News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:J.S. Bach the Rebel: The subversive practice of a canonic... by jacquesm on Friday October 18, 2019 @02:53AM (#21289220)
Bach boring? No arguing about taste I guess. As for the organ not being very versatile compared to a piano: think of an organ not as a piano, but as a very early version of a synthesizer without 'touch sensitivity'.
Re:J.S. Bach the Rebel: The subversive practice of a canonic... by vixen99 on Friday October 18, 2019 @04:19AM (#21289556)
Could one describe a famous mathematician's output (as a whole) as boring and put this opinion down to taste?
Re:J.S. Bach the Rebel: The subversive practice of a canonic... by mikorym on Friday October 18, 2019 @06:07AM (#21290039)
You can describe output as boring, but you can't argue about correctness. Music does not have definibility of the latter.
Re:J.S. Bach the Rebel: The subversive practice of a canonic... by mikorym on Friday October 18, 2019 @06:09AM (#21290048)
Yes, exactly. So Bach was limited by his era and this is my suspicion about why I am not that interested in his music.
Re:J.S. Bach the Rebel: The subversive practice of a canonic... by braythwayt on Friday October 18, 2019 @07:26AM (#21290371)
All composers are limited by their era.

Technology is part of it. What would Bach have produced if he had sampling?

But equally importantly, all composers are limited by only having heard their contemporaries and predecessors. Bach was exposed to a certain set of music. You are exposed to a superset of the music he was exposed to.

People heard his music juxtaposed with everything else they had heard. Some of it sounded fresh, some too different to be enjoyed.

We hear his music juxtaposed with all the music composed after him, including music composed be people who heard his music and innovated further.

That’s the nature of progression. His music, like Mozarts, has timeless beauty. But it will always be “less” in a certain way than the music we hear today.