News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Climate and Unsheltered Homeless in the Continental Unite... by Pfhreak on Sunday October 20, 2019 @01:03AM (#21302381)
We need to invest in proper public housing, pay for its upkeep, and avoid the massive public skyrises that are so expensive to maintain.

We need to allow up zoning and get rid of detached single family only zones.

Heck, I'm all for fully decomodifying housing - which I recognize is radical - but the incentives for buying and building housing today don't align with housing the most people in the best conditions possible.

Re:Climate and Unsheltered Homeless in the Continental Unite... by panic on Sunday October 20, 2019 @05:32AM (#21303105)
> Heck, I'm all for fully decomodifying housing - which I recognize is radical - but the incentives for buying and building housing today don't align with housing the most people in the best conditions possible.

100% on board with this. Having a place to live is too important to leave to the whims of the market. It's arguably more important than having our publicly-funded military—there's no point in defending land if people aren't able to live on it.

Re:Climate and Unsheltered Homeless in the Continental Unite... by kofejnik on Sunday October 20, 2019 @10:33AM (#21304389)
your intentions are certainly nice, but do you want to get Soviet Union? Because state-controlled housing is how you get Soviet Union
Re:Climate and Unsheltered Homeless in the Continental Unite... by coding123 on Sunday October 20, 2019 @06:18AM (#21303277)
Wouldn't a superpower county invade if there was no US military?
Re:Climate and Unsheltered Homeless in the Continental Unite... by roenxi on Sunday October 20, 2019 @08:39AM (#21303758)
Not just superpowers; even the minor powers would likely evaluate their options. Humorously, if the US tried to go completely pacifist then it would be very politically contentious and it might get 'invaded' by one of its own States. Something like a Texas-Mexico alliance, perhaps.
Re:Climate and Unsheltered Homeless in the Continental Unite... by maze-le on Sunday October 20, 2019 @09:32AM (#21304014)
'Pacifist' does not imply no defense spending. Swiss neutrality is arguably a very pacifist foreign policy, while Switzerland has a very well funded military for a country of that size.
Re:Climate and Unsheltered Homeless in the Continental Unite... by panic on Sunday October 20, 2019 @06:28AM (#21303303)
To be clear, I'm not saying the military is unimportant. Just that housing may also deserve the kind of public funding that the military enjoys.
Re:Climate and Unsheltered Homeless in the Continental Unite... by roenxi on Sunday October 20, 2019 @04:02AM (#21302805)
> fully decomodifying housing - which I recognize is radical - but the incentives for buying and building housing today don't align

The incentives for commodity housing are to build more if the price is high. There aren't a lot of incentive structures that improve on that.

The only alternative that doesn't have strictly worse incentives are if the government builds and assigns all housing. I'd bet that turns out to be worse in practice, but if it has ever worked out anywhere ever I'd be interested in the case study.

It would be a much better idea to stick to non-radical things like tweaking the zoning so developers aren't banned from building things.

Re:Climate and Unsheltered Homeless in the Continental Unite... by Pfhreak on Sunday October 20, 2019 @02:54PM (#21306233)
If housing is an asset and its amount is constrained, then its value goes up. If I'm wealthy, I can use the leverage I have on existing properties to buy more properties, to earn a multiplier on whatever the market does. Have 10x properties? You get 10x the returns when the market rises. (And 10x the leverage to buy more property.) Not to mention you can charge more rent.

Once you reach a certain point, it might not be in your best interest for the housing supply to increase, as your existing investments won't be as valuable.

> The only alternative that doesn't have strictly worse incentives are if the government builds and assigns all housing.

It doesn't have to be all or nothing -- we can change the incentives in various ways. For example, tax on land value not property value. (Encouraging housing to be built rather than parking lots). Allow tenants the right of first offer on property they are renting, so an apartment complex can become a coop rather than owned by a private entity. Increase taxes on non-owner occupied properties, to encourage folks not to just buy and hold vacant property. Improve protections for tenants -- increase penalties for landlords who do not maintain their properties. There's probably a lot more ways we could incentivize increasing the number of people housed rather than maximizing the revenue for the landlord.

Build distributed public housing, in smaller, more manageable buildings. Don't require that public housing revenue covers all maintenance for the property -- if we agree that we should build some, why would we let it fall into disrepair? We should adequately fund its care.

In addition to tenant coops, support cohousing.

Re:Climate and Unsheltered Homeless in the Continental Unite... by dredmorbius on Sunday October 20, 2019 @11:11AM (#21304628)
Actually, there's considerable evidence to suggest that for financialised assets, there's an extraordinarily strong incentive to block new production in order to inflate asset prices.

We see this in, for example, housing, diamonds, law degrees, and doctors licences. Until Uber and Lyft came along, in taxi medallions.

Re:Climate and Unsheltered Homeless in the Continental Unite... by sanxiyn on Sunday October 20, 2019 @06:03AM (#21303216)
> The only alternative that doesn't have strictly worse incentives are if the government builds and assigns all housing. I'd bet that turns out to be worse in practice, but if it has ever worked out anywhere ever I'd be interested in the case study.

This is how Singapore works. It has been working great there.

Re:Climate and Unsheltered Homeless in the Continental Unite... by roenxi on Sunday October 20, 2019 @08:35AM (#21303742)
I'll read up on it, but it wouldn't surprise me if Singapore had more land devoted to urban development than they do countryside.

Their policies aren't going to be optimising for general welfare as much as they are working around the fact that they have no land to play with when compared to anyone else. Their system looks like it makes sense for those conditions, but it would be a massive burden elsewhere. Look at the complexity of their quota system, for example [0]. So people are not going to be living where they want and everyone is going to be in the same part of the city anyway because Singapore is small - I could walk the long edge of their land in a single day.

So basically, point taken that it works for Singapore. But Singapore is facing unique geographical constraints and it probably causes a lot of pain in practice that we don't hear about [1]. under normal conditions it would be far cheaper and easier just to build some high density government housing rather than trying to decommoditise. I expect it will turn out that nobody with alternatives should try to copy that aspect of Singapore.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_housing_in_Singapore#Re...

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Press_Freedom_Index - See Singapore, entry 151 of 180

Re:Climate and Unsheltered Homeless in the Continental Unite... by brudgers on Sunday October 20, 2019 @02:43AM (#21302608)
Hope VI eliminated a significant fraction of the US's public housing stock. You could shave the last twenty five years of the housing market with Occam's Razor and a supply demand curve.
Re:Climate and Unsheltered Homeless in the Continental Unite... by dredmorbius on Sunday October 20, 2019 @04:23PM (#21306837)
For those unfamiliar:

HOPE VI is a program of the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development. It is intended to revitalize the worst public housing projects in the United States into mixed-income developments. Its philosophy is largely based on New Urbanism and the concept of defensible space.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HOPE_VI

Re:Climate and Unsheltered Homeless in the Continental Unite... by dredmorbius on Sunday October 20, 2019 @11:09AM (#21304613)
What do you mean by "decommodifying" housing?

My view is increasingly that it needs to be de-assetified, if that's a word, or de-financialised, almost certainly through a land value tax.

Re:Climate and Unsheltered Homeless in the Continental Unite... by Pfhreak on Sunday October 20, 2019 @02:56PM (#21306248)
Yeah, that's basically the same as what I'm saying -- housing shouldn't be a commodity that we speculate on financially. The incentive shouldn't be about how much money it can extract, but rather how many people it can comfortably house.
Re:Climate and Unsheltered Homeless in the Continental Unite... by someguydave on Sunday October 20, 2019 @12:47PM (#21305271)
There’s already significant land taxes. Why do you think even higher taxes will help? How do you propose finding a fair value?
Re:Climate and Unsheltered Homeless in the Continental Unite... by Pfhreak on Sunday October 20, 2019 @02:40PM (#21306120)
Most of my property tax is on the structures, not the land. That means that undeveloped and underdeveloped land gets less taxation than land that, say, has apartments on it. It's the opposite of the way it should be -- taxes should penalize parking lots and incentivize housing.
Re:Climate and Unsheltered Homeless in the Continental Unite... by dredmorbius on Sunday October 20, 2019 @03:49PM (#21306580)
Re:Climate and Unsheltered Homeless in the Continental Unite... by dragonwriter on Sunday October 20, 2019 @12:49PM (#21305292)
> There’s already significant land taxes

Real property taxes as structured anywhere in the US are not LVTs, and in much of the US (California perhaps most notably) are not significant, either.

Re:Climate and Unsheltered Homeless in the Continental Unite... by someguydave on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @09:18AM (#21323262)
1% per year is not significant?? I hope you mean to lower other taxes too in this fantasy...