had similar successes. The cause of abolition (or at least unease about slavery) was enough to elect Lincoln in 1860 despite Lincoln not appearing on the ballots of the entire South. Which, of course, started the process & war which ended slavery. Abolition won, albeit in a very bloody way.
I think it's not a case of people not caring. It's a case of people care enormously but they feel powerless and they feel alone in their caring. This goes on until that day when they realize they're not alone.
It's interesting that we live in the most connected age ever where creating, building, and coordinating social movements has never been easier or more possible yet the labor movement and unions are dying, consumer protections and regulations are inadequate, privacy protections are nonexistent and constitutionally protected freedoms are flagrantly ignored and bypassed. I'm not sure what the problem is, but it seems like every social movement and organization that fought for the rights of the average person up until around the time of the free speech movement got much more accomplished while overcoming much more than we'd have to deal with now.
Protesting slavery was extremely difficult. Protesting the workplace got you labeled a communist or socialist.
And now when we protest against climate change or ask for more workers rights or BLM people are generally against it.
You see this time and time again, whether with tobacco, industrial pollution, oil and gas pollution, or this new vaping stuff. Oh and war; you see this perpetually with war and the military industrial complex.
For whatever reason, there are enough people willing to set aside concern for each other and humanity in general in order to make some cash for themselves. It almost doesn't matter what industry you look at - they all have moments or periods where finances trump (oh do pardon the unfortunate expression) humanity.
If society is unable to prosecute criminal negligence, that's another matter; it's not about a mantra or ethos or something, we just have to do our jobs, and things will get better like they have been.
Take for example the recent deregulation that is undoing clean water and air protections to the benefit of a few industries. That obviously takes something (health) away from the people and gives it to a few companies as financial profits. Of course, those deregulations came because the companies had lobbyists and other agents who were providing financial benefit to a few politicians, and those politicians greedily placed themselves above the people.
When the government bodies that should be prosecuting criminal negligence (such as the 2007/8 banking crisis), the pharma-created opiod crisis, etc. have been gradually staffed by people from the industries doing the bad acting, that leaves society armless and unable to do anything other than protest (which they do, at times). But unless those protests become really violent (which I don't want), nothing can happen. Remember Occupy Wall Street? That was beginning to be an effective protest campaign, but eventually the cities began employing illegal tactics to break it up and shut it down. Since the people didn't turn violent, it was successfully put down.
I don't see a solution to the current situation other than waiting it out until the old corrupt people in power die off naturally. Younger generations are enough pissed that they might change some things once there are fewer kings of the political hills.
Otherwise it opens up any executive to tons of personal risk by taking a leadership role in any major public company with any sort of consumer liability. Or worse getting punished for subordinates behaviour with some idealistic perspective on what the executives show be in control of.
That type of arrangement would likely result in worse executives who are more risk-friendly. While the ones who are careful and averse to risk would stay in a non-executive position with very low risk that kicks upstairs or only take the safe executive jobs (even if the cases are likely to fail in court).
This will create a booming workplace legal insurance industry that will cover downside risks of lawyer costs and loss of income going into prison. Which helps minimize the disincentives this sort of thing would need to create to be effective.
I'm open to these ideas but there really has to be some serious conditions thought out.
We can't keep turning a blind eye to the hundreds of outrageous examples of ignoring health impacts and lying in public whilst the real facts are in a filing cabinet at head office.
Frankly the law should have changed dramatically after discovery of Thomas Midgley and tetra-ethyl lead, "the science on smoking and health isn't settled", or Bhopal etc. We have centuries of proof there aren't adequate consequences.
> getting punished for subordinates behaviour
That's what leadership is. Responsibility for those under you on your watch. If you fired or prosecuted them on first discovery, that forms a decent proportion of mitigating circumstance. Perhaps you'll still be found negligent for not having adequate checks and balances to prevent it happening in the first place...
At least some of those examples are tied up with one industry spinning up misleading studies to make money by known false messages of margarine over butter or sugar vs fat etc. Chances are Nestle, Kraft and Coke or whoever have dozens of studies they didn't reveal sitting in the filing cabinet before they got the couple that gave the misleading results they needed to make a ton more money.
It's nearly always the case that when we find out years or decades later, "they knew" and actually had extensive investigation on the topic - but chose not to care, or found a way to actively brief against the public interest, rather than it had simply never occurred to them to look or an innocent mistake was made. No, it generally turns out they have pretty extensive science and studies, just very very selective about what they let on about. Maybe there's a high profile spokes-PhD or two and everyone spends decades believing the problem is fat not sugars and apparently there are no consequences.
If the company and execs, and past execs were held accountable, and had a duty of care to customers and public, perhaps their past bullshit, PR lies, and talking bollocks under Congressional Committee oath (I believe one was "We don't believe tobacco is addictive" from assorted CEOs under oath) can come back to haunt them. What would match with 2 years CEO jail time for the corporate-personhood? 2 years delisting and forfeit of dividends or profit? That might focus investors and execs on appropriate board integrity a little more... :)
Is it really that old-fashioned to think there should be consequences for those who cheat even if they hide behind a corporation? Back when I was a director I actually gave a shit about us being honest, offering an honest service, and holding the staff to the same standard - especially when they were talking on the company's behalf.
It's all publication bias, but maybe in a post-Columbine witch hunt you'd end up in jail.
The TL;DR the customer is the other party to mutually benefit from our offering, not a cow to be industrially milked regardless. After 40 years I still haven't bought into "greed is good", we should aspire - and regulate - to a higher standard to everyone's benefit. :)
In a more general business context I would hope to show we a) thought about it and investigated it properly then b) took a considered view that we could stand by if it was later publicised or leaked, i.e. properly exercised our duty of care and reasonable ethics.
Knowing there's a problem and carefully keeping quiet about it, or pretending the opposite and spinning against - maybe even hiring a PR agency to sow doubt, or ignoring contaminated product -- well those all seem to tip easily into criminal negligence and should come with serious consequence for both directors and company.
As an aside, I've always found it most odd that US tv is frequently laissez-faire on violence, but will beep out or overdub minor-friendly trivial profanity or get all puritan about a hint of nipple or human relations. Mostly the opposite of the European perspective. I quite often fast forward through the boring over-long fight sequence or shoot outs in US TV and movies... If it's an 18 rated horror I've sat down to watch, sure, bring it - though I'll probably still skip the 5 minute OTT shoot out to save yawns... :)
I think executives should be at major personal risk when their companies do things that cause injury or death to many people. It will force them to make sure that the people under them are following the rules and that their products are safe. Mistakes will surely happen and I don't think we should ignore it when a company who makes every reasonable effort to protect their customers still fails and people are hurt. That shouldn't necessarily get them off the hook entirely but it should matter. In cases where it's more obvious like in the case of the tobacco industry intentionally misleading customers about the risks of their product, or the auto industry selling cars they know are dangerous, or this one where the company was well aware of the problem but did nothing in order to protect their bottom line they should very clearly be held responsible.
I'm not sure that holding executives responsible for clear exploitation would make them more likely to take risks. It seems to me that as long they know they wont be held accountable for killing people they'll be more likely to do it. Companies would also be less likely to promote reckless people if they knew doing so could mean they might face a corporate death penalty.
I do agree however that the specifics of who to hold accountable and to what extent they are punished are complicated issues. We've had decades of examples showing it's far past time we put in the work to come up with something however.
Seems to me that they wouldn't have it both ways...
This is a new conversation about adding risks never seen in the history of business outside of explicit fraud and criminal behaviour.
The Opioid Pharma trials are the closest thing to justice I have seen in my lifetime.
I do hope this is a positive step towards corporate accountability. God knows we severely need it in the US.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zheng_Xiaoyu
http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/china/2009-01/23/content_742298...
People like Tim Danaher should be behind bars. It's amazing to me that you can kill, injure, or put at risk hundreds of thousands of lives in the name of profit, but so long as you do it while working for a large enough business you get to continue to live in the luxury those profits afford you no matter how much innocent blood you spilled to gain them. I don't know exactly when we decided that serial killers in suits are perfectly acceptable to us, but even the companies themselves who allow this sort thing to happen are rarely punished enough to offset the gains they made exploiting their customers.
I expect there to be people in this world who will do anything to satisfy their greed, I just don't understand why we continue to let it happen again and again in industry after industry without holding anyone meaningfully accountable for their part in it.