Surprisingly, things in this digital age are different and you can thank social media for that. If we didn't hav the Internet and live-broadcasting, the Hong Konguese are nothing but history now.
Being seen as a bloody dictatorship makes doing business much harder.
But you can watch as much basketball as you want, and wear fashionable sneakers, and of course call your buddies in the Party over for a party on your smartphones “proudly designed in California”.
Everyone already knows about Tibet, the Uighurs and so on. Everyone. And yet they still do business there unashamedly.
If China murdered thousands of protestors in Hong Kong, I would imagine there would be a lot of shaming of companies doing business with them.
They’ll still be companies who skirt public opinion, but I can imagine many would be affected.
The other impact could be government sanctions against China. Companies wouldn’t have much of an option then.
Hong Kong is different because people in the West relate to Hong Kong people more. They see them as being close; thus attacking them is similar to an attack on the "west" people.
If Xi ordered a massacre in Hong Kong, it would alienate tons of people in the west who have relatives there. It would alienate countless others who see Hong Kong as a westernized place. It might even reignite a McCarthy-esque red scare.
Not just by China's standard, the handling seems very soft by Western standards also. G8 meetings in Western cities regularly look similar, and those are 3-5 days, not weeks or months.
Not that G8 summits don't draw protests, but I'd hardly say they look similar.
I'm not even sure why you ask about the tear gas and water canons though. Water cannons are frequently used as crowd control in German protests precisely to avoid live ammunition. Here's one example of an old guy getting blinded during the Stuttgart 21 demonstrations in Germany [3]
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/27th_G8_summit#Protests
No, they draw smaller protests and violent police oppression with mass arrests and the occasional dead protestor.
There's also a key difference in that crackdowns on G8 protestors are police protecting/facilitating an international summit, and arguably the right of the summit participants to peacefully assemble. By contrast in Hong Kong an authoritarian regime is attempting to suppress human rights through semi-soft force (for the moment), with military forces conspicuously conducting exercises nearby and threats of "Anyone who attempts to split any region from China will perish, with their bodies smashed and bones ground to powder."
You're comparing a foothill to a mountain and calling the mountain smaller.
If you have 3 people instead of 30, yeah, you're going to use less tear gas.
I get, China bad, West good and all that, but still "if it happens in Genua, the police are just upholding the right of the politicians to assemble" vs "if it happens in HK, it's just an authoritarian regime".
I keep waiting for the shoe to drop.
China, by her own standards, has been very soft on the protests so far. China is much more concerned with its global image than back during the Tiananmen Square protests.
But if anyone should think this won’t end similarly, they’d be fooling themselves.
I’d put lower odds on a sudden violent crack down than on a slow, methodical process of arresting leaders and slowly ratcheting up the pressure on protestors.
As sad as it might seem, the CCP will come out on top in the end.