However, an even bigger problem is legal inequalities. Rich people can afford top legal representation and poor people cannot. We should instead have single payer legal representation. Lawyers are required to charge a standard fee and are paid by the government for their work. They are not allowed to accept payments in addition to the standard government payment or to take contingency fees.
Doing this would ensure that the poor in America are not disadvantaged due to the rich having better lawyers.
Really reduces the incentive for overspending the opposing party and encourages cheap quick settlements.
Second issue is that there is a huge variance in the skill of lawyers and that skill has huge impacts on the outcome of cases. It'd be just like fixing the pay of software engineers in terms of results.
If there exists differences in skill, then there exists arbitrage opportunity. How one can prevent that arbitrage opportunity from being used in order to keep things “fair”, I do not know and have not heard of any compelling ideas.
Similarly, can I have expert testimony at my trial? Can everybody?
Lawyers are required to charge a standard fee and
are paid by the government for their work.
Your goal is noble and I agree with it, but surely we need to recognize that some legal cases require orders of magnitude more effort and resources than others. I don't know how a standard fee could possibly cover this, even if we had different standard fees for different classes of crime./s
But there is so many issues with the government taking on _more_ responsibility in our lives (like they usually do things worse). Not to mention in US, we are guaranteed right to lawyer in defense, for equality, and those lawyers make way less than private lawyers, so presumable there is a difference in quality (or something else?). Additionally, its common to see legal fees part of law suits like this zappos suit), so lawyers can work for poor people because they get paid when they win a suit, which is their job anyways.
If you cost 300M people each $20 worth of time and aggravation so that you can make $5B, your net effect on the economy is a cool negative $1B. However, no individual person would ever find it worthwhile to file a lawsuit for $20. That's why we invented class action lawsuits, but if the company settles for say $300M (that's 5 cents on the dollar), 1/3 of that goes to the legal team and 2/3 goes to the class members (in the form of free credit monitoring or a 10%-off coupon or something), and a legal team of 10 splits the legal fees, that's F-U money for every lawyer involved, under a dollar for each class members, and a profit of $4.7B for the company. The transaction is value-destroying for the economy as a whole, but happens regardless because it fits each individual participants' incentives. All because the legal system cannot scale to the harms that may be inflicted upon members of the public.
Arguably, this is the system we're living in now.
Suits do not always make the suing party whole, for a number of reasons, yet still have value in enforcing law.
Additionally, many arrangements (particularly class action) have attorneys assuming the entire financial risk of the a loss, and it's reasonable for them to be paid for this service.
---
That said...we're not taking about 30% to the plaintiff, or even 5%. It's 1.4%!!!
It's like saying Facebook founders get a combined 1.4% of the company.
It reminds me of somebody who lawyered up after being denied disability benefits. The lawyer took the case if the client signed over 25% of the payment in perpetuity.
On one hand, yes, they're helping someone resolve the issue without funds to pay for it. But I'm still bothered by the fact the lawyer is either a) cutting deeply into the funds of somebody who needs it because of a true disability or b) is helping someone game the system if they don't need it.
EG: https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2016/08/peter-thiels-foundat...
In light of that, $1.5m is probably an overall loss for the law firm.
It's similar to a car dealership trading in a car that is 'uneconomical to repair' on a new vehicle. Then they repair it anyway and sell it. Because shop costs and parts costs for them are not the same as shop costs and parts costs for you.
One good software dev will cost a company almost a quarter of a million dollars every year. More if in NY or SF. 6 years of one knowledge worker’s salary would run the bill over the $1.5m. 7 years, with paralegals, expenses (for physically attending the various appeals), and a dozen other small expenses I’d be shocked if their actual costs were under $1.5m.
Paralegals are essentially slave laborers who get billed out at huge rates but who take home a pittance in the hope of making partner one day. The legal profession is not what it's cracked up to be unless you make partner or go into business for yourself.
It's 7 years, and a minimum of 3 in-person court visits, plus any number of briefs, letters, preparation, and communicating with the plaintiffs (only some of this work is done by the paralegals; all the paralegal's work still goes through a lawyer). Perhaps you can be a bit more explicit in how you think all that effort wouldn't cost the firm millions of dollars?
According to the document:
"...Both sides agreed to a settlement to avoid the uncertainty and cost of litigation, ..."
>...In light of that, $1.5m is probably an overall loss for the law firm.
I don't think there is any evidence that this is an overall loss for the firm.
We ran into this at a previous job. The firm got sued by a group of attorneys, who between them didn't have a single plaintiff. We settled out of court, which means that while they didn't get the windfall they wanted, they still got a decent payday that more than paid their filing costs.
Fantastic.
Of course, one could also argue that this has just created a new form of venture lawyering, with attorneys who give zero shits about their clients chasing compliance violations rather than ambulances, and businesses baking these lawsuits into their profitability calculations.