News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The China Cultural Clash by tpmx on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @01:06PM (#21194419)
This article frames this as the US vs China, but it's really been the "Western world" vs China.

And the western world has been incredibly naive and uncoordinated when it comes to dealing with China. We've all accepted the incredibly one-sided deal, in some kind of idealistic hope that the Chinese would latch on to "western" values of democracy etc just by trading with us.

Edit: World -> Western world.

Re:The China Cultural Clash by dmix on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @01:23PM (#21194637)
The US is still special in this context where free speech is really taken to heart and extends to not only dissent against the government but even vile extremely unpopular political opinions are protected ...which is something you don't always find in every western country.

For example, in Charlottesville 2017 [1] the local government tried to prevent Neo-nazis from using a park for a protest but ACLU sued the gov and got approval. From there the police actively protected their right to protest.

Which really highlights the massive gap between the US and China. It's not just 'don't silence them' but they have a right to speak and be protected while protesting on public grounds by the state from violence by other government organizations and citizens who disagree with them.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unite_the_Right_rally#Permits_...

Re:The China Cultural Clash by chillacy on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @03:22PM (#21196075)
> “We are strongly dissatisfied and we oppose Silver’s claim to support Morey’s right of free expression. We believe that any speech that challenges national sovereignty and social stability is not within the scope of freedom of speech,” CCTV said in its statement in Chinese, which was translated by CNBC.

I normally find the "hate speech is free speech" argument to be pretty tiring, but it's also true that once you start carving exemptions to free speech you can easily carve one out that says "criticizing the government is like hate speech", and then you can justify anything.

Re:The China Cultural Clash by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @04:46PM (#21197040)
It's much worse than that. The claim is "you criticizing our government is hate speech". That is, they presume to have the right (or perhaps the moral authority) to say what the rules for free speech should be in other countries. I find that rather staggering.
Re:The China Cultural Clash by tpmx on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @02:10PM (#21195197)
I'd like to say you're wrong... but anti free speech legislation is growing like mad in Europe. :/

(Of course it's always under the guise of "harmony". F*ck, we're beginning to resemble the PRC.)

Re:The China Cultural Clash by dmix on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @02:14PM (#21195243)
It's something that's far easier to take away than it is to stand for and defend. That's why it being enshrined in constitutions and a strong legal culture of defending it is so important.

Short-term thinking and people missing the forest for the trees after some emotional event is far too common for it to be trusted in the hands of the average politician.

Re:The China Cultural Clash by baq on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @04:58PM (#21197198)
this is because free speech on the internet is a powerful tool and it is abused by non-european nation states to influence european voters. smart dictators understand this and firewalled themselves off ages ago, resulting in asymmetry of freedom of speech == capability to influence masses.
Re:The China Cultural Clash by ummwhat on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @02:20PM (#21195321)
I say succinctly "you cannot silence the Americans. They don't know how to shut up".

If the foreigner doesn't feel it, they'll at least find it funny.

Re:The China Cultural Clash by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @01:20PM (#21194609)
> We've all accepted the incredibly one-sided deal, in some kind of idealistic hope that the Chinese would latch on to "western" values of democracy etc just by trading with us

To expand on this, the history of economic and democratic development were thought to go hand in hand. Not only had it borne out in Western Europe, it also showed traction in post-war Japan and India. So the hypothesis, that a wealthier China would become more stable and democratic wasn't insane.

That hypothesis has been proven false. Part of this is the reduced number of people required to hold on to power in our age of digital surveillance. Part of it is the unique culture Mao's Cultural Revolution left behind.

The moment of reckoning came when Xi installed himself as dictator for life. Prior to that, China had been lurching towards mastering peaceful transitions of power under intraparty politics. There was legitimate hope it would think and plan for the long term. With a dictator, however, short-term political survival dominates all else. And so we get the absurdity of a billion peoples' productive power being channeled into stamping out Winnie the Pooh imagery.

Re:The China Cultural Clash by notebookstack on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @04:03PM (#21196565)
Democracy was forcibly imposed on Japan by the US when they lost WWII; India had been colonized by the British and its elites exposed to their cultural and political systems for 200 years before independence. In Western Europe, the process took a couple millenia, dating back to the legacy of Greece and Rome. The Magna Carta started to limit monarchial authority in England beginning in 1215; the French had not one but a whole series of revolutions from the late 1700's through the 1800's. And yet, in between, there were decades and centuries of backslides into fiefdoms and dictatorships and absolute monarchies; even when progress was made, it was incremental - giving political say first to landed aristocracy and clergy, then men, then women.

I think it's a little early to definitely say that this hypothesis has been proven false in China. Keep in mind that China's growth has really only taken off since the mid-to-late 90's. That's less than one generation. Look at the path that comparable economies in Asia took who developed much earlier. Korea's economic miracle took off in 1960, but it was basically ruled by military dictatorships in all but name until 1987. Taiwan saw it's main burst of economic growth in the 60's and 70's, but it was also ruled as a dictatorship by the KMT since they lost the Chinese Civil War. In fact, the first opposition party was not formed until 1986, and martial law, which had been in effect since 1949, was not lifted until 1987, a year before Chiang Ching-kuo, Chiang Kai Shek's son and successor, passed away. Singapore's government all during its economic miracle was famously authoritarian.

Re:The China Cultural Clash by mlyle on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @01:27PM (#21194681)
> So the hypothesis, that a wealthier China would be a more stable, more democratic China wasn't insane.

I think the jury is still out. China has a long way left to develop and a huge populace still toiling without the benefits of that wealth. And some of the ways the economic development has happened are IMO temporarily and not durable.

> There was legitimate hope it would think and plan for the long term. With a dictator, however, short-term political survival dominates all else. And so we get the absurdity of a billion peoples' productive power being channeled into stamping out Winnie the Pooh imagery.

In fairness, I'm not sure that's a huge fraction of the billion peoples' productive power. ;P

Re:The China Cultural Clash by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @01:34PM (#21194753)
> I'm not sure that's a huge fraction of the billion peoples' productive power

The Winnie the Pooh thing is amusing because we like watching powerful people be insecure about childish things.

The dirtier side is senior CCP members using the country's wealth for personal gain to a level not seen since the Soviet Union [1].

[1] https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/asia/china/936509...

Re:The China Cultural Clash by tpmx on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @01:47PM (#21194921)
I feel like this analysis completed my incomplete thinking. Bravo.
Re:The China Cultural Clash by mfer on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @01:17PM (#21194567)
The world vs China? The US, Canada, the EU, and Australia make up less than 20% of the worlds population. India, the many countries of Africa and South and Central America are places I've not heard from on this. And, there is a large population there.

Is it the world vs China or the parts of the world we typically listen to vs China?

Re:The China Cultural Clash by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @01:19PM (#21194593)
India has had its own problems with China. Not the same as the west’s for sure, but then again they have a direct border with each other and a large territory dispute.
Re:The China Cultural Clash by guelo on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @01:33PM (#21194742)
China is applying economic pressure across the world to get its way. If they pull this shit on the US imagine what they can get away with with smaller poorer countries.
Re:The China Cultural Clash by mfer on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @01:40PM (#21194826)
Large businesses often have rules around single sourcing of anything. They don't want that single source to cause them problems if something happens to it. For example, even if they buy 90% of their servers from HPE they may still get 10% from Dell to have multiple suppliers.

It would be wise for many organizations to take that idea and apply it to countries of origin for their things. That way instability in a region doesn't threaten things back home.

This doesn't help things like the NBA whose revenue model is based on bodies and eyeballs. But, it can help some industries break control... as long as they have goals other than to gain all the money.

Re:The China Cultural Clash by jimclegg on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @01:48PM (#21194936)
It takes a certain level of Eurocentricism to believe roughly 4 countries are the world.
Re:The China Cultural Clash by eternalban on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @01:53PM (#21194995)
> And the western world has been incredibly naive and uncoordinated when it comes to dealing with China.

Some of us were paying attention in the '90s and we're still paying attention.

Here are some interesting items to review:

1 - McDonnell Douglas (yep the same gang that ruined Boeing): https://www.nytimes.com/1992/06/29/business/mcdonnell-dougla...

2 - "Pentagon Blessing" https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB832727883654550000

3 - https://www.nytimes.com/1999/10/20/us/us-indicts-mcdonnell-d...

4 - https://mattstoller.substack.com/p/how-bill-clinton-and-amer...

5 - https://www.military.com/defensetech/2013/12/24/report-israe...

6 - https://knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu/article/why-tech-transfe...

"naive and uncoordinated"

It has always seemed rather coordinated to this observer. No comment regarding "naive".

"We've all accepted the incredibly one-sided deal"

Who is this "We"? Did we take a vote on this? This was decided on high up per some undisclosed calculus like everything else substantial while the corporate media beguiles "Us" with peripheral, low brow, histrionics.

Re:The China Cultural Clash by tpmx on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @02:32PM (#21195461)
Upvoted.

(And yeah, I feel like I have been personally aware at least during the past ten years or so. Things move slowly.)

Re:The China Cultural Clash by golergka on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @01:25PM (#21194657)
Is it?

Don't misunderstand me, I'm certainly on US side in this one - but Russia, India, Brazil, and many, many other world powers aren't particularly opposed to China on this one. They're trying to implement the same domestic capabilities, and indeed agree with China's opinion on national sovereignity and limitations of speech.

It was a great time, when US could dictate the world it's values and the world listened - as much as HN public loves to bash US government (I guess, a concious person is always critical of his own country), it's still one of the best democracies in the world. But that time is gone. Liberal consensus is not "the world"'s opinion anymore.

Re:The China Cultural Clash by mc32 on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @01:10PM (#21194475)
That’s true, but I think unless the US acts other players will stay on the sidelines. Maybe I’ve missed it, but has the EU commenced anything that would address some of the one-sidedness? Others are either indifferent, impotent or maybe even approving of the behavior by the CCP.
Re:The China Cultural Clash by markus_zhang on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @01:13PM (#21194511)
No it's Five eyes and part of EU (excluding UK), and even US has a lot differences with EU.
Re:The China Cultural Clash by dmix on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @01:15PM (#21194536)
Sure they have differences but in this context it's very much the western democracy vs authoritarianism, where dissenting opinions are not only tolerated but they are actively protected by the state, usually via an independent judicial body - the most important thing every truly authoritarian country lacks.

China's not the first nation state to be at the butting end of this debate and they won't be the last.

Re:The China Cultural Clash by pfortuny on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @01:30PM (#21194719)
I understand what you are trying to convey but it always harms me to be told that I have had idealistic hopes with China. I always have said that the Olympics was the great self inflicted humiliation of the Western world before China...
Re:The China Cultural Clash by ajross on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @01:15PM (#21194542)
> some kind of idealistic hope that the Chinese would latch on to "western" values of democracy etc just by trading with us

Is that really so idealistic though? Like most folks I'm sure, I've worked with a ton of chinese nationals and expatriots over my career. And not one of them was ignorant of this nonsense. They all know it happens. They agree in principle that it's bad, they just tolerate it as part of the cost of growth. And that's not even arguably a bad trade given China's history over the past century.

As the PRC's growth slows and it reaches parity with the rest of the world, we'll start to see more tension in this space (arguably that's exactly what's happening in Hong Kong right now). And there's danger there, obviously.

But the problem isn't one of "ideals", "values" or "free speech". The values are already there.

Re:The China Cultural Clash by throwawy4trueth on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @04:00PM (#21196532)
China didn't force you to accept their value. But you often (not always) force all the world to accept your cult (with the name of "value" to make it sounds not so irrational) by destroying many countries in Middle East.

The biggest threat is the cult because the cult will cause conflicts. Keep it for yourself would be good. Spread it all over the world and claim it's universal so you have right to judge others inferior "value" and even try to enforce your "value" when the other countries are weaker , literally is the same pattern as ISIS.

Re:The China Cultural Clash by justicezyx on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @01:08PM (#21194455)
> We've all accepted the incredibly one-sided deal

Trust me, most Chinese people believed the same thing when they deal with other nations.

You either need to label all of them being stupid and naive; or you are saying Chinese are so smarter than anyone else...

The deals are never one-sided...

Re:The China Cultural Clash by wefarrell on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @01:27PM (#21194684)
This is not one culture or part of the world vs another.

This is liberalism vs totalitarianism. Totalitarians are successfully using the tools of liberalism against itself. It's time that we in the free world wake up to what's happening and fight back.

Re:The China Cultural Clash by Analemma_ on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @01:11PM (#21194478)
Too many people bought into the Fukuyama "end of history" theory whereby free trade and free markets would automatically lead to democracy and liberal values spreading worldwide. It probably seemed like a reasonable hypothesis right after the Soviet Union fell, but at this point it's pretty clear the events of the last decade have debunked it completely. The silver lining is we're a little smarter now and will hopefully make better decisions going forward.
Re:The China Cultural Clash by mc32 on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @01:12PM (#21194497)
I guess. But it’s worth mentioning that Fukuyama is no longer a Fukuyamaist himself.
Re:The China Cultural Clash by pesmhey on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @01:17PM (#21194562)
His latest thoughts are on corruption and the difference between the rule of law and patrimonialism. All this, well before the election of Donald Trump. Truly amazing and admirable how calibrated he came back after the massive fail that was the end of history.
Re:The China Cultural Clash by jimclegg on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @01:16PM (#21194555)
Not the world vs China, it has always been the West vs China, European leaders' "zero sum" mentality has made it an economic target for the better part of 2+ centuries.

Please don't include the majority of the world that is benefiting from a new benevolent economic actor on the block.

Re:The China Cultural Clash by ashelmire on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @01:21PM (#21194614)
You're considering China to be a new benevolent economic actor?

Can you explain what behavior you consider "benevolent"?

Re:The China Cultural Clash by jimclegg on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @01:34PM (#21194762)
The "well planned" foreign infrastructure projects have had positive impacts on the local communities and economies.

They provide access to loans from an alternative world bank at competitive rates with less strings attached.

Adding depth/liquidity to global markets is beneficial to participants.

Re:The China Cultural Clash by ashelmire on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @03:05PM (#21195877)
Which of those signifies benevolence?

What foreign infrastructure projects? Surely not the ones where they lend money to foreigners but then China owns them? That's just investment, it's not benevolent.

The same for providing loans.

Neither of these are benevolent - they are financial tools to gain traction and influence on the world stage, as well as to make money. I don't think we can attribute any positive intent (towards the rest of the world) to these behaviors.

Re:The China Cultural Clash by crimsonalucard on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @06:37PM (#21198039)
If you think unparalleled manufacturing expertise at unparalleled prices isn't an economic gain for the entire world you need to open your biased eyes wider.

Yes the west and china are economic rivals. This does not mean China has zero economic benefit to the world. To not see this is utter blindness.

Re:The China Cultural Clash by ashelmire on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @09:31AM (#21202995)
I do not question their economic activity. Whether that's been for the good of anyone but China and the world's billionaires... I'm not so sure.

Either way it wasn't done for the benefit of the world. China started manufacturing because they wanted to gain economic power and arrive in the 21st century.

Re:The China Cultural Clash by crimsonalucard on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @01:35PM (#21205611)
Only billionaires gain from higher production of products? Makes sense. You never gained anything clearly because you've never purchased anything made in China.
Re:The China Cultural Clash by crimsonalucard on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @01:19PM (#21194594)
Native Americans were the same way when they didn't want to latch on to Western ideals. It takes a lot to learn the right way to do things including forcefully taking land and slaughter.

What people don't understand is that Western democracy is the only and best way to run the world. I mean look at public transport infrastructure in the United States. Public transport in the United States is so fair and democratic that it's been over two decades and they still haven't been able to ring the Bart around the bay or build a high speed rail thanks to the government being fair and balanced.

I mean look at chinas lack of human rights. They throw a few people out their homes to build an entire high speed rail network across the entire country. More people may benefit from this but it is a serious violation of human rights to move a couple people to another place. Literally borderline evil. Lifting an entire population out of poverty isn't worth giving up a fair and balanced democracy where everyone can fairly debate about a policy for 20 years before anything gets done.

I'm not saying that the US is perfect. But china needs to take a good hard look at the US and realize that their way isn't the only way of doing things. I mean people in the United States aren't so biased as to insult china on every opportunity as an economic rival. People in the west are actually unbiased and have a fair and balanced outlook on the world just like the parent poster. Literally china is like a small child saying that it's the entire world against the United States. This is an immature way of solving a problem or working together.