Consider. Suppose that in a tennis match each point is won or lost independently of all other points, and suppose further that the server has a 95% chance of winning each point. It seems reasonable to assume that the probability of winning the game from a winning position is always greater than the probability of winning the game from the beginning.
But this is not true! The probability of winning the game from 40:30 up is less than the probability of winning from Love All (99.986% vs 99.991%).
Some students, even those who are quite competent at probability and can follow the calculations, find that this offends their sensibilities and decide that it's all rubbish.
People get very upset if you contradict their common sense. To claim that the sentence:
If n is an integer and both even and odd, then n=17.
is true gets some people really confused. The hurdle of understanding why it's true needs to be passed, otherwise most of math will remain unattainable.(edited to add the actual probabilities)
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2126890
Pretty sure no one cares, but I thought I'd add it for completeness.
So mathematicians can only prove theorems by working with the definition of "implies" that makes no causality requirement.
However, there is a sense (albeit informal) in which mathematicians recognise causality, and he alludes to that when he says that probably no one would say that the Riemann hypothesis implies Fermat's last theorem. I think that all mathematicians (or at least those who learned from Herstein!) would agree that Sylow's theorem on the existence of p-subgroups of all possible orders is equivalent to the weaker statement about the existence of p-Sylow subgroups; but no mathematician would mean by that merely that both are true.
I am however interested in this guy's next article, which will hopefully be a 8-page document regarding how, unlike in plain English, "x or y" in logic is still true if x and y.
Well it would sound pretty stupid to say "x XOR y" in regular conversation, which is what is usually meant. I'm trying to imagine how it would sound -- "ok, you can get a pony zhor an xbox?", "you can get ice cream ecks-or health insurance?" Also, not many people would probably talk to you.
It seems like Tim likes to further classify things into "reasonable-sounding" and "unreasonable-sounding" implication statements, but I just don't follow the lines of that distinction at all.