News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gamers for Freedom: A handbook for protesting at this yea... by grawprog on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @03:22PM (#21337915)
>Game publishers and developers certainly have a right to moderate the content that appears on their platforms. And in many cases, moderation is essential to ensure that gamers are safe from harassment, threats of violence, and other dangerous behavior. But silencing gamers from speaking about their identities and experiences puts us all at risk of personal attacks and widespread oppression.

I don't agree with blizzard but this statement really appears contradictory to me. It still advocates censorship and doesn't get at the root of the problem that the censorship was occurring at the behest and pressure of a foreign government. Personally, I think clearly written rules about what is and isn't allowable in a platform, that's enforced equally seems pretty reasonable to me. Enforcing speech selectively, with no clear guidelines will still lead to problems.

Re:Gamers for Freedom: A handbook for protesting at this yea... by ggggtez on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @03:54PM (#21338242)
I recommend reading up on the history of Free Speech in America. You'll find that all of these issues and more have already been thoroughly discussed in the last 400 years of liberal society.

Political speech is protected, but your right to say you're going to go to someone's house and kill their whole family is generally not protected.

It's pretty clear that Blizzard was not following their own guidebook here. I can't imagine them banning a player who said "Free Catalan!". The banning was only because it was anti china. An anti-Spain statement would have just resulted in some scratching of heads, not a 1 year suspension and revoking of prize money.

Re:Gamers for Freedom: A handbook for protesting at this yea... by baddox on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @07:11PM (#21340045)
It's worth noting that while your description of free speech in the USA is somewhat accurate, the USA actually has extremely relaxed restrictions for speech advocating violence. The current federal standard is "imminent lawless action," which means that speech cannot be restricted unless the violence it's advocating is likely to happen immediately. As far as I can tell, you can freely broadcast speech of the form "let's get together sometime and do a bunch of violence against so-and-so." This comes from a Supreme Court case about a Ku Klux Klan rally where the leader addressed the group and literally advocated organized violence against minorities for political purposes (what many would call terrorism).
Re:Gamers for Freedom: A handbook for protesting at this yea... by SamReidHughes on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @08:18PM (#21340436)
That's not the only exception. You can't make "true threats." There are laws against conspiracy to commit crimes, which you might have described ("let's get together sometime") in your example.
Re:Gamers for Freedom: A handbook for protesting at this yea... by marcusverus on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @11:20PM (#21341377)
Conspiracy requires more than speech. Two accountants who agree over drinks that "the shareholders are assholes, we should defraud them!" are not commiting a crime until they take some action past speech alone. Based on a quick Google search of the legal elements of conspiracy crimes, you need an actual agreement/plan to commit a crime and some consummating act that shows intent to follow through. Point being, these aren't really speech restrictions.
Re:Gamers for Freedom: A handbook for protesting at this yea... by SamReidHughes on Thursday October 24, 2019 @01:22AM (#21341871)
Apparently not, see U.S. v. Shabini, so an overt act requirement isn't a consequence of the 1st Amendment rule; just many laws (but not all) happen to require one.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Shabani

Re:Gamers for Freedom: A handbook for protesting at this yea... by thaumasiotes on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @08:50PM (#21340609)
> It's pretty clear that Blizzard was not following their own guidebook here. I can't imagine them banning a player who said "Free Catalan!". The banning was only because it was anti china. An anti-Spain statement would have just resulted in some scratching of heads, not a 1 year suspension and revoking of prize money.

As far as I've read (which is basically nothing but https://www.shamusyoung.com/twentysidedtale/?p=48310 ), the response to blitzchung came from NetEase, Blizzard's legally-required publisher/distributor in China. Unlike Blizzard, NetEase is a Chinese company.

It seems unsurprising that the Chinese distributor for Hearthstone would react like a Chinese company -- that's the point of the requirement. Was Blizzard even consulted on the response?

Re:Gamers for Freedom: A handbook for protesting at this yea... by sharkjacobs on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @10:54PM (#21341259)
I think you're misreading that article. There is no question that suspending Blitzchung and stripping him of his prize money was done by Blizzard, not NetEase.

The Chinese social media statement was from NetEase, and Blizzard may or may not have had any say in that.

Re:Gamers for Freedom: A handbook for protesting at this yea... by thaumasiotes on Thursday October 24, 2019 @12:52AM (#21341729)
The NetEase statement details what the punishment will be. (It is explicitly set in the future.)

I'm quite willing to believe that NetEase made that statement only after discussing the punishment with Blizzard, or hearing an official public statement from Blizzard, or some such. But (and again, I am not informed on the topic) I'd also be willing to believe otherwise.

Re:Gamers for Freedom: A handbook for protesting at this yea... by ggggtez on Thursday October 24, 2019 @02:07AM (#21342063)
Blizzard presumably has control of their own checkbook.

They didn't just ban him from playing in China. Some of the tournaments he participated in were in other countries, like Singapore.

To suggest that China should be able to cause a US company to ban a player from playing in Singapore... it's silly. Does Blizzard run it's own company or is it run by the Chinese Government?

Re:Gamers for Freedom: A handbook for protesting at this yea... by freeflight on Thursday October 24, 2019 @10:50PM (#21351387)
> I can't imagine them banning a player who said "Free Catalan!".

Because imagination overrides precedent?

Re:Gamers for Freedom: A handbook for protesting at this yea... by ggggtez on Saturday October 26, 2019 @08:54PM (#21367263)
Sure, when did Blizzard ban a pro player for making a pro-Catalan statement? Or censor any references to the Spanish Inquisition, and other Spanish atrocities?

Because they sure do that sort of thing for China... Imagination isn't required, you can just look at the world and see that China gets special treatment.

Re:Gamers for Freedom: A handbook for protesting at this yea... by SolaceQuantum on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @03:52PM (#21338224)
From what I can tell, if you read purely on rhetoric, it isn't contradictory- it states moderation is essential to ensure safety from harassment but that moderation should not be used for speaking about personal experiences. For example, it is essential for moderators to prevent "I am going to find where you live and hurt you" but to allow "I feel threatened".
Re:Gamers for Freedom: A handbook for protesting at this yea... by grawprog on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @04:50PM (#21338863)
What if my personal experiences are attending klan or nazi rallies, protests against lgbt people, what if I live in a country where it's ok to domestically abuse my spouse and that's my experience? Maybe I live in a place where it's encouraged to round up and beat minorities or gay people. Not being threatening or harassing, where would personal experiences like that fall under?

I'm being a bit hyperbolic, but that's the point about the vagueness, it leads to ridiculous interpretations that will end up still being selectively moderated in the end. Clearly stating what is and is acceptable on a platform and following it consistently removes that ambiguity and doesn't leave it up to arbitrary feelings to decide.

Re:Gamers for Freedom: A handbook for protesting at this yea... by thaumasiotes on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @08:54PM (#21340633)
There's plenty of such experience to go around:

http://www.unz.com/gnxp/norway-offers-migrants-a-lesson-no-r...

> The statistics are pretty straightforward, and some are outlined in the article. This is a robust and replicated dynamic in Scandinavia; people of “migrant background” are over-represented in rape statistics. It’s an open secret, in that when push come to shove the authorities tend to make excuses rather than lying about it.

> Migrants themselves can often be quite frank and astute observers of cross-cultural differences:

>> “Men have weaknesses and when they see someone smiling it is difficult to control,” Mr. Kelifa said, explaining that in his own country, Eritrea, “if someone wants a lady he can just take her and he will not be punished,” at least not by the police.

It is my understanding that people are generally discouraged from offering these personal experiences, for fear of likely public reaction, regardless of how illuminating they may be.

Re:Gamers for Freedom: A handbook for protesting at this yea... by SkyBelow on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @05:25PM (#21339166)
>that's enforced equally seems pretty reasonable to me

What counts as equal?

>The law, in its majestic equality, forbids the rich as well as the poor to sleep under bridges, to beg in the streets, and to steal bread.

Blizzard could create the rule "No political messages that cause a large country to ban us" and then equally enforce it by banning "Boo China" and allowing "Yay China".

As such, I don't think equal enforcement of the law gets at the root issue of China being willing to entirely ban things that make them look bad.

Re:Gamers for Freedom: A handbook for protesting at this yea... by jamie_ca on Thursday October 24, 2019 @12:53AM (#21341732)
Equal in this case might be that when a Collegiate team held up a sign supporting HK, Blizzard gave them the same 6mo ban that Blitzchung eventually settled at.

They then also banned future livestream footage from the entire Collegiate format.

Re:Gamers for Freedom: A handbook for protesting at this yea... by kevin_thibedeau on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @10:47PM (#21341223)
They could just segregate their players and let the rest of the world do as it pleases.
Re:Gamers for Freedom: A handbook for protesting at this yea... by freeflight on Thursday October 24, 2019 @10:49PM (#21351382)
> It still advocates censorship and doesn't get at the root of the problem that the censorship was occurring at the behest and pressure of a foreign government.

Is that actually the root of the problem? I keep reading this claim about how China supposedly strongarmed Blizzard into doing it but what evidence do we actually have for that?

Because it's not like this is unprecedented: Blizzard has been banning plenty of pro-players over voicing their particular political opinions, even when players did it on their personal streams.

The reality is very likely that Blizzard simply does not want any political speech at all, especially not on their major events. As such Blizzchung could probably also have called out Barcelona or Palestine and the result would very likely have been the same.

But because this is China, there's a whole lot of people heavily, and professionally, invested in spinning the situation as much as possible, very comparable to that whole Ubisoft situation with R6:Siege "censorship".

Re:Gamers for Freedom: A handbook for protesting at this yea... by xtracto on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @11:05PM (#21341304)
>pressure of a foreign government

Define foreign. Not american does not mean foreign for huge multinational corporations.

Re:Gamers for Freedom: A handbook for protesting at this yea... by WillPostForFood on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @11:16PM (#21341358)
"From another country", which is indeed "not American" in this case. Activision is Delaware corp, headquartered in Santa Monica. Blizzard developed Hearthstone in Irvine, CA. I think it reasonable to consider China a foreign government in this context.
Re:Gamers for Freedom: A handbook for protesting at this yea... by unethical_ban on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @03:26PM (#21337963)
Moderation != censorship.
Re:Gamers for Freedom: A handbook for protesting at this yea... by grawprog on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @03:31PM (#21338009)
No, but selective moderation based on unclear inconsistent guidelines is. Look at hn, I'd say it's heavily moderated, but the guidelines are clear and the moderation is mostly consistent. When accounts and comments get banned or killed here, it's usually obvious how the guidelines were broken, most of the time.
Re:Gamers for Freedom: A handbook for protesting at this yea... by empath75 on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @04:19PM (#21338535)
censorship isn't just bad moderation.
Re:Gamers for Freedom: A handbook for protesting at this yea... by grawprog on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @04:41PM (#21338774)
I never said it was. Censorship comes in many forms. I was just pointing out I don't believe all moderation is censorship, but selective, inconsistent moderation can become a form of censorship.
Re:Gamers for Freedom: A handbook for protesting at this yea... by odessacubbage on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @05:04PM (#21339001)
in most cases, and certainly within the context of online discussions, moderation is explicitly censorship.
Re:Gamers for Freedom: A handbook for protesting at this yea... by unethical_ban on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @05:37PM (#21339275)
Sigh.

Where is this armchair analysis coming from? Are you American? If so, do you understand the 1st amendment and what it protects?

It doesn't protect me saying "I'm going to kill you tonight, in your house, get ready" or "Hey everyone, there is a fire in the room!" when there isn't.

Not all verbal speech is speech. Not all removal of content is censorship, in the context of free speech.

https://www.uscourts.gov/about-federal-courts/educational-re...

Re:Gamers for Freedom: A handbook for protesting at this yea... by kodablah on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @05:52PM (#21339435)
Censorship has more contexts than just government-protected free public speech. Maybe this doesn't fit the definition of censorship under the context you are framing the term, but it definitely does under other contexts of the term.
Re:Gamers for Freedom: A handbook for protesting at this yea... by unethical_ban on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @06:41PM (#21339837)
Considering this entire discussion is about the censorship/moderation of content with the intent to suppress political speech, I think it is important to be clear. Also, most people don't use the term "censorship" when they talk about moderating forums. It is as radical as saying "taxation = theft".
Re:Gamers for Freedom: A handbook for protesting at this yea... by stale2002 on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @06:34PM (#21339786)
Nobody said anything about the 1st amendment.

Instead, the topic is censorship.

Censorship does not need to have anything to do with the 1st amendment.

Re:Gamers for Freedom: A handbook for protesting at this yea... by ameister14 on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @06:44PM (#21339850)
The fire in crowded theatre comment is kind of a tell that you dont actually know what the history of is and limits are on free speech in the US. It was a comment from the 1920s prior to the dismantling of restrictions on free speech over the next 90 years of court rulings. Plus it may actually be protected speech.
Re:Gamers for Freedom: A handbook for protesting at this yea... by unethical_ban on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @07:52PM (#21340270)
Literally from the link I posted, a federal government website:

Freedom of speech does not include the right:

    To incite actions that would harm others (e.g., “[S]hout[ing] ‘fire’ in a crowded theater.”).
    Schenck v. United States, 249 U.S. 47 (1919). 
So at least your last sentence is rubbage.
Re:Gamers for Freedom: A handbook for protesting at this yea... by erik_seaberg on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @08:18PM (#21340431)
“Shouting ‘fire’ in a crowded theater” was a metaphor for protesting the draft during WWI.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schenck_v._United_States

Re:Gamers for Freedom: A handbook for protesting at this yea... by ameister14 on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @08:43PM (#21340581)
That might be a federal website but it was never prevailing supreme court opinion, even when the judge wrote it.
Re:Gamers for Freedom: A handbook for protesting at this yea... by ameister14 on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @05:00PM (#21338957)
Sure it is. A censor exists to make sure you don't produce content that the community doesn't like. That's what a moderator does, too.
Re:Gamers for Freedom: A handbook for protesting at this yea... by hurrdurr2 on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @05:40PM (#21339320)
Blizzard is a private company and if they want to moderate/censor certain content on their platforms it is totally up to them. This really isn't a free speech issue.

Just like how you can't post certain types of content on YouTube/Instagram/name your social media.

Re:Gamers for Freedom: A handbook for protesting at this yea... by stale2002 on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @06:01PM (#21339510)
They are free to do so, and society is free to retaliate against them, and senators are free to send threats to them, about what future action that they might take against blizzard.
Re:Gamers for Freedom: A handbook for protesting at this yea... by hurrdurr2 on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @06:52PM (#21339901)
So Blizzard must be forced to allow political speech and protesting on their platform... a company that makes video games?
Re:Gamers for Freedom: A handbook for protesting at this yea... by stale2002 on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @07:15PM (#21340066)
> So Blizzard must be forced to allow political speech

They can do whatever they want.

And other are free to retaliate against them.

Freedom means that both sides are free to do this. It is a consumer's absolute right to retaliate in this way.

Re:Gamers for Freedom: A handbook for protesting at this yea... by hurrdurr2 on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @11:22PM (#21341381)
So we're only supposed to get upset at Blizzard right? Or should us morally rightious folk be boycotting every studio owned by Activision?
Re:Gamers for Freedom: A handbook for protesting at this yea... by stale2002 on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @11:27PM (#21341404)
Blizzard was the one who was most recently involved in this decision specifically. So it makes some sense to definitely get mad at them.

If you want to get mad at other studios as well, then go ahead!

Re:Gamers for Freedom: A handbook for protesting at this yea... by rubbingalcohol on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @07:10PM (#21340036)
No, but people are free to protest their lousy behavior.