The American Hospital Association (the biggest hospital industry lobbying group) spends about as much as Phrma (the big pharma lobbying group) according to open secrets [0][1]. But the hospital industry has much more "soft power" because they are such a huge employer.
One solution is for payers to own more of their own providers, although that is challenging to implement and can lead to its own issues and bad incentives. I think one effective angle is to help more physicians stay independent -- there is probably a way to do this without legislation and i think some companies are working on this.
But i think one thing people can do is spread awareness of this issue -- you dont see it talked about in the media that much bc no group has an incentive to do so
[0] https://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/lobby.php?id=D000000116
[1] https://www.opensecrets.org/lobby/clientsum.php?id=d00000050...
https://jacobinmag.com/2019/09/elizabeth-warren-campaign-med...
The issue with any political solution is that hospitals will fight any legislation like crazy. Hospitals probably have more political power than even the drug industry, and the drug industry has obviously been able to fight price controls pretty well.
The risk I see with any political solutions is that politicians create watered-down legislation that makes voters think they are tackling the issue, but don't really have much teeth. That's the win-win for politicians -- if you pass a toothless medicare for all bill, voters will applaud you, and you won't anger potential donors from industry.
> The risk I see with any political solutions is that politicians create watered-down legislation that makes voters think they are tackling the issue, but don't really have much teeth
I agree, which is why you have to start from the strongest possible negotiating stake with a corresponding infrastructure of mass organization and support (again, Bernie and his bill).
These industries are absolutely ruthless, profit from people at their most vulnerable, and will fight tooth and nail to continue this deeply predatory behavior. If you approach them with even the slightest indication that you will bend to their will, they will eat you for lunch.
Merge all the regional monopolies into one big national hospital monopoly, with all the drug buying power that brings. Then get the Trump/Clinton Care bill passed that controls insurance prices and regulates this new 'National Health Service' as the hospital monopoly might be called.
Hospital consolidation has been increasing the last few decades. Many hospitals are regional monopolies and have a ton of leverage in negotiations with insurers. Insurance companies put the squeeze on smaller providers, increasing pressure on them to sell to big hospitals. After buying a smaller hospital or clinic, the hospital system can bill insurance companies at the hospital systems' much higher negotiated rate -- for the exact same care (at least this is what i heard from several execs at big hospital systems).
My first job out of college was an investment banking analyst and our most profitable clients were hospital systems (HCA, Community Health, Tenet Healthcare, etc). They were so profitable that their profit margins were 20-30% even after writing off 30% of their revenues as uncollectible (this was before the Affordable Care Act).
These hospital systems were major targets of private equity buyouts. A buyout fund would buy a big hospital system, finance the deal with a ton of debt, then buy more hospitals and clinics and roll them up into the bigger system. They made so much cash that they could pay down huge amounts of debt quickly so the private equity groups made tons of money. Many non-profit hospital systems engage in similar aggressive behavior