News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by krick on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @07:28PM (#21277220)
I'm afraid that the moment you chose to use the word "wasteful" it became a philosophical discussion and they don't typically have final words at all.

The stripped down reason you see it as wasteful is that you have some set of beliefs about what is "right" and "meaningful" (many of which, I'll take liberty to say, most likely likely NOT consciously thought out) and since the core technical principle behind Bitcoin is simple enough, it's easy for you to see it does something that seemingly does not contribute to the fulfillment of what you consider "meaningful" (i.e. performing tons of computation that essentially compute nothing "meaningful").

Technical principles behind markets, industries or your own existence are not simple enough, so you cannot see through them and decide at a glance that they are "wasteful". And since you generally avoid falling into philosophical discussions (rightfully so), this is good enough for you. This doesn't mean that they achieve something that will turn out "obviously meaningful" to you (I'm cynical enough to assume they actually not), it's all just too complicated to tell at a glance.

If this is all too abstract, I'm saying that Bitcoin is actually doing something, and this something is much more complicated than the technical principle you can easily see behind it. You should take this into consideration when thinking about what this giant CO₂ emitting machine actually is. It is not a machine for computing hashes, as it might seem from a purely technical perspective.

Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by spookthesunset on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @07:46PM (#21277395)
Bitcoin is absolutely wasteful to the vast majority of the population on earth. It provides no benefit to them, and makes their energy bill (and video card bill) go up.
Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by celticninja on Thursday October 17, 2019 @03:32AM (#21279740)
But the same could be applied to almost any consumer product. My kids want to buy these crappy plastic toys at the supermarket, wastefully packaged and shipped from China, of no-use to anyone yet energy is expended to design, make and ship them internationally. And this is just one consumer product from China. Have you seen Alibaba offerings of late?
Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by jron on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @08:22PM (#21277668)
There isn't a person on earth mining bitcoin with GPUs.
Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by spookthesunset on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @08:24PM (#21277685)
Tons are mining alt coins with them. These stories never include the rather sizable market for alt-coins, almost all of which use the same energy-sucking design that bitcoin does.

I’ve never seen an article like this for the entire crypto space as a whole but I imagine it is much, much worse.

Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by solveit on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @08:38PM (#21277784)
No, energy expenditure for bitcoin mining is larger than that of all altcoins combined. Despite the considerable technical innovations of some altcoins, bitcoin remains king in this world for now.
Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by jron on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @08:40PM (#21277800)
The energy consumption of the next closest altcoin is almost an order of magnitude less even with ASICs. After that, you'll find the security model of almost every altcoin to be total garbage (low energy consumption).
Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by aeternum on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @08:01PM (#21277512)
The increased electricity demand may drive research funding resulting in more efficient energy production.
Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by spookthesunset on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @08:07PM (#21277578)
LOL. Sure, but that is only being done because bitcoin gobbled up all the electricity that could have been used doing useful things like running data centers, smelting aluminum, air conditioning homes, etc.

Bitcoin is a drain on the electrical system. You are basically arguing that it is okay to litter because it will create jobs and spawn new anti-litter technology.

Doesn’t work that way, sorry.

Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by jron on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @08:32PM (#21277740)
I'll shutdown my bitcoin mining operation if you shutdown your AC. I find 21c living to be incredibly wasteful and a luxury only offered to those blessed to be born in the first world.

This type of argument goes nowhere fast.

Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by labster on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @08:58PM (#21277927)
Of course I can see. People’s sense of entitlement means we are all doomed. Mass extinction is always someone else’s fault, not my problem.
Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by billions on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @11:07PM (#21278580)
Please turn off your computer. You're wasting watts shaming first world folk. Go convince the 3rd world to stop burning trash and making babies. Oh, right - they'll stop by themselves when they reach your level of wealth.
Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by celticninja on Thursday October 17, 2019 @03:36AM (#21279760)
That electricity could not always have been used to smelt aluminium or whatever else you suggest. Some of that power is hydro based and cannot travel a significant distance. You can move bitcoin mining equipment closer to power sources much more easily than you can move an aluminium furnace and supporting infrastructure.
Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by wmf on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @07:39PM (#21277310)
Or you could say Bitcoin is wasteful because PoS accomplishes the same thing with 99.99% less energy.
Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by krick on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @07:59PM (#21277496)
Oh, does it? Does it accomplish all the speculation, all the drama going on? All the drug deals made with Bitcoin, all the kids that became rich out of nothing because they played with some obscure technology 10 years ago? I'm pretty sure you don't know everything Bitcoin accomplished (or maybe still does). Neither do I, nor anyone.

To be clear: if you ask my opinion on technical side of Bitcoin, I wouldn't be really praising it. But, as I said already, Bitcoin is not a technical thing. It is a very complicated sociocultural phenomena that definitely did achieve something. And you need to consider everything X is, to apply words such as "wasteful" to X.

Again, if this seems too abstract: if you are living in the USA, you are consuming twice more energy (per capita) than Japanese people, having lower life expectancy (both are far from the ends of the spectrum, BTW). So, the existence of USA citizens is wasteful.

Now, doesn't stripping down all the nuance of living different lives in different countries seem a bit outrageous to you? It surely does seem so to me.

Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by cwkoss on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @07:43PM (#21277362)
PoS opens up new threat models concerning the tyranny of the majority.

PoW utilizes the honest indicator of un-forgeable expense to mitigate this class of risks.

Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by spookthesunset on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @07:47PM (#21277401)
A class of risks that the normal financial system doesn’t have. My bank doesn’t expose me to “double spend” attacks.
Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by limomium on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @08:11PM (#21277602)
I don't know. My bank "double spent" a hundred bucks the other day, that took them half a month to return.

There was some error with the debit card system where it wouldn't accept my card, then when the cashier rebooted the device, it informed me that my account balance was insufficient. Sure enough, checking my balance I see that somehow the first try "stuck" into the system as a 'pre-authorization' -- inexplicably unusable money. The bank just shrugged, it would fix itself in two weeks.

I stopped paying with plastic. Fear the day the ATM fails to produce the bills yet drains my account.

Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by Geee on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @11:51PM (#21278773)
Yes they absolutely do. Someone buys something from you and then they reverse the payment. They go on and buy something else with the same money. Reversible payments are a huge issue for online merchants.
Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by aey on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @08:06PM (#21277569)
At the cost of 2 trillion a year. Or 1 trillion if if you only count service fees and not liquidity.

https://www.mckinsey.com/~/media/mckinsey/industries/financi...

Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by spookthesunset on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @08:11PM (#21277601)
Care to actually quote where the banks are spending $2 trillion a year to stop double spends?
Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by aey on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @11:20PM (#21278644)
The world is. There is no engineering reason why it’s so expensive to move numbers around in a bank.

In comparison the search engine market is 170 billion. If a google sized company or decentralized network could reduce the 2 trillion global spend on payments to 170b, that would be fantastic regardless of how much it spends on preventing double spends.

Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by spookthesunset on Thursday October 17, 2019 @01:20AM (#21279123)
Dude. That $2 trillion is all of finance. Finance is a hell of a lot more than preventing double spends (which don’t exist outside of bitcoin). On a per transaction and even global domestic product basis, the cost of our financial system is tiny. By comparison the cost of bitcoins financial system by any metric is astronomical.
Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by aey on Thursday October 17, 2019 @04:16PM (#21285962)
Read the report, it's 2 trillion of revenue for payments only, not all of finance. That report doesn't cover trading, derivatives, mortgages, etc... 1 trillion of payments revenue comes from credit lines, about 1 trillion is fees moving money around.

Bitcoin is just one settlement layer. There is no reason for my day to day transactions to settle there. My day to day payments can be settlement on a chain with much higher throughput and faster finality and different security assumptions.

There is also no reason why I can't lend my funds to 100m user credit cards directly without a middleman through software either.

So whats the cost comparison of moving $100,000 out of China into the the US via bitcoin vs the traditional banking system?

Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by cwkoss on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @08:11PM (#21277605)
Fraud is absolutely a big deal in banking.
Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by spookthesunset on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @08:15PM (#21277634)
Thankfully many types of fraud can be reversed in our modern financial system. With bitcoin, virtually any form of fraud leaves you completely fucked with absolutely no recourse.

Which makes bitcoin an even bigger joke because on a per transaction basis (one that includes miner subsidies) bitcoin costs several orders of magnitude more and cannot even deliver the same basic features that mainstream fiat offers.

Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by cwkoss on Thursday October 17, 2019 @01:56AM (#21279297)
You're discounting the costs of maintaining system which allows fiat to keep it's value: 20% of the value of human productivity is spent maintaining the financial system.

Saying that you can transact fiat cheaply is a silly comparison: bitcoin can be transacted for free as well. It is flawed to compare the fractional expense of maintaining the entire system for Bitcoin against any value but the fractional cost of maintaining the entire financial sector: comparing against the cost to consumer without accounting for the system maintenance costs is fallacious.

Re:Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index by Erlich_Bachman on Thursday October 17, 2019 @08:59AM (#21281519)
> can be reversed in our modern financial system

It's not like it is free to have a system like that!