The same should happen to Apple.
Both companies are anti-consumer monopolies.
Do you think that being broken up will have no impact whatsoever on the incentives and outcomes for consumers?
Or simply that the effect will be insignificant?
This is a non issue for me.
But I agree with your premise, Apple has been pulling this for a decade, consumers and developers all lose.
One day ads will start being plexed with content over websockets and the DOM-level protections will be all we have. Firefox is really the only alternative here.
No, Safari content blockers can target selectors as well.
Still, I’m not a fan—I don’t trust apple to be a good judge of behavior here.
Now, whether Google is abusing its monopoly on Search to prop up its Chrome install numbers is a different matter.
Chrome has 2/3 of the browser market and growing. At what point does it become a monopoly? Also don't forget the vast majority of Firefox's revenue is a royalty from Google.
Having a large market share does not make you a monopoly if you do not control the supply and restrict or prevent new market participants.
Since a browser is a piece of software you can install with a couple clicks in a couple minutes, and anyone who wants to can make one, even mostly based on the same code as Chrome in fact - I fail to see how Chrome can be considered a monopoly. Even if it had 90% market share.
Chrome got where it is by computer savvy users telling everyone who would listen to just install Chrome and going to every computer they helped keep running and installing Chrome on it. The exact same thing could happen for Firefox over the next 5 years if the winds really start blowing in that direction.
Only on Legacy Windows. This is not so clear cut on nuWindows or even Android. Ignoring iOS for this particular discussion, that's a separate monopoly.
iOS is also not a monopoly. When you contort the definition of "monopoly" to mean a "non-open ecosystem" then IMO you seek to abuse the anti-trust regulations on the books to promote an open-ecosystem ideology.
iOS is a closed ecosystem in a highly competitive marketplace. Customers -- when given the choice -- have chosen to opt-in to that closed ecosystem billions of times over the last decade.
There are absolutely pros and cons to a closed ecosystem. Which is why it's so great that we have so many options for computing devices on the market occupying various spaces on that closed-open spectrum to choose from!
And yet, Apple's profits grow, including per-unit. Not much competition there.
Firefox compiled for iOS cannot be distributed on the store, and since there is no way to sideload apps, Apple has a literal monopoly on Browsers. Where's the choice there?
It's a precarious situation, but so far Google hasn't asserted their power on that front.
It's actually baffling how people are defending Google and saying it does not have a monopoly in the browser market. Just imagine Microsoft banning your software for arbitrary reasons from being installed on Windows, and then being told that there are still other operating systems on the market.
A monopoly deciding on the kind of browser extensions we get to distribute and use is sickening. As Chrome is a dominant platform, our work is prevented from reaching users if it does not align with the bussiness goals of Google, and extensions that users want on their devices are effectively censored out of existence.
Again, the solution in the face of this company is not to ask them to behave nicely, but to force them to open up their platforms, so that the future of software we enjoy today does not depend on the whims of Google.
As an example of their behavior, I've shared my discussion [1] with Chrome Web Store reviewers when the time came for one of my projects to be taken down. You cannot expect them to respond properly and apply critical thinking, and showing even slight resistance may lead to further retaliation from their part.
The extension review process at Firefox is not flawless either, but you get to talk to human beings who respond appropiately, offer sensible viewpoints, listen to your feedback, and adjust their position during reviews.
[1] https://github.com/dessant/search-by-image/issues/57