News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:First Paper to Link CO2 and Global Warming (1856) by Brakenshire on Monday October 14, 2019 @03:59AM (#21246069)
One of the tragedies of our failure to tackle GHG emissions is that now reasonable pathways to stay under 2C of warming require massive negative carbon sequestration after 2040, and at the moment the only way to do that is burning wood and capturing the CO2 emissions. The volume of wood which will have to be burnt each year is more than the volume of all international shipping. That is going to mean covering huge areas of land in industrial plantations which will probably damage wildlife further. Because we’ve delayed action, we’re entering into the teeth of a dilemma which will drive further mass extinctions whatever we do, either remove habitat for wood production for negative carbon, or accept high levels of warming.
Re:First Paper to Link CO2 and Global Warming (1856) by abraae on Monday October 14, 2019 @04:36AM (#21246203)
Why does sequestration involve burning wood? Isn't it easier to leave the carbon in wood form and build e.g furniture, buildings, structures out of wood, and leave the carbon there?
Re:First Paper to Link CO2 and Global Warming (1856) by dredmorbius on Monday October 14, 2019 @06:04AM (#21246578)
I think you're missing the other element: continued access to fuel and energy sources.

Before the switch to coal, wood was the primary thermal energy souce for humans (well, after direct passive solar heat). By the 19th century, and in many parts of the world, centuries or millennia prior, woodfuel burning, directly and as charcoal for kilns and smelters, had deforested vast parts of the globe, transforming many formerly forested parts of the world to desert or scrub (Mesopotamia, Egypt, Lebanon, Greece, Italy).

We have the dual problems of 1) replacing coal, oil, and natural gas, and 2) removing CO2 from the atmosphere and oceans.

Burning wood accomplishes #1, but not #2.

There's the additional slight problem that the scale of present energy consumption, let alone increases which would bring another 5-8 billions of souls up to modern European or US standards of living, largely defined by per-capita energy consumption, greatly exceeds total available biomass production in total, not merely wood growth.

Re:First Paper to Link CO2 and Global Warming (1856) by baq on Monday October 14, 2019 @06:27AM (#21246684)
do you need a thousand chairs? skyscrapers can't be built out of wood, too.

the easiest way would be to just bury the wood (we dug it out in the first place, right?) but we need to make sure that it doesn't rot and thus reenter the atmosphere. that's where burning makes sense.

Re:First Paper to Link CO2 and Global Warming (1856) by imtringued on Monday October 14, 2019 @10:17AM (#21248505)
>skyscrapers can't be built out of wood, too.

Skyscrapers can't be built out of concrete either. It's the rebar that is the structural component that makes it possible to build skyscrapers. We can build skyscrapers with mass timber and steel reinforcement nowadays.

Re:First Paper to Link CO2 and Global Warming (1856) by Brakenshire on Monday October 14, 2019 @05:06AM (#21246335)
You’re talking about perhaps 10 tonnes of wood each year for each person. It’s an interesting concept, though, I wonder what uses we could find for it if we tried to do that.
Re:First Paper to Link CO2 and Global Warming (1856) by eesmith on Monday October 14, 2019 @05:57AM (#21246548)
Cross-laminated timber? https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20171026-the-rise-of-skys... and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cross-laminated_timber .

Though from what I've heard, it's difficult to figure out if they are net negative CO2, and of course the timber needs to come from sustainably managed forests.

Re:First Paper to Link CO2 and Global Warming (1856) by Danieru on Monday October 14, 2019 @04:59AM (#21246303)
Now many deck chairs do are you willing to pay for, on a yearly basis? I would bet few people are willing to purchase 100 or so new deck chairs per year. Burning seems a sensible alternative.