What if debt collectors could one day consider a kidney a monetary asset like a house, and force them to give it up? How would you feel, if you sold a kidney at 30, and now you're 70 and your remaining kidney fails?
What if the social security basket shrinks proportionally because 10% of people now opt to sell their kidneys and take less social security- is that REALLY better than letting them keep their damn kidney and paying a bit more taxes on social security? A purely economic perspective would say yes...
Broadly speaking, you are reducing a much bigger problem into a small "economics 101" lens.
So, i'll ask again: What if any, specific, negative consequences will accrue to individuals or society at large as a result of a market in kidneys?
Yes, that's a problem. However, it does not impact life expectancy for kidney donors. Kidney donors do not have significant health complications.
> Any shred of common sense would tell you that yes, having one of your organs removed IS a problem.
Yes, it does seem that way. Until you read about it, and realize that it isn't.
> And you ignored everything about perverse incentives that it creates. As if you. in your infinite wisdom, can predict every single "specific, negative consequence" caused by those.
"Perverse" incentives are not, in and of themselves, negative consequences. Perverse incentives may cause negative consequences. I am asking you what those consequences are. You enumerated one: kidney failure. A great start. However, it's not something medical practitioners in the area worry particularly much about.
Living donor programs already exist in many states and hospitals - If you want to help reduce medicare spending by donating your organs, go for it! But don't expect to get paid for it any time soon.
And it remove a source of cash from an entire population, with all that entails.
Many hospitals will cover most if not all of these costs, including your wages, health maintenance, checkups, etc. If the hospital near you won't cover these things, the National Living Donor Assistance Program will help.
> And it remove a source of cash from an entire population, with all that entails
There's something like 100,000 people on the kidney donor list right now (UNOS). Maybe 20,000 of these get a kidney donation per year. It's not really that much of lost productivity, and as we have already explained these costs are usually covered by programs for living donors.
You're acting like this isn't a solved problem, when it is except that people are attached to their own body parts. I for one don't really want to give my kidney away unless I'm already dead. Maybe we should argue for opt-out deceased organ donation programs nationally, instead of this asinine idea that we should allow poor people to sell their kidneys.
I can sell my life (ok, 8 hours of every day) and no problem.
The 18% overhead of insurance companies, just like the overuse of care argument rebutted in the article, does not explain the high relative cost of care in the US.
The problems start because 99% people aren't educated on the true value of their kidney.
They are not in an adequate position to judge the value of an essential organ and the ramifications for missing it for the rest of their life. Because they are not doctors and not experts.
It's immoral, because in this exchange exists information asymmetry, where the kidney seller is not informed enough.
And which problems are those? There are no significant issues that arise from having one fewer kidney.
> They are not in an adequate position to judge the value of an essential organ and the ramifications for missing it for the rest of their life. Because they are not doctors and not experts.
Sure, but that problem exists in tons of market interactions that we solve in various ways. Information disclosure and education, certification programs, etc..This is a very, very easy solve.
And, as I asked elsewhere - how much money are you expecting these organs to be sold for? There are far, far, far more desperate individuals than those who need kidneys - it'd be a buyers market for human organs.
So, you think people are incapable of making this decision for themselves? Or perhaps that, in general, the government should step in to prevent people from taking undue risks in exchange for money? Should we therefore criminalize dangerous jobs like alaskan crab fishing too?
> And, as I asked elsewhere - how much money are you expecting these organs to be sold for? There are far, far, far more desperate individuals than those who need kidneys - it'd be a buyers market for human organs.
a) It doesn't really matter what the equilibrium price ends up being.
b) We don't need to speculate. Iran has a legal market in kidneys: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kidney_trade_in_Iran Their equilibrium price is about $4,000.
$4,000 seems like a perfectly reasonable and fair price for someone to undertake the risks associated with kidney donation.
Yes, literally why OHS exists and should continue to exist.
> $4,000 seems like a perfectly reasonable and fair price for someone to undertake the risks associated with kidney donation.
Who is going to need that sum, but also afford all the post-op medical care and time off? In case of complication, who is responsible? Something tells me if you're needing that sum, you're not going to have the medical coverage required to take care of yourself. Iran seems to have a higher level of general healthcare coverage than America [1].
I'm not familiar with any agency by the name of OHS. Do you mean OSHA? Because they don't regulate employees, they regulate employers.
> Who is going to need that sum, but also afford all the post-op medical care and time off? In case of complication, who is responsible? Something tells me if you're needing that sum, you're not going to have the medical coverage required to take care of yourself. Iran seems to have a higher level of general healthcare coverage than America [1].
First of all, 'time off' isn't a thing for many people. Many people are unemployed, so time off costs them nothing. Secondly, obviously the person purchasing the kidney would cover all aspects of care related to the operation.
Sorry, I'm not American, assumed you'd figure it out from context. And you can frame it how you would - either way it's rules about what's safe and not.
> First of all, 'time off' isn't a thing for many people. Many people are unemployed, so time off costs them nothing.
Sweet, so now we're giving unemployed desperate people a couple grand.
> Secondly, obviously the person purchasing the kidney would cover all aspects of care related to the operation.
How is this guaranteed? If this becomes a buyers market, what's stopping the buyer from saying they won't cover it? Are you suggesting government regulations as such, or hoping that the free-market capitalism of organ trading will do it just because they are decent people?
Well, two couples. But that's a lot of money to a lot of people. It would allow someone to get a car so they could drive to job interviews, pay several months of rent in many places, etc..
There is a very, very large number of people in the world who's lives would be substantially improved by obtaining $4,000 right now. There is also a very substantial number of people in the world who have $4,000 that they do not need, but who's lives would be substantially improved by having a new kidney. It is currently illegal for those pairs of people to help each other out.
> How is this guaranteed? If this becomes a buyers market, what's stopping the buyer from saying they won't cover it? Are you suggesting government regulations as such, or hoping that the free-market capitalism of organ trading will do it just because they are decent people?
For one, i've never suggested that the market should be completely unregulated. So solving this by regulating the process is fine with me. However, it stands to reason that nobody is going to sell their kidney for less than the process costs them in medical costs. That'd just be a money losing trade that wouldn't make sense.
b) One extraordinarily simple thing we could do to deflate medical costs in this country that would have essentially zero negative effects would be to create a market in kidneys. Medicare currently spends 90k per patient per year on dialysis. Allowing people to sell a spare kidney would completely and totally solve this problem, essentially overnight. Everyone currently on dialysis would get a transplant, and the costs would go to zero. 7% of Medicare's budget would evaporate instantly, and the numbers would probably be similar for private insurers.