Re:Timothy Gowers on mathematical implication
by mayank on Wednesday January 19, 2011 @08:15PM
(#2122090)
> which will hopefully be a 8-page document regarding how, unlike in plain English, "x or y" in logic is still true if x and y.
Well it would sound pretty stupid to say "x XOR y" in regular conversation, which is what is usually meant. I'm trying to imagine how it would sound -- "ok, you can get a pony zhor an xbox?", "you can get ice cream ecks-or health insurance?" Also, not many people would probably talk to you.
Re:Timothy Gowers on mathematical implication
by baddox on Thursday January 20, 2011 @10:35AM
(#2123938)
That's my point. Mathematic terminology is expected to be different than plain English.
Re:Timothy Gowers on mathematical implication
by RiderOfGiraffes on Thursday January 20, 2011 @11:16AM
(#2124091)
In my experience, this is not true when people are learning the basics of formal reasoning. More, people expect that mathematical logic will not contradict their strongly-held intuitions about logic and causality.
I am however interested in this guy's next article, which will hopefully be a 8-page document regarding how, unlike in plain English, "x or y" in logic is still true if x and y.