Re:Timothy Gowers on mathematical implication
by JadeNB on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @08:43PM
(#2122184)
> He doesn't mention this (I guess it goes without saying among mathematicians), but part of the problem is that in mathematics one fact doesn't generally seem to cause another: certainly there's no adequate causality that can trivially be verified by intuition or common sense.
However, there is a sense (albeit informal) in which mathematicians recognise causality, and he alludes to that when he says that probably no one would say that the Riemann hypothesis implies Fermat's last theorem. I think that all mathematicians (or at least those who learned from Herstein!) would agree that Sylow's theorem on the existence of p-subgroups of all possible orders is equivalent to the weaker statement about the existence of p-Sylow subgroups; but no mathematician would mean by that merely that both are true.
So mathematicians can only prove theorems by working with the definition of "implies" that makes no causality requirement.