Furthermore, any systemic solution that does not enforce global compliance and population control (I went there) is guaranteed to fail.
But even ignoring that, it's important to define "worse". Worse than a year round fire season constantly threatening to burn down your home? Worse than 50 year floods every single year? As the impacts of climate change become more real to individuals, I think you'll find the "worse" situation is not doing anything.
I'm not sure if this is referencing the current predicament in California (which Gavin Newsom is attempting to blame on climate change [0]), but if so the reality is closer to...
-failure to carry out proper controlled burns [1]
-corrupt California legislature being heavily backed by PG&E lobbying [2]
-those same California politicians not reigning in PG&E [3]
-and a couple other more minor things.. maybe including people living in risky areas [4]
The sea level change of 3 inches over the last 25 years, while ultimately an issue, is a cop-out for political failings in California right now.
[0] https://www.politico.com/states/california/story/2019/10/28/...
[1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/chuckdevore/2018/11/16/californ...
[2] https://www.nytimes.com/2019/02/23/us/pge-california-politic...
[3] https://www.sfchronicle.com/business/article/PG-E-plans-near...
[4] https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2019-10-28/kincade-...
Shifting focus to alternatives is noble, but the technology is years from maturation. It took us a long time to master the steam that drives electricity generation whether the plant is coal, oil, natural gas or nuclear (hydroelectric being the lone exception). These sources are mature enough to be reliable. We often take for granted the level of engineering effort involved in building and deploying a stable power grid. Switching to alternatives before they are mature will introduce instabilities across the grid, rolling brownouts/blackouts will be prevalent. Subways will shutdown in major cities at arbitrary times etc. It will dramatically reduce the quality of life. This is what happens in third world countries with inadequate and unstable grids. If you wonder why cellphones outsell desktops and laptops in Africa, this is partly why.
The energy density per unit volume that gasoline offers is unmatched by all other sources except nuclear. It’s stable and portable, and yes it definitely damages the environment when produced or consumed, but then every fuel source does. There’s certainly some great work on better batteries, but it’s years, potentially decades, away from production grade. It’s also unclear whether there won’t be other externalities from mining and transmuting rare earth metals at the scale required to replace gasoline. We may be trading one problem for another. The world is also slowly running out of potable water.
A big problem like climate change requires big solutions. A complete rethink of transportation, energy infrastructure, food production, housing, etc. at a national scale. And any sustainable solution will have to address population limits. But nobody has the courage to talk in those terms. Thing is, even if one country manages to wean itself off of fossil fuels, other, poorer countries will be happy to absorb the excess supply in the form of lower prices. How do we stop that? Put a global price on carbon? Look above for why certain countries won’t agree to that. That requires a one world govt., and we’re probably not getting one of those until we face a mass extinction event (meteor, aliens).
Climate change is the ultimate tragedy of the commons. And humanity has a terrible track record as far as the commons are concerned.
Many of the things we'd need to do are simply better overall but aren't happening fast enough because of political coordination issues.
I believe most of the people complaining about how it will be really tough are actually just spreading (unwittingly or not) propaganda from the narrow interests who benefit from the status quo.
It's no different from all the people talking about how much a less idiotic healthcare system in the US would cost. While multiple other nations already do more with less.
Such a solution cannot work, as long as we have a growth-based economy. The fact is that economists have long regarded natural resources as infinite, and their models are conceived accordingly.
Infinite growth is by definition incompatible with a finite planet. Until we have come up with a new, finite economic model (which means also a profound change to our way of living), I'm afraid there's no easy solution to the climate crisis.
If the roughly 60-75% of Americans who believe human activity is causing climate change were to stop voting for individuals who don't believe this, we'd have meaningful change coming from the federal government within 2 years.
This is not just semantics, some who believe in global warming fly every month or week, some who don't believe in global warming have not flown their entire life (to pick just one example). The latter do more to mitigate it than the former.
Electing leaders who ignore the problem does way more harm than the lifestyles of average people.
Climate change has some really terrible consequences, but until it gets real for people they'll only suffer so much inconvenience. My own pet peeve is when recycling bins get thrown in with the garbage... Shitty solutions will regress us, but shitty solutions are necessary for iteration, so /shrug.
Not everyone's priorities are yours and even if they were its difficult to coordinate action.
The only remedy to the above problems is abolishing first-past-the-post elections in favor of instant runoff.
One estimate of a 3.7C warming scenario is a total cost of $550 trillion: https://www.axios.com/climate-change-costs-wealth-carbon-tax.... That's about in the 2100 timeframe.
That sounds like a lot, except OECD projects that by 2060 world GDP will be $267 trillion annually: https://data.oecd.org/gdp/gdp-long-term-forecast.htm. Estimates of world GDP in 2100 are in the $250-$500 trillion range annually.
That means that adopting policies that cause us to hit the lower end of that range instead of the upper end of that range could cost us more than the total cost of a 3.7C increase in just a few years. And if those government policies don't work then you will have paid that cost, and you'll have to deal with the cost of climate change on top of it.
Now, of course lots of things could happen. Climate change could be an extinction-level problem. (According to the IPCC, there is "virtually no chance" of anthropogenic causes resulting in a Venus-like runaway greenhouse effect.) Or we could figure out workable CCS in 2050 and average climate change entirely. (That's also not super likely.)
Ultimately, the rational course depends on what you think of government action in this area. If you think it'll cost a lot but end up ineffective (like say the "War on Poverty") then it's completely rational to vote against it. If you think it'll work without hurting economic growth significantly, then it's rational to vote for it.
That is true, and I easily agree with everything you said, but FWIW there have been studies on whether cost-benefit analysis actually works by examining the outcomes after the fact. For example this set of case studies demonstrating that cost-benefit decision making would have historically made the wrong choice, and that sometimes our estimates for costs in the future are wrong by orders of magnitude.
https://scholarship.law.georgetown.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?a...
Point being that the completely rational vote isn’t always the right vote. Focusing on costs rather than goals sometimes leads us to miss the big picture.
> focusing on goals rather than costs lead to programs that cost stratospheric amounts without producing the desired results.
Just curious, I don’t doubt there are some, I just don’t know what they are. What would count as some examples of that having happened in the past, akin to the examples I linked of leaded gasoline, damming the Grand Canyon, or removing vinyl chloride from workplaces?
First, the article paints a strawman of cost-benefit analysis. Cost-benefit analysis can consider different scenarios, probabilistic measures, and even qualitative components.
Second, what's the alternative? If you don't at least quantify the things that are quantifiable, all you're doing is going by gut feelings and emotion. And that's the province of savages.
> Just curious, I don’t doubt there are some, I just don’t know what they are. What would count as some examples of that having happened in the past, akin to the examples I linked of leaded gasoline, damming the Grand Canyon, or removing vinyl chloride from workplaces?
There are many areas where over-emphasis on desired outcomes and goals, while ignoring costs, led to poor results.
The war on poverty: https://www.heritage.org/poverty-and-inequality/report/the-w...
The war on drugs: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/31/opinion/failed-war-on-dru...
Doubling education spending per student since 1970 (in constant dollars): http://www.foundry.org/wp-content/uploads/ed-spend-fam-facts...
The Iraq War, most of our Middle East policy, and the TSA.
Socialism: https://www.fff.org/explore-freedom/article/socialism-markin.... (Huge disaster from an environmental standpoint.)
Many environmental disasters are the result of focusing on goals or outcomes without thinking about costs. Irrigating the southwest, damming the Colorado, hydroelectric power, opposition to nuclear power in the 1960s and 1970s, etc.
Blasting China won't change it since a lot of China's pollution is due to the developed countries exporting their most polluting industries. Europe is seriously confronting the situation, America's denying it (starting by its president).
Here is a good article about it: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/sep/25/lambas...
It seems that some of what already happened, like melting of icebergs, is not easy to be revert.
I'm pretty sure we do not know what those interventions will do and what their impact will eventually be.
You paint far too rosy a picture here. A carbon tax is preventative, not active. There is no viable path to scale current sequestration techniques to global scale.
What we're talking about with a carbon tax is not 'solving climate change'. It is limiting the change to approximately what current models predict.
This is a problem that is very well suited to direct public funding (we all benefit if a solution is found) and poorly suited for private enterprise (privatizing the benefit is unlikely to offset the costs to develop it on an average basis).
Here's our meetup on pulling carbon from the air, mainly in the Bay Area but want to spread out: https://meetup.com/airminers
The damage already done has a very long tail.
Thermal expansion will continue to increase sea level rise for hundreds of years even if we stop emitting co2 now [0].
We need to think about mitigation of the impact of future climate change in addition to addressing the root cause.
[0] https://royalsociety.org/topics-policy/projects/climate-chan...
The science tells us we don't have much to turn things around, not nearly enough.
Based on our history of energy transitions, even rolling out commercially available tech for low/zero carbon generation left to market forces will take many decades, almost a century.
Then there are hard problems we simply have no low/zero carbon solution for at scale. Manufacturing pig iron for primary steel, ammonia, cement, industrial agriculture, plastics, shipping, aviation, etc.
Also, AFAIK there does not exist a demonstrated technology for CO2 sequestration that scales and has the required CO2 emission balance (needs energy to run). Storage is also unsolved. I'm curious if you have a link.
It took a century to build out the global oil infrastructure with its millions of miles of pipelines, pumps, oil tankers, etc.
We'll need to handle multiple times the material flow for CO2 sequestration. And overhaul/retrofit/upgrade the entire global energy system, industry, transportation, shipping, agriculture... Even allowing for existing sequestration tech - there's no time.
We need a quick head start that only cutting back consumption can give us. 10% of the population is responsible for 50% of global anthropogenic emissions.
If the top 1% of emitters or the ~75 million people at the top cut back their consumption to the level of the average European's, global emissions would decrease by 30%.
The current economics paradigm (~growth is a must) guarantees we can't solve climate change as growth cannot be decoupled from CO2 increase.
This is a physics problem. Physics doesn't care about ROI or discount rates or tactics.
We were given a diagnosis of terminal cancer quite some time ago and we refused to do chemo or undergo surgery because it would have meant a drastic change in our lifestyle. Now we are stage three. We still meet with our oncologist team from time to time, only to actively sabotage all of their attempts to save us.
In 1988 the UN established the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. In 31 years, after 51 IPCC sessions and 25 major conferences our yearly CO2 emissions increased by 60%. That's how much we care.
In 2019, Energy companies are still set on fully realizing their extractions rights and are actively seeking new oil and gas fields to exploit, including in the thawing arctic.
We're still buliding 1500+ new coal power plants and hundreds of airports.
We're busy entrenching our fossil fuel dependence. Anthropogenic CO2 emissions are still on the rise.
There's just no political will.
The simple solution to this big global catastrophe is my favorite money making scam. Here, just create this market for carbon credits. It makes my guys money while doing Jack shit.
Seriously, if you think CO2 is the problem, the solution is to simply tax those that either take it out of the ground or import it. Any other solution is political.
Not saying I agree with the premise, but if you do, that's the solution.
What exactly is it that you're saying?
Made by a former geologist, science journalists for 25 years.
Hope that helps! I'm a bit puzzled you know all those terms but apparently don't have the tools to find answers. Try googling that stuff and see what academic papers you find!
[1] https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2019/03/oceans-do-us-a-huge-s...
In Colorado, for years the state government spent a lot of time and money trying to show that China was the reason we couldn't meet Federal air quality standards. It was a moronic exercise- no matter who is responsible for the ozone, we are the ones breathing it. Skip the blame game and get to fixing it.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ocean_acidification
Also, no one knows the exact percentage breakdown. No one. We can't even say with any sort of certainty what the current climate is, because it's something that is only really available retrospectively.
I just want to remind everyone that there are solutions to climate change. We know how to produce clean energy and sequester CO2. The current free market does not make those solutions profitable for investors, though, and we will have to change that.
Solving climate change can be as simple as getting a carbon price adopted. It needs to ramp up over time, allow a secondary market for offsets, and create a cross-border network effect (e.g. carbon free trade zone), but it can actually be that simple.
A "carbon tax" may be infeasible given current political norms, but a revenue neutral "carbon dividend" would have the same effect while being more progressive.
So, if you are curious what you can do to solve climate change, consider contacting your representative.