Technology is part of it. What would Bach have produced if he had sampling?
But equally importantly, all composers are limited by only having heard their contemporaries and predecessors. Bach was exposed to a certain set of music. You are exposed to a superset of the music he was exposed to.
People heard his music juxtaposed with everything else they had heard. Some of it sounded fresh, some too different to be enjoyed.
We hear his music juxtaposed with all the music composed after him, including music composed be people who heard his music and innovated further.
That’s the nature of progression. His music, like Mozarts, has timeless beauty. But it will always be “less” in a certain way than the music we hear today.
Imagine doing that in real life. Every time you witness a conversation about something that doesn't interest you you go over there and tell them.
Bach is so celebrated because it has a precision to it, and because all of the musical quality is right there on the page. It's the exact opposite of modern pop music, for example, which is production-driven, and relies much more on dramatic musical gestures.
Bradley Lehman has a bizarre theory, which you could look up if you're interested. I am not qualified to have an opinion on whether it's a good theory.
I think this is sad, because musician should be about fooling around and experimenting with sounds, melodies and phrases that come out of your instrument. Of course you can refine it all for a concert, but beeing a perfect classical musician should be more like Picasso and less like someone who tries to paint like a photograph (and keep in mind: Picasso was pretty good at the photorealistic stuff too if you look at early stuff). Music needs soul and that you only get through interpretation.
I wouldn't say that at all. It's versatile in a different way. Listen to some 20th century organ music - maybe start with Howells, Duruflé, Cochereau and explore from there.
I would concede that I would appreciate Bach better if there was less public emphasis on his music. Someone like Grieg is to me fresh because it is unfamiliar. In that sense I would have had a much more open approach to Bach if the first time I heard his music had been through exploration, rather than publicity.
You can argue that laws are an absolute joke, morality is an absolute joke, society is an absolute joke, nations are an absolute joke, company cultures are an absolute joke (to be sure!), relationships are an absolute joke (evnen an absurd joke) and so on.
Nothing of interest to humans has immutable laws that are so objective to never require judgement.
I stress the word “immutable” because if you give me a law that intends to produce a certain outcome, I’ll give you a game, and once it becomes a game, we’ll need to adjust the laws to preserve the intended outcome.
That’s why we have moderators. And that’s why HN evolves over time. Old timers like me may shake their fist at the way it has changed, but we cannot expect it to remain preserved in crystal like a mosquito in amber.
I usually don't understand from his music why he is celebrated. Is it that he is just historically important? Like the discovery of logarithmic tuning of sqrt_12(2)?
It could also be that I am just moved more by the romantic era. Mozart generally gets relegated lower in my list of great composers, but in Mozart's case my objection is the strict adherence to tempo and clear tone.
Edit: It should also be mentioned that the organ is not a very versatile instrument when compared to a piano. Although I have been treated to some great organ interpretation with a distinct familiarity to Daft Punk.